Laurence P. G. Wakelin

Kinetics of drug-DNA interaction: Dependence of the binding mechanism on structure of the ligand

Abstract Kinetic and equilibrium studies of the binding of several phenanthridines and acridines to DNA have been performed to investigate the physical processes underlying the direct ligand transfer mechanism of drug-DNA interaction· Substitution of the 6-phenyl ring of dimidium with a p -carboxyl residue, or complete removal of either the 6-substituent or the 3-amino group, does not prevent the phenanthridine chromophore from transferring directly between binding sites. Loss of the aromatic ring increases association rate constants three- to ninefold and enhances dissociation rates by factors of up to 12; the rates of direct transfer and dissociation from site 1 are the most perturbed. The presence of a phenyl ring stabilizes the site 1 complex and lowers the binding constant to site 2. Introduction of the p -carboxyl group does not affect the equilibrium distribution of bound forms but produces equivalent increases (2·5-fold) in forward and reverse rate constants for binding to site 1 and for the direct transfer step. The 3-amino group greatly stabilizes the site 1 complex. Its removal accelerates all kinetic processes except for the reverse transfer step; the transfer rate is enhanced 25-fold and binding to site 2 is increased 12-fold. The dissociation rate from site 1 rises by a factor of 45 and that from site 2 by a factor of 5·8. 10-Methyl-9-aminoacridine binds via the direct transfer pathway with rate and equilibrium constants similar to those of the 3-desamino derivative of ethidium. This compound provides the first fully characterized example of an acridine that utilizes bimolecular transfer. By contrast, rivanol (6,9-diamino-2-ethoxyacridine) interacts with DNA via a two-step sequential mechanism analogous to that seen with proflavine, yet its intrinsic association constant is three times higher. This results from tighter ‘external’ attachment to the helix, together with a decrease in equilibrium constant for the insertion step, which is markedly slower than that of proflavine. There appears to be a simple relation between the apparent enthalpy of binding and the number of extracyclic amino substituents on the intercalating chromophore. We propose that the two bound forms that participate in direct ligand transfer represent molecules intercalated via one or other of the grooves of DNA, and that the transfer pathway corresponds to exchange of drug between the wide groove of one helix and the narrow groove of another. The ability to form strongly bound complexes at the surface of the helix appears to play a major role in determining the mechanism of ligand binding.

Mechanisms of Action of DNA Intercalating Acridine-based Drugs: How Important are Contributions from Electron Transfer and Oxidative Stress?

Reactive oxygen species (ROS) are produced continuously in living cells as a by-product of respiration and other metabolic activity. Some ROS may react with DNA, and in some cases may abstract an electron from the double helix, leading to long range electron transfer (ET) reactions. Thus, the DNA of living cells may be in a continuous state of ET. We consider here whether acridine-based anticancer or antimicrobial drugs, which bind to DNA by intercalation, might either donate electrons to, or accept electrons from, the double helix, thus actively participating in ET reactions. We focus in particular on two acridine-based drugs that have been tested against human cancer in the clinic. Amsacrine is a 9-anilinoacridine derivative that appears to act as an electron donor in ET reactions on DNA, while N-[2-(dimethylamino)ethyl]acridine-4-carboxamide (DACA) may act as an electron acceptor. Such reactions may make important contributions to the antitumor activity of these drugs.

A solvent-partition method for measuring the binding of drugs to DNA. Application to the quinoxaline antibiotics echinomycin and triostin A

The development of a novel solvent-partition method for measuring the interaction between nucleic acids and drugs of limited water solubility is described. Factors relevant to the choice of a suitable water-immiscible solvent are summarised. i-Amyl acetate was selected for studying the binding of echinomycin and triostin A to DNA. Details of the experimental determination of extinction and partition coefficients are given; in the i-amyl acetate/buffer system employed for most experiments, the partition coefficients for echinomycin and triostin A were 111 +/- 4 and 943 +/- 23, respectively. Equilibration of echinomycin between the organic and aqueous phases was 90% complete within a few minutes, and a period of 2 h shaking was found satisfactory to ensure full attainment of equilibrium. Representative results are presented showing specific binding of the quinoxaline antibiotics to DNA, strong preference for double-helical as opposed to heat-denatured or single-stranded DNA, and restricted uptake by closed circular duplex PM2 DNA. The method is potentially applicable, with appropriate modifications, to the study of interactions between other ligands and DNA.

Equilibrium constants for the binding of an homologous series of monofunctional and bifunctional intercalating diacridines to calf thymus DNA.

The search for drugs having enhanced af”finity and specifkity for binding to DNA centres largely on bifunctional intercalating agents [l--9

Radiosensitization of Mammalian Cells in Vitro by Nitroacridines

Thr; expectation is that the free energy ofbinding o~~h~omopho~es may be additive in po~yfun~tjun~ ~om~unds= However, many factors influence a~o~~at~~n cor&mtss, e.

The interaction of substituted and rigidly linked diquinolines with DNA

,, entrupy and enthaIpy effects durs to hydra~#n and st~re~~hern~~~ oonstra&ts inposed by the po&me~+, and it has not yet been estabhshed to what

Structural Characterisation of Bisintercalation in Higher-order DNA at a Junction-like Quadruplex

The nitroacridine nitracrine (1-NC) is a DNA intercalator and a hypoxia-selective, electron-affinic radiosensitizer. Sensitization of Chinese hamster fibroblast cultures at 0 degrees C by the nitro positional isomers of 1-NC has now been compared to help establish structure-activity relationships. The des-nitro analog (E(1) at pH 7 = -899 mV) did not sensitize, suggesting that an electron-affinic chromophore is required. All the nitroacridines (E(1) range -376 to -257 mV) sensitized hypoxic cells with a maximum sensitizer enhancement ratio of about 1.7, but with a 200-fold range in potency. When mean intracellular drug concentrations were compared, 2-, 3-, and 4-NC had potencies which were similar, independent of E(1), and no greater than predicted for non-DNA binding nitroheterocycles. Sensitization by these three isomers occurred at intracellular concentrations likely to saturate the potential intercalation sites on DNA. A large fraction of the radical sites sensitized by O2 are apparently inaccessible to these drugs. It is suggested that sensitization results from electron transfer from migrating transient charge carriers of low reduction potential to immobile bound intercalators. An additional sensitizing mechanism may be available to 1-NC, which was 20 times more potent, a potency not accounted for by E(1), cell uptake, or DNA binding affinity. The dissociation kinetics of the DNA-drug complex was faster for 1-NC than for the other isomers. The higher potency of 1-NC may reflect a short mean residence time (less than 1 ms) in its intercalation site, allowing significant mobility on the DNA within the lifetime of relatively stable radiation-induced target radicals.

Interaction of paired homologous series of diacridines and triacridines with deoxyribonucleic acid

DNA topoisomerase I (Top1) is over-expressed in tumour cells and is an important target in cancer chemotherapy. It relaxes DNA torsional strain generated during DNA processing by introducing transient single-strand breaks and allowing the broken strand to rotate around the intermediate Top1 – DNA covalent complex. This complex can be trapped by a group of anticancer agents interacting with the DNA bases and the enzyme at the cleavage site, preventing further topoisomerase activity. Here we have identified novel Top1 inhibitors as potential anticancer agents by using a combination of structure- and ligand-based molecular modelling methods. Pharmacophore models have been developed based on the molecular characteristics of derivatives of the alkaloid camptothecin (CPT), which represent potent antitumour agents and the main group of Top1 inhibitors. The models generated were used for in silico screening of the National Cancer Institute (NCI, USA) compound database, leading to the identification of a set of structurally diverse molecules. The strategy is validated by the observation that amongst these molecules are several known Top1 inhibitors and agents cytotoxic against human tumour cell lines. The potential of the untested hits to inhibit Top1 activity was further evaluated by docking into the binding site of a Top1 – DNA complex, resulting in a selection of 10 compounds for biological testing. Limited by the compound availability, 7 compounds have been tested in vitro for their Top1 inhibitory activity, 5 of which display mild to moderate Top1 inhibition. A further compound, found by similarity search to the active compounds, also shows mild activity. Although the tested compounds display only low in vitro antitumour activity, our approach has been successful in the identification of structurally novel Top1 inhibitors worthy of further investigation as potential anticancer agents.

DNA threading bis(9-aminoacridine-4-carboxamides): Effects of piperidine sidechains on DNA binding, cytotoxicity and cell cycle arrest

Viscometric measurements with circular and sonicated rodlike DNA fragments were used to explore whether ring substituents or conformationally restricted linkers promote bifunctional intercalation amongst a series of binuclear 4-aminoquinolines bridged via their 4-amino group. We find that ligands comprising unsubstituted quinolines and piperazine or pyrazole linkages bisintercalate. Quinoline-substituted alkyl-linked dimers intercalate in either a mixed monofunctional-bifunctional mode or bind with only one of their chromophores intercalated depending on the nature of the substituents. Equilibrium dialysis measurements show that the binding affinity for calf thymus DNA of the compounds studied ranges from (1.2-12) . 10(4) M-1 in buffer of ionic strength 0.1. Both co-operative and antico-operative binding isotherms were obtained and there is evidence for a second binding mode for the piperazine-linked diquinoline at saturating binding levels. For this compound the high-affinity association constant decreases with increasing ionic strength, 3.4 cations being released per bound ligand molecule. Partition dialysis measurements with DNAs of differing base composition indicate that the compounds studied are either AT selective or sequence neutral depending on ligand structure. For example, the pyrazole linker imparts a marked specificity for binding to AT-rich DNA, whereas the piperazine linker does not. Kinetic measurements using the surfactant-sequestration method reveal that DNA-diquinoline complexes dissociate very rapidly by complex mechanisms with rate constants greater than 100 s-1 in buffer of ionic strength 0.1.