Marta Perez-Gussinye

Rheological evolution during extension at nonvolcanic rifted margins: Onset of serpentinization and development of detachments leading to continental breakup

Within the continent-ocean transition several nonvolcanic rifted margins exhibit a zone of partially serpentinized peridotites which continue under the thinned and faulted continental crust and are thought to represent subcontinental lithosphere serpentinized by contact with water. As water in sufficient volumes can only come from the surface, we suggest that a major condition for the onset of serpentinization is the embrittlement of the entire crust during progressive extension and hence the development of active crustal penetrating faults acting as fluid conduits. We investigate this possibility by modeling the rheological evolution of the lithosphere during extension and hence determining at what stretching factors the lower crust enters the brittle regime for a variety of different strain rates and lower crustal rheologies. Using an initial thermal structure appropriate for nonvolcanic margins, we find that the entire crust becomes brittle at stretching factors of between ∼3 and 5, depending on the strain rate. This compares well with the thickness of the crust observed just landward of the onset of partially serpentinized peridotites west of Iberia. The predicted thickness of the serpentinized peridotites (depth of the thermal limit of serpentinite stability beneath the crust-mantle boundary) also compares reasonably well with their observed thickness. As serpentinites are characterized by low friction coefficients, we suggest that the onset of mantle serpentinization controls the development of decollements at the crust-mantle boundary such as the S and H reflectors west of Iberia (leading to crustal separation). The development of thick serpentinites probably contributes to the weakening of the upper lithosphere and hence the localization of final breakup.

Rift migration explains continental margin asymmetry and crustal hyper-extension.

When continents break apart, continental crust and lithosphere are thinned until break-up is achieved and an oceanic basin is formed. The most remarkable and least understood structures associated with this process are up to 200 km wide areas of hyper-extended continental crust, which are partitioned between conjugate margins with pronounced asymmetry. Here we show, using high-resolution thermo-mechanical modelling, that hyper-extended crust and margin asymmetry are produced by steady state rift migration. We demonstrate that rift migration is accomplished by sequential, oceanward-younging, upper crustal faults, and is balanced through lower crustal flow. Constraining our model with a new South Atlantic plate reconstruction, we demonstrate that larger extension velocities may account for southward increasing width and asymmetry of these conjugate magma-poor margins. Our model challenges conventional ideas of rifted margin evolution, as it implies that during rift migration large amounts of material are transferred from one side of the rift zone to the other.

The long-term strength of Europe and its implications for plate-forming processes

Field-based geological studies show that continental deformation preferentially occurs in young tectonic provinces rather than in old cratons. This partitioning of deformation suggests that the cratons are stronger than surrounding younger Phanerozoic provinces. However, although Archaean and Phanerozoic lithosphere differ in their thickness and composition, their relative strength is a matter of much debate. One proxy of strength is the effective elastic thickness of the lithosphere, Te. Unfortunately, spatial variations in Te are not well understood, as different methods yield different results. The differences are most apparent in cratons, where the ‘Bouguer coherence’ method yields large Te values (> 60 km) whereas the ‘free-air admittance’ method yields low values (< 25 km). Here we present estimates of the variability of Te in Europe using both methods. We show that when they are consistently formulated, both methods yield comparable Te values that correlate with geology, and that the strength of old lithosphere (≥ 1.5 Gyr old) is much larger (mean Te > 60 km) than that of younger lithosphere (mean Te < 30 km). We propose that this strength difference reflects changes in lithospheric plate structure (thickness, geothermal gradient and composition) that result from mantle temperature and volatile content decrease through Earths history.

The role of crustal quartz in controlling Cordilleran deformation

Large-scale deformation of continents remains poorly understood more than 40 years after the plate tectonic revolution. Rock flow strength and mass density variations both contribute to stress, so both are certain to be important, but these depend (somewhat nebulously) on rock type, temperature and whether or not unbound water is present. Hence, it is unclear precisely how Earth material properties translate to continental deformation zones ranging from tens to thousands of kilometres in width, why deforming zones are sometimes interspersed with non-deforming blocks and why large earthquakes occasionally rupture in otherwise stable continental interiors. An important clue comes from observations that mountain belts and rift zones cyclically form at the same locations despite separation across vast gulfs of time (dubbed the Wilson tectonic cycle), accompanied by inversion of extensional basins and reactivation of faults and other structures formed in previous deformation events. Here we show that the abundance of crustal quartz, the weakest mineral in continental rocks, may strongly condition continental temperature and deformation. We use EarthScope seismic receiver functions, gravity and surface heat flow measurements to estimate thickness and seismic velocity ratio, vP/vS, of continental crust in the western United States. The ratio vP/vS is relatively insensitive to temperature but very sensitive to quartz abundance. Our results demonstrate a surprising correlation of low crustal vP/vS with both higher lithospheric temperature and deformation of the Cordillera, the mountainous region of the western United States. The most plausible explanation for the relationship to temperature is a robust dynamical feedback, in which ductile strain first localizes in relatively weak, quartz-rich crust, and then initiates processes that promote advective warming, hydration and further weakening. The feedback mechanism proposed here would not only explain stationarity and spatial distributions of deformation, but also lend insight into the timing and distribution of thermal uplift and observations of deep-derived fluids in springs.

Sequential faulting explains the asymmetry and extension discrepancy of conjugate margins

During early extension, cold continental lithosphere thins and subsides, creating rift basins. If extension continues to final break-up, the split and greatly thinned plates subside deep below sea level to form a conjugate pair of rifted margins. Although basins and margins are ubiquitous structures, the deformation processes leading from moderately extended basins to highly stretched margins are unclear, as studies consistently report that crustal thinning is greater than extension caused by brittle faulting. This extension discrepancy might arise from differential stretching of brittle and ductile crustal layers, but that does not readily explain the typical asymmetric structure of conjugate margins—in cross-section, one margin displays gradual thinning accompanied by large faults, and the conjugate margin displays abrupt thinning but smaller-scale faulting. Whole-crust detachments, active from early in the rifting, could in theory create both thinning and asymmetry, but are mechanically problematical. Furthermore, the extension discrepancy occurs at both conjugate margins, leading to the apparent contradiction that both seem to be upper plates to a detachment fault. Alternative models propose that much brittle extension is undetected because of seismic imaging limitations caused either by subseismic-resolution faulting, invisible deformation along top-basement 100-km-scale detachments or the structural complexity of cross-cutting arrays of faults. Here we use depth-migrated seismic images to accurately measure fault extension and compare it with crustal thinning. The observations are used to create a balanced kinematic model of rifting that resolves the extension discrepancy by producing both fault-controlled crustal thinning which progresses from a rift basin to the asymmetric structure, and extreme thinning of conjugate rifted margins. Contrary to current wisdom, the observations support the idea that thinning is to a first degree explained by simple Andersonian faulting that is unambiguously visible in seismic data.

On the recovery of effective elastic thickness using spectral methods: Examples from synthetic data and from the Fennoscandian Shield

There is considerable controversy regarding the long-term strength of continents (Te). While some authors obtain both low and high Te estimates from the Bouguer coherence and suggest that both crust and mantle contribute to lithospheric strength, others obtain estimates of only <25 km using the free-air admittance and suggest that the mantle is weak. At the root of this controversy is how accurately Te can be recovered from coherence and admittance. We investigate this question by using synthetic topography and gravity anomaly data for which Te is known. We show that the discrepancies stem from comparison of theoretical curves to multitaper power spectral estimates of free-air admittance. We reformulate the admittance method and show that it can recover synthetic Te estimates similar to those recovered using coherence. In light of these results, we estimate Te in Fennoscandia and obtain similar results using both techniques. Te is 20-40 km in the Caledonides, 40-60 km in the Swedish Svecofennides, 40-60 km in the Kola peninsula, and 70-100 km in southern Karelia and Svecofennian central Finland. Independent rheological modeling, using a xenolith-controlled geotherm, predicts similar high Te in central Finland. Because Te exceeds crustal thickness in this area, the mantle must contribute significantly to the total strength. Te in Fennoscandia increases with tectonic age, seismic lithosphere thickness, and decreasing heat flow, and low Te correlates with frequent seismicity. However, in Proterozoic and Archean lithosphere the relationship of Te to age is ambiguous, suggesting that compositional variations may influence the strength of continents. Copyright 2004 by the American Geophysical Union.

Chilean flat slab subduction controlled by overriding plate thickness and trench rollback

How flat slab geometries are generated has been long debated. It has been suggested that trenchward motion of thick cratons in some areas of South America and Cenozoic North America progressively closed the asthenospheric wedge and induced flat subduction. Here we develop time-dependent numerical experiments to explore how trenchward motion of thick cratons may result in flat subduction. We find that as the craton approaches the trench and the wedge closes, two opposite phenomena control slab geometry: the suction between ocean and continent increases, favoring slab flattening, while the mantle confined within the closing wedge dynamically pushes the slab backward and steepens it. When the slab retreats, as in the Peru and Chile flat slabs, the wedge closure rate and dynamic push are small and suction forces generate, in some cases, flat subduction. We model the past 30 m.y. of subduction in the Chilean flat slab area and demonstrate that trenchward motion of thick lithosphere, 200–300 km, currently ∼700–800 km away from the Peru-Chile Trench, reproduces a slab geometry that fits the stress pattern, seismicity distribution, and temporal and spatial evolution of deformation and volcanism in the region. We also suggest that varying trench kinematics may explain some differing slab geometries along South America. When the trench is stationary or advances, the mantle flow within the closing wedge strongly pushes the slab backward and steepens it, possibly explaining the absence of flat subduction in the Bolivian orocline.

Detachment faulting, mantle serpentinization, and serpentinite- mud volcanism beneath the Porcupine Basin, southwest of Ireland

The Porcupine Basin southwest of Ireland provides an opportunity to study the symmetry of rifting at stretching factors approaching continental breakup. Profiles across the basin image a bright reflection that appears to represent a detachment fault, and may in part be a decollement at the top of partially serpentinized mantle. Although overall the basin appears symmetric, the consistent westward structural dip of the detachment implies that, at high stretching factors, extension was asymmetric. Farther south, the Porcupine median high appears in cross section to be a triangular construction overlying tilted fault blocks and onlapped by postrift sediment. Despite no evidence for synrift magmatism, this high has previously been interpreted as a basaltic structure. However, it may represent a serpentinite-mud volcano or diapir: we suggest that such structures produce the serpentinite breccias found within the rifted continent-ocean transition of nonvolcanic margins.

Serpentinization and magmatism during extension at non-volcanic margins: the effect of initial lithospheric structure

Abstract At several non-volcanic margins serpentinized peridotites occur within a wide continent-ocean transition (COT) and beneath the edge of the thinned continental crust. However, other margins such as the Woodlark Basin appear to have a sharp COT and no reported serpentinites. We investigate the thermal, magmatic and rheological evolution of margins during extension as a function of initial lithospheric structure, rift duration and stretching factor. For cratonic and old orogen models, the entire crust should become brittle at stretching factors c. 3–4. The resultant crust-cutting faults allow water to reach and serpentinize the mantle, leading to the development of serpentinite décollements at the crust-mantle boundary and exhumation of mantle at the COT. Our predictions are consistent with the spatial limit and thickness of serpentinites at the SW Greenland and West Iberia margins, and the Rockall Trough. They also explain the absence of a broad zone of unroofed, serpentinized mantle at the COT of the Woodlark Basin: here the crust was too thick and hot for serpentinites to form before break-up. Larger melt production than in the West Iberia type margins and concentration of the lithospheric strength in the crust leads to synchronous crustal separation and lithospheric failure, yielding a sharp COT.

A tectonic model for hyperextension at magma-poor rifted margins: an example from the West Iberia–Newfoundland conjugate margins

Abstract Hyperextended, magma-poor margins are characterized by a wide continent–ocean transition and anomalously small fractions of magmatism during mantle exhumation prior to oceanic spreading. Here, I bring together several aspects of their rift to drift transition and give a coherent picture of their evolution from platform to deep-sea environments. I focus mainly on the West Iberia Margin (WIM)–Newfoundland (NF) conjugates in the North Atlantic Ocean. The architectural evolution of these margins is characterized by upper-crustal faulting and lower-crustal deformation that are tightly coupled, resulting in fault displacement that is accompanied by underlying, equal and coeval crustal thinning. Lower crust deforms first ductilely, but then progressively switches to brittle due to enhanced conductive cooling at very slow extension velocities (<c. 6 mm a−1 half-rate). The switch from ductile to progressively brittle lower crust is accompanied by the emergence of a dominant basinwards fault dip and oceanwards younging of fault activity. It is shown that these processes, acting in concert: (1) reconcile the horizontal extension on faults with crustal thinning without the need of lower-crustal flow; (2) explain, within one common Andersonian framework (faults active at 65°–30°), the change in fault geometry from planar to listric to detachment-like with increasing extension; and (3) generate the tectonic asymmetry observed between conjugate pairs. This work also discusses a high-resolution seismic section of the WIM showing that the ‘detachment-like’ fault S is truncated prior to the peridotite ridge where mantle exhumation first takes place. This suggests that serpentinized mantle rises due to its own buoyancy, separating and pulling the thinned crustal blocks apart. Once the crust has been separated, further mantle exhumation takes place by magma-poor extension of the underlying mantle. I show with numerical models that either a small reduction of mantle potential temperature (c. 25–50 °C), a mantle depletion of more than 10% or very slow half-extension velocities (c. 6 mm a−1) are required to reproduce the small amount of magmatism inferred. Available observations support either a very slow extension velocity or a smaller than normal mantle temperature; however, estimation errors may be large. Ultimately, unravelling which of these factors most contribute to magma-poor mantle exhumation will provide an improved understanding of the mantle lateral homogeneity and the three-dimensional nature of the rifting to drifting process.