Maribel Berru

AID Associates with Single-Stranded DNA with High Affinity and a Long Complex Half-Life in a Sequence-Independent Manner

ABSTRACT Activation-induced cytidine deaminase (AID) initiates secondary antibody diversification processes by deaminating cytidines on single-stranded DNA. AID preferentially mutates cytidines preceded by W(A/T)R(A/G) dinucleotides, a sequence specificity that is evolutionarily conserved from bony fish to humans. To uncover the biochemical mechanism of AID, we compared the catalytic and binding kinetics of AID on WRC (a hot-spot motif, where W equals A or T and R equals A or G) and non-WRC motifs. We show that although purified AID preferentially deaminates WRC over non-WRC motifs to the same degree observed in vivo, it exhibits similar binding affinities to either motif, indicating that its sequence specificity is not due to preferential binding of WRC motifs. AID preferentially deaminates bubble substrates of five to seven nucleotides rather than larger bubbles and preferentially binds to bubble-type rather than to single-stranded DNA substrates, suggesting that the natural targets of AID are either transcription bubbles or stem-loop structures. Importantly, AID displays remarkably high affinity for single-stranded DNA as indicated by the low dissociation constants and long half-life of complex dissociation that are typical of transcription factors and single-stranded DNA binding protein. These findings suggest that AID may persist on immunoglobulin and other target sequences after deamination, possibly acting as a scaffolding protein to recruit other factors.

Expression of the (Recombinant) Endogenous Immunoglobulin Heavy-Chain Locus Requires the Intronic Matrix Attachment Regions

The elements which regulate gene expression have traditionally been identified by their effects on reporter genes which have been transfected into cell lines or animals. It is generally assumed that these elements have a comparable role in expression of the corresponding endogenous locus. Nevertheless, several studies of immunoglobulin heavy-chain (IgH) gene expression have reported that the requirements for expressing IgH-derived transgenes differ from the requirements for expression of the endogenous IgH locus. Thus, although expression of transgenes requires multiple elements from the J(H)-C mu intron--the E mu core enhancer, the matrix attachment regions (MARs) which flank E mu, and several switch-associated elements--B-cell lines in which expression of the endogenous heavy-chain gene is maintained at the normal level in the absence of these intronic elements have occasionally been reported. Gene targeting offers an alternative method for assessing regulatory elements, one in which the role of defined segments of endogenous genes can be evaluated in situ. We have applied this approach to the IgH locus of a hybridoma cell line, generating recombinants which bear predetermined modifications in the functional, endogenous mu heavy-chain gene. Our analysis indicates the following. (i) Ninety-eight percent of the expression of the recombinant endogenous mu gene depends on elements in the MAR-E mu-MAR segment. (ii) Expression of the recombinant mu gene depends strongly on the MARs of the J(H)-C mu intron but not on the adjoining E mu core enhancer and switch regions; because our recombinant cell lines bear only a single copy of the mu gene, our results indicate that mu expression is activated by MAR elements lying within that same mu transcription unit. (iii) The MAR segment includes at least one activating element in addition to those defined previously by the binding of presumptive activating proteins in the nuclear matrix. (iv) Close association of the MARs with the E mu enhancer is not required for MAR-stimulated expression. (v) The other MARs in the IgH locus do not in their normal context provide the requisite MAR function.

Variegated expression of the endogenous immunoglobulin heavy-chain gene in the absence of the intronic locus control region.

ABSTRACT The expression of chromosomally integrated transgenes usually varies greatly among independent transfectants. This variability in transgene expression has led to the definition of locus control regions (LCRs) as elements which render expression consistent. Analyses of expression in single cells revealed that the expression of transgenes which lack an LCR is often variegated, i.e., on in some cells and off in others. In many cases, transgenes which show variegated expression were found to have inserted near the centromere. These observations have suggested that the LCR prevents variegation by blocking the inhibitory effect of heterochromatin and other repetitive-DNA-containing structures at the insertion site and have raised the question of whether the LCR plays a similar role in endogenous genes. To address this question, we have examined the effects of deleting the LCR from the immunoglobulin heavy-chain locus of a mouse hybridoma cell line in which expression of the immunoglobulin μ heavy-chain gene is normally highly stable. Our analysis of μ expression in single cells shows that deletion of this LCR resulted in variegated expression of the μ gene. That is, in the absence of the LCR, expression of the μ gene in the recombinant locus could be found in either of two epigenetically maintained, metastable states, in which transcription occurred either at the normal rate or not at all. In the absence of the LCR, the on state had a half-life of ∼100 cell divisions, while the half-life of the off state was ∼40,000 cell divisions. For recombinants with an intact LCR, the half-life of the on state exceeded 50,000 cell divisions. Our results thus indicate that the LCR increased the stability of the on state by at least 500-fold.

Negative Supercoiling Creates Single-Stranded Patches of DNA That Are Substrates for AID–Mediated Mutagenesis

Antibody diversification necessitates targeted mutation of regions within the immunoglobulin locus by activation-induced cytidine deaminase (AID). While AID is known to act on single-stranded DNA (ssDNA), the source, structure, and distribution of these substrates in vivo remain unclear. Using the technique of in situ bisulfite treatment, we characterized these substrates—which we found to be unique to actively transcribed genes—as short ssDNA regions, that are equally distributed on both DNA strands. We found that the frequencies of these ssDNA patches act as accurate predictors of AID activity at reporter genes in hypermutating and class switching B cells as well as in Escherichia coli. Importantly, these ssDNA patches rely on transcription, and we report that transcription-induced negative supercoiling enhances both ssDNA tract formation and AID mutagenesis. In addition, RNaseH1 expression does not impact the formation of these ssDNA tracts indicating that these structures are distinct from R-loops. These data emphasize the notion that these transcription-generated ssDNA tracts are one of many in vivo substrates for AID.

Role of the Intronic Elements in the Endogenous Immunoglobulin Heavy Chain Locus EITHER THE MATRIX ATTACHMENT REGIONS OR THE CORE ENHANCER IS SUFFICIENT TO MAINTAIN EXPRESSION

High level expression in mice of transgenes derived from the immunoglobulin heavy chain (IgH) locus requires both the core enhancer (Eμ) and the matrix attachment regions (MARs) that flank Eμ. The need for both elements implies that they each perform a different function in transcription. While it is generally assumed that expression of the endogenous IgH locus has similar requirements, it has been difficult to assess the role of these elements in expression of the endogenous heavy chain gene, because B cell development and IgH expression are strongly interdependent and also because the locus contains other redundant activating elements. We have previously described a gene-targeting approach in hybridoma cells that overcomes the redundancy problem to yield a stable cell line in which expression of the IgH locus depends strongly on elements in the MAR-Eμ-MAR segment. Using this system, we have found that expression of the endogenous μ gene persists at substantially (∼50%) normal levels in recombinants which retain either the MARs or Eμ. That is, despite the dissimilar biochemical activities of these two elements, either one is sufficient to maintain high level expression of the endogenous locus. These findings suggest new models for how the enhancer and MARs might collaborate in the initiation or maintenance of transcription.

Differences in the enzymatic efficiency of human and bony fish AID are mediated by a single residue in the C terminus modulating single-stranded DNA binding

Activation‐induced cytidine deaminase (AID) mediates antibody diversification by deaminating deoxycytidines to deoxyuridine within immunoglobulin genes. However, it also generates genome‐wide DNA lesions, leading to transformation. Though the biochemical properties of AID have been described, its 3‐dimensional structure has not been determined. Hence, to investigate the relationship between the primary structure and biochemical characteristics of AID, we compared the properties of human and bony fish AID, since these are most divergent in amino acid sequence. We show that AIDs of various species have different catalytic rates that are thermosensitive and optimal at native physiological temperatures. Zebrafish AID is severalfold more catalytically robust than human AID, while catfish AID is least active. This disparity is mediated by a single amino acid difference in the C terminus. Using functional assays supported by models of AID core and surface structure, we show that this residue modulates activity by affecting ssDNA binding. Furthermore, the cold‐adapted catalytic rates of fish AID result from increased ssDNA binding affinity at lower temperatures. Our work suggests that AID may generate DNA damage with variable efficiencies in different organisms, identifies residues critical in regulating AID activity, and provides insights into the evolution of the APOBEC family of enzymes.—Dancyger, A. M., King, J. J., Quinlan, M. J., Fifield, H., Tucker, S., Saunders, H. L., Berru, M., Magor, B. G., Martin, A., Larijani, M. Differences in the enzymatic efficiency of human and bony fish AID are mediated by a single residue in the C terminus modulating single‐stranded DNA binding. FASEB J. 26, 1517‐1525 (2012). www.fasebj.org

The Epigenetic Stability of the Locus Control Region-Deficient IgH Locus in Mouse Hybridoma Cells Is a Clonally Varying, Heritable Feature

Cis-acting elements such as enhancers and locus control regions (LCRs) prevent silencing of gene expression. We have shown previously that targeted deletion of an LCR in the immunoglobulin heavy-chain (IgH) locus creates conditions in which the immunoglobulin μ heavy chain gene can exist in either of two epigenetically inherited states, one in which μ expression is positive and one in which μ expression is negative, and that the positive and negative states are maintained by a cis-acting mechanism. As described here, the stability of these states, i.e., the propensity of a cell to switch from one state to the other, varied among subclones and was an inherited, clonal feature. A similar variation in stability was seen for IgH loci that both lacked and retained the matrix attachment regions associated with the LCR. Our analysis of cell hybrids formed by fusing cells in which the μ expression had different stabilities indicated that stability was also determined by a cis-acting feature of the IgH locus. Our results thus show that a single-copy gene in the same chromosomal location and in the presence of the same transcription factors can exist in many different states of expression.

Positive and negative transcriptional states of a variegating immunoglobulin heavy chain (IgH) locus are maintained by a cis-acting epigenetic mechanism.

Analyses of transgene expression have defined essential components of a locus control region (LCR) in the JH-Cμ intron of the IgH locus. Targeted deletion of this LCR from the endogenous IgH locus of hybridoma cells results in variegated expression, i.e., cells can exist in two epigenetically inherited states in which the Igμ H chain gene is either active or silent; the active or silent state is typically transmitted to progeny cells through many cell divisions. In principle, cells in the two states might differ either in their content of specific transcription factors or in a cis-acting feature of the IgH locus. To distinguish between these mechanisms, we generated LCR-deficient, recombinant cell lines in which the Igμ H chain genes were distinguished by a silent mutation and fused cells in which the μ gene was active with cells in which μ was silent. Our analysis showed that both parental active and silent transcriptional states were preserved in the hybrid cell, i.e., that two alleles of the same gene in the same nucleus can exist in two different states of expression through many cell divisions. These results indicate that the expression of the LCR-deficient IgH locus is not fully determined by the cellular complement of transcription factors, but is also subject to a cis-acting, self-propagating, epigenetic mark. The methylation inhibitor, 5-azacytidine, reactivated IgH in cells in which this gene was silent, suggesting that methylation is part of the epigenetic mark that distinguishes silent from active transcriptional states.

Mutations in the terminase genes of bacteriophage lambda that bypass the necessity for FI.

DNA maturation in bacteriophage λ is the process by which the concatemeric precursor DNA is cleaved at sites called cos to generate mature λ DNA molecules. These DNA molecules are then packaged into procapsids, the empty capsid precursors. The enzyme that catalyses these events is λ DNA terminase. It is composed of two subunits, made of 181 and 641 amino acids, the products of genes Nu1 and A, respectively. The product of the FI gene (gpFI ) stimulates the formation of an intermediate in capsid assembly called complex II, which contains a procapsid, terminase and DNA. The mechanism of stimulation remains unknown. It has been suggested that gpFI may also stimulate terminase‐mediated cos cleavage, in the absence of procapsids, by increasing enzyme turnover. Mutants in FI fail to mature and package DNA but, in comparison with other capsid gene mutants, FI mutants are leaky. Second site mutants of FI phages, called ‘fin’ (for FI independence), bypass the necessity for gpFI. These mutants were originally localized to the region of Nu1 and A and are of two classes: finA includes those that induce the synthesis of fourfold more gene A product (gpA ) than wild‐type phages, and finB includes those that produce normal amounts of gpA. Whereas all finA mutants analysed map to Nu1, finB mutants have been found both in E and in Nu1. The existence of E mutants able to bypass the necessity for gpFI in vivo shows that gpE and gpFI interact, directly or indirectly.

A weakened transcriptional enhancer yields variegated gene expression.

Identical genes in the same cellular environment are sometimes expressed differently. In some cases, including the immunoglobulin heavy chain (IgH) locus, this type of differential gene expression has been related to the absence of a transcriptional enhancer. To gain additional information on the role of the IgH enhancer, we examined expression driven by enhancers that were merely weakened, rather than fully deleted, using both mutations and insulators to impair enhancer activity. For this purpose we used a LoxP/Cre system to place a reporter gene at the same genomic site of a stable cell line. Whereas expression of the reporter gene was uniformly high in the presence of the normal, uninsulated enhancer and undetectable in its absence, weakened enhancers yielded variegated expression of the reporter gene; i.e., the average level of expression of the same gene differed in different clones, and expression varied significantly among cells within individual clones. These results indicate that the weakened enhancer allows the reporter gene to exist in at least two states. Subtle aspects of the variegation suggest that the IgH enhancer decreases the average duration (half-life) of the silent state. This analysis has also tested the conventional wisdom that enhancer activity is independent of distance and orientation. Thus, our analysis of mutant (truncated) forms of the IgH enhancer revealed that the 250 bp core enhancer was active in its normal position, ∼1.4 kb 3′ of the promoter, but inactive ∼6 kb 3′, indicating that the activity of the core enhancer was distance-dependent. A longer segment – the core enhancer plus ∼1 kb of 3′ flanking material, including the 3′ matrix attachment region – was active, and the activity of this longer segment was orientation-dependent. Our data suggest that this 3′ flank includes binding sites for at least two activators.