Karen B. Whittington

Genetic ablation of interferon-gamma up-regulates interleukin-1beta expression and enables the elicitation of collagen-induced arthritis in a nonsusceptible mouse strain.

OBJECTIVE To determine whether the lack of interferon-gamma (IFNgamma) alters resistance to collagen-induced arthritis (CIA) in a nonsusceptible mouse strain, and if so, to identify changes in the antibody, cellular type II collagen (CII)-specific immune responses, and cytokine gene expression that might account for the altered susceptibility. METHODS CIA-resistant C57BL/6 and C57BL/6 IFNgamma-/- mice were immunized with bovine CII in Freunds complete adjuvant (CFA) or in CFA alone. Animals were monitored for signs of arthritis for up to 80 days; arthritis severity was assessed visually and histologically. Sera were collected at various time points after immunization for measurement of anti-CII antibody levels. T cell responses to bovine CII were assessed in proliferation assays. Cytokine messenger RNA (mRNA) expression in lymph node cells and in synovial cells from arthritic paws was measured by RNase protection assays, and levels of cytokine protein production were determined by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. RESULTS IFNgamma-/- mice developed a severe autoimmune arthritis that was dependent on immunization with CII. IFNgamma-/- mice produced significantly higher amounts of IgG1 and IgG2b antibody to the autoantigen, murine CII, compared with wild-type C57BL/6 mice and had an enhanced T cell proliferative response to bovine CII. Enhanced production of mature interleukin-1/beta (IL-1beta) protein was observed, but no significant changes in Th1 or Th2 cytokines. Although IL-6 and tumor necrosis factor alpha transcripts were clearly evident in the synovial cells from the arthritic paws of IFNgamma-/- mice, neither message was elevated to the levels measured for IL-1beta expression. Treatment of IFNgamma-/- mice with anti-IL-1beta significantly reduced the incidence and severity of the inflammation. CONCLUSION Endogenous IFNgamma plays a role in the regulation of IL-1beta, in this model of autoimmune arthritis.

HLA-DR1 (DRB1*0101) and DR4 (DRB1*0401) Use the Same Anchor Residues for Binding an Immunodominant Peptide Derived from Human Type II Collagen

Rheumatoid arthritis is an autoimmune disease in which susceptibility is strongly associated with the expression of specific HLA-DR haplotypes, including DR1 (DRB1*0101) and DR4 (DRB1*0401). As transgenes, both of these class II molecules mediate susceptibility to an autoimmune arthritis induced by immunization with human type II collagen (hCII). The dominant T cell response of both the DR1 and DR4 transgenic mice to hCII is focused on the same determinant core, CII(263–270). Peptide binding studies revealed that the affinity of DR1 and DR4 for CII(263–270) was at least 10 times less than that of the model Ag HA(307–319), and that the affinity of DR4 for the CII peptide is 3-fold less than that of DR1. As predicted based on the crystal structures, the majority of the CII-peptide binding affinity for DR1 and DR4 is controlled by the Phe263; however, unexpectedly the adjacent Lys264 also contributed significantly to the binding affinity of the peptide. Only these two CII amino acids were found to provide binding anchors. Amino acid substitutions at the remaining positions had either no effect or significantly increased the affinity of the hCII peptide. Affinity-enhancing substitutions frequently involved replacement of a negative charge, or Gly or Pro, hallmark amino acids of CII structure. These data indicate that DR1 and DR4 bind this CII peptide in a nearly identical manner and that the primary structure of CII may dictate a different binding motif for DR1 and DR4 than has been described for other peptides that bind to these alleles.

Ex Vivo Characterization of the Autoimmune T Cell Response in the HLA-DR1 Mouse Model of Collagen-Induced Arthritis Reveals Long-Term Activation of Type II Collagen-Specific Cells and Their Presence in Arthritic Joints

Although the pathogenesis of collagen-induced arthritis (CIA), a model of rheumatoid arthritis, is mediated by both collagen-specific CD4+ T cells and Ab specific for type II collagen (CII), the role of CII-specific T cells in the pathogenesis of CIA remains unclear. Using tetrameric HLA-DR1 with a covalently bound immunodominant CII peptide, CII259–273, we studied the development of the CII-specific T cell response in the periphery and arthritic joints of DR1 transgenic mice. Although the maximum number of DR1-CII-tetramer+ cells was detected in draining lymph nodes 10 days postimmunization, these T cells accounted for only 1% or less of the CD4+ population. After day 10, their numbers gradually decreased, but were still detectable on day 130. Examination of TCR expression and changes in CD62L, CD44high, and CD69 expression by these T cells indicated that they expressed a limited TCR-BV repertoire and had clearly undergone activation. RT-PCR analysis of cytokine expression by the tetramer+ T cells compared with tetramer− cells indicated the tetramer+ cells expressed high levels of Th1 and proinflammatory cytokines, including IL-2, IFN-γ, IL-6, TNF-α, and especially IL-17. Additionally, analysis of the synovium from arthritic paws indicated that the same CD4+/BV8+/BV14+/tetramer+ T cells were present in the arthritic joints. These data demonstrate that although only small numbers of CII-specific T cells are generated during the development of CIA, these cells express very high levels of cytokine mRNA and appear to preferentially migrate to the arthritic joint, indicating a potential direct role of CII-specific T cells in the pathogenesis of CIA.

Detection of early changes in autoimmune T cell phenotype and function following intravenous administration of type II collagen in a TCR-transgenic model.

To study the phenotypic and functional changes in naive type II collagen (CII)-specific autoimmune T cells following a tolerogenic signal, a TCR-transgenic (Tg) mouse model of collagen-induced arthritis was developed. These Tg mice express an I-Aq-restricted CII (260–267)-specific TCR that confers severe accelerated autoimmune arthritis following immunization with CII. Despite the fact that >90% of the αβ T cells express the Tg, these mice can be rendered completely tolerant to the induction of arthritis by i.v. administration of 200 μg of CII. As early as 24 h after CII administration, CII-specific T cells demonstrated a decreased ability to proliferate in response to the CII immunodominant peptide and phenotypically altered the expression of L-selectin to CD62Llow and of phagocytic glycoprotein-1 to CD44high, expression levels consistent with the phenotype of memory T cells. In addition, they up-regulated the expression of the activation markers CD71 and CD69. Functionally, following tolerogenic stimulation, the CII-specific T cells produced similar levels of IL-2 in comparison to controls when challenged with CII peptide, however, by 48 h after exposure to tolerogen, IL-2 production dropped and was replaced by high levels of IL-10 and IL-4. Based on their production of Th2 cytokines, these data suggest that T regulatory cells expressing activation and memory markers are induced by the tolerogen and may exert their influence via cytokines to protect the animals from the induction of arthritis.

Collagen-Induced Arthritis Mediated by HLA-DR1 (*0101) and HLA-DR4 (*0401)

&NA; Although associations between the expression of particular HLA genes and susceptibility to specific autoimmune diseases has been known for some time, the role HLA molecules play in the autoimmune response is unclear. Through the establishment of chimeric HLA‐DR/I‐E transgenes, the authors examined the function of the rheumatoid arthritis (RA) susceptibility alleles HLA‐DR1 (DRB1*0101) and DR4 (DRB1*0401) in presenting antigenic peptides derived from the model antigen, type II collagen (CII), and in mediating an autoimmune response. As a transgene, these chimeric DR molecules confer susceptibility to an autoimmune arthritis induced by immunization with human CII. Both the DR1 and DR4‐restricted T cell responses to CII are focused on an immunodominant determinant CII(263–270). Peptide binding studies revealed that the majority of the CII‐peptide binding affinity for DR1 and DR4 is controlled by the Phe at 263 and, unexpectedly, the adjacent Lys. Only these 2 CII amino acids were found to provide binding anchors. Amino acid substitutions at the remaining positions had either no effect or significantly increased the affinity of the hCII peptide. These data indicate that DR1 and DR4 bind this CII peptide in a nearly identical manner and that the primary structure of CII may dictate a different binding motif for DR1 and DR4 than has been described for other peptides. In all, these studies demonstrate that DR1 and DR4 are capable of binding peptides derived from human type II collagen (hCII) and support the hypothesis that autoimmune responses to hCII play a role in the pathogenesis of RA.

Crystallographic structure of a rheumatoid arthritis MHC susceptibility allele, HLA-DR1 (DRB1*0101), complexed with the immunodominant determinant of human type II collagen

The expression of HLA-DR1 (DRB1*0101) is associated with an enhanced risk for developing rheumatoid arthritis (RA). To study its function, we have solved the three-dimensional structure of HLA-DR1 complexed with a candidate RA autoantigen, the human type II collagen peptide CII (259–273). Based on these structural data, the CII peptide is anchored by Phe263 at the P1 position and Glu266 at P4. Surprisingly, the Lys at the P2 position appears to play a dual role by participating in peptide binding via interactions with DRB1-His81 and Asn82, and TCR interaction, based on functional assays. The CII peptide is also anchored by the P4 Glu266 residue through an ionic interaction with DRB1-Arg71 and Glu28. Participation of DRB1-Arg71 is significant because it is part of the shared epitope expressed by DR alleles associated with RA susceptibility. Potential anchor residues at P6 and P9 of the CII peptide are both Gly, and the lack of side chains at these positions appears to result in both a narrower binding groove with the peptide protruding out of the groove at this end of the DR1 molecule. From the TCR perspective, the P2-Lys264, P5-Arg267, and P8-Lys270 residues are all oriented away from the binding groove and collectively represent a positive charged interface for CII-specific TCR binding. Comparison of the DR1-CII structure to a DR1-hemagglutinin peptide structure revealed that the binding of these two peptides generates significantly different interfaces for the interaction with their respective Ag-specific TCRs.

An Autoantigen-Specific, Highly Restricted T Cell Repertoire Infiltrates the Arthritic Joints of Mice in an HLA-DR1 Humanized Mouse Model of Autoimmune Arthritis

Although it is clear that CD4+ T cells play a major role in mediating the pathogenesis of autoimmunity, they often represent only a minor population at the site of inflammation in autoimmune diseases. To investigate the migration and specificity of autoimmune T cells to the inflammatory site, we used the collagen-induced arthritis model to determine the frequency, clonotype, and specificity of T cells that infiltrate arthritic joints. We demonstrate that despite the fact that CD4+ T cells are a minor population of the synovial infiltrate, the CD4+ T cells present are a highly selective subset of the TCR repertoire and, based on CDR3 length polymorphisms, have a limited clonality. Although a similar repertoire of type II collagen (CII)-specific TCR-BV8 and BV14-expressing T cells was found in peripheral lymphoid organs, the clonality of the TCR-BV8 and BV14 T cells that migrate to the arthritic joint generally made up a single CDR3 length. T cell hybridomas produced from these joint-derived cells revealed that many of these infiltrating T cells are CII specific, and the majority recognize mouse CII. These data suggest that despite being a minor population at the site of inflammation, autoantigen-specific T cells are selectively recruited and/or retained in the arthritic joint and may be playing a significant role in the pathogenesis of the autoimmune arthritis. In addition, this model may be very useful for studying the function in situ and the mechanism by which autoimmune T cells are recruited to the site of inflammation.

Engineered Regulatory T Cells Coexpressing MHC Class II:Peptide Complexes Are Efficient Inhibitors of Autoimmune T Cell Function and Prevent the Development of Autoimmune Arthritis

Regulatory T cells (Tregs) are critical homeostatic components in preventing the development of autoimmunity, and are a major focus for their therapeutic potential for autoimmune diseases. To enhance the efficacy of Tregs in adoptive therapy, we developed a strategy for generating engineered Tregs that have the capacity to target autoimmune T cells in an Ag-specific manner. Using a retroviral expression system encoding Foxp3 and HLA-DR1 covalently linked to the immunodominant peptide of the autoantigen type II collagen (DR1-CII), naive T cells were engineered to become Tregs that express DR1-CII complexes on their surface. When these cells were tested for their ability to prevent the development of collagen induced arthritis, both the engineered DR1-CII-Foxp3 and Foxp3 only Tregs significantly reduced the severity and incidence of disease. However, the mechanism by which these two populations of Tregs inhibited disease differed significantly. Disease inhibition by the DR1-CII-Foxp3 Tregs was accompanied by significantly lower numbers of autoimmune CII-specific T cells in vivo and lower levels of autoantibodies in comparison with engineered Tregs expressing Foxp3 alone. In addition, the numbers of IFN-γ– and IL-17–expressing T cells in mice treated with DR1-CII-Foxp3 Tregs were also significantly reduced in comparison with mice treated with Foxp3 engineered Tregs or vector control cells. These data indicate that the coexpression of class II autoantigen–peptide complexes on Tregs provides these cells with a distinct capacity to regulate autoimmune T cell responses that differs from that used by conventional Tregs.

I-Aq and I-Ap Bind and Present Similar Antigenic Peptides Despite Differing in their Ability to Mediate Susceptibility to Autoimmune Arthritis

Susceptibility to collagen induced arthritis (CIA) in the murine model is linked to expression of the MHC class II alleles, I-Aq and I-Ar. We have examined the molecular basis for this MHC-linked susceptibility by studying the antigen presentation function of two class II molecules, I-Aq and I-Ap, that are closely related yet differ in mediating susceptibility to CIA. These class II molecules differ by only 4 amino acids, yet only mice expressing I-Aq develop CIA. Although the I-Ap molecule can bind the same immunodominant determinant from type II collagen as I-Aq, H-2P APC have difficulty generating I-AP:CII peptide complexes when processing of CII is required. Immunization of H-2P mice with type II collagen (CII) generated only a weak T cell response when compared to H-2q mice, whereas immunization with the a CII peptide containing the dominant determinant induced a strong T cell response in both strains. In antigen presentation assays, H-2P APC were very inefficient in stimulating T cells when native CII was used as antigen, however they presented CII synthetic peptides with similar efficiency as H-2q APC. Processing and presentation of other antigens by H-2P APC was not affected. Using soluble class II binding assays, the affinity of I-Ap for the CII dominant peptide was 10 to 50 fold lower than I-Aq, however, this reduced affinity was not a general defect in I-Ap function. I-Aq and I-Ap had virtually identical affinities for binding other antigenic peptides. These data indicate that MHC-based susceptibility to autoimmunity may involve more than simple determinant selection and that the successful generation of an antigenic peptide by processing may be related to the overall affinity of the peptide for the MHC molecule.