Lalima G. Ahuja

Kinases and Pseudokinases: Lessons from RAF

ABSTRACT Protein kinases are thought to mediate their biological effects through their catalytic activity. The large number of pseudokinases in the kinome and an increasing appreciation that they have critical roles in signaling pathways, however, suggest that catalyzing protein phosphorylation may not be the only function of protein kinases. Using the principle of hydrophobic spine assembly, we interpret how kinases are capable of performing a dual function in signaling. Its first role is that of a signaling enzyme (classical kinases; canonical), while its second role is that of an allosteric activator of other kinases or as a scaffold protein for signaling in a manner that is independent of phosphoryl transfer (classical pseudokinases; noncanonical). As the hydrophobic spines are a conserved feature of the kinase domain itself, all kinases carry an inherent potential to play both roles in signaling. This review focuses on the recent lessons from the RAF kinases that effectively toggle between these roles and can be “frozen” by introducing mutations at their hydrophobic spines.

Kinase Regulation by Hydrophobic Spine Assembly in Cancer

ABSTRACT A new model of kinase regulation based on the assembly of hydrophobic spines has been proposed. Changes in their positions can explain the mechanism of kinase activation. Here, we examined mutations in human cancer for clues about the regulation of the hydrophobic spines by focusing initially on mutations to Phe. We identified a selected number of Phe mutations in a small group of kinases that included BRAF, ABL1, and the epidermal growth factor receptor. Testing some of these mutations in BRAF, we found that one of the mutations impaired ATP binding and catalytic activity but promoted noncatalytic allosteric functions. Other Phe mutations functioned to promote constitutive catalytic activity. One of these mutations revealed a previously underappreciated hydrophobic surface that functions to position the dynamic regulatory αC-helix. This supports the key role of the C-helix as a signal integration motif for coordinating multiple elements of the kinase to create an active conformation. The importance of the hydrophobic space around the αC-helix was further tested by studying a V600F mutant, which was constitutively active in the absence of the negative charge that is associated with the common V600E mutation. Many hydrophobic mutations strategically localized along the C-helix can thus drive kinase activation.

Divalent Metal Ions Mg2+ and Ca2+ Have Distinct Effects on Protein Kinase A Activity and Regulation

cAMP-dependent protein kinase (PKA) is regulated primarily in response to physiological signals while nucleotides and metals may provide fine-tuning. PKA can use different metal ions for phosphoryl transfer, yet some, like Ca(2+), do not support steady-state catalysis. Fluorescence Polarization (FP) and Surface Plasmon Resonance (SPR) were used to study inhibitor and substrate interactions with PKA. The data illustrate how metals can act differentially as a result of their inherent coordination properties. We found that Ca(2+), in contrast to Mg(2+), does not induce high-affinity binding of PKA to pseudosubstrate inhibitors. However, Ca(2+) works in a single turnover mode to allow for phosphoryl-transfer. Using a novel SPR approach, we were able to directly monitor the interaction of PKA with a substrate in the presence of Mg(2+)ATP. This allows us to depict the entire kinase reaction including complex formation as well as release of the phosphorylated substrate. In contrast to Mg(2+), Ca(2+) apparently slows down the enzymatic reaction. A focus on individual reaction steps revealed that Ca(2+) is not as efficient as Mg(2+) in stabilizing the enzyme:substrate complex. The opposite holds true for product dissociation where Mg(2+) easily releases the phospho-substrate while Ca(2+) traps both reaction products at the active site. This explains the low steady-state activity in the presence of Ca(2+). Furthermore, Ca(2+) is able to modulate kinase activity as well as inhibitor binding even in the presence of Mg(2+). We therefore hypothesize that the physiological metal ions Mg(2+) and Ca(2+) both play a role in kinase activity and regulation. Since PKA is localized close to calcium channels and may render PKA activity susceptible to Ca(2+), our data provide a possible mechanism for novel crosstalk between cAMP and calcium signaling.

A dynamic hydrophobic core orchestrates allostery in protein kinases

The synchronized motions of inner core residues allosterically modulate the activity of the protein kinase A catalytic subunit. Eukaryotic protein kinases (EPKs) constitute a class of allosteric switches that mediate a myriad of signaling events. It has been postulated that EPKs’ active and inactive states depend on the structural architecture of their hydrophobic cores, organized around two highly conserved spines: C-spine and R-spine. How the spines orchestrate the transition of the enzyme between catalytically uncommitted and committed states remains elusive. Using relaxation dispersion nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy, we found that the hydrophobic core of the catalytic subunit of protein kinase A, a prototypical and ubiquitous EPK, moves synchronously to poise the C subunit for catalysis in response to binding adenosine 5′-triphosphate. In addition to completing the C-spine, the adenine ring fuses the β structures of the N-lobe and the C-lobe. Additional residues that bridge the two spines (I150 and V104) are revealed as part of the correlated hydrophobic network; their importance was validated by mutagenesis, which led to inactivation. Because the hydrophobic architecture of the catalytic core is conserved throughout the EPK superfamily, the present study suggests a universal mechanism for dynamically driven allosteric activation of kinases mediated by coordinated signal transmission through ordered motifs in their hydrophobic cores.

Mutation of a kinase allosteric node uncouples dynamics linked to phosphotransfer

Significance Our Girvan–Newman-based community network analysis provides a strategy to explore the effects of protein kinase mutations on the dynamic properties of the kinase core and the allosteric network underlying the catalytic cycle. With this approach, which allows us to identify subtle shifts in dynamics and in particular side-chain rotamer preferences, we can explain the underlying mechanism for loss of function in many different scenarios. Our method is especially relevant for disease-causing mutations that lie far from the active site but show no obvious structural perturbations based on X-ray crystallography. The expertise of protein kinases lies in their dynamic structure, wherein they are able to modulate cellular signaling by their phosphotransferase activity. Only a few hundreds of protein kinases regulate key processes in human cells, and protein kinases play a pivotal role in health and disease. The present study dwells on understanding the working of the protein kinase-molecular switch as an allosteric network of “communities” composed of congruently dynamic residues that make up the protein kinase core. Girvan–Newman algorithm-based community maps of the kinase domain of cAMP-dependent protein kinase A allow for a molecular explanation for the role of protein conformational entropy in its catalytic cycle. The community map of a mutant, Y204A, is analyzed vis-à-vis the wild-type protein to study the perturbations in its dynamic profile such that it interferes with transfer of the γ-phosphate to a protein substrate. Conventional biochemical measurements are used to ascertain the effect of these dynamic perturbations on the kinetic profiles of both proteins. These studies pave the way for understanding how mutations far from the kinase active site can alter its dynamic properties and catalytic function even when major structural perturbations are not obvious from static crystal structures.

Molecular Analysis of Aedes aegypti Classical Protein Tyrosine Phosphatases Uncovers an Ortholog of Mammalian PTP-1B Implicated in the Control of Egg Production in Mosquitoes

Background Protein Tyrosine Phosphatases (PTPs) are enzymes that catalyze phosphotyrosine dephosphorylation and modulate cell differentiation, growth and metabolism. In mammals, PTPs play a key role in the modulation of canonical pathways involved in metabolism and immunity. PTP1B is the prototype member of classical PTPs and a major target for treating human diseases, such as cancer, obesity and diabetes. These signaling enzymes are, hence, targets of a wide array of inhibitors. Anautogenous mosquitoes rely on blood meals to lay eggs and are vectors of the most prevalent human diseases. Identifying the mosquito ortholog of PTP1B and determining its involvement in egg production is, therefore, important in the search for a novel and crucial target for vector control. Methodology/Principal Findings We conducted an analysis to identify the ortholog of mammalian PTP1B in the Aedes aegypti genome. We identified eight genes coding for classical PTPs. In silico structural and functional analyses of proteins coded by such genes revealed that four of these code for catalytically active enzymes. Among the four genes coding for active PTPs, AAEL001919 exhibits the greatest degree of homology with the mammalian PTP1B. Next, we evaluated the role of this enzyme in egg formation. Blood feeding largely affects AAEL001919 expression, especially in the fat body and ovaries. These tissues are critically involved in the synthesis and storage of vitellogenin, the major yolk protein. Including the classical PTP inhibitor sodium orthovanadate or the PTP substrate DiFMUP in the blood meal decreased vitellogenin synthesis and egg production. Similarly, silencing AAEL001919 using RNA interference (RNAi) assays resulted in 30% suppression of egg production. Conclusions/Significance The data reported herein implicate, for the first time, a gene that codes for a classical PTP in mosquito egg formation. These findings raise the possibility that this class of enzymes may be used as novel targets to block egg formation in mosquitoes.

Bi-Domain Protein Tyrosine Phosphatases Reveal an Evolutionary Adaptation to Optimize Signal Transduction

SIGNIFICANCE The bi-domain protein tyrosine phosphatases (PTPs) exemplify functional evolution in signaling proteins for optimal spatiotemporal signal transduction. Bi-domain PTPs are products of gene duplication. The catalytic activity, however, is often localized to one PTP domain. The inactive PTP domain adopts multiple functional roles. These include modulation of catalytic activity, substrate specificity, and stability of the bi-domain enzyme. In some cases, the inactive PTP domain is a receptor for redox stimuli. Since multiple bi-domain PTPs are concurrently active in related cellular pathways, a stringent regulatory mechanism and selective cross-talk is essential to ensure fidelity in signal transduction. RECENT ADVANCES The inactive PTP domain is an activator for the catalytic PTP domain in some cases, whereas it reduces catalytic activity in other bi-domain PTPs. The relative orientation of the two domains provides a conformational rationale for this regulatory mechanism. Recent structural and biochemical data reveal that these PTP domains participate in substrate recruitment. The inactive PTP domain has also been demonstrated to undergo substantial conformational rearrangement and oligomerization under oxidative stress. CRITICAL ISSUES AND FUTURE DIRECTIONS The role of the inactive PTP domain in coupling environmental stimuli with catalytic activity needs to be further examined. Another aspect that merits attention is the role of this domain in substrate recruitment. These aspects have been poorly characterized in vivo. These lacunae currently restrict our understanding of neo-functionalization of the inactive PTP domain in the bi-domain enzyme. It appears likely that more data from these research themes could form the basis for understanding the fidelity in intracellular signal transduction.

Decoding the Interactions Regulating the Active State Mechanics of Eukaryotic Protein Kinases.

Eukaryotic protein kinases regulate most cellular functions by phosphorylating targeted protein substrates through a highly conserved catalytic core. In the active state, the catalytic core oscillates between open, intermediate, and closed conformations. Currently, the intramolecular interactions that regulate the active state mechanics are not well understood. Here, using cAMP-dependent protein kinase as a representative model coupled with biochemical, biophysical, and computational techniques, we define a set of highly conserved electrostatic and hydrophobic interactions working harmoniously to regulate these mechanics. These include the previously identified salt bridge between a lysine from the β3-strand and a glutamate from the αC-helix as well as an electrostatic interaction between the phosphorylated activation loop and αC-helix and an ensemble of hydrophobic residues of the Regulatory spine and Shell. Moreover, for over three decades it was thought that the highly conserved β3-lysine was essential for phosphoryl transfer, but our findings show that the β3-lysine is not required for phosphoryl transfer but is essential for the active state mechanics.

A Catalytically Disabled Double Mutant of Src Tyrosine Kinase Can Be Stabilized into an Active-Like Conformation

Tyrosine kinases are enzymes playing a critical role in cellular signaling. Molecular dynamics umbrella sampling potential of mean force computations are used to quantify the impact of activating and inactivating mutations of c-Src kinase. The potential of mean force computations predict that a specific double mutant can stabilize c-Src kinase into an active-like conformation while disabling the binding of ATP in the catalytic active site. The active-like conformational equilibrium of this catalytically dead kinase is affected by a hydrophobic unit that connects to the hydrophobic spine network via the C-helix. The αC-helix plays a crucial role in integrating the hydrophobic residues, making it a hub for allosteric regulation of kinase activity and the active conformation. The computational free-energy landscapes reported here illustrate novel design principles focusing on the important role of the hydrophobic spines. The relative stability of the spines could be exploited in future efforts to artificially engineer active-like but catalytically dead forms of protein kinases.