Melissa A. Cunningham

Estrogen Receptors in Immunity and Autoimmunity

Due to the female predominance of autoimmune diseases, the role of gender and sex hormones in the immune system is of long-term interest. Estrogens primary effects are mediated via estrogen receptors alpha and beta (ER α/β) that are expressed on most immune cells. ERs are nuclear hormone receptors that can either directly bind to estrogen response elements in gene promoters or serve as cofactors with other transcription factors (i.e., NFkB/AP1). Cytoplasmic ER and membrane associated ER impact specific kinase signaling pathways. ERs have prominent effects on immune function in both the innate and adaptive immune responses. Genetic deficiency of ERα in murine models of lupus resulted in significantly decreased disease and prolonged survival, while ERβ deficiency had minimal to no effect in autoimmune models. The protective effect of ERα in lupus is multifactoral. In arthritis models, ERα agonists appears to mediate a protective effect. The modulation of ERα function appears to be a potential target for therapy in autoimmunity.

Estrogen receptor alpha modulates Toll-like receptor signaling in murine lupus.

Systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is a disease that disproportionately affects females. Despite significant research effort, the mechanisms underlying the female predominance in this disease are largely unknown. Previously, we showed that estrogen receptor alpha knockout (ERαKO) lupus prone female mice had significantly less pathologic renal disease and proteinuria, and significantly prolonged survival. Since autoantibody levels and number and percentage of B/T cells were not significantly impacted by ERα genotype, we hypothesized that the primary benefit of ERα deficiency in lupus nephritis was via modulation of the innate immune response. Using BMDCs and spleen cells/B cells from female wild-type or ERαKO mice, we found that ERαKO-derived cells have a significantly reduced inflammatory response after stimulation with TLR agonists. Our results indicate that the inflammatory response to TLR ligands is significantly impacted by the presence of ERα despite the absence of estradiol, and may partially explain the protective effect of ERα deficiency in lupus-prone animals.

Estrogen Receptor Alpha Modulates Mesangial Cell Responses to Toll-Like Receptor Ligands

Abstract:The female predominance in lupus is incompletely understood. The mechanisms for this difference are multifactorial involving the sex chromosomes, the hormones, and their receptors. We, and others, demonstrated that estrogen receptor alpha (ER&agr;)–deficient female mice developed significantly less lupus-like renal disease. This protective effect of ER&agr; deficiency occurred despite no impact on glomerular immune complex deposition. We hypothesized that decreased renal disease in ER&agr;-deficient mice was due to a dampened renal response to inflammatory stimuli. Given the role of Toll-like receptors (TLRs) in lupus, we assessed whether there was an interaction between TLR responses and ER&agr;. Herein, we show that TLR3, 4, and 7 ligands all enhanced mesangial cell (MC) ER&agr; expression, whereas neither estrogen, nor ER&agr;, impacted TLR3, 4, or 7 expression in MCs. The lack of ER&agr; markedly decreased MC production of interleukin 6 and monocyte chemoattractant protein 1 (MCP-1) following addition of TLR3, 4, and 7 ligands. In MCs, TLR ligands induced ER&agr; phosphorylation and nuclear localization. TLR3-induced nuclear factor &kgr;B nuclear translocation in MCs was not significantly affected by estrogen or ER&agr;. Finally, we demonstrate that female MCs express more TLR3 and respond to TLR ligands with a significantly increased production of interleukin-6 compared with male MCs. These results identify a significant impact/interaction of ER&agr; in TLR-mediated inflammatory responses in MCs.

Estrogen Receptor α Deficiency Modulates TLR Ligand–Mediated PDC-TREM Expression in Plasmacytoid Dendritic Cells in Lupus-Prone Mice

Female lupus-prone NZM2410 estrogen receptor α (ERα)–deficient mice are protected from renal disease and have prolonged survival compared with wild-type littermates; however, the mechanism of protection is unknown. Plasmacytoid dendritic cells (pDCs) and type I IFN drive lupus pathogenesis. Estrogen acting via ERα enhances both pDC development and IFN production. The objectives for this study were to determine if ERα modulates pDC function and IFN activity in predisease NZM2410 mice as a possible protective mechanism of ERα deficiency in lupus-prone mice. We measured the effect of ERα deficiency on spleen pDC frequency, number, maturation, and activation state. ERα deficiency reduced type I IFN activity and the frequency of MHC class II+ pDCs in the spleen without altering overall pDC frequency, number, or maturation state. Additionally, ERα-deficient NZM2410 mice had a significantly decreased frequency of pDCs expressing PDC-TREM, a modulator of TLR-mediated IFN production. After in vitro TLR9 stimulation, ERα deficiency significantly reduced the expression of PDC-TREM on pDCs from both NZM2410 and C57BL/6 mice. Thus, we have identified a significant effect of ERα deficiency on pDCs in predisease NZM2410 mice, which may represent a mechanism by which ERα deficiency protects NZM2410 mice from lupuslike disease.

Are microparticles the missing link between thrombosis and autoimmune diseases? Involvement in selected rheumatologic diseases.

Microparticles (MPs) are membrane-bound vesicles with important physiologic effects. MPs exchange information intercellularly, with each kind of MP carrying antigens and receptors of the cells from which they originated. They are biologic effectors in inflammation, angiogenesis, vascular injury, and thrombosis. Thrombosis is generally caused by abnormalities in blood flow, blood composition, and/or properties of the vessel wall. Thrombosis is a well-described feature of cardiovascular disease and cerebrovascular disease. Accumulating evidence suggests that increased risk of thrombosis is also characteristic of autoimmune disorders and immune-mediated diseases affecting all age groups, although the older adults are most vulnerable. Current research has also implicated MPs as a source of autoantigenic nuclear material that can form immune complexes, activate the innate immune system, and may lead to autoimmunity. This review focuses on the contribution of MPs to both the pathogenesis of autoimmune diseases and, as the immune and coagulation systems are tightly linked, their role in hypercoagulability in the setting of autoimmunity in an aging population.

Early Ovariectomy Results in Reduced Numbers of CD11c+/CD11b+ Spleen Cells and Impacts Disease Expression in Murine Lupus

Ninety percent of those diagnosed with systemic lupus erythematosus are female, with peak incidence between the ages of 15 and 45, when women are most hormonally active. Despite significant research effort, the mechanisms underlying this sex bias remain unclear. We previously showed that a functional knockout of estrogen receptor alpha (ERα) resulted in significantly reduced renal disease and increased survival in murine lupus. Dendritic cell (DC) development, which requires both estrogen and ERα, is impacted, as is activation status and cytokine production. Since both estrogen and testosterone levels have immunomodulating effects, we presently studied the phenotype of NZM2410 lupus-prone mice following post- and prepubertal ovariectomy (OVX) ± estradiol (E2) replacement to determine the impact of hormonal status on disease expression and DC development in these mice. We observed a trend toward survival benefit in addition to decreased proteinuria and improved renal histology in the early OVX, but not late OVX- or E2-repleted WT mice. Interestingly, there was also a significant difference in splenic DC subsets by flow cytometry. Spleens from NZM mice OVX’d early had a significant decrease in proinflammatory CD11c+CD11b+ DCs (vs. unmanipulated WTs, late OVX- and E2-repleted mice). These early OVX’d animals also had a significant increase in tolerogenic CD11c+CD8a+ DCs vs. WT. These data join a growing body of evidence that supports a role for hormone modulation of DCs that likely impacts the penetrance and severity of autoimmune diseases, such as lupus.

Estrogen receptor alpha deficiency protects against development of cognitive impairment in murine lupus

BackgroundOne of the more profound features of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is that females have a 9:1 prevalence of this disease over males. Up to 80% of SLE patients have cognitive defects or affective disorders. The mechanism of CNS injury responsible for cognitive impairment is unknown. We previously showed that ERα deficiency significantly reduced renal disease and increased survival in lupus-prone mice. We hypothesized that ERα deficiency would be similarly protective in the brain, and that ERα may play a role in modulating blood-brain barrier (BBB) integrity and/or neuroinflammation in lupus-prone mice.MethodsMRL/lpr ERα+/+ and ERαKO mice (n = 46) were ovariectomized, received 17β-estradiol pellets, and underwent radial arm water maze (WRAM) and novel object recognition (NOR) testing starting at eight weeks of age. Mice were sacrificed and brains were hemisected and processed for either immunohistochemistry, or hippocampus and parietal cortex dissection for Western blotting.ResultsMRL/lpr ERαKO mice (n = 21) performed significantly better in WRAM testing than wild-type MRL/lpr mice (n = 25). There was a significant reduction in reference memory errors (P <0.007), working memory errors (P <0.05), and start arm errors (P <0.02) in ERαKO mice. There were significant differences in NOR testing, particularly total exploration time, with ERα deficiency normalizing behavior. No significant differences were seen in markers of tight junction, astrogliosis, or microgliosis in the hippocampus or cortex by Western blot, however, there was a significant reduction in numbers of Iba1+ activated microglia in the hippocampus of ERαKO mice, as evidenced by immunohistochemietry (IHC).ConclusionERα deficiency provides significant protection against cognitive deficits in MRL/lpr mice as early as eight weeks of age. Additionally, the significant reduction in Iba1+ activated microglia in the MRL/lpr ERαKO mice was consistent with reduced inflammation, and may represent a biological mechanism for the cognitive improvement observed.

Plasmacytoid dendritic cell distribution and maturation are altered in lupus prone mice prior to the onset of clinical disease.

Plasmacytoid dendritic cells (pDCs) and their production of type I interferons (IFN) are key pathogenic mediators of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). Despite the key role of pDCs in SLE, the mechanism by which pDCs promote disease is not well understood. The first objective for this study was to assess the number and maturation state of pDCs in pre-disease NZM2410 lupus prone mice compared to control mice. Second, we sought to identify mechanisms responsible for the alteration in pDCs in NZM mice prior to onset of clinical disease. We compared the number and percent of pDCs in the spleens and bone marrow (BM) of pre-disease NZM24010 (NZM) mice to C57BL/6 (B6) control mice. In the spleens of pre-disease NZM mice, pDC percent and number were increased. This increase occurs in parallel with a decrease in BM pDC number and percent in the NZM mice. The decrease in BM pDC number suggests the increase in spleen pDCs is a result of altered pDC distribution and not increased production of pDCs in the BM. To determine if pDC developmental potential is altered in lupus prone mice, we cultured BM from NZM and B6 mice in vitro. We found a reduced percentage/number of pDCs developing from the BM of NZM mice compared to B6 mice, which further supports that the increase in pDC number is a result of altered pDC distribution rather than increased pDC production. To better characterize the pDC population, we compared the percentage of mature pDCs in the spleens and BM of NZM mice to controls. In the NZM mice, there is a dramatic reduction in the number of mature pDCs in the BM of NZM mice, suggesting that mature pDCs exit the BM at a higher rate/earlier maturation time compared to healthy mice. We conclude that pDCs contribution to disease pathogenesis in NZM mice may include the alteration of pDC distribution to increase the number of pDCs in the spleen prior to disease onset.

IgG4-Related Disease Presenting as Recurrent Mastoiditis With Central Nervous System Involvement

We report a case of a 43-year-old female who presented with right ear fullness and otorrhea. She was initially diagnosed with mastoiditis that was not responsive to multiple courses of antibiotics and steroids. She was then diagnosed with refractory inflammatory pseudotumor, and subsequent treatments included several mastoidectomies, further steroids, and radiation therapy. The patient went on to develop mastoiditis on the contralateral side as well as central nervous system involvement with headaches and right-sided facial paresthesias. Reexamination of the mastoid tissue revealed a significantly increased number of IgG4-positive cells, suggesting a diagnosis of IgG4-related disease. The patient improved clinically and radiographically with rituximab and was able to taper off azathioprine and prednisone. IgG4-related disease should be considered in patients with otologic symptoms and be on the differential diagnosis in patients with inflammatory pseudotumor. Staining for IgG and IgG4 is essential to ensure a prompt diagnosis and treatment.