Malgorzata Szybka

Glioma cells showing IDH1 mutation cannot be propagated in standard cell culture conditions.

Background:It has recently been reported by several sources that original (i.e., present in vivo) glioma cell phenotypes or genotypes cannot be maintained in vitro. For example, glioblastoma cell lines presenting EGFR amplification cannot be established.Methods and results:IDH1 sequencing and loss of heterozygosity analysis was performed for 15 surgery samples of astrocytoma and early and late passages of cells derived from those and for 11 archival samples. We were not able to culture tumour cells presenting IDH1 mutations originating from currently proceeded 10 tumours; the same results were observed in 7 samples of archival material.Conclusion:The IDH1 mutation is expected to be almost mutually exclusive with EGFR amplification, so glioma cells with IDH1 mutations seem to represent a new group of tumour cells, which cannot be readily analysed in vitro because of their elimination. The reasons for this intriguing phenomenon should be investigated since its understanding can help to define a new therapeutic approach based on simulating in vivo conditions, responsible for tumour cells elimination in vitro. Moreover, a new model for culturing glioma cells in vitro should be designed since the current one does not provide conditions corresponding to in vivo growth.

Arrested neural and advanced mesenchymal differentiation of glioblastoma cells-comparative study with neural progenitors

BackgroundAlthough features of variable differentiation in glioblastoma cell cultures have been reported, a comparative analysis of differentiation properties of normal neural GFAP positive progenitors, and those shown by glioblastoma cells, has not been performed.MethodsFollowing methods were used to compare glioblastoma cells and GFAP+NNP (NHA): exposure to neural differentiation medium, exposure to adipogenic and osteogenic medium, western blot analysis, immunocytochemistry, single cell assay, BrdU incorporation assay. To characterize glioblastoma cells EGFR amplification analysis, LOH/MSI analysis, and P53 nucleotide sequence analysis were performed.ResultsIn vitro differentiation of cancer cells derived from eight glioblastomas was compared with GFAP-positive normal neural progenitors (GFAP+NNP). Prior to exposure to differentiation medium, both types of cells showed similar multilineage phenotype (CD44+/MAP2+/GFAP+/Vimentin+/Beta III-tubulin+/Fibronectin+) and were positive for SOX-2 and Nestin. In contrast to GFAP+NNP, an efficient differentiation arrest was observed in all cell lines isolated from glioblastomas. Nevertheless, a subpopulation of cells isolated from four glioblastomas differentiated after serum-starvation with varying efficiency into derivatives indistinguishable from the neural derivatives of GFAP+NNP. Moreover, the cells derived from a majority of glioblastomas (7 out of 8), as well as GFAP+NNP, showed features of mesenchymal differentiation when exposed to medium with serum.ConclusionOur results showed that stable co-expression of multilineage markers by glioblastoma cells resulted from differentiation arrest. According to our data up to 95% of glioblastoma cells can present in vitro multilineage phenotype. The mesenchymal differentiation of glioblastoma cells is advanced and similar to mesenchymal differentiation of normal neural progenitors GFAP+NNP.

High incidence of MGMT promoter methylation in primary glioblastomas without correlation with TP53 gene mutations

O(6)-methylguanine DNA methyltransferase (MGMT) reduces cytotoxicity of therapeutic or environmental alkylating agents. MGMT promoter methylation has been associated with TP53 G: C to A:T transition mutations in various types of cancers, and with poor prognosis in patients who did not receive chemotherapy. Mutations of TP53 are more frequent in secondary than in primary glioblastoma, thus the expected MGMT promoter methylation was low in primary glioblastoma. Glioblastoma patients with MGMT promoter methylation showed better response to chemotherapy based on alkylating agents and longer survival than patients without MGMT methylation. We examined 32 primary glioblastomas, treated with radiotherapy and surgery, for TP53 mutation by direct sequencing and MGMT promoter methylation by methylation-specific PCR. MGMT promoter methylation and TP53 mutations were detected in 72% and 31% of primary glioblastoma, respectively. Although not statistically significant, the frequency of TP53 G:C to A:T mutations were higher in cases with (26%) than without (11%) MGMT promoter methylation (p=0.376). MGMT promoter methylation had no impact on patient survival. Our data indicate that MGMT promoter methylation occurs frequently in primary glioblastoma, but does not lead to G:C to A:T TP53 mutations, has no independent prognostic value and is not a predictive marker unless glioblastoma patients are treated with chemotherapy.

Regulation of PrPC expression: nerve growth factor (NGF) activates the prion gene promoter through the MEK1 pathway in PC12 cells.

A high expression of PrP(C) in cells is one factor that increases the risk of conversion to the misfolded, disease-associated form (PrP(Sc)) characteristic of transmissible spongiform encephalopathies. Thus, developing a method to control the level of PrP(C) expression in cells could be one way to delay or prevent the onset of clinical signs of these diseases. In this study the mechanisms controlling the expression of the Prnp gene in PC12 cells and in rat brain were examined. We observed a slight activation of a cloned fragment of the human PRNP gene promoter using the luciferase reporter system in PC12 cells stimulated with nerve growth factor (NGF). The activating effect of NGF was enhanced by mitogen-activated protein kinase (MEK1) and suppressed by myristylated serine/threonine kinase (myrAKT). These results suggest that MEK1 is a positive activator of the PRNP promoter that inhibits the AKT pathway. Independent experiments suggested that high expression of PrP(C) in the brain depends on the rate of translation and/or the efficiency of PrP(C) stabilization. We also investigated the epigenic status of the Prnp promoter. We observed no increase of PrP(C) or Prnp mRNA levels in PC12 cells after treatment with the DNA-demethylating agent. The Prnp promoter did not display methylation either in NGF-treated and untreated PC12 cells, or in the rat brain. These results improve the understanding of the regulation of the Prnp gene promoter, a DNA regulatory element controlling the expression of PrP(C), a protein involved in several neurological diseases.

Elimination of wild-type P53 mRNA in glioblastomas showing heterozygous mutations of P53

We screened 50 glioblastomas for P53 mutations. Five glioblastomas showed heterozygous mutations, while three were putatively heterozygous. Six of these eight glioblastomas showed elimination of wild-type P53 mRNA. These results strongly suggest that some sort of mechanism(s) favouring mutated over wild-type P53 mRNA exists in glioblastoma cells with heterozygous mutations of this gene.

Screening for EGFR Amplifications with a Novel Method and Their Significance for the Outcome of Glioblastoma Patients

Glioblastoma is a highly aggressive tumour of the central nervous system, characterised by poor prognosis irrespective of the applied treatment. The aim of our study was to analyse whether the molecular markers of glioblastoma (i.e. TP53 and IDH1 mutations, CDKN2A deletion, EGFR amplification, chromosome 7 polysomy and EGFRvIII expression) could be associated with distinct prognosis and/or response to the therapy. Moreover, we describe a method which allows for a reliable, as well as time- and cost-effective, screening for EGFR amplification and chromosome 7 polysomy with quantitative Real-Time PCR at DNA level. In the clinical data, only the patient’s age had prognostic significance (continuous: HR = 1.04; p<0.01). At the molecular level, EGFRvIII expression was associated with a better prognosis (HR = 0.37; p = 0.04). Intriguingly, EGFR amplification was associated with a worse outcome in younger patients (HR = 3.75; p<0.01) and in patients treated with radiotherapy (HR = 2.71; p = 0.03). We did not observe any difference between the patients with the amplification treated with radiotherapy and the patients without such a treatment. Next, EGFR amplification was related to a better prognosis in combination with the homozygous CDKN2A deletion (HR = 0.12; p = 0.01), but to a poorer prognosis in combination with chromosome 7 polysomy (HR = 14.88; p = 0.01). Importantly, the results emphasise the necessity to distinguish both mechanisms of the increased EGFR gene copy number (amplification and polysomy). To conclude, although the data presented here require validation in different groups of patients, they strongly advocate the consideration of the patient’s tumour molecular characteristics in the selection of the therapy.

cDNA sequencing improves the detection of P53 missense mutations in colorectal cancer

BackgroundRecently published data showed discrepancies beteween P53 cDNA and DNA sequencing in glioblastomas. We hypothesised that similar discrepancies may be observed in other human cancers.MethodsTo this end, we analyzed 23 colorectal cancers for P53 mutations and gene expression using both DNA and cDNA sequencing, real-time PCR and immunohistochemistry.ResultsWe found P53 gene mutations in 16 cases (15 missense and 1 nonsense). Two of the 15 cases with missense mutations showed alterations based only on cDNA, and not DNA sequencing. Moreover, in 6 of the 15 cases with a cDNA mutation those mutations were difficult to detect in the DNA sequencing, so the results of DNA analysis alone could be misinterpreted if the cDNA sequencing results had not also been available. In all those 15 cases, we observed a higher ratio of the mutated to the wild type template by cDNA analysis, but not by the DNA analysis. Interestingly, a similar overexpression of P53 mRNA was present in samples with and without P53 mutations.ConclusionIn terms of colorectal cancer, those discrepancies might be explained under three conditions: 1, overexpression of mutated P53 mRNA in cancer cells as compared with normal cells; 2, a higher content of cells without P53 mutation (normal cells and cells showing K-RAS and/or APC but not P53 mutation) in samples presenting P53 mutation; 3, heterozygous or hemizygous mutations of P53 gene. Additionally, for heterozygous mutations unknown mechanism(s) causing selective overproduction of mutated allele should also be considered. Our data offer new clues for studying discrepancy in P53 cDNA and DNA sequencing analysis.

Limited importance of the dominant-negative effect of TP53 missense mutations

BackgroundHeterozygosity of TP53 missense mutations is related to the phenomenon of the dominant-negative effect (DNE). To estimate the importance of the DNE of TP53 mutations, we analysed the percentage of cancer cases showing a single heterozygous mutation of TP53 and searched for a cell line with a single heterozygous mutation of this gene. This approach was based on the knowledge that genes with evident DNE, such as EGFR and IDH1, represent nearly 100% of single heterozygous mutations in tumour specimens and cell lines.MethodsGenetic analyses (LOH and sequencing) performed for early and late passages of several cell lines originally described as showing single heterozygous TP53 mutations (H-318, G-16, PF-382, MOLT-13, ST-486 and LS-123). Statistical analysis of IARC TP53 and SANGER databases. Genetic analyses of N-RAS, FBXW7, PTEN and STR markers to test cross-contamination and cell line identity. Cell cloning, fluorescence-activated cell sorting and SSCP performed for the PF-382 cell line.ResultsA database study revealed TP53 single heterozygous mutations in 35% of in vivo (surgical and biopsy) samples and only 10% of cultured cells (in vitro), although those numbers appeared to be overestimated. We deem that published in vivo TP53 mutation analyses are not as rigorous as studies in vitro, and we did not find any cell line showing a stable, single heterozygous mutation. G16, PF-382 and MOLT-13 cells harboured single heterozygous mutations temporarily. ST-486, H-318 and LS-123 cell lines were misclassified. Specific mutations, such as R175H, R273H, R273L or R273P, which are reported in the literature to exert a DNE, showed the lowest percentage of single heterozygous mutations in vitro (about 5%).ConclusionWe suggest that the currently reported percentage of TP53 single heterozygous mutations in tumour samples and cancer cell lines is overestimated. Thus, the magnitude of the DNE of TP53 mutations is questionable. This scepticism is supported by database investigations showing that retention of the wild-type allele occurs with the same frequency as either nonsense or missense TP53 mutations.

Prevalence of mutated TP53 on cDNA (but not on DNA template) in pleomorphic xanthoastrocytoma with positive TP53 immunohistochemistry

Pleomorphic xanthoastrocytoma (PXA) is a tumor of astrocytic lineage that may have anaplastic features; such a phenotype usually correlates with a less favorable outcome. The molecular profile of PXA differs from other astrocytic tumors, but the molecular mechanisms of its formation and progression are still undefined. We analyzed a loss of heterozygosity and mutations of the SMARCB1 (also known as SNF5 or INI1) and TP53 genes in four cases of PXA. In just one case a TP53 mutation (Cys238Tyr) was readily detectable at the mRNA level, but it was almost undetectable during DNA sequencing. This case was also the only one exhibiting anaplastic features and TP53 overexpression as defined by immunohistochemistry. This observation supports our earlier findings on discrepancies in TP53 status in glioblastomas. We suggest that the incidence of TP53 mutations in pleomorphic xanthoastrocytoma may be underestimated and that molecular approaches should be used for greater diagnostic precision.

Molecular alterations in meningiomas: association with clinical data.

The aim of our study was to evaluate the frequency of deletions on chromosomes 1, 9, 10, 14, 18 and 22 in 75 benign and 15 atypical meningiomas and correlate them with clinical findings. Paired normal and tumor DNA samples were analyzed for loss of heterozygosity (LOH), using 24 microsatellite markers and PCR techniques. Statistical analysis showed that deletions on chromosomes 14 and 18 were significantly associated with tumor grade of meningiomas (p = 0.048 and p = 0.03, respectively). In addition, we found a marginally increased frequency of LOH on chromosome 9 in atypical meningiomas (p = 0.06). Interestingly, LOH on chromosome 14 was significantly associated with tumor size (p = 0.049), as the risk of developing a tumor of more than 4 cm in diameter was 6-times the risk of developing tumor with diameter below 4 cm. The most frequent genetic abnormality in meningiomas is 22 LOH, which seems to be confirmed by the present study in which high frequency of such abnormality was observed (67%). We found associations between chromosome 22 status and histological subtype. LOH on chromosome 22 was more frequent in fibrous meningiomas than in the meningothelial variant (p = 0.001). Besides that, we found a relationship between 22 LOH status and tumor localization: the frequency of LOH in skull base-localized tumors was significantly lower compared to parasagittal meningiomas (p = 0.0004). Our results indicated that allelic loss on chromosomes 9, 10, 14, 18 and 22 may be associated with meningioma pathogenesis and progression.