Karen Margaret Wright

Aggression in a high secure hospital: Staff and patient attitudes

Responding to aggressive behaviour is a key activity for nurses and other care staff in high secure hospitals. The attitudes and beliefs of staff regarding patient aggression will influence the management strategies they adopt. Patients will also hold attitudes regarding the causes of and best ways to respond to aggressive behaviour. This study measured the attitudes towards aggression of staff (n= 109) and patients (n= 27) in a high secure hospital in the UK using the Management of Aggression and Violence Attitude Scale (MAVAS). There was considerable concordance of views, staff and patients disagreeing on only two items on the MAVAS. Aggression was felt to have a range of causes, embracing factors internal to the person, factors in the external environment and situational or interactional factors. Interpersonal means of managing aggression were supported, but both staff and patients also advocated the use of controlling management strategies such as medication, seclusion and restraint. The implications of these findings for aggression management in high secure settings are discussed in the light of best practice guidelines that promote interpersonal approaches over controlling strategies.

An angel on my shoulder: a study of relationships between women with anorexia and healthcare professionals.

Accessible summary • This study explored the therapeutic relationship among adults who access day care services for anorexia and their healthcare professionals. • There were six important themes that emerged from interviews with healthcare professionals and patients: the authenticity of the relationship, safety, the externalization of the eating disorder, recovery measured in kilos, the power of hope and optimism and maternalism. • Women attending day care for anorexia felt safer and more optimistic and therefore more supported when the healthcare professional had a nurturing and maternalistic approach. Abstract Adults with anorexia are an under-researched group because the usual focus is on adolescents. The relationships that occur between healthcare professionals and adults with anorexia are often challenging, because they do not necessarily agree on the goals of treatment. The therapeutic relationship is widely recognized as crucial to care, even healing and restorative in its own right but problematic in this setting. This is a phenomenological study of how therapeutic relationships are negotiated and maintained in a day care service. Six women with anorexia nervosa and seven of their healthcare professionals were interviewed in the care setting to explore their lived experience of their relationships. Six important themes emerged from the interviews: the authenticity of the relationship, safety, the externalization of the eating disorder, recovery measured in kilos, the power of hope and optimism and the use and acceptance of maternalism in the care setting. Findings suggest that patients appreciated the safety and security of care, but some were using the service as respite rather than recovery. Patients saw goals and tasks related directly to weight gain as irrelevant to their main concerns, but engagement with people who provided a secure, nurturing and maternalistic context for safety and optimism was seen as supportive.Adults with anorexia are an under-researched group because the usual focus is on adolescents. The relationships that occur between healthcare professionals and adults with anorexia are often challenging, because they do not necessarily agree on the goals of treatment. The therapeutic relationship is widely recognized as crucial to care, even healing and restorative in its own right but problematic in this setting. This is a phenomenological study of how therapeutic relationships are negotiated and maintained in a day care service. Six women with anorexia nervosa and seven of their healthcare professionals were interviewed in the care setting to explore their lived experience of their relationships. Six important themes emerged from the interviews: the authenticity of the relationship, safety, the externalization of the eating disorder, recovery measured in kilos, the power of hope and optimism and the use and acceptance of maternalism in the care setting. Findings suggest that patients appreciated the safety and security of care, but some were using the service as respite rather than recovery. Patients saw goals and tasks related directly to weight gain as irrelevant to their main concerns, but engagement with people who provided a secure, nurturing and maternalistic context for safety and optimism was seen as supportive.

It's the talk: a study of involvement initiatives in secure mental health settings

A study of involvement initiatives within secure mental health services across one UK region, where these have been organized to reflect alliances between staff and service users. There is little previous relevant international research, but constraints upon effective involvement have been noted.

A qualitative study into the attitudes of patients and staff towards violence and aggression in a high security hospital

This paper provides a brief overview of research conducted within a high security hospital to ascertain staff and patient views on how aggression and violence are managed and their subsequent impact on all parties. Both the National Institute for Mental Health in England (NIMHE, 2004) and the National Institute of Clinical Excellence (NICE, 2005) have emphasized the need to take account of contextual factors when considering the cause and management of aggression. While patient variables (internal) are important within psychiatry, the environment or setting (including culture), relational issues (including gender) and staff attitude are equally important (Jansen et al. 2006). Duxbury & Whittington (2005) found that poor communication contributed to the development of patient aggression, whereby restrictions and environmental factors are fundamental to relational issues. There is currently very little research conducted in high secure services (HSS) that focuses on the management of violence and aggression (MVA) in this context. Uppal & McMurran (2009) report on the frequency and nature of incidents of violence, selfharm and security and Ireland (2006) consider bullying within this context. However, these studies do not focus specifically on the attitudes of staff and patients to violence and aggression. McKeown & Stowell-Smith (2006) speak about the construction of ‘difference’ between staff and patients, who exist in conditions of high security; they suggest that we separate ourselves from those with psychopathic personalities to cope with the work, but acknowledge that this creates its own difficulties within the establishment of the therapeutic relationship. More recently, Canadian authors Jacob et al. (2009) stated that ‘Forensic psychiatric nurses work with individuals who may evoke feelings of empathy as well as feelings of disgust, repulsion, and fear.’ (p. 153). They attribute these emotions to the fear of caring for individuals who are viewed as ‘monsters’ (Jacob et al. 2009). This view resonates with that of McKeown & Stowell-Smith (2006), who suggest that in the face of abjection, staff create a context that constructs a sense of difference and ‘otherness’ between themselves and the patients. They suggest that developing greater understanding, and thus a better attitude towards the client group, would benefit forensic mental health nurses. This in turn, would enable them to engage in a reflective process regarding their professional practice, and, as a result, improve the provision of nursing care. Such commentary is valuable, but is based upon observation and experience rather than research.

Care planning: a neoliberal three card trick

Introduction The three card game, sometimes called find the queen, is a classic confidence trick, typically taking place on an impromptu table top, set up on pavement or street corner. The tricksters usually operate in teams, pulling in punters and ‘losing’ games with their fellows to persuade prospective speculators the game is winnable. For our titular purposes the three card trick serves as a metaphor for broader deceits. We are concerned with how well-meaning mental health nurses can enter into a set of apparently rational practices, insisted upon by policy and protocol, seemingly motivated by ideals of care and protection from harm, yet functioning to destroy the very essence of what it might mean to be a caring, progressive practitioner by contributing to a mutuality of alienation that, at the relational level, is the opposite of what services intend to achieve. This may prove to be the case because an external confidence trickster (neoliberalism) is actually in charge, and the real function of the game serves other ends. The whole point of the game is that genuine players can never win, and for the trickster to triumph it is necessary that these punters are willing, gullible and in most circumstances accept losses without too much fuss. When the losers do not go quietly this is referred to in the argot of the con as ‘squawking’, and personnel are deployed on the periphery to ensure any squawk is minimised. Various strategies can be used to ‘cool out the mark’, and are analogous to the means by which people are assisted to adjust to life’s disappointments in other contexts, including encounters with priests or sundry psy-professionals (Goffman 1952; McKeown et al. 2013). This commentary paper seeks to provoke nursing out of its state of gullibility and self-deception even if this involves painful reflection on the losses inherent in our collective game of mental health care. If we are to defend the importance of mental health nursing we must think more critically about our complicity within oppressive systems of control and do something about it. There is a lengthy critical tradition to draw on. We urge mental health nurses to squawk, asserting a more recalcitrant and rebellious standpoint, preferably in alliance with service users, refusers and survivors. Acknowledging the constraints upon nursing’s agency, deficits of power, and structural disadvantage need not default to impotence and inaction: collective resistance is always possible, however difficult the circumstances.

Turning the Tables

In bioethics, the concept of vulnerability is applied almost exclusively to research participants and patients. We turn the tables and apply the concept to nurses caring for anorexia nervosa (AN) sufferers. In doing so, and using results from a qualitative research study undertaken in the UK, we show that AN nurses face a significant probability of incurring identifiable harms (inauthentic relationships and nonreciprocal relationships). Some recommendations on how these harms can be avoided or mitigated are given, but further research is needed.

The impact of a night confinement policy on patients in a UK high secure inpatient mental health service

Purpose – From 2012, all high-secure forensic mental health services in England began operating a policy of confining patients to their locked bedrooms overnight to increase service efficiency and reduce costs. The purpose of this paper is to assess the views of staff and patients concerning the policy and examine the specific impact of the policy on patients. Design/methodology/approach – Measures of patients’ sleep hygiene, patients’ behaviour, ward atmosphere, engagement with therapy and adverse incidents were taken both before and after the night confinement (NC) policy was implemented. Both patients and staff also expressed their views of the impact of the NC policy. Findings – Results provide converging evidence that the impact of the NC policy on patients is negligible. There were no consistent negative effects of confining patients overnight. Rather, patients and staff were broadly positive about the impact that the practice had on patients. Practical implications – Confining patients to locked bedrooms overnight does not exert any consistent influence, positive or negative, on patients’ sleep hygiene, behaviour or engagement with therapy, and patients expressed a broadly positive view of the practice of NC. Thus, a NC policy may have a contribution to make to the provision an effective high-secure mental health service. Originality/value – The study provides convincing evidence that secure inpatient mental health services that are considering the adoption of a NC policy may do so without fear of a negative impact on patients.

“They’re Really PD Today” An Exploration of Mental Health Nursing Students’ Perceptions of Developing a Therapeutic Relationship With Patients With a Diagnosis of Antisocial Personality Disorder

The therapeutic relationship is of particular importance when working with patients with antisocial personality disorder, but despite this, there is a paucity of literature exploring student nurses’ perceptions of developing a therapeutic relationship with such patients. Hence, this qualitative study explored the perceptions of second-year mental health nursing students of developing a therapeutic relationship with this patient group. Student nurses from a University in the Northwest of England participated in two focus groups, to compare the perceptions of a group of student nurses who had experience in secure settings (forensic hospital) with those who had not. Four key themes emerged: diagnosis, safety, engagement, and finally environmental influences. Both groups commented on looking beyond the diagnosis and seeing the person. The student nurses cited other staff in their clinical placement areas as hugely influential in terms of the development of their perceptions of patients with antisocial personality disorder and how to relate to them.

“It’s not just about prostate cancer, it’s about being a gay man”: A qualitative study of gay men’s experiences of healthcare provision in the UK

Following a diagnosis of prostate cancer, men require information and support from healthcare providers which is tailored to their individual needs. Studies reporting on the needs of gay men with prostate cancer, and their experiences of healthcare provision, are lacking. This study highlights the issues affecting this group of men and the implications for healthcare delivery in the United Kingdom. In-depth interviews were conducted with 12 gay men who had been diagnosed with prostate cancer. A phenomenological approach was used to collect and analyse data. Participants wanted, and expected, candid discussions with healthcare professionals, about how prostate cancer could affect their lives, sexual function, and how to access culturally relevant support before and after treatment. Participants perceived that their healthcare team had little knowledge about their needs, and if, or how, their experience differed due to their sexual orientation. Information provided was perceived as being misplaced or informed by heteronormative assumptions. Consideration should be given to requesting sexual orientation when recording patient information, if patients are willing to disclose. Training should be provided for healthcare professionals to enable them to provide information and support that is culturally relevant at all stages of the consultation.

An Exploration of the Psychosocial Impact of Prostate Cancer on Gay Men: A Review of Current Literature

BACKGROUND: The World Health Organisation reports that cancer mortality rates in developing African countries are rising because late diagnosis limits treatment options. In the UK there is evidence of inequalities in the delivery of cancer services to black and minority ethnic groups contributing to deaths from late diagnoses. UK studies of the African population are limited and focus on the African Caribbean community. Hence, UK cancer prevention strategies may not account for the African population’s cultural beliefs or attitudes towards cancer; this may affect awareness of the signs and symptoms. AIM: To identify evidence-based information about African immigrants’ views regarding cancer. METHODS: Six databases were searched: Academic Search Complete, AMED, CINAHL, MEDLINE, PsycInfo, and Soc Index. The literature search was extended to include grey literature and a search of reference lists of relevant studies. Publications not written in English were excluded. RESULTS: Six qualitative, nine quantitative, and one mixed method study were identified; all except two were conducted in the USA. The majority indicated that African people had low levels of knowledge about cancer risk factors, signs and symptoms. Misconceptions, cultural and religious belief and fear appear to influence African people’s views towards cancer; this may affects their behaviour in terms of seeking treatment. CONCLUSION: This review demonstrates a need for UK based studies to determine the relevance of review findings towards, and fill the gaps in knowledge about, the growing UK based African population.