Karin S. Bentley

A Tiered Approach to Life Stages Testing for Agricultural Chemical Safety Assessment

Aproposal has been developed by the Agricultural Chemical Safety Assessment (ACSA) Technical Committee of the ILSI Health and Environmental Sciences Institute (HESI) for an improved approach to assessing the safety of crop protection chemicals. The goal is to ensure that studies are scientifically appropriate and necessary without being redundant, and that tests emphasize toxicological endpoints and exposure durations that are relevant for risk assessment. The ACSA Life Stages Task Force proposes a tiered approach to toxicity testing that assesses a compounds potential to cause adverse effects on reproduction, and that assesses the nature and severity of effects during development and adolescence, with consideration of the sensitivity of the elderly. While incorporating many features from current guideline studies, the proposed approach includes a novel rat reproduction and developmental study with enhanced endpoints and a rabbit development study. All available data, including toxicokinetics, ADMEdata, and systemic toxicity information, are considered in the design and interpretation of studies. Compared to existing testing strategies, the proposed approach uses fewer animals, provides information on the young animal, and includes an estimation of human exposure potential for making decisions about the extent of testing required.

Fluorescence in situ hybridisation with chromosome-specific centromeric probes: a sensitive method to detect aneuploidy.

Cytochalasin B-blocked binucleate human lymphocytes from female donors have been used to measure micronucleus induction and other aneuploidy events after treatment with colchicine, vinblastine or carbendazim. For the aneuploidy events, centromeric probes for 6 selected chromosomes (1, 8, X, 11, 17, 18) were used to measure chromosome loss, addition and non-disjunction in the interphase nuclei of these binucleate cells. The chromosomes were probed in pairs using Cy-3 (red) and FITC (green) labels for the 2 different centromeric regions. For colchicine, the total non-disjunction frequencies for chromosomes 1 and 8 were similar to the total micronucleus frequencies, but were detected as significant at lower concentrations. For vinblastine (chromosomes 1 and 8) and carbendazim (all 6 chromosomes) the frequencies of non-disjunction far exceeded (7 and > 2-fold, respectively) the peak frequencies of micronucleus induction. Although most chromosomes exhibited similar sensitivity in all the aneuploidy events measured, there was an indication that chromosome X was more than susceptible to non-disjunction than the other chromosomes. We believe that measurement of non-disjunction in binucleate human lymphocytes using chromosome specific centromeric probes offers a sensitive method for detection of aneuploidy and is particularly appropriate for the establishment of thresholds.

Evalution of benomyl and carbendazim in the vivo aneuploidy/micronucleus assay in BDF1 mouse bone marrow

Abstract Benomyl and its active metabolite carbendazim were investigated in BDF1 mouse bone marrow to establish whether micronuclei induced by these fungicides are caused by clastogenic or aneugenic events. Micronuclei were evaluated for kinetochores using immunofluorescent antikinetochore antibodies. Kinetochore positive (K + ) micronuclei are likely to arise from chromosome loss since they presumably contain intact kinetochores and are indicative of aneuploidy. Conversely, kinetochore negative (K − ) micronuclei are most likely to contain acentric chromosome fragments arising primarily from clastogenic damage. Benomyl and carbendazim were administered as single oral doses of 0.3, 8.6 or 17.2 mmol/kg (for benomyl, equivalent to 100, 2500 or 5000 mg/kg; for carbendazim, equivalent to 66, 1646 or 3293 mg/kg). Both compounds were positive in the micronucleus test at doses of 8.6 and 17.2 mmol/kg, and an average of 82% (benomyl)_and 87% (carbendazim) of the total micronucleated polychromatic erythrocytes were K + . No effects were seen with either fungicide at 0.3 mmol/kg. These results are analogous to findings with known aneugens such as vincristine but are in contrast to results with classical such as cyclophosphamide. Thus, benomyl and carbendazim induced micronuclei in mmouse bone marrow cells primarily throygh an aneugenic mechanism.

Relevance Weighting of Tier 1 Endocrine Screening Endpoints by Rank Order

Weight of evidence (WoE) approaches are recommended for interpreting various toxicological data, but few systematic and transparent procedures exist. A hypothesis-based WoE framework was recently published focusing on the U.S. EPAs Tier 1 Endocrine Screening Battery (ESB) as an example. The framework recommends weighting each experimental endpoint according to its relevance for deciding eight hypotheses addressed by the ESB. Here we present detailed rationale for weighting the ESB endpoints according to three rank ordered categories and an interpretive process for using the rankings to reach WoE determinations. Rank 1 was assigned to in vivo endpoints that characterize the fundamental physiological actions for androgen, estrogen, and thyroid activities. Rank 1 endpoints are specific and sensitive for the hypothesis, interpretable without ancillary data, and rarely confounded by artifacts or nonspecific activity. Rank 2 endpoints are specific and interpretable for the hypothesis but less informative than Rank 1, often due to oversensitivity, inclusion of narrowly context-dependent components of the hormonal system (e.g., in vitro endpoints), or confounding by nonspecific activity. Rank 3 endpoints are relevant for the hypothesis but only corroborative of Ranks 1 and 2 endpoints. Rank 3 includes many apical in vivo endpoints that can be affected by systemic toxicity and nonhormonal activity. Although these relevance weight rankings (WREL ) necessarily involve professional judgment, their a priori derivation enhances transparency and renders WoE determinations amenable to methodological scrutiny according to basic scientific premises, characteristics that cannot be assured by processes in which the rationale for decisions is provided post hoc.

A 1-year toxicity study in dogs is no longer a scientifically justifiable core data requirement for the safety assessment of pesticides.

A review of publications on pesticides assessing the need for 1-year toxicity studies in dogs was performed. Four key peer-reviewed papers with different approaches investigated the value of a 1-year dog study in addition to a 3-month study. Despite different databases and approaches, each concluded with the recommendation to limit the testing of pesticides in dogs to a duration of 3 months. The combined weight of evidence presented in this review reinforces these independent conclusions. Therefore, the routine inclusion of a 1-year dog study as a mandated regulatory requirement for the safety assessment of pesticides is no longer justifiable and a globally harmonized approach should be taken to match the latest legislation of the European Union and the US EPA.

Effect of 4-vinylcyclohexene on micronucleus formation in the bone marrow of rats and mice

This study was conducted to evaluate the potential of 4-vinylcyclohexene (VCH) to induce micronuclei in the bone marrow of mice and rats. Male and female Cr1:CD BR (Sprague-Dawley) rats and B6C3F1/CrBR mice were exposed to VCH 6 hr/day for 2 days or for 13 weeks. In the 2-day study, mice were exposed by inhalation to 0, 250, 500, or 1000 ppm, and rats were exposed to 0, 500, 1000, or 2000 ppm. In the 13-week study, mice were exposed to 0, 50, 250, or 1000 ppm, and rats were exposed to 0, 250, 1000, or 1500 ppm. In each study, a separate group of mice was exposed to 1000 ppm 1,3-butadiene (BD) so that a comparison could be made between the two compounds. Likewise, cyclophosphamide was also included for rats as a positive control. Bone marrow was collected from VCH-exposed animals approximately 24 h and 48 h after the final exposure. There were no statistically significant increases in micronucleatedpolychromatic erythrocytes (MN-PCEs) among VCH-treated mice and rats at any dose level or sampling interval at either 2-days or 13-weeks. Also, no statistically significant difierences in the polychromatic erythrocytes (PCE) to normochromatic erythrocytes (NCE) ratios were observed 273 in any of the VCH-treated mice and rats compared to air-exposed animals. As expected, both the butadiene-treated mice and the cyclophosphamide- treated rats showed significantly more MN-PCEs than the control animals.

Inhalation Toxicity and Genotoxicity of Hydrofluorocarbon (HFC)-236fa and HFC-236ea

The acute, subchronic, and developmental and genetic toxicity of hydrofluorocarbon (HFC)-236fa and HFC-236ea were evaluated to assist in establishing proper handling guidance. In acute inhalation studies, rats were exposed whole body for 4 hours to various concentrations of each isomer. Based on the lack of mortality, the approximate lethal concentration for HFC-236ea for male rats was > 85,000 ppm. For HFC-236fa, the LC50 for males and females (combined) was > 457,000 ppm. Narcotic-like effects, e.g., prostration, incoordination, and reduced motor activity, were observed only during exposure to either isomer, but were not evident after termination of exposure. In cardiac sensitization studies, HFC-236ea induced cardiac sensitization at ≥ 35,000 ppm, with fatal responses occurring at 50,000 ppm and greater. For HFC-236fa, a cardiac sensitization response was observed at 150,000 ppm and greater but not at 100,000 ppm. A fatal cardiac sensitization response was observed in one dog exposed to 150,000 ppm HFC-236fa. In 90-day subchronic inhalation studies, male and female rats were exposed whole body to HFC-236ea at concentrations of 0, 5000, 20,000, or 50,000 ppm for 6 hours/day, 5 days/week. Similarly, male and female rats were exposed whole body to HFC-236fa at concentrations of 0, 5000, 20,000, or 50,000 ppm for 6 hours/day, 5 days/week. During exposure, narcotic-like effect (reduced acoustic startle response) was observed at 50,000 ppm with both isomers, although there appeared to be an adaptive response to this effect as the study progressed. With HFC-236ea, dilatation of the seminiferous tubules, without effects on germ or Sertoli cells, was observed only in rats at 50,000 ppm. No other effects on in-life measures or on clinical or anatomic pathology, including histopathology, were observed for either isomer. In rat developmental toxicity studies, no evidence of embryotoxicity or teratogenicity was observed with either isomer exposed up to 50,000 ppm during gestational days 7 to 16. Also, no developmental toxicity was observed in rabbits exposed to HFC-236fa at concentrations of up to 50,000 ppm during gestational days 7 to 19. Neither of the HFC-236 isomers was mutagenic in the Ames reverse mutation assay or clastogenic in the chromosomal aberration assay with human lymphocytes. No increase in chromosomal aberrations was observed in in vivo micronucleus studies with either isomer.

Chapter 102 – Chlorantraniliprole: An Insecticide of the Anthranilic Diamide Class

Publisher Summary This chapter appraises the identity, metabolism, and toxicity of Chlorantraniliprole. It is a new insecticide belonging to the anthranilic diamide class of chemistry and is intended for the control of Lepidopteran, Coleopteran, and some Dipteran pests in commercial agriculture on both perennial and annual crops. Ingestion is the most effective method of entry and typically requires a lower dose for response. Chlorantraniliprole provides excellent plant protection since affected insects cease feeding almost immediately after contact with the product. The mode of action of Chlorantraniliprole is currently only shared with one other commercial insecticide active substance, flubendiamide. Insects exposed to Chlorantraniliprole exhibit general lethargy and muscle paralysis followed ultimately by death. Findings indicate that Chlorantraniliprole exhibits excellent differential selectivity for insect ryanodine receptors over mammalian ryanodine receptors. This selectivity is likely a major contributing factor to the mammalian safety observed with Chlorantraniliprole. It has no significant acute toxicity via the oral, dermal, and inhalation routes of exposure; is not an eye or skin irritant; and does not cause skin sensitization. The effects of Chlorantraniliprole on reproduction and development were investigated in developmental studies in both rat and rabbit and in a rat two-generation reproduction study. It has been manufactured and marketed for a limited time. No reports of adverse health effects in manufacturing personnel or agricultural workers have been received.

An in vitro approach for comparative interspecies metabolism of agrochemicals

ABSTRACT The metabolism and elimination of a xenobiotic has a direct bearing on its potential to cause toxicity in an organism. The confidence with which data from safety studies can be extrapolated to humans depends, among other factors, upon knowing whether humans are systemically exposed to the same chemical entities (i.e. a parent compound and its metabolites) as the laboratory animals used to study toxicity. Ideally, to understand a metabolite in terms of safety, both the chemical structure and the systemic exposure would need to be determined. However, as systemic exposure data (i.e. blood concentration/time data of test material or metabolites) in humans will not be available for agrochemicals, an in vitro approach must be taken. This paper outlines an in vitro experimental approach for evaluating interspecies metabolic comparisons between humans and animal species used in safety studies. The aim is to ensure, where possible, that all potential human metabolites are also present in the species used in the safety studies. If a metabolite is only observed in human in vitro samples and is not present in a metabolic pathway defined in the toxicological species already, the toxicological relevance of this metabolite must be evaluated. HIGHLIGHTSGuidance outlining in vitro comparative metabolism approaches for agrochemicals.The design allows metabolic comparison between humans and species in safety studies.This experimental approach allows identification of human unique metabolites.Human unique metabolites may need to be addressed in the regulatory risk assessment.

Relevance of the 1-year dog study in assessing human health risks for registration of pesticides. An update to include pesticides registered in Japan.

Abstract Over 400 active pesticides are registered in Japan (4). The results of dog toxicity studies (usually, the 1-year study) were used by the Japanese regulatory authorities to establish the acceptable daily intake (ADI) for 45 pesticide active ingredients (about 9%). A retrospective review of ADIs established in Japan with dog studies as pivotal data for their derivation was performed: the ADIs were reassessed under the assumption that the 1-year dog study would not be available and an alternate ADI was derived based on the remaining toxicology database. In 35 of the 45 cases (77.8%) the ADI resulting from the absence of the 1-year dog study was no greater than twice the Japanese ADI, a difference considered not to be of biological significance. In 6 cases (13%) the resulting ADI was 2–5 times higher, which is considered of questionable biological relevance. On further evaluation of the database, three of these six cases were assessed as to clarify that there is no clear difference and for the other three additional studies to clarify that uncertain findings would have been required. In 3 of the 45 cases (7%) there may be a real difference within the ADI ratio of 2–5. Only in 1 case (2.2%) ADI was five times higher than that has been set. Accordingly, the absence of a 1-year dog study does not appear to influence the ADI derivation in a relevant manner in more than 98% of cases. For the four compounds with a real difference in ADI, consumer exposure would still be well below the alternative ADI. Therefore, a strong case can be made that the standard mandatory requirement to conduct a 1-year dog study, in addition to the 3-month study, is not justified and of no additional value in protecting human health. In addition, a substantial reduction in test animals could be achieved.