Lawrence A. Amy

Onset of submarine debris flow deposition far from original giant landslide

Submarine landslides can generate sediment-laden flows whose scale is impressive. Individual flow deposits have been mapped that extend for 1,500 km offshore from northwest Africa. These are the longest run-out sediment density flow deposits yet documented on Earth. This contribution analyses one of these deposits, which contains ten times the mass of sediment transported annually by all of the world’s rivers. Understanding how this type of submarine flow evolves is a significant problem, because they are extremely difficult to monitor directly. Previous work has shown how progressive disintegration of landslide blocks can generate debris flow, the deposit of which extends downslope from the original landslide. We provide evidence that submarine flows can produce giant debris flow deposits that start several hundred kilometres from the original landslide, encased within deposits of a more dilute flow type called turbidity current. Very little sediment was deposited across the intervening large expanse of sea floor, where the flow was locally very erosive. Sediment deposition was finally triggered by a remarkably small but abrupt decrease in sea-floor gradient from 0.05° to 0.01°. This debris flow was probably generated by flow transformation from the decelerating turbidity current. The alternative is that non-channelized debris flow left almost no trace of its passage across one hundred kilometres of flat (0.2° to 0.05°) sea floor. Our work shows that initially well-mixed and highly erosive submarine flows can produce extensive debris flow deposits beyond subtle slope breaks located far out in the deep ocean.

Submarine pyroclastic deposits formed at the Soufrière Hills volcano, Montserrat (1995–2003): What happens when pyroclastic flows enter the ocean?

The Soufriere Hills volcano, Montserrat, West Indies, has undergone a series of dome growth and collapse events since the eruption began in 1995. Over 90% of the pyroclastic material produced has been deposited into the ocean. Sampling of these submarine deposits reveals that the pyroclastic flows mix rapidly and violently with the water as they enter the sea. The coarse components (pebbles to boulders) are deposited proximally from dense basal slurries to form steep-sided, near-linear ridges that intercalate to form a submarine fan. The finer ash-grade components are mixed into the overlying water column to form turbidity currents that flow over distances >30 km from the source. The total volume of pyroclastic material off the east coast of Montserrat exceeds 280 × 106 m3, with 65% deposited in proximal lobes and 35% deposited as distal turbidites.

Deposits of flows transitional between turbidity current and debris flow

The relationship between submarine sediment gravity flows and the character of their deposits is poorly understood. Annular flume experiments were used to investigate the depositional dynamics and deposits of waning sediment-laden flows. Decelerating fast (>3 m/s) flows with fixed sand content (10 vol%) and variable mud content (0–17 vol%) resulted in only four deposit types. Clean sand with a mud cap that resembled a turbidity current deposit (turbidite) formed if the flow was turbulent when deposition began, or if the muddy fluid had insufficient strength to suspend the sand. The clean sand could contain structures if mud content was low ( 300 s. Ungraded muddy sand with a mud cap that resembled a debris-flow deposit (debrite) formed if the flow became laminar before sand could deposit. Clean sand overlain by ungraded muddy sand and a mud cap formed either from a transitional flow or by late-stage settling of sand from a muddy suspension. These deposits resemble enigmatic submarine flow deposits called linked debrite-turbidites. The experiments provide a basis for inferring flow type from deposit character for submarine sediment-laden flows.

Facies architecture of the Gres de Peira Cava, SE France: landward stacking patterns in ponded turbiditic basins

Basins in which turbidity currents are completely or partially trapped are common in many tectonically active, deep-water settings. Field study of an Eocene–Oligocene turbiditic system in the Peïra Cava area, a sub-basin of the Alpine foreland in southeastern France, allows spatial characterization of a ponded basin fill on the basis of a correlation framework derived from measured outcrop sections and photomosaics. The basin-fill architecture comprises a sand-rich, proximal scour-and-fill facies and a downstream transition to mud-rich, basin-plain turbidite sheet facies. The proximal facies is interpreted to have formed directly downstream of a slope break, where currents were highly erosional during some periods and highly depositional during other periods, as a result of the interacting effects of turbulence enhancement and rapid deceleration. Both the proximal facies and the downstream transition to distal basin-plain facies occur in progressively landward positions at higher stratigraphic levels. The landward shift in depositional facies is likely to have resulted from the basin-floor aggradation and a landward migration of the slope break. This ‘back-stepping’ process may be expected to occur in many ponded turbiditic basins and to produce a similar type of sedimentary architecture.

The influence of a lateral basin-slope on the depositional patterns of natural and experimental turbidity currents

Abstract Understanding topographic effects upon the depositional processes of turbidity currents and the resulting deposit characteristics is key to producing reliable depositional models for turbidity currents. In this study, the effect on depositional patterns of a lateral slope whose strike is parallel to the principal direction of flow is explored using field and experimental results. This type of basin topography is commonly found in confined turbidite systems. Field data from the Peïra Cava turbidite system of the Tertiary Alpine Foreland Basin (SE France) and experimental data show that a characteristic depositional pattern is produced by surge-type waning flows that interact with a lateral slope. This pattern comprises beds that thin (and fine in the field study) not only downstream but also markedly away from the lateral slope (Type I beds). In the Peïra Cava system, this pattern is also observed in average values of sandstone bed thickness, sandstone percentage and grain-size, derived from measured sections, demonstrating that the processes responsible for this pattern also control gross properties within this sheet system. The characteristic thinning-away-from-slope deposit geometry is interpreted as an effect of the lateral slope via its influence on spatial variations in flow properties and on the suspended load fallout rate (SLFR) from currents. Flow velocity non-uniformity cannot explain thinning into the basin because flow has a higher deceleration along streamlines away from the slope that should cause higher SLFR and thicker deposits away from the slope instead of close to the slope. A concentration non-uniformity mechanism is invoked that has the effect of maintaining relatively high flow concentrations and hence SLFR in medial and distal locations close to the slope. Experiments suggest that this may arise due to different rates of flow expansion on the obstructed and unobstructed sides of the current in proximal regions. Velocity non-uniformity can, however, explain the geometry of deposits that thicken away from slope. Beds of this type do occur occasionally in the Peïra Cava system (Type II beds). Flow velocity non-uniformity patterns have been used previously to successfully explain the spatial distributions of depositional facies of turbidity currents that have interacted with topography. The analysis in this study demonstrates that velocity non-uniformity, by itself, cannot explain depositional patterns in all basin settings. Future depositional models need to incorporate the effects of spatial changes in other flow properties, such as flow concentration, upon deposition to be able to predict turbidite facies in many different types of basin setting.

Planform geometry, stacking pattern, and extrabasinal origin of low strength and intermediate strength cohesive debris flow deposits in the Marnoso-arenacea Formation, Italy

The Miocene Marnoso-arenacea Formation (Italy) is the only ancient sequence where deposits of individual submarine density flow deposits have been mapped in detail for long (>100 km) distances, thereby providing unique information on how such flows evolve. These beds were deposited by large and infrequent flows in a low-relief basin plain. An almost complete lack of bed amalgamation aids bed correlation, and resembles some modern abyssal plains, but contrasts with ubiquitous bed amalgamation seen in fan-lobe deposits worldwide. Despite the subdued topography of this basin plain, the beds have a complicated character. Previous work showed that a single flow can commonly comprise both turbidity current and cohesive mud-rich debris flows. The debris flows were highly mobile on low gradients, but their deposits are absent in outcrops nearest to source. Similar hybrid beds have been documented in numerous distal fan deposits worldwide, and they represent an important process for delivering sediment into the deep ocean. It is therefore important to understand their origin and flow dynamics. To account for the absence of debrites in proximal Marnoso-arenacea Formation outcrops, it was proposed that debris flows originated within the study area due to erosion of mud-rich seafloor; we show that this is incorrect. Clast and matrix composition show that sediment within the cohesive debris flows originated outside the study area. Previous work showed that intermediate and low strength debris flows produced different downflow-trending facies tracts. Here, we show that intermediate strength debris flows entered the study area as debris flows, while low strength (clast poor) debris flows most likely formed through local transformation from an initially turbulent mud-rich suspension. New field data document debrite planform shape across the basin plain. Predicting this shape is important for subsurface oil and gas reservoirs. Low strength and intermediate strength debrites have substantially different planform shapes. However, the shape of each type of debrite is consistent. Low strength debrites occur in two tongues at the margins of the outcrop area, while intermediate strength debrite forms a single tongue near the basin center. Intermediate strength debrites are underlain by a thin layer of structureless clean sandstone that may have settled out from the debris flow at a late stage, as seen in laboratory experiments, or been deposited by a forerunning turbidity current that is closely linked to the debris flow. Low strength debrites can infill relief created by underlying dune crests, suggesting gentle emplacement. Dewatering of basal clean sand did not cause a long runout of debris flows in this location. Hybrid beds are common in a much thicker stratigraphic interval than was studied previously, and the same two types of debrite occur there. Hybrid flows transported large volumes (as much as 10 km3 per flow) of sediment into this basin plain, over a prolonged period of time.

First results from shallow stratigraphic boreholes on the eastern flank of the Rockall Basin, offshore western Ireland

The results of an integrated sedimentological and seismic stratigraphical analysis of three borehole sites on the eastern flank of the Rockall Basin, offshore western Ireland are reported. Two sites were drilled on the western slope of the Porcupine High, above the North and South Brona basins (boreholes 83/20-sb01, 83/24-sb01 and 83/24-sb02), and one on the northern flank of the Porcupine High (16/28-sb01), above the Macdara Basin. The cores establish that the half-graben basins marginal to the eastern Rockall Basin contain Jurassic deposits and that they were inverted sometime in the Late Jurassic or Early Cretaceous. An angular unconformity above the Brona basins is overlain by a condensed, tripartite Cretaceous succession (‘brownsand’, ‘greensand’, chalky micrite) that records stepwise deepening, with evidence for a Cenomanian-Turonian phase of normal faulting. Above the Macdara Basin, the unconformity is overlain by a basalt that was cored at the 16/28 site and is interpreted to represent a flow of Cretaceous age derived from the Drol Igneous Centre. At all three borehole sites, Cretaceous strata are onlapped (or downlapped) by Paleocene-Eocene strata that display evidence of a minor episode of fault reactivation above the Brona basins. Cored Eocene strata vary from clastic to carbonate-prone from north to south and smectitic clays are common at the 16/28 site. Post-Mid-Eocene westward tilting of the Rockall slope rotated the Eocene stratigraphy and the underlying Cretaceous deposits (including the lava flow in the 16/28 area) at least 3° down to the west. Slope development resulted in extensional sliding and the erosion of the C30 deep-water unconformity that is onlapped by Miocene slope deposits. C30 was cored in the 83/20 area where it cuts down into Cretaceous strata and is crusted with phosphates and the Cretaceous beneath Mn-impregnated.

The character and origin of thick base-of-slope sandstone units of the Peïra Cava outlier, SE France

Abstract Many hydrocarbon reservoirs occur within confined turbidite systems in which the depositional pattern of turbidity currents has been strongly influenced by basin-floor topography. In certain settings basin-floor topography may cause the development of anomalously thick (tens of metres) sandstones that are potentially excellent reservoir units. Southern exposures of the Peïra Cava outlier (Eocene-Oligocene; Annot Sandstones) provide well-exposed outcrops of such decametre-thick sandstone bodies. These units are located close to basin margins and downstream from an inferred topographic break-in-slope. Several base-of-slope sandstone bodies are examined that illustrate a common sedimentary theme of a complex basal unit, comprising laterally pinching or inter-fingering debrite and turbidite, abruptly overlain by a single, thick normally graded turbidite deposit. One of these sandstone bodies pinches out laterally over less than several hundred metres and sits within a deep (>20 m) ‘spoon shaped’ erosional scour. The scour is similar to morphological features observed in modern base-of-slope settings recently imaged using high-resolution submarine bathymetric surveys. Several different process interpretations may explain the occurrence of such sandstone bodies including remobilization of newly deposited sediment off basinmargins and enhanced deposition due to flow across a break-in-slope. A submarine channel interpretation is not consistent with the field observations. However, these units do share a number of similar features to channels that could lead to the misinterpretation of reservoir geometry.

Recovery efficiency from a turbidite sheet system: numerical simulation of waterflooding using outcrop-based geological models

A series of waterflood simulations were performed to investigate the effect of basinal position and facies permeability within a turbidite sheet system on oil recovery efficiency. Simulations used three-dimensional outcrop models of the Peïra Cava system, comprising gravel, sandstone, thin-bedded heterolithic and mudstone facies. Recovery efficiency declines with increasing permeability heterogeneity and is influenced by the interaction of vertical bed-permeability trends and flood-front gravity slumping. The occurrence of gravels with permeabilities lower than overlying sandstones produces optimum recoveries. High permeability gravels act as thief zones, enhanced by downward gravity slumping, reducing normalized recovery by up to 34 %. The effect of thief zones on recovery is related to their permeability contrast, abundance, thickness, lateral continuity, vertical position within permeable units and the permeability of underlying facies. Proximal to distal stratigraphic variations produce relatively small differences in normalized recovery of up to 13 % in models with the highest permeability heterogeneity. Differences in recovery are interpreted to reflect spatial trends in facies architecture, which determine the effectiveness of high permeability gravel thief zones. The poorest recovery is recorded from the medial model where recovery is lower than distal areas because of higher gravel abundance and thicknesses and lower compared to proximal areas because of the higher lateral continuity of gravels and underlying low-permeability mudstones.

Particle Size Distribution Controls the Threshold Between Net Sediment Erosion and Deposition in Suspended Load Dominated Flows

©2018. American Geophysical Union. All Rights Reserved. The central problem of describing most environmental and industrial flows is predicting when material is entrained into, or deposited from, suspension. The threshold between erosional and depositional flow has previously been modeled in terms of the volumetric amount of material transported in suspension. Here a new model of the threshold is proposed, which incorporates (i) volumetric and particle size limits on a flows ability to transport material in suspension, (ii) particle size distribution effects, and (iii) a new particle entrainment function, where erosion is defined in terms of the power used to lift mass from the bed. While current suspended load transport models commonly use a single characteristic particle size, the model developed herein demonstrates that particle size distribution is a critical control on the threshold between erosional and depositional flow. The new model offers an order of magnitude, or better, improvement in predicting the erosional-depositional threshold and significantly outperforms existing particle-laden flow models.