Nicola MacDonald

Screening for ovarian cancer: a pilot randomised controlled trial

BACKGROUND The value of screening for ovarian cancer is uncertain. We did a pilot randomised trial to assess multimodal screening with sequential CA 125 antigen and ultrasonography. METHODS Postmenopausal women aged 45 years or older were randomised to a control group (n=10,977) or screened group (n=10,958). Women randomised to screening were offered three annual screens that involved measurement of serum CA 125, pelvic ultrasonography if CA 125 was 30 U/mL or more, and referral for gynaecological opinion if ovarian volume was 8.8 mL or more on ultrasonography. All women were followed up to see whether they developed invasive epithelial cancers of the ovary or fallopian tube (index cancers). FINDINGS Of 468 women in the screened group with a raised CA 125, 29 were referred for a gynaecological opinion; screening detected an index cancer in six and 23 had false-positive screening results. The positive predictive value was 20.7%. During 7-year follow-up, ten further women with index cancers were identified in the screened group and 20 in the control group. Median survival of women with index cancers in the screened group was 72.9 months and in the control group was 41.8 months (p=0.0112). The number of deaths from an index cancer did not differ significantly between the control and screened groups (18 of 10,977 vs nine of 10,958, relative risk 2.0 [95% CI 0.78-5.13]). INTERPRETATION These results show that a multimodal approach to ovarian cancer screening in a randomised trial is feasible and justify a larger randomised trial to see whether screening affects mortality.

PTEN methylation is associated with advanced stage and microsatellite instability in endometrial carcinoma.

Loss of heterozygosity and mutations in the PTEN (MMAC1) tumor suppressor gene are frequent in endometrial carcinoma. Promoter hypermethylation has recently been identified as an alternative mechanism of tumor suppressor gene inactivation in cancer, but its importance in the PTEN gene in endometrial carcinoma is unknown. The purpose of our study was to assess the frequency of promoter methylation of the PTEN gene and to determine its correlation with clinicopathologic variables in a prospective and population‐based series of endometrial carcinomas with complete follow‐up. Presence of PTEN promoter methylation was seen in 26 of 138 patients (19%). Methylation was significantly associated with metastatic disease (p = 0.01) and a microsatellite unstable phenotype (p = 0.006). In conclusion, we find that PTEN promoter methylation is relatively frequent in endometrial carcinoma. Its association with metastatic disease and microsatellite instability implicates its importance in the development of this tumor type. Int. J. Cancer 91:22–26, 2001.

Calculation of the risk of ovarian cancer from serial CA-125 values for preclinical detection in postmenopausal women.

PURPOSE Previous studies of CA-125 levels from screening trials for ovarian cancer have indicated that serial CA-125 levels may identify cases better than a fixed CA-125 cutoff. We conducted a study to assess the screening performance of the risk of ovarian cancer calculation based on serial CA-125 levels from prospectively collected serum samples compared with a fixed CA-125 cutoff. PATIENTS AND METHODS The calculation was applied to data from a prospective trial of screening for ovarian cancer involving 22,000 postmenopausal women older than 45 years. The analysis was performed using 33,621 CA-125 results from 9,233 women for whom two or more serial samples were available. All serum samples from the patients with ovarian cancer were obtained before clinical detection. Sensitivity and specificity levels for preclinical detection of index cancers were calculated for various cutoffs for the risk and a single CA-125 measurement, and receiver operator curves were constructed. RESULTS The risk calculation significantly improved the area under the curve from 84% to 93% compared with a fixed cutoff for CA-125 (P =.01). For a target specificity of 98%, the risk achieved a sensitivity of 86% for preclinical detection of ovarian cancer, whereas CA-125 achieved a sensitivity of 62%. The estimates of performance are unbiased, because the risk calculation was derived independent of the data from this trial. CONCLUSION These results provide the first evidence that preclinical detection of ovarian cancer using serial CA-125 levels interpreted with the risk calculation significantly improves screening performance compared with a fixed cutoff for CA-125. The results justify the incorporation of the risk calculation in a prospective, randomized, controlled trial.

Prospective Study Using the Risk of Ovarian Cancer Algorithm to Screen for Ovarian Cancer

PURPOSE To evaluate prevalence screening in the first prospective trial of a new ovarian cancer screening (OCS) strategy (risk of ovarian cancer or ROC algorithm) on the basis of age and CA125 profile. PATIENTS AND METHODS Postmenopausal women, > or = 50 years were randomly assigned to a control group or screen group. Screening involved serum CA125, interpreted using the ROC algorithm. Participants with normal results returned to annual screening; those with intermediate results had repeat CA125 testing; and those with elevated values underwent transvaginal ultrasound (TVS). Women with abnormal or persistently equivocal TVS were referred for a gynecologic opinion. RESULTS Thirteen thousand five hundred eighty-two women were recruited. Of 6,682 women randomly assigned to screening, 6,532 women underwent the first screen. After the initial CA125, 5,213 women were classified as normal risk, 91 women elevated, and 1,228 women intermediate. On repeat CA125 testing of the latter, a further 53 women were classified as elevated risk. All 144 women with elevated risk had TVS. Sixteen women underwent surgery. Eleven women had benign pathology; one woman had ovarian recurrence of breast cancer; one woman had borderline; and three women had primary invasive epithelial ovarian cancer (EOC). The specificity and positive predictive value (PPV) for primary invasive EOC were 99.8% (95% CI, 99.7 to 99.9) and 19% (95% CI, 4.1 to 45.6), respectively. CONCLUSION An OCS strategy using the ROC algorithm is feasible and can achieve high specificity and PPV in postmenopausal women. It is being used in the United Kingdom Collaborative Trial of Ovarian Cancer Screening and in the United States in both the Cancer Genetics Network and the Gynecology Oncology Group trials of high-risk women.

Mutations in the autoregulatory domain of β-tubulin 4a cause hereditary dystonia

Dystonia type 4 (DYT4) was first described in a large family from Heacham in Norfolk with an autosomal dominantly inherited whispering dysphonia, generalized dystonia, and a characteristic hobby horse ataxic gait. We carried out a genetic linkage analysis in the extended DYT4 family that spanned 7 generations from England and Australia, revealing a single LOD score peak of 6.33 on chromosome 19p13.12‐13. Exome sequencing in 2 cousins identified a single cosegregating mutation (p.R2G) in the β‐tubulin 4a (TUBB4a) gene that was absent in a large number of controls. The mutation is highly conserved in the β‐tubulin autoregulatory MREI (methionine–arginine–glutamic acid–isoleucine) domain, highly expressed in the central nervous system, and extensive in vitro work has previously demonstrated that substitutions at residue 2, specifically R2G, disrupt the autoregulatory capability of the wild‐type β‐tubulin peptide, affirming the role of the cytoskeleton in dystonia pathogenesis. Ann Neurol 2013;73:546–553

Performance of ultrasound as a second line test to serum CA125 in ovarian cancer screening

To assess the performance of ultrasonography in a multimodal ovarian cancer screening strategy.

Ultrasound assessment of ovarian cancer risk in postmenopausal women with CA125 elevation.

SummaryWe have previously shown that, in asymptomatic post-menopausal women, serum CA125 elevation is associated with a 36-fold increase in risk of ovarian cancer. This study was undertaken to assess the value of pelvic ultrasound for further stratification of ovarian cancer risk. Of 22 000 post-menopausal women, aged ≥ 45 participating in an Ovarian Cancer Screening Trial, 741 with a CA125 ≥ 30 U ml–1 underwent pelvic ultrasonography. Twenty index cancers (primary invasive epithelial carcinomas of the ovary and fallopian tube) were diagnosed amongst these 741 women during a median follow-up of 6.8 years. Ultrasound results separated the women with CA125 elevation into two groups. Those with normal ovarian morphology had a cumulative risk (CR) of index cancer of 0.15% (95% confidence interval (CI) 0.02–1.12) which is similar to that of the entire population of 22 000 women (0.22%, 95% CI 0.18–0.30). In contrast, women with abnormal ovarian morphology had a CR of 24% (15–37) and a significantly increased relative risk (RR) of 327 (156–683). Ultrasound can effectively separate post-menopausal women with raised CA125 levels into those with normal scan findings who are not at increased risk of index cancer and those with abnormal findings who are at substantially increased risk of index cancer.

MSI-low, a real phenomenon which varies in frequency among cancer types

This study assessed whether low‐level microsatellite instability (MSI‐L) is a phenomenon specific to colorectal cancers or is also present in other tumour types. Breast (grade III ductal and lobular), endometrial and ovarian carcinomas, as well as colorectal cancers, were analysed for MSI‐L using eight microsatellite markers. The markers were selected from a panel that had previously been shown to be sensitive for the detection of MSI‐L in colorectal cancers. It was found that MSI‐L was present in 30 of 87 (35%) colorectal cancers, 2 of 59 (3%) grade III breast carcinomas, 1 of 35 (3%) lobular breast cancers, 16 of 50 (32%) endometrial cancers, and 9 of 34 (26%) ovarian cancers. These results suggest that MSI‐L is a very rare occurrence in breast carcinomas, but does occur as a real phenomenon in colorectal, endometrial, and ovarian carcinomas, which are all part of the hereditary non‐polyposis colon cancer (HNPCC) syndrome. PCR artefact was also found to masquerade as MSI‐L; criteria for the assessment of MSI‐L are suggested to eliminate this problem. Copyright

Low frequency of BRAF and CDKN2A mutations in endometrial cancer.

Several pathways have been implicated in the pathogenesis of endometrial carcinoma. Based on recent reports, BRAF mutations provide an alternative route for activation of the RAS signalling pathway. The CDKN2A (p16) tumour suppressor gene is also altered in several tumour types. We therefore wanted to assess the pattern and prognostic impact of BRAF mutations and p16 alterations in endometrial carcinomas. Only 1 of 48 tumours (2%) was found to have a BRAF mutation in exon 15, whereas 8 of 45 tumours (18%) had a K‐ras mutation. Homozygous deletion, amplification, promoter region methylation or mutation of the p16 gene was seen in 6 cases (13%), and 18 cases (38%) carried polymorphisms in the p16 gene. All tumours with presence of p16 methylation, non‐sense mutation, deletion or amplification exhibited loss of p16 expression as evaluated by immunohistochemistry. Presence of a p16 hit was significantly correlated with high FIGO stage (p = 0.04), high histologic grade (p = 0.02), estrogen receptor negativity (p = 0.05), pathologic expression of p53 (p = 0.02), pathologic expression of p16 (p = 0.05) and poor survival (p = 0.02). There was also a significant correlation between loss of p16 expression and K‐ras mutations, pathologic p53 expression and serous papillary/clear cell histologic types (p = 0.05/p = 0.001/p = 0.002). In conclusion, BRAF mutation is an infrequent finding in endometrial carcinomas. Loss of p16 expression is seen in all cases with alterations of the p16 gene. The presence of a p16 hit might be important in a subset of endometrial carcinomas with aggressive clinical behaviour. However, the mechanism of p16 inactivation remains unclear for the majority of cases exhibiting loss of expression, but the interactions with K‐ras and p53 should be further studied.

A comparison of national cancer registry and direct follow-up in the ascertainment of ovarian cancer

SummaryThe National Health Service Central Register (NHSCR) and direct follow-up were used to document ovarian and fallopian tube cancers in 22 000 women from 1986 to 1993. Direct follow-up identified 47/49 cases (96%) and the NHSCR 38/49 (78%). NHSCR ascertainment was incomplete and direct follow-up provided additional information. These findings have implications for interpretation of national cancer statistics and for use of the NHSCR in research trials.