Lisa Lang

Thermodynamics of protein destabilization in live cells

Significance A key question in structural biology is how protein properties mapped out under simplified conditions in vitro transfer to the complex environment in live cells. The answer, it appears, varies. Defying predictions from steric crowding effects, experimental data have shown that cells in some cases stabilize and in other cases destabilize the native protein structures. In this study, we reconcile these seemingly conflicting results by showing that the in-cell effect on protein thermodynamics is sequence specific: The outcome depends both on the individual target protein and on its detailed host-cell environment. Although protein folding and stability have been well explored under simplified conditions in vitro, it is yet unclear how these basic self-organization events are modulated by the crowded interior of live cells. To find out, we use here in-cell NMR to follow at atomic resolution the thermal unfolding of a β-barrel protein inside mammalian and bacterial cells. Challenging the view from in vitro crowding effects, we find that the cells destabilize the protein at 37 °C but with a conspicuous twist: While the melting temperature goes down the cold unfolding moves into the physiological regime, coupled to an augmented heat-capacity change. The effect seems induced by transient, sequence-specific, interactions with the cellular components, acting preferentially on the unfolded ensemble. This points to a model where the in vivo influence on protein behavior is case specific, determined by the individual protein’s interplay with the functionally optimized “interaction landscape” of the cellular interior.

Fibrillation precursor of superoxide dismutase 1 revealed by gradual tuning of the protein-folding equilibrium

Although superoxide dismutase 1 (SOD1) stands out as a relatively soluble protein in vitro, it can be made to fibrillate by mechanical agitation. The mechanism of this fibrillation process is yet poorly understood, but attains considerable interest due to SOD1’s involvement in the neurodegenerative disease amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS). In this study, we map out the apoSOD1 fibrillation process from how it competes with the global folding events at increasing concentrations of urea: We determine how the fibrillation lag time (τlag) and maximum growth rate (νmax) depend on gradual titration of the folding equilibrium, from the native to the unfolded state. The results show that the agitation-induced fibrillation of apoSOD1 uses globally unfolded precursors and relies on fragmentation-assisted growth. Mutational screening and fibrillation m-values (∂ log τlag/∂[urea] and ∂ log νmax/∂[urea]) indicate moreover that the fibrillation pathway proceeds via a diffusely bound transient complex that responds to the global physiochemical properties of the SOD1 sequence. Fibrillation of apoSOD1, as it bifurcates from the denatured ensemble, seems thus mechanistically analogous to that of disordered peptides, save the competing folding transition to the native state. Finally, we examine by comparison with in vivo data to what extent this mode of fibrillation, originating from selective amplification of mechanically brittle aggregates by sample agitation, captures the mechanism of pathological SOD1 aggregation in ALS.

Cutting Off Functional Loops from Homodimeric Enzyme Superoxide Dismutase 1 (SOD1) Leaves Monomeric β-Barrels

Demetallation of the homodimeric enzyme Cu/Zn-superoxide dismutase (SOD1) is known to unleash pronounced dynamic motions in the long active-site loops that comprise almost a third of the folded structure. The resulting apo species, which shows increased propensity to aggregate, stands out as the prime disease precursor in amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS). Even so, the detailed structural properties of the apoSOD1 framework have remained elusive and controversial. In this study, we examine the structural interplay between the central apoSOD1 barrel and the active-site loops by simply cutting them off; loops IV and VII were substituted with short Gly-Ala-Gly linkers. The results show that loop removal breaks the dimer interface and leads to soluble, monomeric β-barrels with high structural integrity. NMR-detected nuclear Overhauser effects are found between all of the constituent β-strands, confirming ordered interactions across the whole barrel. Moreover, the breathing motions of the SOD1 barrel are overall insensitive to loop removal and yield hydrogen/deuterium protection factors typical for cooperatively folded proteins (i.e. the active-site loops act as a “bolt-on” domain with little dynamic influence on its structural foundation). The sole exceptions are the relatively low protection factors in β-strand 5 and the turn around Gly-93, a hot spot for ALS-provoking mutations, which decrease even further upon loop removal. Taken together, these data suggest that the cytotoxic function of apoSOD1 does not emerge from its folded ground state but from a high energy intermediate or even from the denatured ensemble.

SOD1 aggregation in ALS mice shows simplistic test tube behavior

Significance Here, we address the longstanding question to what extent protein fibrillation behavior as measured under simplified conditions in the test tube is transferrable to protein aggregation disease? Somewhat unexpectedly, we find that superoxide dismutase 1 (SOD1) fibrillation in vitro and growth of pathological SOD1 aggregates in transgenic ALS mice are mechanistically indistinguishable: Both processes reveal exponential kinetics and the typical characteristics of fragment-assisted growth. Although this precise agreement between in vitro and in vivo data opens new possibilities for quantitative examination of the molecular mechanism of neural damage at tissue level, it also moves the question about the medical relevance of our existing experimental tools one step farther: to what extent is protein aggregation in overexpressing mice transferable to late-onset human disease? A longstanding challenge in studies of neurodegenerative disease has been that the pathologic protein aggregates in live tissue are not amenable to structural and kinetic analysis by conventional methods. The situation is put in focus by the current progress in demarcating protein aggregation in vitro, exposing new mechanistic details that are now calling for quantitative in vivo comparison. In this study, we bridge this gap by presenting a direct comparison of the aggregation kinetics of the ALS-associated protein superoxide dismutase 1 (SOD1) in vitro and in transgenic mice. The results based on tissue sampling by quantitative antibody assays show that the SOD1 fibrillation kinetics in vitro mirror with remarkable accuracy the spinal cord aggregate buildup and disease progression in transgenic mice. This similarity between in vitro and in vivo data suggests that, despite the complexity of live tissue, SOD1 aggregation follows robust and simplistic rules, providing new mechanistic insights into the ALS pathology and organism-level manifestation of protein aggregation phenomena in general.

Global structural motions from the strain of a single hydrogen bond

The origin and biological role of dynamic motions of folded enzymes is not yet fully understood. In this study, we examine the molecular determinants for the dynamic motions within the β-barrel of superoxide dismutase 1 (SOD1), which previously were implicated in allosteric regulation of protein maturation and also pathological misfolding in the neurodegenerative disease amyotrophic lateral sclerosis. Relaxation-dispersion NMR, hydrogen/deuterium exchange, and crystallographic data show that the dynamic motions are induced by the buried H43 side chain, which connects the backbones of the Cu ligand H120 and T39 by a hydrogen-bond linkage through the hydrophobic core. The functional role of this highly conserved H120–H43–T39 linkage is to strain H120 into the correct geometry for Cu binding. Upon elimination of the strain by mutation H43F, the apo protein relaxes through hydrogen-bond swapping into a more stable structure and the dynamic motions freeze out completely. At the same time, the holo protein becomes energetically penalized because the twisting back of H120 into Cu-bound geometry leads to burial of an unmatched backbone carbonyl group. The question then is whether this coupling between metal binding and global structural motions in the SOD1 molecule is an adverse side effect of evolving viable Cu coordination or plays a key role in allosteric regulation of biological function, or both?

Cutting off the functional loops from the homo-dimeric enzyme superoxide dismutase 1 (SOD1) monomeric β-barrels

Demetallation of the homodimeric enzyme Cu/Zn-superoxide dismutase (SOD1) is known to unleash pronounced dynamic motions in the long active-site loops that comprise almost a third of the folded structure. The resulting apo species, which shows increased propensity to aggregate, stands out as the prime disease precursor in amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS). Even so, the detailed structural properties of the apoSOD1 framework have remained elusive and controversial. In this study, we examine the structural interplay between the central apoSOD1 barrel and the active-site loops by simply cutting them off; loops IV and VII were substituted with short Gly-Ala-Gly linkers. The results show that loop removal breaks the dimer interface and leads to soluble, monomeric β-barrels with high structural integrity. NMR-detected nuclear Overhauser effects are found between all of the constituent β-strands, confirming ordered interactions across the whole barrel. Moreover, the breathing motions of the SOD1 barrel are overall insensitive to loop removal and yield hydrogen/deuterium protection factors typical for cooperatively folded proteins (i.e. the active-site loops act as a “bolt-on” domain with little dynamic influence on its structural foundation). The sole exceptions are the relatively low protection factors in β-strand 5 and the turn around Gly-93, a hot spot for ALS-provoking mutations, which decrease even further upon loop removal. Taken together, these data suggest that the cytotoxic function of apoSOD1 does not emerge from its folded ground state but from a high energy intermediate or even from the denatured ensemble.

Structural and kinetic analysis of protein-aggregate strains in vivo using binary epitope mapping

Significance The levels of aggregated specific proteins in the CNS in neurodegenerative diseases are minute, hampering analysis of structure and growth kinetics. Here we describe a generally applicable method based on binary epitope mapping. It was applied to analysis of superoxide dismutase aggregation in amyotrophic lateral sclerosis model mice. Two different strains of aggregates with different structures, physical stabilities, and growth kinetics were readily distinguished. Moreover, they were different from superoxide dismutase aggregates formed in vitro under a variety of conditions, revealing a key role of the CNS in shaping the aggregation process. Despite considerable progress in uncovering the molecular details of protein aggregation in vitro, the cause and mechanism of protein-aggregation disease remain poorly understood. One reason is that the amount of pathological aggregates in neural tissue is exceedingly low, precluding examination by conventional approaches. We present here a method for determination of the structure and quantity of aggregates in small tissue samples, circumventing the above problem. The method is based on binary epitope mapping using anti-peptide antibodies. We assessed the usefulness and versatility of the method in mice modeling the neurodegenerative disease amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, which accumulate intracellular aggregates of superoxide dismutase-1. Two strains of aggregates were identified with different structural architectures, molecular properties, and growth kinetics. Both were different from superoxide dismutase-1 aggregates generated in vitro under a variety of conditions. The strains, which seem kinetically under fragmentation control, are associated with different disease progressions, complying with and adding detail to the growing evidence that seeding, infectivity, and strain dependence are unifying principles of neurodegenerative disease.

Pruning the ALS-Associated Protein SOD1 for in-Cell NMR

To efficiently deliver isotope-labeled proteins into mammalian cells poses a main challenge for structural and functional analysis by in-cell NMR. In this study we have employed cell-penetrating peptides (CPPs) to deliver the ALS-associated protein superoxide dismutase (SOD1) into HeLa cells. Our results show that, although full-length SOD1 cannot be efficiently internalized, a variant in which the active-site loops IV and VII have been truncated (SOD1(ΔIVΔVII)) yields high cytosolic delivery. The reason for the enhanced delivery of SOD1(ΔIVΔVII) seems to be the elimination of negatively charged side chains, which alters the net charge of the CPP-SOD1 complex from neutral to +4. The internalized SOD1(ΔIVΔVII) protein displays high-resolution in-cell NMR spectra similar to, but not identical to, those of the lysate of the cells. Spectral differences are found mainly in the dynamic β strands 4, 5, and 7, triggered by partial protonation of the His moieties of the Cu-binding site. Accordingly, SOD1(ΔIVΔVII) doubles here as an internal pH probe, revealing cytosolic acidification under the experimental treatment. Taken together, these observations show that CPP delivery, albeit inefficient at first trials, can be tuned by protein engineering to allow atomic-resolution NMR studies of specific protein structures that have evaded other in-cell NMR approaches: in this case, the structurally elusive apoSOD1 barrel implicated as precursor for misfolding in ALS.

Transient small molecule interactions kinetically modulate amyloid β peptide self-assembly

Small organic molecules, like Congo red and lacmoid, have been shown to modulate the self‐assembly of the amyloid β peptide (Aβ). Here, we show that Aβ forms NMR invisible non‐toxic co‐aggregates together with lacmoid as well as Congo red. We find that the interaction involves two distinct kinetic processes and at every given time point only a small fraction of Aβ is in the co‐aggregate. These weak transient interactions kinetically redirect the aggregation prone Aβ from self‐assembling into amyloid fibrils. These findings suggest that even such weak binders might be effective as therapeutics against pathogenic protein aggregation.

Physicochemical code for quinary protein interactions in Escherichia coli

Significance This study shows that the diffusive motions of proteins in live cells are by no means without control but follow simplistic physical−chemical rules that can be quantified and optimized through surface composition. Most strikingly, human proteins are observed to stick to the “foreign” environment of bacterial cells, whereas the bacterial analogue moves around freely. Even so, the human proteins can predictably be transformed to bacterial behavior with a few structurally benign surface mutations, and, conversely, the bacterial protein can be made to stick. The findings have not only fundamental implications for how protein function is controlled at the physical−chemical level but can also be used to adjust protein motion in Escherichia coli at will. How proteins sense and navigate the cellular interior to find their functional partners remains poorly understood. An intriguing aspect of this search is that it relies on diffusive encounters with the crowded cellular background, made up of protein surfaces that are largely nonconserved. The question is then if/how this protein search is amenable to selection and biological control. To shed light on this issue, we examined the motions of three evolutionary divergent proteins in the Escherichia coli cytoplasm by in-cell NMR. The results show that the diffusive in-cell motions, after all, follow simplistic physical−chemical rules: The proteins reveal a common dependence on (i) net charge density, (ii) surface hydrophobicity, and (iii) the electric dipole moment. The bacterial protein is here biased to move relatively freely in the bacterial interior, whereas the human counterparts more easily stick. Even so, the in-cell motions respond predictably to surface mutation, allowing us to tune and intermix the protein’s behavior at will. The findings show how evolution can swiftly optimize the diffuse background of protein encounter complexes by just single-point mutations, and provide a rational framework for adjusting the cytoplasmic motions of individual proteins, e.g., for rescuing poor in-cell NMR signals and for optimizing protein therapeutics.