L. Giannone

Physics optimization of stellarators

The theoretical and experimental development of stellarators has removed some of the specific deficiencies of this configuration, viz., the limitations in β, the high neoclassical transport, and the low collisionless confinement of α particles. These optimized stellarators can best be realized with a modular coil system. The W7‐AS experiment [Plasma Phys. Controlled Fusion 31, 1579 (1989)] has successfully demonstrated two aspects of advanced stellarators, the improved equilibrium and the modular coil concept. Stellarator optimization will much more viably be demonstrated by W7‐X [Plasma Physics and Controlled Fusion Research, Proceedings of the 12th International Conference, Nice, 1988 (IAEA, Vienna, 1989), Vol. 2, p. 369], the successor experiment presently under design. Optimized stellarators seem to offer an independent reactor option. In addition, they supplement, in a unique form, the toroidal confinement fusion program, e.g., energy transport is anomalous in stellarators too, but possibly more easily understandable in the frame of existing theoretical concepts than in tokamaks.

Divertor power load feedback with nitrogen seeding in ASDEX Upgrade

Feedback control of the divertor power load by means of nitrogen seeding has been developed into a routine operational tool in the all-tungsten clad ASDEX Upgrade tokamak. For heating powers above about 12?MW, its use has become inevitable to protect the divertor tungsten coating under boronized conditions. The use of nitrogen seeding is accompanied by improved energy confinement due to higher core plasma temperatures, which more than compensates the negative effect of plasma dilution by nitrogen on the neutron rate. This paper describes the technical details of the feedback controller. A simple model for its underlying physics allows the prediction of its behaviour and the optimization of the feedback gain coefficients used. Storage and release of nitrogen in tungsten surfaces were found to have substantial impact on the behaviour of the seeded plasma, resulting in increased nitrogen consumption with unloaded walls and a latency of nitrogen release over several discharges after its injection. Nitrogen is released from tungsten plasma facing components with moderate surface temperature in a sputtering-like process; therefore no uncontrolled excursions of the nitrogen wall release are observed. Overall, very stable operation of the high-Z tokamak is possible with nitrogen seeding, where core radiative losses are avoided due to its low atomic charge Z and a high ELM frequency is maintained.

Impurity seeding for tokamak power exhaust: from present devices via ITER to DEMO

A future fusion reactor is expected to have all-metal plasma facing materials (PFMs) to ensure low erosion rates, low tritium retention and stability against high neutron fluences. As a consequence, intrinsic radiation losses in the plasma edge and divertor are low in comparison to devices with carbon PFMs. To avoid localized overheating in the divertor, intrinsic low-Z and medium-Z impurities have to be inserted into the plasma to convert a major part of the power flux into radiation and to facilitate partial divertor detachment. For burning plasma conditions in ITER, which operates not far above the L–H threshold power, a high divertor radiation level will be mandatory to avoid thermal overload of divertor components. Moreover, in a prototype reactor, DEMO, a high main plasma radiation level will be required in addition for dissipation of the much higher alpha heating power. For divertor plasma conditions in present day tokamaks and in ITER, nitrogen appears most suitable regarding its radiative characteristics. If elevated main chamber radiation is desired as well, argon is the best candidate for the simultaneous enhancement of core and divertor radiation, provided sufficient divertor compression can be obtained. The parameter Psep/R, the power flux through the separatrix normalized by the major radius, is suggested as a suitable scaling (for a given electron density) for the extrapolation of present day divertor conditions to larger devices. The scaling for main chamber radiation from small to large devices has a higher, more favourable dependence of about Prad,main/R2. Krypton provides the smallest fuel dilution for DEMO conditions, but has a more centrally peaked radiation profile compared to argon. For investigation of the different effects of main chamber and divertor radiation and for optimization of their distribution, a double radiative feedback system has been implemented in ASDEX Upgrade (AUG). About half the ITER/DEMO values of Psep/R have been achieved so far, and close to DEMO values of Prad,main/R2, albeit at lower Psep/R. Further increase of this parameter may be achieved by increasing the neutral pressure or improving the divertor geometry.

Major results from the stellarator Wendelstein 7-AS (Review Article)

Wendelstein 7-AS was the first modular stellarator device to test some basic elements of stellarator optimization: a reduced Shafranov shift and improved stability properties resulted in β-values up to 3.4% (at 0.9 T). This operational limit was determined by power balance and impurity radiation without noticeable degradation of stability or a violent collapse. The partial reduction of neoclassical transport could be verified in agreement with calculations indicating the feasibility of the concept of drift optimization. A full neoclassical optimization, in particular a minimization of the bootstrap current was beyond the scope of this project. A variety of non-ohmic heating and current drive scenarios by ICRH, NBI and in particular, ECRH were tested and compared successfully with their theoretical predictions. Besides, new heating schemes of overdense plasmas were developed such as RF mode conversion heating—Ordinary mode, Extraordinary mode, Bernstein-wave (OXB) heating—or 2nd harmonic O-mode (O2) heating. The energy confinement was about a factor of 2 above ISS95 without degradation near operational boundaries. A number of improved confinement regimes such as core electron-root confinement with central Te ≤ 7 keV and regimes with strongly sheared radial electric field at the plasma edge resulting in Ti ≤ 1.7 keV were obtained. As the first non-tokamak device, W7-AS achieved the H-mode and moreover developed a high density H-mode regime (HDH) with strongly reduced impurity confinement that allowed quasi-steady-state operation (τ ≈ 65 · τE) at densities (at 2.5 T). The first island divertor was tested successfully and operated with stable partial detachment in agreement with numerical simulations. With these results W7-AS laid the physics background for operation of an optimized low-shear steady-state stellarator.

First island divertor experiments on the W7-AS stellarator

1. Abstract In the past, under limiter conditions, it has been impossible to produce high-power, highdensity, quasi-stationary neutral beam injection (NBI) discharges in W7-AS. Such discharges tended to evince impurity accumulation, lack of density control and subsequent radiation collapse (Normal Confinement). Presently, W7-AS is operating with a modular, open island divertor similar to that foreseen for W7-X. The divertor enables access to a new NBI heated, high density (ne up to 4·10 20 m -3 ) operating regime (High Density H-mode). It is extant above a threshold density, and is characterized by flat density profiles, high energyand low impurity confinement times and edge-localized radiation. The HDH-mode shows strong similarity to ELM-free H-mode scenarios previously observed in W7-AS, but in contrast to these avoids impurity accumulation. These new features enable full density control and quasi steady-state operation over many confinement times (at present only technically limited by the availability of NBI) also under conditions of partial detachment from the divertor targets. In HDH-mode, even in attached discharges, the divertor target load is considerable reduced. This is mainly due to favourable upstream conditions (higher nes), edge localized radiation and increased power deposition width. The benefits of the HDH-mode do not restrict only to hydrogen plasmas. They also occur ‐ albeit in a modified manner ‐ in deuterium plasmas. Undoubtedly, there are clear isotope effects between hydrogen and deuterium discharges. The results obtained in W7-AS render good prospects for W7-X and support the island divertor concept as a serious candidate for devices with magnetic islands at the edge. 2. Results Fig. 1 summarizes the behaviour of the energy confinement time E =W/Pabs, the normalized radiated power Prad/Pabs, and separatrix density nes obtained from quasi-stationary discharges with Pabs=1.4 MW as a function of the line-averaged density ne. E-values in NC follow the scaling E ISS95 =0.26· a 0.4 ·Bt 0.83 ·a 2.21 ·R 0.65 ·ne 0.51 ·Pabs -0.59 , [2], whereas for the HDH-mode one finds E ~ 2· E ISS95 . P rad /P abs grows smoothly with ne until partial plasma detachment, where a jump in the normalized radiated power occurs. The separatrix density n es increases sharply at the NC HDH-mode transition point, then continues to climb with ne and saturates

Assessment of compatibility of ICRF antenna operation with full W wall in ASDEX Upgrade

The compatibility of ICRF (ion cyclotron range of frequencies) antenna operation with high-Z plasma facing components is assessed in ASDEX Upgrade (AUG) with its tungsten (W) first wall.The mechanism of ICRF-related W sputtering was studied by various diagnostics including the local spectroscopic measurements of W sputtering yield YW on antenna limiters. Modification of one antenna with triangular shields, which cover the locations where long magnetic field lines pass only one out of two (0π)-phased antenna straps, did not influence the locally measured YW values markedly. In the experiments with antennas powered individually, poloidal profiles of YW on limiters of powered antennas show high YW close to the equatorial plane and at the very edge of the antenna top. The YW-profile on an unpowered antenna limiter peaks at the location projecting to the top of the powered antenna.An interpretation of the YW measurements is presented, assuming a direct link between the W sputtering and the sheath driving RF voltages deduced from parallel electric near-field (E||) calculations and this suggests a strong E|| at the antenna limiters. However, uncertainties are too large to describe the YW poloidal profiles.In order to reduce ICRF-related rise in W concentration CW, an operational approach and an approach based on calculations of parallel electric fields with new antenna designs are considered. In the operation, a noticeable reduction in YW and CW in the plasma during ICRF operation with W wall can be achieved by (a) increasing plasma–antenna clearance; (b) strong gas puffing; (c) decreasing the intrinsic light impurity content (mainly oxygen and carbon in AUG). In calculations, which take into account a realistic antenna geometry, the high E|| fields at the antenna limiters are reduced in several ways: (a) by extending the antenna box and the surrounding structures parallel to the magnetic field; (b) by increasing the average strap–box distance, e.g. by increasing the number of toroidally distributed straps; (c) by a better balance of (0π)-phased contributions to RF image currents.

Non-boronized compared with boronized operation of ASDEX Upgrade with full-tungsten plasma facing components

After completion of the tungsten coating of all plasma facing components, ASDEX Upgrade has been operated without boronization for 1 1/2 experimental campaigns. This has allowed the study of fuel retention under conditions of relatively low D co-deposition with low-Z impurities as well as the operational space of a full-tungsten device for the unfavourable condition of a relatively high intrinsic impurity level. Restrictions in operation were caused by the central accumulation of tungsten in combination with density peaking, resulting in H?L backtransitions induced by too low separatrix power flux. Most important control parameters have been found to be the central heating power, as delivered predominantly by ECRH, and the ELM frequency, most easily controlled by gas puffing. Generally, ELMs exhibit a positive impact, with the effect of impurity flushing out of the pedestal region overbalancing the ELM-induced W source. The restrictions of plasma operation in the unboronized W machine occurred predominantly under low or medium power conditions. Under medium-high power conditions, stable operation with virtually no difference between boronized and unboronized discharges was achieved. Due to the reduced intrinsic radiation with boronization and the limited power handling capability of VPS coated divertor tiles (?10?MW?m?2), boronized operation at high heating powers was possible only with radiative cooling. To enable this, a previously developed feedback system using (thermo-)electric current measurements as approximate sensor for the divertor power flux was introduced into the standard AUG operation. To avoid the problems with reduced ELM frequency due to core plasma radiation, nitrogen was selected as radiating species since its radiative characteristic peaks at lower electron temperatures in comparison with Ne and Ar, favouring SOL and divertor radiative losses. Nitrogen seeding resulted not only in the desired divertor power load reduction but also in improved energy confinement, as well as in smaller ELMs.

The Isotope Effect in ASDEX

The paper describes the effect of the isotopic mass on plasma parameters as observed in the ASDEX tokamak. The paper comprises Ohmic as well as L mode, H mode and H* mode scenarios. The measurements reveal that the ion mass is a substantial and robust parameter, which affects all the confinement times (energy, particle and momentum) in the whole operational window. Both core properties such as the sawtooth repetition time and edge properties such as the separatrix density change with the isotopic mass. Specific emphasis is given to the edge parameters and changes of the edge plasma due to different types of wall conditioning, such as carbonization and boronization. The pronounced isotope dependences of the edge and divertor parameters are explained by the secondary effect of different power fluxes into the scrape-off layer plasma and onto the divertor plates. Finally, the observations serve to test different transport theories. With respect to the ion temperature gradient driven turbulence, the isotope effect is also studied in pellet refuelled discharges with peaked density profiles. The results from ASDEX are compared with the results from other experiments

Tokamak operation with high-Z plasma facing components

Plasma operation with high-Z plasma facing components is investigated with regard to sputtering, core impurity contamination and scenario restrictions. A simple model based on dimensionless quantities for fuel and high-Z ion sources and transport to describe the high-Z concentration in the plasma core is introduced. The impurity release and further transport is factorized into the sputtering yield, the relative pedestal penetration probability and a core confinement enhancement factor. Since there are quite large uncertainties, in particular, in the sputtering source and the edge transport of high-Z impurities, very different scenarios covering a wide parameter range are taken into account in order to resolve the experimental trends. Sputtering of tungsten by charge exchange neutrals in the energy range 0.5–2 keV is comparable to the effect of impurity ion sputtering, while the impact of thermal fuel ions is negligible. Fast ions produced by neutral beam injection as well as sheath acceleration during ICR heating may cause considerable high-Z sources if the limiters on the lowfield side have high-Z surfaces. The critical behaviour of the central high-Z concentration in some experimental scenarios could be attributed to edge and core transport parameters in the concentration model. The improved H-mode with off-central heating turns out to be the most critical one, since a hot edge is combined with peaked density profiles. (Some figures in this article are in colour only in the electronic version)

Partial detachment of high power discharges in ASDEX Upgrade

Detachment of high power discharges is obtained in ASDEX Upgrade by simultaneous feedback control of core radiation and divertor radiation or thermoelectric currents by the injection of radiating impurities. So far 2/3 of the ITER normalized heat flux Psep/R = 15 MW m−1 has been obtained in ASDEX Upgrade under partially detached conditions with a peak target heat flux well below 10 MW m−2. When the detachment is further pronounced towards lower peak heat flux at the target, substantial changes in edge localized mode (ELM) behaviour, density and radiation distribution occur. The time-averaged peak heat flux at both divertor targets can be reduced below 2 MW m−2, which offers an attractive DEMO divertor scenario with potential for simpler and cheaper technical solutions. Generally, pronounced detachment leads to a pedestal and core density rise by about 20–40%, moderate (<20%) confinement degradation and a reduction of ELM size. For AUG conditions, some operational challenges occur, like the density cut-off limit for X-2 electron cyclotron resonance heating, which is used for central tungsten control.