Mitchell S. Golbus

Fetal cystic adenomatoid malformation: Prenatal diagnosis and natural history

We studied the natural history and pathophysiology of congenital cystic adenomatoid malformation (CCAM) detected prenatally by ultrasound in twelve fetuses. Two types of fetal CCAM can be distinguished by gross anatomy, ultrasound findings, and prognosis. Microcystic lesions are usually associated with fetal hydrops and have a poor prognosis (five cases with one survivor). Antenatal diagnosis, maternal transport, and immediate thoracotomy after birth allowed the first reported survival of a newborn with a large microcystic CCAM. Macrocystic lesions are not usually associated with hydrops and have a favorable prognosis (five of seven survived). We conclude that fetuses with hydrops are at high risk for fetal or neonatal demise without intervention. Fetuses with CCAM but without hydrops have a good chance for survival with maternal transport, planned delivery, and immediate neonatal resuscitation and surgery.

Prenatal Genetic Diagnosis in 3000 Amniocenteses

We analyzed 3000 consecutive amniocenteses for prenatal diagnosis to assess the frequency of abnormalities, safety of the procedure, technical and interpretive difficulties and overall diagnostic accuracy. Chromosomal abnormalities were detected in 2.4 per cent of the 2404 pregnancies tested because of advanced maternal age (greater than or equal to 35 years), in 1.2 per cent of 240 monitored because of prior trisomy 21 and in 9.1 per cent of 55 examined for other cytogenetic indications. Mosaicism was detected in 0.4 per cent, and unexpected translocations in 0.4 per cent. Amniotic fluid was obtained on the first attempt in 99.3 per cent of the last 1000 cases, and cultures established from 99.7 per cent of patients attending our clinic. The fluid was discolored in 1.2 per cent of patients, a quarter of whom had missed abortions. The rate of spontaneous abortion after amniocentesis was 1.5 per cent. There were 14 diagnostic errors, six serious enough to affect the outcome of pregnancy. The karyotyping error rate was 0.07 per cent. We conclude that prenatal diagnosis is safe, highly reliable and extremely accurate.

Correction of congenital diaphragmatic hernia in utero, V. Initial clinical experience

Review of our experience with 45 cases of prenatally diagnosed congenital diaphragmatic hernia (CDH) confirms that most fetuses (77%) will not survive despite optimal pre- and postnatal care. Polyhydramnios, associated anomalies, early diagnosis, and a large volume of herniated viscera (including liver) are associated with a particularly dismal prognosis. After extensive experimental work demonstrated the efficacy, feasibility, and safety of repair in utero, we attempted to salvage six highly selected fetuses with severe CDH by open fetal surgery. Five had liver incarcerated in the chest: three died at operation because attempts to reduce the liver compromised umbilical venous return. In one, a Goretex diaphragm was constructed around the liver, but the baby died after birth. The last two fetuses, one with incarcerated liver, were successfully repaired. Both demonstrated rapid growth of the lung in utero, had surprisingly good lung function after birth despite prematurity, had the abdominal patch removed at 2 weeks, and subsequently died of nonpulmonary problems (an unrelated nursery accident in one and intestinal complications in the other). The only maternal complication was amniotic fluid leak and preterm labor. All six women are well and four have had subsequent normal children. From this phase I experience, we conclude that fetal surgery appears safe for the mother and her reproductive potential, that fetal CDH repair is feasible in selected cases, and that the fetal lung responds quickly after decompression. However, fetal repair remains a formidable technical challenge.

Primary fetal hydrothorax : natural history and management

Primary fetal hydrothorax presents a wide spectrum of severity ranging from small, harmless effusions, to life-threatening thoracic compression. To define natural history and management, we reviewed 32 cases seen at two large perinatal centers from 1980 to 1987. Spontaneous resolution of the effusions was seen in three fetuses, all of whom survived. Three fetuses were electively terminated. The overall mortality was 53%. In the 24 untreated fetuses, sex and the presence of polyhydramnios did not influence mortality, but hydrops, gestational age less than 35 weeks at delivery, and bilateral effusions were associated with a poor prognosis. Five fetuses underwent in utero decompression. In four, thoracentesis was performed, with rapid reaccumulation of the effusion. All four died from pulmonary insufficiency. In the fifth fetus, a thoracoamniotic shunt permanently decompressed the effusion, with resolution of the hydrops, and delivery of a normal viable infant. We conclude that (1) primary fetal hydrothorax may resolve or progress to hydrops, necessitating close follow-up with ultrasound; (2) pulmonary hypoplasia as a result of undrained large pleural effusions may result in neonatal mortality; (3) the gestational age at both diagnosis and delivery, the development of hydrops, and bilaterality of effusions are important prognostic predictors; and (4) the fetus with large effusions and hydrops has a poor prognosis, and thoracic decompression with a thoracoamniotic shunt may prove life saving.

Fetal intervention in obstructive uropathy: Prognosticindicators and efficacy of intervention

Management of the fetus with bilateral hydronephrosis is controversial; ability to predict outcome and efficacy of prenatal intervention are unknown. We studied 40 fetuses referred for ultrasonography, examination of fetal urine, and possible therapy. We retrospectively assigned fetuses to a good prognosis group if fetal urine was hypotonic (sodium less than 100 mEq/L, chloride less than 90 mEq/L, osmolarity less than 210 mOsm/L) and there was no ultrasonographic evidence of dysplasia; we assigned fetuses to a poor prognosis group if even one criterion was abnormal. Survival was greater in the good prognosis group than in the poor prognosis group (81% vs 12.5%; 87% vs 30%, excluding abortions) (p less than 0.005). We then attempted to assess the efficacy of prenatal urinary decompression by comparing outcome within the good and poor prognosis groups. Survival with intervention was greater in both the good prognosis group and the poor prognosis group (89% vs 70% and 30% vs 0%). In 6 of the 8 survivors in the good prognosis group, severe oligohydramnios was reversed by decompression. We conclude the fetal urine electrolyte levels and ultrasonographic appear helpful in predicting residual fetal renal function and neonatal outcome and that prenatal decompression may prevent the development of fatal pulmonary hypoplasia.

Management of the fetus with congenital hydronephrosis

Twenty-six fetuses with dilated urinary tracts were studied with serial sonograms. Eight fetuses with unilateral hydronephrosis were followed without intervention; all are well after postnatal surgical correction. Three cases of bilateral hydronephrosis resolved spontaneously before birth. Eight fetuses with bilateral hydronephrosis had evidence of poor function: Three were not treated and died shortly after birth with small lungs and dysplastic kidneys; three others had diagnostic intervention that demonstrated irreversible disease and allowed termination of the pregnancy; two had obstruction successfully corrected in utero, but renal damage proved irreversible and precluded survival at birth. Seven fetuses with bilateral hydronephrosis and equivocal function underwent early decompression. Four were delivered early and corrected ex utero; 1 has renal failure and the other 3 are well. Three had obstruction relieved in utero by a catheter shunt placed percutaneously; 1 had multiple anomalies and died; the other 2 are well. Serial sonographic observation improves perinatal management of the fetus with a dilated urinary tract. The need for diagnostic or therapeutic intervention depends on the type and severity of obstruction and the time in gestation when it is discovered. Most fetuses do not require treatment before birth; a few may benefit from early decompression in or ex utero.

A Randomized Comparison of Transcervical and Transabdominal Chorionic-Villus Sampling

BACKGROUND Chorionic-villus sampling is done in early pregnancy to obtain fetal cells for the prenatal diagnosis of genetic and chromosomal defects. Transcervical chorionic-villus sampling has been shown to be safe and effective in national trials. Recently, an alternative transabdominal technique has been suggested as potentially easier and safer. METHODS From April 1987 through September 1989, we prospectively compared transcervical and transabdominal chorionic-villus sampling in 3999 women with singleton pregnancies in whom the risk of a genetically abnormal fetus was increased. Women between 7 and 12 weeks of gestation underwent ultrasonographic evaluation of placental and uterine position. Those with active vaginal infections, active bleeding, or cervical polyps were excluded. If the obstetrician thought either sampling procedure was acceptable, the woman was asked to consent to random assignment to one of the two procedures. Both groups were followed to determine the outcome of pregnancy and the rate of spontaneous fetal loss after chorionic-villus sampling. RESULTS Among the 3999 women who entered the study, sampling was attempted in 3873 (97 percent), 1944 of whom had been assigned to undergo transcervical sampling and 1929 to undergo transabdominal sampling. Of these 3873 women, sampling was eventually successful in 3863. Sampling was successful after a single insertion of the sampling instrument in 94 percent of the transabdominal procedures and 90 percent of the transcervical procedures. Among the women with cytogenetically normal pregnancies who had sampling because of maternal age, the rate of spontaneous fetal loss through 28 weeks of pregnancy was 2.5 percent in the transcervical-sampling group and 2.3 percent in the transabdominal-sampling group (difference, 0.26 percent; 95 percent confidence interval, -0.5 to 1.0 percent). CONCLUSIONS Transabdominal and transcervical chorionic-villus sampling appear to be equally safe procedures for first-trimester diagnosis of fetal abnormalities.

Fetal Surgery for Cystic Adenomatoid Malformation of the Lung

We reviewed our experience with fetal therapy for congenital cystic adenomatoid malformation of the lung (CCAM) at the University of California, San Francisco Fetal Treatment Center. Fetuses with life-threatening CCAM were selected for prenatal treatment according to predetermined guidelines, including the gestational age of the fetus, the size of the intrathoracic lesion, maternal health, and the development of fetal hydrops. The knowledge that fetuses with hydrops are at high risk for fetal or neonatal death led to fetal surgical resection of the massively enlarged pulmonary lobe (fetal lobectomy) in six cases. In the first case, resection was too late, since preoperative labor and maternal preeclampsia could not be reversed, leading to premature delivery of a nonviable infant. In the next four cases, CCAM resection led to resolution of the hydrops, impressive in utero lung growth, and neonatal survival. Right middle and lower lobe resection in the sixth fetus at 21 weeks was successful, but subsequent inexplicable fetal death highlights the need for better postoperative fetal monitoring and treatment. Three other fetuses with a single predominant cyst underwent thoracoamniotic shunt placement alone; two survived after delivery and prompt neonatal surgery with the assistance of high-frequency ventilation or extracorporeal membrane oxygenation. Fetal therapy can now be considered for otherwise fatal space-occupying intrathoracic lesions in the fetus.

The psychological sequelae of abortion performed for a genetic indication

Psychometric testing and psychiatric interviews were conducted on 13 families in which the women had undergone amniocentesis for the prenatal detection of a genetic defect in the fetus and, upon receiving positive results, elected to have a therapeutic abortion. The indication for amniocentesis was maternal age in two families, a previous child with Downs syndrome in one family, a previous child with a recessively inherited inborn error of metabolism in four families, and the mother being a carrier for an X-linked disease in six families. The incidence of depression following selective abortion may be as high as 92 per cent among the women and as high as 82 per cent among the men studied, and was greater than that usually associated with elective abortion for psychosocial indications or with delivery of a stillborn. Four families experienced separations during the pregnancy-abortion period. Despite the emotional trauma of the procedure, most of the families studied would repeat their course of action and consider selective abortion preferable to the alternative birth of a defective child. Several modifications in the amniocentesis and selective abortion procedure which might diminish the concomitant emotional trauma are suggested.

Efficacy of second-trimester selective termination for fetal abnormalities: International collaborative experience among the world's largest centers

OBJECTIVE Our goal was to develop the most comprehensive database possible to counsel patients about selective termination for fetal abnormalities, because no one center has sufficient data to assess much more than crude loss rates. STUDY DESIGN A total of 183 completed cases of selective termination from 9 centers in 4 countries were combined (169 twins, 11 triplets, 3 quadruplets). Variables included indications, methods, (potassium chloride, exsanguination, air embolus), gestational age at procedure, pregnancies lost (< or = 24 weeks), gestational age at delivery, and neonatal outcome. RESULTS Indications for selective termination were 96 chromosomal, 76 structural, and 11 mendelian. Selective termination was technically successful in 100% of cases. In 23 of 183 (12.6%) miscarriage occurred before 24 weeks; 2 of 37 (5.4%) occurred when the procedure done at < or = 16 weeks and 21 of 146 (14.4%) when it was done thereafter. Air embolization had a higher loss rate: 10 of 24 (41.7%) compared with 13 of 156 (8.3%) by potassium chloride (chi 2 = 117, p < 0.0001). Three cases of selective termination performed in monochorionic pregnancies all resulted in pregnancy loss. Among 183 potentially viable deliveries, 7 occurred before 28 weeks, 19 at 29 to 32 weeks, 41 at 33 to 36 weeks, and 93 at > or = 37 weeks. Gestational age at delivery was not influenced by the technique used or the indication but was negatively correlated with gestational age at the time of selective termination. No coagulopathy or ischemic damage was observed in survivors. There was no maternal morbidity. CONCLUSIONS (1) Selective termination in experienced hands for a dizygotic abnormal twin is safe and effective when done with potassium chloride. A total of 83.8% of viable deliveries occurred after 33 weeks and only 4.3% at 25 to 28 weeks. (2) Gestational age at the procedure correlated positively with loss rate and inversely with gestational age at delivery; this emphasizes the need for early diagnosis in multifetal pregnancies. (3) Coagulopathy tests are probably unnecessary.