Mari Katayama

Comparison of Therapeutic Efficacies of Type A and F Botulinum Toxins for Blepharospasm A double-blind, controlled study

Article abstract-Type F botulinum toxin can be used for treating patients with dystonia who become refractory to type A toxin injection due to antibody development. We compared the therapeutic efficacy of type F botulinum toxin to that of type A toxin in a self-controlled, double-blind clinical trial. In nine patients with blepharospasm, we injected type A toxin on one side and the same units of type F toxin on the other side. Although the onset of clinical effect, maximal benefit, and adverse reactions were similar between type A and F toxins, the duration of the clinical effect was significantly shorter on the side injected with type F toxin. Although type F toxin proved its promise as an alternative to type A toxin, its usefulness is limited by the shorter duration of action. NEUROLOGY 1995;45: 506-508

Abnormal contingent negative variation in writer's cramp.

OBJECTIVE To investigate the physiological abnormality in writers cramp, a focal dystonia which specifically affects writing. METHODS We recorded brain potentials that precede hand and neck movements (contingent negative variation or CNV) in 11 patients and 11 age-matched normal subjects. A 1000 Hz tone burst (S1) was delivered to the right or left ear in random sequence, and 2 s after, a 2000 Hz tone burst (S2) was delivered to both ears simultaneously. For the response task to S2, the subjects were instructed to extend their fingers ipsilateral to the ear to which S1 was given in one experiment or to rotate the head to the side of the S1 presentation in another. All the patients had symptoms in the right hand only, and performed both tasks normally. CNV amplitudes were compared between normals and patients using unpaired t test. RESULTS They showed normal CNV for neck movement but significantly decreased CNV amplitudes for movements both in the affected and unaffected hands. CONCLUSIONS Our findings suggest that motor programming is specifically abnormal for the affected body part, including the asymptomatic contralateral limb, and that the clinical symptom may result from a deficient compensatory mechanism for abnormal motor programs or subroutines.

Effect of photic conditioning on blink reflex recovery function in blepharospasm.

Patients with blepharospasm may have selective sensitivity to photic stimuli, for their symptoms are often aggravated after exposure to brightness. To investigate the pathophysiology underlying this phenomenon, we compared the effects of electric and photic conditioning on electrically-evoked blink reflex in 21 patients with blepharospasm and 11 age-matched control subjects. With electric conditioning, R1 was facilitated at inter-stimulus intervals (ISIs) of up to 100 ms in both groups. R2 was inhibited at all ISIs longer than 20 ms in the normals, but to a much lesser extent in the patients, suggesting increased excitability of the multi-synaptic reflex pathway. Compared to electric conditioning, photic conditioning was less potent in inhibiting R2 in the normals. In contrast, photic conditioning in the patients produced R2 inhibition as powerful as electric conditioning. These findings indicate that, in patients with blepharospasm, photic input has a relatively more profound inhibitory effect on the test blink reflex than electric conditioning as compared with normal subjects. The greater susceptibility of the brainstem interneurons to photic conditioning in blepharospasm may be related to the clinically-observed light sensitivity.