Paul V. Dunlap

Physiological, Biochemical and Genetic Control of Bacterial Bioluminescence

Publisher Summary The bioluminescent bacteria comprise one of several groups of luminous organisms. Significant differences exist between the bioluminescence reactions of different organisms, including the structure and properties of the luciferases and substrates. Molecular oxygen is the only common feature of bioluminescence reactions, indicating that the luminescent systems in most organisms may have evolved independently. Luminescent bacteria are present in marine environment, freshwater, and terrestrial habitats. They can occur as free-living forms, saprophytes, commensal symbionts, parasites of animals, and specific light-organ symbionts. The luminescence produced by these bacteria, because of its inherent beauty and ease of detection, has attracted scientific attention. With the use of molecular approaches to study the luminescence systems of these bacteria, population biology, ecology, and molecular mechanisms of luminescence (lux) gene regulation can be studied. This chapter describes the current status of bioluminescent systems of luminous bacteria, emphasizing the biochemistry, lux gene organization, and the physiological and genetic regulation of lux gene expression. The effects of oxygen on luminescence illustrate the application of bacterial luminescence system as a sensor of specific molecules that affect metabolic function and gene expression. Knowledge of the basic biochemistry, molecular biology, and physiology of luminescent bacteria is thus not only of interest but of importance for future scientific endeavors.

Phylogeny, genomics, and symbiosis of Photobacterium

Photobacterium comprises several species in Vibrionaceae, a large family of Gram-negative, facultatively aerobic, bacteria that commonly associate with marine animals. Members of the genus are widely distributed in the marine environment and occur in seawater, surfaces, and intestines of marine animals, marine sediments and saline lake water, and light organs of fish. Seven Photobacterium species are luminous via the activity of the lux genes, luxCDABEG. Much recent progress has been made on the phylogeny, genomics, and symbiosis of Photobacterium. Phylogenetic analysis demonstrates a robust separation between Photobacterium and its close relatives, Aliivibrio and Vibrio, and reveals the presence of two well-supported clades. Clade 1 contains luminous and symbiotic species and one species with no luminous members, and Clade 2 contains mostly nonluminous species. The genomes of Photobacterium are similar in size, structure, and organization to other members of Vibrionaceae, with two chromosomes of unequal size and multiple rrn operons. Many species of marine fish form bioluminescent symbioses with three Photobacterium species: Photobacterium kishitanii, Photobacterium leiognathi, and Photobacterium mandapamensis. These associations are highly, but not strictly species specific, and they do not exhibit symbiont-host codivergence. Environmental congruence instead of host selection might explain the patterns of symbiont-host affiliation observed from nature.

Phylogenetic analysis of host–symbiont specificity and codivergence in bioluminescent symbioses

Several groups of marine fishes and squids form mutualistic bioluminescent symbioses with luminous bacteria. The dependence of the animal on its symbiont for light production, the animals specialized anatomical adaptations for harboring bacteria and controlling light emission, and the host family bacterial species specificity characteristic of these associations suggest that bioluminescent symbioses are tightly coupled associations that might involve coevolutionary interactions. Consistent with this possibility, evidence of parallel cladogenesis has been reported for squid–bacterial associations. However, genetic adaptations in the bacteria necessary for and specific to symbiosis have not been identified, and unlike obligate endosymbiotic associations in which the bacteria are transferred vertically, bacterially bioluminescent hosts acquire their light‐organ symbionts from the environment with each new host generation. These contrasting observations led us to test the hypotheses of species specificity and codivergence in bioluminescent symbioses, using an extensive sampling of naturally formed associations. Thirty‐five species of fish in seven teleost families (Chlorophthalmidae, Macrouridae, Moridae, Trachichthyidae, Monocentridae, Acropomatidae, Leiognathidae) and their light‐organ bacteria were examined. Phylogenetic analysis of a taxonomically broad sampling of associations was based on mitochondrial 16S rRNA and cytochrome oxidase I gene sequences for the fish and on recA, gyrB and luxA sequences for bacteria isolated from the light organs of these specimens. In a fine‐scale test focused on Leiognathidae, phylogenetic analysis was based also on histone H3 subunit and 28S rRNA gene sequences for the fish and on gyrB, luxA, luxB, luxF and luxE sequences for the bacteria. Deep divergences were revealed among the fishes, and clear resolution was obtained between clades of the bacteria. In several associations, bacterial species identities contradicted strict host family bacterial species specificity. Furthermore, the fish and bacterial phylogenies exhibited no meaningful topological congruence; evolutionary divergence of host fishes was not matched by a similar pattern of diversification in the symbiotic bacteria. Re‐analysis of data reported for squids and their luminous bacteria also revealed no convincing evidence of codivergence. These results refute the hypothesis of strict host family bacterial species specificity and the hypothesis of codivergence in bioluminescent symbioses.

Phylogenetic Analysis of the Incidence of lux Gene Horizontal Transfer in Vibrionaceae

Horizontal gene transfer (HGT) is thought to occur frequently in bacteria in nature and to play an important role in bacterial evolution, contributing to the formation of new species. To gain insight into the frequency of HGT in Vibrionaceae and its possible impact on speciation, we assessed the incidence of interspecies transfer of the lux genes (luxCDABEG), which encode proteins involved in luminescence, a distinctive phenotype. Three hundred three luminous strains, most of which were recently isolated from nature and which represent 11 Aliivibrio, Photobacterium, and Vibrio species, were screened for incongruence of phylogenies based on a representative housekeeping gene (gyrB or pyrH) and a representative lux gene (luxA). Strains exhibiting incongruence were then subjected to detailed phylogenetic analysis of horizontal transfer by using multiple housekeeping genes (gyrB, recA, and pyrH) and multiple lux genes (luxCDABEG). In nearly all cases, housekeeping gene and lux gene phylogenies were congruent, and there was no instance in which the lux genes of one luminous species had replaced the lux genes of another luminous species. Therefore, the lux genes are predominantly vertically inherited in Vibrionaceae. The few exceptions to this pattern of congruence were as follows: (i) the lux genes of the only known luminous strain of Vibrio vulnificus, VVL1 (ATCC 43382), were evolutionarily closely related to the lux genes of Vibrio harveyi; (ii) the lux genes of two luminous strains of Vibrio chagasii, 21N-12 and SB-52, were closely related to those of V. harveyi and Vibrio splendidus, respectively; (iii) the lux genes of a luminous strain of Photobacterium damselae, BT-6, were closely related to the lux genes of the lux-rib(2) operon of Photobacterium leiognathi; and (iv) a strain of the luminous bacterium Photobacterium mandapamensis was found to be merodiploid for the lux genes, and the second set of lux genes was closely related to the lux genes of the lux-rib(2) operon of P. leiognathi. In none of these cases of apparent HGT, however, did acquisition of the lux genes correlate with phylogenetic divergence of the recipient strain from other members of its species. The results indicate that horizontal transfer of the lux genes in nature is rare and that horizontal acquisition of the lux genes apparently has not contributed to speciation in recipient taxa.

LuxO controls luxR expression in Vibrio harveyi : evidence for a common regulatory mechanism in Vibrio

Quorum‐sensing control of luminescence in Vibrio harveyi, which involves an indirect autoinducer‐mediated phosphorelay signal transduction system, contrasts with the prototypical quorum‐sensing system of Vibrio fischeri, in which the autoinducer and the transcriptional activator LuxR directly activate lux operon expression. In V. harveyi, a regulator not homologous to V. fischeri LuxR and also designated LuxR (LuxRvh), binds specifically to the lux operon promoter region and activates the expression of luminescence. A direct connection has not been identified previously between V. harveyi LuxRvh and the autoinducer‐mediated phosphorelay system. Here, we demonstrate by mobility shift assays and measurement of luxRvh mRNA levels with luxO+ and luxO– cells that the central response regulator of the V. harveyi phosphorelay system (LuxO) represses the level of LuxRvh. Expression of a luxRvh‐bearing plasmid strongly stimulated luminescence of a luxO– mutant but had no effect on luminescence of wild‐type luxO+ cells, indicating tight regulation of luxRvh by LuxO. Furthermore, luxO null mutants of V. fischeri MJ‐1 and two autoinducer mutants, MJ‐211 (luxI–) and MJ‐215 (luxI–ainS–), emitted more light and exhibited more elevated levels of litR, a newly identified V. harveyi luxRvh homologue, than their luxO+ counterparts. These results suggest that activity of the autoinducer‐mediated phosphorelay system is coupled to LuxRvh/LitR control of luminescence through LuxO in V. harveyi and V. fischeri. The presence of homologues of V. harveyi LuxRvh, LuxO and other phosphorelay system proteins in various Vibrio species and the control of LuxRvh and its homologues by LuxO identified here in V. harveyi and V. fischeri and recently in Vibrio cholerae suggest that the luxO–luxRvh couple is a central feature of this quorum‐sensing system in members of the genus Vibrio.

Phylogenetic analysis of the lux operon distinguishes two evolutionarily distinct clades of Photobacterium leiognathi

The luminous marine bacterium Photobacterium mandapamensis was synonymized several years ago with Photobacterium leiognathi based on a high degree of phenotypic and genetic similarity. To test the possibility that P. leiognathi as now formulated, however, actually contains two distinct bacterial groups reflecting the earlier identification of P. mandapamensis and P. leiognathi as separate species, we compared P. leiognathi strains isolated from light-organ symbiosis with leiognathid fishes (i.e., ATCC 25521T, ATCC 25587, lequu.1.1 and lleuc.1.1) with strains from seawater originally described as P. mandapamensis and later synonymized as P. leiognathi (i.e., ATCC 27561T and ATCC 33981) and certain strains initially identified as P. leiognathi (i.e., PL-721, PL-741, 554). Analysis of the 16S rRNA and gyrB genes did not resolve distinct clades, affirming a close relationship among these strains. However, strains ATCC 27561T, ATCC 33981, PL-721, PL-741 and 554 were found to bear a luxF gene in the lux operon (luxABFE), whereas ATCC 25521T, ATCC 25587, lequu.1.1 and lleuc.1.1 lack this gene (luxABE). Phylogenetic analysis of the luxAB(F)E region confirmed this distinction. Furthermore, ATCC 27561T, ATCC 33981, PL-721, PL-741 and 554 all produced a higher level of luminescence on high-salt medium, as previously described for PL-721, whereas ATCC 25521T, ATCC 25587, lequu.1.1 and lleuc.1.1 all produced a higher level of luminescence on low-salt medium, a characteristic of P. leiognathi from leiognathid fish light organs. These results demonstrate that P. leiognathi contains two evolutionarily and phenotypically distinct clades, P. leiognathi subsp. leiognathi (strains ATCC 25521T, ATCC 25587, lequu.1.1 and lleuc.1.1), and P. leiognathi subsp. mandapamensis (strains ATCC 27561T, ATCC 33981, PL-721, PL-741 and 554).

Phylogenetic diversity and cosymbiosis in the bioluminescent symbioses of "Photobacterium mandapamensis".

ABSTRACT “Photobacterium mandapamensis” (proposed name) and Photobacterium leiognathi are closely related, phenotypically similar marine bacteria that form bioluminescent symbioses with marine animals. Despite their similarity, however, these bacteria can be distinguished phylogenetically by sequence divergence of their luminescence genes, luxCDAB(F)E, by the presence (P. mandapamensis) or the absence (P. leiognathi) of luxF and, as shown here, by the sequence divergence of genes involved in the synthesis of riboflavin, ribBHA. To gain insight into the possibility that P. mandapamensis and P. leiognathi are ecologically distinct, we used these phylogenetic criteria to determine the incidence of P. mandapamensis as a bioluminescent symbiont of marine animals. Five fish species, Acropoma japonicum (Perciformes, Acropomatidae), Photopectoralis panayensis and Photopectoralis bindus (Perciformes, Leiognathidae), Siphamia versicolor (Perciformes, Apogonidae), and Gadella jordani (Gadiformes, Moridae), were found to harbor P. mandapamensis in their light organs. Specimens of A. japonicus, P. panayensis, and P. bindus harbored P. mandapamensis and P. leiognathi together as cosymbionts of the same light organ. Regardless of cosymbiosis, P. mandapamensis was the predominant symbiont of A. japonicum, and it was the apparently exclusive symbiont of S. versicolor and G. jordani. In contrast, P. leiognathi was found to be the predominant symbiont of P. panayensis and P. bindus, and it appears to be the exclusive symbiont of other leiognathid fishes and a loliginid squid. A phylogenetic test for cospeciation revealed no evidence of codivergence between P. mandapamensis and its host fishes, indicating that coevolution apparently is not the basis for this bacteriums host preferences. These results, which are the first report of bacterial cosymbiosis in fish light organs and the first demonstration that P. leiognathi is not the exclusive light organ symbiont of leiognathid fishes, demonstrate that the host species ranges of P. mandapamensis and P. leiognathi are substantially distinct. The host range difference underscores possible differences in the environmental distributions and physiologies of these two bacterial species.

REGULATORY CIRCUITRY CONTROLLING LUMINESCENCE AUTOINDUCTION IN Vibrio fischeri

Abstract— Luminescence in the marine symbiotic bacterium Vibrio fischeri is subject to control by autoinduction, a regulatory mechanism that activates light production at high population density and suppresses light production at low population density. Several genetic, physiological and environmental factors contribute to autoinduction. Primary among these are a self‐produced, membrane‐permeable compound, N‐3‐oxohexanoyI‐L‐homoserine lactone, called autoinducer, which accumulates in a population density‐dependent manner during growth of V. fischeri, and a transcriptional activator protein, LuxR, which with autoinducer activates transcription of the luminescence (lux) genes (luxICDABEG; encoding proteins for autoinducer synthesis and light production). Additional genetically defined regulatory elements involved in autoinduction include 3′:5′‐cyclic AMP (cAMP), which via cAMP receptor protein activates transcription of luxR, and the GroESL proteins, which stabilize LuxR in its active form. Evidence exists also for the involvement of LexA protein, for a second autoinducer, N‐octanoyl‐l‐homoserine lactone, and under anaerobic conditions for Fnr protein. Besides these regulatory elements, nutrient limitation, presence of glucose, availability of iron and oxygen, temperature, salts and an au‐toinducer‐LuxR protein‐independent modulation also contribute to the autoinduction phenomenon. The multiplicity of genetic, physiological and environmental factors indicates that luminescence autoinduction is mediated by a complex regulatory circuitry, one that is highly integrated with and responsive to the physiological and ecological status of the cells. Long thought to be unique to V. fischeri and certain closely related marine luminous bacteria, luminescence autoinduction is now viewed as a model for understanding population density‐responsive control of gene expression in a wide variety of terrestrial and marine bacteria in which N‐acyl‐l‐homoserine lactones and homologs of Luxl and LuxR recently have been found.

Genomic and Phylogenetic Characterization of Luminous Bacteria Symbiotic with the Deep-Sea Fish Chlorophthalmus albatrossis (Aulopiformes: Chlorophthalmidae)

ABSTRACT Bacteria forming light-organ symbiosis with deep-sea chlorophthalmid fishes (Aulopiformes: Chlorophthalmidae) are considered to belong to the species Photobacterium phosphoreum. The identification of these bacteria as P. phosphoreum, however, was based exclusively on phenotypic traits, which may not discriminate between phenetically similar but evolutionarily distinct luminous bacteria. Therefore, to test the species identification of chlorophthalmid symbionts, we carried out a genomotypic (repetitive element palindromic PCR genomic profiling) and phylogenetic analysis on strains isolated from the perirectal light organ of Chlorophthalmus albatrossis. Sequence analysis of the 16S rRNA gene of 10 strains from 5 fish specimens placed these bacteria in a cluster related to but phylogenetically distinct from the type strain of P. phosphoreum, ATCC 11040T, and the type strain of Photobacterium iliopiscarium, ATCC 51760T. Analysis of gyrB resolved the C. albatrossis strains as a strongly supported clade distinct from P. phosphoreum and P. iliopiscarium. Genomic profiling of 109 strains from the 5 C. albatrossis specimens revealed a high level of similarity among strains but allowed identification of genomotypically different types from each fish. Representatives of each type were then analyzed phylogenetically, using sequence of the luxABFE genes. As with gyrB, analysis of luxABFE resolved the C. albatrossis strains as a robustly supported clade distinct from P. phosphoreum. Furthermore, other strains of luminous bacteria reported as P. phosphoreum, i.e., NCIMB 844, from the skin of Merluccius capensis (Merlucciidae), NZ-11D, from the light organ of Nezumia aequalis (Macrouridae), and pjapo.1.1, from the light organ of Physiculus japonicus (Moridae), grouped phylogenetically by gyrB and luxABFE with the C. albatrossis strains, not with ATCC 11040T. These results demonstrate that luminous bacteria symbiotic with C. albatrossis, together with certain other strains of luminous bacteria, form a clade, designated the kishitanii clade, that is related to but evolutionarily distinct from P. phosphoreum. Members of the kishitanii clade may constitute the major or sole bioluminescent symbiont of several families of deep-sea luminous fishes.

Analysis of LuxR Regulon Gene Expression during Quorum Sensing in Vibrio fischeri

The regulation of the lux operon (luxICDABEG) of Vibrio fischeri has been intensively studied as a model for quorum sensing in proteobacteria. Two-dimensional sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis analysis previously identified several non-Lux proteins in V. fischeri MJ-100 whose expression was dependent on LuxR and 3-oxo-hexanoyl-l-homoserine lactone (3-oxo-C6-HSL). To determine if the LuxR-dependent regulation of the genes encoding these proteins was due to direct transcriptional control by LuxR and 3-oxo-C6-HSL or instead was due to indirect control via an unidentified regulatory element, promoters of interest were cloned into a lacZ reporter and tested for their LuxR and 3-oxo-C6-HSL dependence in recombinant Escherichia coli. The promoters for qsrP, acfA, and ribB were found to be directly activated via LuxR-3-oxo-C6-HSL. The sites of transcription initiation were established via primer extension analysis. Based on this information and the position of the lux box-binding site near position -40, all three promoters appear to have a class II-type promoter structure. In order to more fully characterize the LuxR regulon in V. fischeri MJ-100, real-time reverse transcription-PCR was used to study the temporal expression of qsrP, acfA, and ribB during the exponential and stationary phases of growth, and electrophoretic mobility shift assays were used to compare the binding affinities of LuxR to the promoters under investigation. Taken together, the results demonstrate that regulation of the production of QsrP, RibB, and AcfA is controlled directly by LuxR at the level of transcription, thereby establishing that there is a LuxR regulon in V. fischeri MJ-100 whose genes are coordinately expressed during mid-exponential growth.