Karine Smans

Lipogenesis and lipolysis: the pathways exploited by the cancer cells to acquire fatty acids

One of the most important metabolic hallmarks of cancer cells is enhanced lipogenesis. Depending on the tumor type, tumor cells synthesize up to 95% of saturated and mono-unsaturated fatty acids (FA) de novo in spite of sufficient dietary lipid supply. This lipogenic conversion starts early when cells become cancerous and further expands as the tumor cells become more malignant. It is suggested that activation of FA synthesis is required for carcinogenesis and for tumor cell survival. These observations suggest that the enzymes involved in FA synthesis would be rational therapeutic targets for cancer treatment. However, several recent reports have shown that the anti-tumor effects, following inhibition of endogenous FA synthesis in cancer cell lines may be obviated by adding exogenous FAs. Additionally, high intake of dietary fat is reported to be a potential risk factor for development and poor prognosis for certain cancers. Recently it was reported that breast and liposarcoma tumors are equipped for both de novo fatty acid synthesis pathway as well as LPL-mediated extracellular lipolysis. These observations indicate that lipolytically acquired FAs may provide an additional source of FAs for cancer. This review focuses on our current understanding of lipogenic and lipolytic pathways in cancer cell progression.

De novo Lipogenesis Protects Cancer Cells from Free Radicals and Chemotherapeutics by Promoting Membrane Lipid Saturation

Activation of de novo lipogenesis in cancer cells is increasingly recognized as a hallmark of aggressive cancers and has been implicated in the production of membranes for rapid cell proliferation. In the current report, we provide evidence that this activation has a more profound role. Using a mass spectrometry-based phospholipid analysis approach, we show that clinical tumor tissues that display the lipogenic phenotype show an increase in the degree of lipid saturation compared with nonlipogenic tumors. Reversal of the lipogenic switch in cancer cells by treatment with the lipogenesis inhibitor soraphen A or by targeting lipogenic enzymes with small interfering RNA leads to a marked decrease in saturated and mono-unsaturated phospholipid species and increases the relative degree of polyunsaturation. Because polyunsaturated acyl chains are more susceptible to peroxidation, inhibition of lipogenesis increases the levels of peroxidation end products and renders cells more susceptible to oxidative stress-induced cell death. As saturated lipids pack more densely, modulation of lipogenesis also alters lateral and transversal membrane dynamics as revealed by diffusion of membrane-targeted green fluorescent protein and by the uptake and response to doxorubicin. These data show that shifting lipid acquisition from lipid uptake toward de novo lipogenesis dramatically changes membrane properties and protects cells from both endogenous and exogenous insults. These findings provide important new insights into the role of de novo lipogenesis in cancer cells, and they provide a rationale for the use of lipogenesis inhibitors as antineoplastic agents and as chemotherapeutic sensitizers.

ATP-Citrate Lyase: A Key Player in Cancer Metabolism

ATP-citrate lyase (ACLY) is a cytosolic enzyme that catalyzes the generation of acetyl CoA from citrate. Acetyl CoA is a vital building block for the endogenous biosynthesis of fatty acids and cholesterol and is involved in isoprenoid-based protein modifications. Acetyl CoA is also required for acetylation reactions that modify proteins, such as histone acetylation. ACLY is upregulated or activated in several types of cancers, and its inhibition is known to induce proliferation arrest in cancer cells both in vitro and in vivo. The present review highlights current knowledge about the role of ACLY in cancer cells, with special reference to the different pathways that are linked by ACLY.

ATP-citrate lyase: a mini-review.

ATP-citrate lyase (ACLY) is a cytosolic enzyme that catalyzes generation of acetyl-CoA from citrate. Acetyl-CoA is a vital building block for the endogenous biosynthesis of fatty acids and cholesterol and is involved in isoprenoid-based protein modifications. Acetyl-CoA is also required for acetylation reactions that modify proteins such as histone acetylation. In the present review some of the known features of ACLY such as tissue distribution, subcellular localization, enzymatic properties, gene regulation and associated physiological conditions are highlighted.

Cancer Cells Differentially Activate and Thrive on De Novo Lipid Synthesis Pathways in a Low-Lipid Environment

Increased lipogenesis is a hallmark of a wide variety of cancers and is under intense investigation as potential antineoplastic target. Although brisk lipogenesis is observed in the presence of exogenous lipids, evidence is mounting that these lipids may adversely affect the efficacy of inhibitors of lipogenic pathways. Therefore, to fully exploit the therapeutic potential of lipid synthesis inhibitors, a better understanding of the interrelationship between de novo lipid synthesis and exogenous lipids and their respective role in cancer cell proliferation and therapeutic response to lipogenesis inhibitors is of critical importance. Here, we show that the proliferation of various cancer cell lines (PC3M, HepG2, HOP62 and T24) is attenuated when cultured in lipid-reduced conditions in a cell line-dependent manner, with PC3M being the least affected. Interestingly, all cell lines - lipogenic (PC3M, HepG2, HOP62) as well as non-lipogenic (T24) - raised their lipogenic activity in these conditions, albeit to a different degree. Cells that attained the highest lipogenic activity under these conditions were best able to cope with lipid reduction in term of proliferative capacity. Supplementation of the medium with very low density lipoproteins, free fatty acids and cholesterol reversed this activation, indicating that the mere lack of lipids is sufficient to activate de novo lipogenesis in cancer cells. Consequently, cancer cells grown in lipid-reduced conditions became more dependent on de novo lipid synthesis pathways and were more sensitive to inhibitors of lipogenic pathways, like Soraphen A and Simvastatin. Collectively, these data indicate that limitation of access to exogenous lipids, as may occur in intact tumors, activates de novo lipogenesis is cancer cells, helps them to thrive under these conditions and makes them more vulnerable to lipogenesis inhibitors. These observations have important implications for the design of new antineoplastic strategies targeting the cancer cells lipid metabolism.

ATP Citrate Lyase Knockdown Induces Growth Arrest and Apoptosis through Different Cell- and Environment-Dependent Mechanisms

ATP citrate lyase (ACLY) is a cytosolic enzyme that catalyzes generation of acetyl-CoA, which is a vital building block for fatty acid, cholesterol, and isoprenoid biosynthesis. ACLY is upregulated in several types of cancer, and its inhibition induces proliferation arrest in certain cancer cells. As ACLY is involved in several pathways, its downregulation may affect multiple processes. Here, we have shown that short hairpin RNA-mediated ACLY silencing in cell lines derived from different types of cancers induces proliferation, cell-cycle arrest, and apoptosis. However, this antiproliferative effect of ACLY knockdown was observed only when cells were cultivated under lipid-reduced growth conditions. Proliferation arrest induced by ACLY silencing was partially rescued by supplementing the media with fatty acids and/or cholesterol. This indicates that the ACLY knockdown-mediated growth arrest might be the result of either fatty acid or cholesterol starvation or both. In the absence of ACLY, the cancer cells displayed elevated expression of sterol regulatory element binding protein–regulated downstream genes involved in de novo fatty acid and cholesterol biosynthesis. Furthermore, ACLY suppression resulted in elevated expression of acyl-CoA synthetase short-chain family member 2 (ACSS2), an enzyme that also produces acetyl-CoA using acetate as a substrate. Acetate supplementation partially rescued the cancer cells from ACLY suppression–induced proliferation arrest. We also observed that the absence of ACLY enhanced ACSS2-dependent lipid synthesis. These findings provide new insights into the role of ACLY in cancer cell growth and give critical information about the effects of ACLY silencing on different pathways. This information is crucial in understanding the possible application of ACLY inhibition in cancer therapeutics. Mol Cancer Ther; 11(9); 1925–35. ©2012 AACR.

Atypical plasma lipid profile in cancer patients: cause or consequence?

The aberrant blood lipoprotein levels in cancer patients are reported to be associated with cancer risk and mortality incidents however, there are several discrepancies in the previous reports. Hence the clinical usefulness of plasma/serum levels in risk stratification of a variety of cancers remains elusive. The present review highlights and compiles findings from different research groups regarding association of plasma lipoprotein levels with the risk of developing various types of cancer. We will discuss some prospective underlying mechanisms for this reported association. In addition to that the potential roles of plasma lipids in promoting carcinogenesis will be conferred.

Abstract 4747: Design and synthesis of a series highly potent and bioavailable FASN KR domain inhibitors for cancer

Fatty Acid Synthase (FASN) is a multi-domain protein that carries out de novo fatty acid (palmitate) synthesis from acetate and malonate in mammalian cells. FASN is up-regulated in cancer cells, providing fatty acid building blocks for rapid cell growth and cell division. Increased FASN expression is correlated with disease progression and poor prognosis in many cancers including prostate, breast, ovary, colon, and lung. FASN has been demonstrated to play an important role in carcinogenesis by protecting cells from apoptosis. Herein we report a new series of potent, selective and orally bioavailable FASN inhibitors. Recent publications disclose several FASN inhibitor chemotypes that share a common pharmacophore, wherein an aromatic group and an acylated cyclic amine are attached to a central scaffold. We postulated that a spirocyclic imidazolinone core would be an acceptable and drug-like scaffold, inspired by the precedent of irbesartan, an approved antihypertensive drug in which a spirocyclopentyl-imidazolinone core replaces the substituted imidazole ring of losartan, an older approved agent from the same drug class. This hypothesis led to a new spirocyclic imidazolinone based FASN inhibitors. Extensive SAR efforts resulted in FASN inhibitors with potent enzyme and cell activity, selectivity, and oral bioavailability exemplified by JNJ-54302833. JNJ-54302833 is a potent inhibitor of human FASN (IC50 = 28 nM) and also potently inhibits proliferation of A2780 ovarian cells (IC50 = 13 nM) in lipid-reduced medium. This cellular activity can be rescued by addition of palmitate, demonstrating on-target effects. JNJ-54302833 is also potent in many other cells, including PC3M (IC50 = 25 nM) and LnCaP-Vancouver prostate cells (IC50 = 66 nM), and is highly bioavailable (F 61%) with good exposures. In a pharmacodynamics study in H460 lung xenograft-bearing mice, oral treatment with JNJ-54302833 resulted in elevated tumor levels of malonyl-CoA and decreased tumor levels of palmitate. This novel series potently inhibits the FASN KR domain (IC50 = 54 nM for JNJ-54302833); specific binding to KR was confirmed by crystal structures.In summary, we have designed and discovered a new series of FASN inhibitors that are potent both in enzyme and in cell proliferation assays, are highly bioavailable, and bind to KR domain. Additionally, palmitate rescue of lipid-reduced cellular activity suggests selectivity and pharmacodynamics studies confirm target engagement. Citation Format: Tianbao Lu, Richard Alexander, Gilles Bignan, James Bischoff, Peter Connolly, Max Cummings, Sabine De Breucker, Norbert Esser, Erwin Fraiponts, Ron Gilissen, Bruce Grasberger, Boudewijn Janssens, Donald Ludovici, Lieven Meerpoel, Christophe Meyer, Michael Parker, Danielle Peeters, Carsten Schubert, Karine Smans, Luc Van Nuffel, Peter Vermeulen. Design and synthesis of a series highly potent and bioavailable FASN KR domain inhibitors for cancer. [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the 105th Annual Meeting of the American Association for Cancer Research; 2014 Apr 5-9; San Diego, CA. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Res 2014;74(19 Suppl):Abstract nr 4747. doi:10.1158/1538-7445.AM2014-4747

Abstract 801: Sensitivity of cell lines to Fatty Acid Synthase inhibitors depends on the lipid content in the cellular environment

Fatty Acid Synthase (FASN) catalyzes the final step in palmitate (PA) synthesis, using acetyl-CoA, malonyl-CoA and NADPH. Most normal tissues express low levels of FASN and rely on uptake of fatty acids (FA) from the diet. It has been proposed that FASN overexpressing tumors including prostate and breast tumors depend on de novo FA synthesis, which is advantageous to tumors by providing lipids for membrane synthesis and increased growth factor receptor expression/signaling in lipid rafts. Overexpression of FASN leads to a higher amount of saturated lipids in membranes which can lead to resistance to cytotoxic chemotherapy. Lastly, NADPH consumption during PA synthesis keeps the redox balance in check. All of the above imply that FASN represents a potential therapeutic target for the treatment of multiple cancer types. At this AACR we report two novel chemical series (posters Connolly et al., Lu et al.). JNJ-53793220 and JNJ-54302833 potently and selectively ( In a lipid reduced environment many cell lines, particularly of prostate, breast, ovarian or heme origin, proved to be sensitive to JNJ-53793220. However co-administration of PA dose-dependently reversed the anti-proliferative effects. Also androgen driven proliferation of LNCaP cells was potently blocked by JNJ-53793220 (EC50 30 nM), and decreased PSA levels. Both effects were partially rescued by the addition of PA. While the rescue of tumor cells by PA confirmed the on-target activity of the compounds, it also suggested that cancer cells are capable of using external FA. To extend these findings, we screened more than 400 cell lines in lipid containing medium (LCM) for their sensitivity to JNJ-53793220. In LCM sensitivity to FASN inhibition was lower than in LRM conditions. In most, but not all, cases the addition of PA reverted the antiproliferative effects of JNJ-53793220, although target engagement was not reduced in LCM conditions. The EC50 of 14C-acetate incorporation in lipids of ∼30 nM corresponded well with enzymatic and anti-proliferative effects in LRM (27 and 13 nM respectively). Furthermore, growth of pre-established LNCaP xenografts in vivo was not blocked significantly by JNJ-53793220, even though malonyl-CoA levels were increased as expected upon FASN inhibition in the tumor. While circulating lipids in vivo are likely culprits for the lack of efficacy, other factors may play a role as well. In a 3D culture model (poster Vidic et al.) the growth of LNCaP and PC346c spheroids was blocked by JNJ-54302833 (1µM), but growth of PC346c spheroids co-cultured with cancer associated fibroblasts was not inhibited. Taken together our data suggest that the outcome of FASN inhibition is influenced by the tumor environment. Citation Format: Karine A. Smans, Sabine De Breucker, Norbert Esser, Erwin Fraiponts, Ron Gilissen, Ralph Graeser, Boudewijn Janssen, Lieven Meerpoel, Danielle Peeters, Geert Van Hecke, Luc Van Nuffel, Yolanda Chong, Peter Vermeulen, Gilles Bignan, James Bischoff, Peter Connolly, Bruce Grasberger, Tianbao Lu, Donald Ludovici, Carsten Schubert, Michael Parker, Christophe Meyer, Suzana Vidic. Sensitivity of cell lines to Fatty Acid Synthase inhibitors depends on the lipid content in the cellular environment. [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the 105th Annual Meeting of the American Association for Cancer Research; 2014 Apr 5-9; San Diego, CA. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Res 2014;74(19 Suppl):Abstract nr 801. doi:10.1158/1538-7445.AM2014-801

Design and synthesis of a series of bioavailable fatty acid synthase (FASN) KR domain inhibitors for cancer therapy

We designed and synthesized a new series of fatty acid synthase (FASN) inhibitors with potential utility for the treatment of cancer. Extensive SAR studies led to highly active FASN inhibitors with good cellular activity and oral bioavailability, exemplified by compound 34. Compound 34 is a potent inhibitor of human FASN (IC50 = 28 nM) that effectively inhibits proliferation of A2780 ovarian cells (IC50 = 13 nM) in lipid-reduced serum (LRS). This cellular activity can be rescued by addition of palmitate, consistent with an on-target effect. Compound 34 is also active in many other cell types, including PC3M (IC50 = 25 nM) and LnCaP-Vancouver prostate cells (IC50 = 66 nM), and is highly bioavailable (F 61%) with good exposure after oral administration. In a pharmacodynamics study in H460 lung xenograft-bearing mice, oral treatment with compound 34 results in elevated tumor levels of malonyl-CoA and decreased tumor levels of palmitate, fully consistent with the desired target engagement.