Michael L. Kahn

New Recombination Methods for Sinorhizobium meliloti Genetics

ABSTRACT The availability of bacterial genome sequences has created a need for improved methods for sequence-based functional analysis to facilitate moving from annotated DNA sequence to genetic materials for analyzing the roles that postulated genes play in bacterial phenotypes. A powerful cloning method that uses lambda integrase recombination to clone and manipulate DNA sequences has been adapted for use with the gram-negative α-proteobacterium Sinorhizobium meliloti in two ways that increase the utility of the system. Adding plasmid oriT sequences to a set of vehicles allows the plasmids to be transferred to S. meliloti by conjugation and also allows cloned genes to be recombined from one plasmid to another in vivo by a pentaparental mating protocol, saving considerable time and expense. In addition, vehicles that contain yeast Flp recombinase target recombination sequences allow the construction of deletion mutations where the end points of the deletions are located at the ends of the cloned genes. Several deletions were constructed in a cluster of 60 genes on the symbiotic plasmid (pSymA) of S. meliloti, predicted to code for a denitrification pathway. The mutations do not affect the ability of the bacteria to form nitrogen-fixing nodules on Medicago sativa (alfalfa) roots.

Regulatory and DNA Repair Genes Contribute to the Desiccation Resistance of Sinorhizobium meliloti Rm1021

ABSTRACT Sinorhizobium meliloti can form a nitrogen-fixing symbiotic relationship with alfalfa after bacteria in the soil infect emerging root hairs of the growing plant. To be successful at this, the bacteria must be able to survive in the soil between periods of active plant growth, including when conditions are dry. The ability of S. meliloti to withstand desiccation has been known for years, but genes that contribute to this phenotype have not been identified. Transposon mutagenesis was used in combination with novel screening techniques to identify four desiccation-sensitive mutants of S. meliloti Rm1021. DNA sequencing of the transposon insertion sites identified three genes with regulatory functions (relA, rpoE2, and hpr) and a DNA repair gene (uvrC). Various phenotypes of the mutants were determined, including their behavior on several indicator media and in symbiosis. All of the mutants formed an effective symbiosis with alfalfa. To test the hypothesis that UvrC-related excision repair was important in desiccation resistance, uvrA, uvrB, and uvrC deletion mutants were also constructed. These strains were sensitive to DNA damage induced by UV light and 4-NQO and were also desiccation sensitive. These data indicate that uvr gene-mediated DNA repair and the regulation of stress-induced pathways are important for desiccation resistance.

Sinorhizobium meliloti dctA Mutants with Partial Ability To Transport Dicarboxylic Acids

Sinorhizobium meliloti dctA encodes a transport protein needed for a successful nitrogen-fixing symbiosis between the bacteria and alfalfa. Using the toxicity of the DctA substrate fluoroorotic acid as a selective agent in an iterated selection procedure, four independent S. meliloti dctA mutants were isolated that retained some ability to transport dicarboxylates. Two mutations were located in a region called motif B located in a predicted transmembrane helix of the protein that has been shown in other members of the glutamate transporter family to be involved in cation binding. A G114D mutation was located in the third transmembrane helix, which had not previously been directly implicated in transport. Multiple sequence alignment of more than 60 members of the glutamate transporter family revealed a glycine at this position in nearly all members of the family. The fourth mutant was able to transport succinate at almost wild-type levels but was impaired in malate and fumarate transport. It contains two mutations: one in a periplasmic domain and the other predicted to be in the cytoplasm. Separation of the mutations showed that each contributed to the altered substrate preference. dctA deletion mutants that contain the mutant dctA alleles on a plasmid can proceed further in symbiotic development than null mutants of dctA, but none of the plasmids could support symbiotic nitrogen fixation, although they can transport dicarboxylates, some at relatively high levels.

A mutant GlnD nitrogen sensor protein leads to a nitrogen-fixing but ineffective Sinorhizobium meliloti symbiosis with alfalfa

The nitrogen-fixing symbiosis between rhizobia and legume plants is a model of coevolved nutritional complementation. The plants reduce atmospheric CO2 by photosynthesis and provide carbon compounds to symbiotically associated bacteria; the rhizobia use these compounds to reduce (fix) atmospheric N2 to ammonia, a form of nitrogen the plants can use. A key feature of symbiotic N2 fixation is that N2 fixation is uncoupled from bacterial nitrogen stress metabolism so that the rhizobia generate “excess” ammonia and release this ammonia to the plant. In the symbiosis between Sinorhizobium meliloti and alfalfa, mutations in GlnD, the major bacterial nitrogen stress response sensor protein, led to a symbiosis in which nitrogen was fixed (Fix+) but was not effective (Eff−) in substantially increasing plant growth. Fixed 15N2 was transported to the shoots, but most fixed 15N was not present in the plant after 24 h. Analysis of free-living S. meliloti strains with mutations in genes related to nitrogen stress response regulation (glnD, glnB, ntrC, and ntrA) showed that catabolism of various nitrogen-containing compounds depended on the NtrC and GlnD components of the nitrogen stress response cascade. However, only mutants of GlnD with an amino terminal deletion had the unusual Fix+Eff− symbiotic phenotype, and the data suggest that these glnD mutants export fixed nitrogen in a form that the plants cannot use. These results indicate that bacterial nitrogen stress regulation is important to symbiotic productivity and suggest that GlnD may act in a novel way to influence symbiotic behavior.

Deletion of Citrate Synthase Restores Growth of Sinorhizobium meliloti 1021 Aconitase Mutants

The symbiotic nitrogen-fixing bacterium Sinorhizobium meliloti 1021 encodes only one predicted aconitase (AcnA) in its genome. AcnA has a significant degree of similarity with other bacterial aconitases that behave as dual proteins: enzymes and posttranscriptional regulators of gene expression. Similar to the case with these bacterial aconitases, AcnA activity was reversibly labile and was regained upon reconstitution with reduced iron. The aconitase promoter was active in root nodules. acnA mutants grew very poorly, had secondary mutations, and were quickly outgrown by pseudorevertants. The acnA gene was stably interrupted in a citrate synthase (gltA) null background, indicating that the intracellular accumulation of citrate may be deleterious for survival of strain 1021. No aconitase activity was detected in this mutant, suggesting that the acnA gene encodes the only functional aconitase of strain 1021. To uncover a function of AcnA beyond its catalytic role in the tricarboxylic acid cycle pathway, the gltA acnA double mutant was compared with the gltA single mutant for differences in motility, resistance to oxidative stress, nodulation, and growth on different substrates. However, no differences in any of these characteristics were found.

GlnB/GlnK PII Proteins and Regulation of the Sinorhizobium meliloti Rm1021 Nitrogen Stress Response and Symbiotic Function

The Sinorhizobium meliloti Rm1021 Delta glnD-sm2 mutant, which is predicted to make a GlnD nitrogen sensor protein truncated at its amino terminus, fixes nitrogen in symbiosis with alfalfa, but the plants cannot use this nitrogen for growth (S. N. Yurgel and M. L. Kahn, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 105:18958-18963, 2008). The mutant also has a generalized nitrogen stress response (NSR) defect. These results suggest a connection between GlnD, symbiotic metabolism, and the NSR, but the nature of this connection is unknown. In many bacteria, GlnD modifies the PII proteins, GlnB and GlnK, as it transduces a measurement of bacterial nitrogen status to a cellular response. We have now constructed and analyzed Rm1021 mutants missing GlnB, GlnK, or both proteins. Rm1021 Delta glnK Delta glnB was much more defective in its NSR than either single mutant, suggesting that GlnB and GlnK overlap in regulating the NSR in free-living Rm1021. The single mutants and the double mutant all formed an effective symbiosis, indicating that symbiotic nitrogen exchange could occur without the need for either GlnB or GlnK. N-terminal truncation of the GlnD protein interfered with PII protein modification in vitro, suggesting either that unmodified PII proteins were responsible for the glnD mutants ineffective phenotype or that connecting GlnD and appropriate symbiotic behavior does not require the PII proteins.

Determination of nitrogen fixation effectiveness in selected Medicago truncatula isolates by measuring nitrogen isotope incorporation into pheophytin

Effectiveness is a term used to describe the input that a bacterial nitrogen-fixing symbiosis makes to plant nitrogen metabolism. In legumes, effectiveness is considered a polymorphic trait where specific interactions between the plant and symbiotic rhizobia contribute to the success of the interaction. Evaluation of effectiveness using model legumes like Medicago truncatula may open new avenues for genetic studies. In previous work, an isotope dilution mass spectrometry method, which uses the effect of nitrogen fixation on the nitrogen isotope composition of chlorophyll in plants grown on 15N fertilizer as a measure of effectiveness, was developed for estimating the contribution of symbiotic nitrogen fixation to plant nitrogen content. This 15N-dilution assay was used to evaluate the level of nitrogen fixation effectiveness in three Medicago truncatula lines that have been used as parents in generating recombinant inbred lines. Three Sinorhizobium meliloti strains, USDA 1600, 102F51 and MK506, differ in this measure of effectiveness on three lines of M. truncatula: Jemalong A17, DZA315.16 and F83005.5. Plant–rhizobia combinations grown in two different conditions showed comparable differences in effectiveness.

Probing the Sinorhizobium meliloti-Alfalfa Symbiosis Using Temperature-Sensitive and Impaired-Function Citrate Synthase Mutants

To study the role of the decarboxylating leg of the bacterial TCA cycle in symbiotic nitrogen fixation, we used DNA shuffling and localized random polymerase chain reaction mutagenesis to construct a series of temperature-sensitive and impaired-function mutants in the Sinorhizobium meliloti Rm104A14 citrate synthase (gltA) gene. Reducing citrate synthase (CS) activity by mutation led to a corresponding decrease in the free-living growth rate; however, alfalfa plants formed fully effective nodules when infected with mutants having CS activities as low as 7% of the wild-type strain. Mutants with approximately 3% of normal CS activity formed nodules with lower nitrogenase activity and a mutant with less than 0.5% of normal CS activity formed Fix- nodules. Two temperature-sensitive (ts) mutants grew at a permissive temperature (25 degrees C) with 3% of wild-type CS activities but were unable to grow on minimal medium at 30 degrees C. Alfalfa plants that were inoculated with the ts mutants and grown with a root temperature of 20 degrees C formed functional nodules with nitrogenase activities approximately 20% of the wild type. When the roots of plants infected with the ts mutants were transferred to 30 degrees C, the nodules lost the ability to fix nitrogen over several days. Microscopic examination of these nodules revealed the loss of bacteroids and senescence, indicating that CS activity was essential for nodule maintenance.

Nitrogen Metabolism in Sinorhizobium meliloti-Alfalfa Symbiosis: Dissecting the Role of GlnD and PII Proteins

To contribute nitrogen for plant growth and establish an effective symbiosis with alfalfa, Sinorhizobium meliloti Rm1021 needs normal operation of the GlnD protein, a bifunctional uridylyltransferase/uridylyl-cleavage enzyme that measures cellular nitrogen status and initiates a nitrogen stress response (NSR). However, the only two known targets of GlnD modification in Rm1021, the PII proteins GlnB and GlnK, are not necessary for effectiveness. We introduced a Tyr→Phe variant of GlnB, which cannot be uridylylated, into a glnBglnK background to approximate the expected state in a glnD-sm2 mutant, and this strain was effective. These results suggested that unmodified PII does not inhibit effectiveness. We also generated a glnBglnK-glnD triple mutant and used this and other mutants to dissect the role of these proteins in regulating the free-living NSR and nitrogen metabolism in symbiosis. The glnD-sm2 mutation was dominant to the glnBglnK mutations in symbiosis but recessive in some free-living phenotypes. The data show that the GlnD protein has a role in free-living growth and in symbiotic nitrogen exchange that does not depend on the PII proteins, suggesting that S. meliloti GlnD can communicate with the cell by alternate mechanisms.

Role of a Conserved Membrane Glycine Residue in a Dicarboxylate Transporter from Sinorhizobium meliloti

Nitrogen-fixing rhizobial bacteroids import dicarboxylates by using the DctA transporter. G114 of DctA is highly conserved. A G114D mutant is inactive, but DctA with a small amino acid (G114A) or a helix disrupter (G114P) retains significant activity. G114 probably interacts with other membrane helices in stabilizing a substrate-binding pocket.