Kelvin D. Montagu

Allometry for estimating aboveground tree biomass in tropical and subtropical eucalypt woodlands: towards general predictive equations

A fundamental tool in carbon accounting is tree-based allometry, whereby easily measured variables can be used to estimate aboveground biomass (AGB). To explore the potential of general allometry we combined raw datasets from 14 different woodland species, mainly eucalypts, from 11 sites across the Northern Territory, Queensland and New South Wales. Access to the raw data allowed two predictor variables, tree diameter (at 1.3-m height; D) and tree height (H), to be used singly or in various combinations to produce eight candidate models. Following natural log (ln) transformation, the data, consisting of 220 individual trees, were re-analysed in two steps: first as 20 species–site-specific AGB equations and, second, as a single general AGB equation. For each of the eight models, a comparison of the species–site-specific with the general equations was made with the Akaike information criterion (AIC). Further model evaluation was undertaken by a leave-one-out cross-validation technique. For each of the model forms, the species–site-specific equations performed better than the general equation. However, the best performing general equation, ln(AGB) = –2.0596 + 2.1561 ln(D) + 0.1362 (ln(H))2, was only marginally inferior to the species–site-specific equations. For the best general equation, back-transformed predicted v. observed values (on a linear scale) were highly concordant, with a slope of 0.99. The only major deviation from this relationship was due to seven large, hollow trees (more than 35% loss of cross-sectional stem area at 1.3 m) at a single species–site combination. Our best-performing general model exhibited remarkable stability across species and sites, when compared with the species–site equations. We conclude that there is encouraging evidence that general predictive equations can be developed across sites and species for Australia’s woodlands. This simplifies the conversion of long-term inventory measurements into AGB estimates and allows more resources to be focused on the extension of such inventories.

Patterns of Below- and Aboveground Biomass in Eucalyptus populnea Woodland Communities of Northeast Australia along a Rainfall Gradient

In vegetated terrestrial ecosystems, carbon in below- and aboveground biomass (BGB, AGB) often constitutes a significant component of total-ecosystem carbon stock. Because carbon in the BGB is difficult to measure, it is often estimated using BGB to AGB ratios. However, this ratio can change markedly along resource gradients, such as water availability, which can lead to substantial errors in BGB estimates. In this study, BGB and AGB sampling was carried out in Eucalyptus populnea-dominated woodland communities of northeast Australia to examine patterns of BGB to AGB ratio and vertical root distribution at three sites along a rainfall gradient (367, 602, and 1,101 mm). At each site, a vegetation inventory was undertaken on five transects (100 × 4 m), and trees representing the E. populnea vegetation structure were harvested and excavated to measure aboveground and coarse-root (diameter of at least 15 mm) biomass. Biomass of fine and small roots (diameter less than 15 mm) at each site was estimated from 40 cores sampled to 1 m depth. The BGB to AGB ratio of E. populnea-dominated woodland plant communities declined from 0.58 at the xeric end to 0.36 at the mesic end of the rainfall gradient. This was due to a marked decline in AGB with increased aridity whereas the BGB was relatively stable. The vertical distribution of fine roots in the top 1 m of soil varied along the rainfall gradient. The mesic sites had more fine-root biomass (FRB) in the upper soil profile and less at depth than the xeric site. Accordingly, at the xeric site, a much larger proportion of FRB was found at depth compared to the mesic sites. The vertical distribution patterns of small roots of the E. populnea woodland plant communities were consistently )-shaped, with the highest biomass occurring at 15–30-cm depth. The potential significance of such a rooting pattern for grass–tree and shrub–tree co-existence in these ecosystems is discussed. Overall, our results revealed marked changes in BGB to AGB ratio of E. populnea woodland communities along a rainfall gradient. Because E. populnea woodlands cover a large area (96 M ha), their contribution to continental-scale carbon sequestration and greenhouse gas emission can be substantial. Use of the rainfall-zone-specific ratios found in this study, in lieu of a single generic ratio for the entire region, will significantly improve estimates of BGB carbon stocks in these woodlands. In the absence of more specific data, our results will also be relevant in other regions with similar vegetation and rainfall gradients (that is, arid and semiarid woodland ecosystems).

Leaf water use efficiency differs between Eucalyptus seedlings from contrasting rainfall environments

This study investigates the putative role of thicker leaves in enhancing photosynthetic capacity and water-use efficiency (WUE) of Eucalyptus species native to xeric environments. Three Eucalyptus species, Eucalyptus grandis Hill. (ex Maiden), E. sideroxylon Cunn. (ex Woolls) and E. occidentalis (Endl.), were grown under well-watered or water-limited conditions in a single compartment of a temperature-controlled glasshouse. Eucalyptus grandis is native to a mesic environment while E. sideroxylon and E. occidentalis are native to xeric environments. Leaves of E. sideroxylon and E. occidentalis were thicker and contained more nitrogen (N) on a leaf-area basis than E. grandis. Leaf gas-exchange measurements indicated that the photosynthetic capacity of E. sideroxylon and E.occidentalis was greater than E. grandis and that stomatal conductance and WUE were negatively correlated. Whole-plant, gas-exchange and carbon-isotope measurements showed that E. sideroxylon and E. occidentalis had lower WUE than E. grandis under both well-watered and water-limited conditions. However, there was no difference in N-use efficiency between species. We suggest that stomatal conductance and leaf N content are functionally linked in these seedlings and conclude that thick leaves can, in some conditions, result in low WUE.

Evaluation of a semi-empirical model for predicting fine root biomass in compositionally complex woodland vegetation

We used measures of plant size, distribution and root core data to evaluate capability of the model of Ammer and Wagner [2] for spatially explicit prediction of fine root biomass (FRB) in Eucalyptus populnea-dominaied woodlands from xeric and mesic regions of Australia. Tree diameter and height were tested as proxy variables for plant size. For the xeric site, which had no understorey grass cover, both the height- and diameter-based models gave reasonable estimates of FRB. However, the height-model provided a better match to the measured data than the diameter-model. For the mesic site, which had a substantial ground cover dominated by C4-grasses whose contribution to FRB could not be captured by the model, neither the height- nor the diameter- model was able to predict FRB satisfactorily. This was also the case even when the contribution of the C4-grasses to FRB was estimated and accounted for after δ13C analysis of fine root samples. Overall, while it is evident that the model can be a useful tool for estimating FRB from aboveground stand inventory in both even-aged plantations and compositionally complex natural vegetation, it is also clear that it does not always provide satisfactory prediction, e.g., the mesic site. Thus, to improve the wider applicability of the model further work is needed to identify why it fails and situations it is likely to be useful.RésuméNous avons utilisé des mesures de dimensions des plants, de distribution et de carotte de racine pour évaluer la capacité du modèle de Ammer et Wagner [2] pour une prédiction spatiale explicite de la biomasse des fines racines (FRB) dans des zones boisées où Eucalyptus populnea est dominant, dans les régions très sèches et mésoïques d’Australie. La hauteur et le diamètre des arbres ont été testés comme des variables de procuration de la dimension du plant. Pour le site sec qui n’avait pas de sous-bois herbeux, l’un et l’autre des modèles basés sur la hauteur et le diamètre donnent une estimation raisonnable de FRB. Cependant, le modèle hauteur fourni une meilleure adéquation aux données mesurées que le modèle diamètre. Pour le site mésoïque, qui a une couverture herbeuse importante dominée par des espèces en C4 et dont la contribution à FRB ne peut pas être prise en compte par le modèle, ni l’un ni l’autre du modèle hauteur et du modèle diamètre était capable de prédire FRB correctement. C’était aussi le cas même quand la contribution des herbes en C4 à FRB a été estimée et justifiée par des analyses de δ13C de fines racines. En général, quoiqu’il soit évident que le modèle peut être un outil utile pour estimer FRB à partir d’un inventaire au-dessus du sol dans les deux plantations équiennes et dans la végétation naturelle composite, il est aussi clair que cela ne permet pas toujours une prédiction satisfaisante, par exemple pour le site moyennement sec. Alors, pour améliorer une plus large applicabilité du modèle davantage de travail est nécessaire pour identifier pourquoi il ne convient pas et les situations où il est possible de l’utiliser.

Corrigendum to: Leaf water use efficiency differs between Eucalyptus seedlings from contrasting rainfall environments

This study investigates the putative role of thicker leaves in enhancing photosynthetic capacity and water-use efficiency (WUE) of Eucalyptus species native to xeric environments. Three Eucalyptus species, Eucalyptus grandis Hill. (ex Maiden), E. sideroxylon Cunn. (ex Woolls) and E. occidentalis (Endl.), were grown under well-watered or water-limited conditions in a single compartment of a temperature-controlled glasshouse. Eucalyptus grandis is native to a mesic environment while E. sideroxylon and E. occidentalis are native to xeric environments. Leaves of E. sideroxylon and E. occidentalis were thicker and contained more nitrogen (N) on a leaf-area basis than E. grandis. Leaf gas-exchange measurements indicated that the photosynthetic capacity of E. sideroxylon and E.occidentalis was greater than E. grandis and that stomatal conductance and WUE were negatively correlated. Whole-plant, gas-exchange and carbon-isotope measurements showed that E. sideroxylon and E. occidentalis had lower WUE than E. grandis under both well-watered and water-limited conditions. However, there was no difference in N-use efficiency between species. We suggest that stomatal conductance and leaf N content are functionally linked in these seedlings and conclude that thick leaves can, in some conditions, result in low WUE.