Paul Yaswen

Expression of the telomerase catalytic subunit, hTERT, induces resistance to transforming growth factor beta growth inhibition in p16INK4A(-) human mammary epithelial cells.

Failures to arrest growth in response to senescence or transforming growth factor β (TGF-β) are key derangements associated with carcinoma progression. We report that activation of telomerase activity may overcome both inhibitory pathways. Ectopic expression of the human telomerase catalytic subunit, hTERT, in cultured human mammary epithelial cells (HMEC) lacking both telomerase activity and p16INK4A resulted in gaining the ability to maintain indefinite growth in the absence and presence of TGF-β. The ability to maintain growth in TGF-β was independent of telomere length and required catalytically active telomerase capable of telomere maintenance in vivo. The capacity of ectopic hTERT to induce TGF-β resistance may explain our previously described gain of TGF-β resistance after reactivation of endogenous telomerase activity in rare carcinogen-treated HMEC. In those HMEC that overcame senescence, both telomerase activity and TGF-β resistance were acquired gradually during a process we have termed conversion. This effect of hTERT may model a key change occurring during in vivo human breast carcinogenesis.

p53-dependent integration of telomere and growth factor deprivation signals

Ectopically expressed hTERT enables p16INK4A(−) human mammary epithelial cells to proliferate in the absence of growth factors, a finding that has led to the hypothesis that hTERT has growth regulatory properties independent of its role in telomere maintenance. We now show that telomerase can alter the growth properties of cells indirectly through its role in telomere maintenance, without altering growth stimulatory pathways. We find that telomere dysfunction, indicated by 53BP1/phosphorylated histone H2AX foci at chromosome ends, is present in robustly proliferating human mammary epithelial cells long before senescence. These foci correlate with increased levels of active p53. Ectopic expression of hTERT reduces the number of foci and the level of active p53, thereby decreasing sensitivity to growth factor depletion, which independently activates p53. The continuous presence of hTERT is not necessary for this effect, indicating that telomere maintenance, rather than the presence of the enzyme itself, is responsible for the increased ability to proliferate in the absence of growth factors. Our findings provide a previously unrecognized mechanistic explanation for the observation that ectopically expressed hTERT conveys growth advantages to cells, without having to postulate nontelomeric functions for the enzyme.

Accumulation and altered localization of telomere-associated protein TRF2 in immortally transformed and tumor-derived human breast cells.

We have used cultured human mammary epithelial cells (HMEC) and breast tumor-derived lines to gain information on defects that occur during breast cancer progression. HMEC immortalized by a variety of agents (the chemical carcinogen benzo(a)pyrene, oncogenes c-myc and ZNF217, and/or dominant negative p53 genetic suppressor element GSE22) displayed marked upregulation (10–15 fold) of the telomere-binding protein, TRF2. Upregulation of TRF2 protein was apparently due to differences in post-transcriptional regulation, as mRNA levels remained comparable in finite lifespan and immortal HMEC. TRF2 protein was not upregulated by the oncogenic agents alone in the absence of immortalization, nor by expression of exogenously introduced hTERT genes. We found TRF2 levels to be at least twofold higher than in control cells in 11/15 breast tumor cell lines, suggesting that elevated TRF2 levels are a frequent occurrence during the transformation of breast tumor cells in vivo. The dispersed distribution of TRF2 throughout the nuclei in some immortalized and tumor-derived cells indicated that not all the TRF2 was associated with telomeres in these cells. The process responsible for accumulation of TRF2 in immortalized HMEC and breast tumor-derived cell lines may promote tumorigenesis by contributing to the cells’ ability to maintain an indefinite lifespan.

Soothing the watchman : Telomerase reduces the p53-dependent cellular stress response

In addition to conferring an indefinite replicative life span, telomerase renders p16(-) human mammary epithelial cells (HMEC) resistant to growth arrest by TGFβ or by loss of EGF or insulin signaling. In contrast to earlier reports, we recently found that growth factor signaling was not directly affected by telomerase expression. Rather, short dysfunctional or near-dysfunctional telomeres in proliferating telomerase(-) HMEC sensitized the cells to p53-dependent signals for growth arrest. We showed that during serial passage and before any signs of replicative senescence, HMEC lacking telomerase experience enhanced p53 stability and DNA damage signaling, as determined by increased phosphorylation on p53-Ser15 and Chk2-Thr68, and formation of 53BP1/phosphorylated histone H2AX foci at chromosome ends. This heightened activity of the p53 pathway enhanced the efficiency with which cells arrested growth in response to TGFβ or to EGF or insulin withdrawal, and was abolished by ectopic expression of hTERT, the catalytic subunit of telomerase. Telomerase elongated short telomeres, thereby reducing the basal level of activated p53 and raising cellular tolerance for other p53-dependent signals, including those emanating from non-genotoxic sources. These findings explain a number of observed effects of telomerase expression on cell growth and survival without postulating additional functions for telomerase.

Telomerase activation by c-Myc in human mammary epithelial cells requires additional genomic changes

A central question in breast cancer biology is how cancer cells acquire telomerase activity required for unlimited proliferation. According to one model, proliferation of telomerase(-) pre-malignant cells leads to telomere dysfunction and increased genomic instability. Such instability leads in rare cases to reactivation of telomerase and immortalization. The mechanism of telomerase reactivation remains unknown. We have studied immortalization of cultured human mammary epithelial cells by c-Myc, a positive transcriptional regulator of the hTERT gene encoding the catalytic subunit of telomerase. Retrovirally introduced c-Myc cDNA resulted in immortalization of human mammary epithelial cells in which the cyclin dependent kinase inhibitor, p16INK4A, was inactivated by an shRNA-encoding retrovirus. However, while c-Myc introduction immediately resulted in increased activity of transiently transfected hTERT promoter reporter constructs, endogenous hTERT mRNA levels did not change until about 60 population doublings after c-Myc introduction. Increased endogenous hTERT transcripts and stabilization of telomeric DNA in cells expressing exogenous c-Myc coincided with telomere dysfunction-associated senescence in control cultures. Genome copy number analyses of immortalized cells indicated amplifications of some or all of chromosome 5, where hTERT genes are located. hTERT gene copy number, however, was not increased in one case. The results are consistent with the hypothesis that changes in chromosome 5, while not necessarily increasing hTERT gene copy number, resulted in removal of repressive chromatin structures around hTERT loci, allowing induction of hTERT transcription. These in vitro results model one possible sequence of events leading to immortalization of breast epithelial cells during cancer progression.

Modelling breast cancer requires identification and correction of a critical cell lineage-dependent transduction bias

Clinically relevant human culture models are essential for developing effective therapies and exploring the biology and etiology of human cancers. Current breast tumour models, such as those from oncogenically transformed primary breast cells, produce predominantly basal-like properties, whereas the more common phenotype expressed by the vast majority of breast tumours are luminal. Reasons for this puzzling, yet important phenomenon, are not understood. We show here that luminal epithelial cells are significantly more resistant to viral transduction than their myoepithelial counterparts. We suggest that this is a significant barrier to generating luminal cell lines and experimental tumours in vivo and to accurate interpretation of results. We show that the resistance is due to lower affinity of luminal cells for virus attachment, which can be overcome by pretreating cells—or virus—with neuraminidase. We present an analytical method for quantifying transductional differences between cell types and an optimized protocol for transducing unsorted primary human breast cells in context.

A tumor suppressing function in the epithelial adhesion protein Trask

Trask/CDCP1 is a transmembrane glycoprotein widely expressed in epithelial tissues whose functions are just beginning to be understood, but include a role as an anti-adhesive effector of Src kinases. Early studies looking at RNA transcript levels seemed to suggest overexpression in some cancers, but immunostaining studies are now providing more accurate analyses of its expression. In an immuno-histochemical survey of human cancer specimens, we find that Trask expression is retained, reduced or sometimes lost in some tumors compared with their normal epithelial tissue counterparts. A survey of human cancer cell lines also show a similar wide variation in the expression of Trask, including some cell types with the loss of Trask expression, and additional cell types that have lost the physiological detachment-induced phosphorylation of Trask. Three experimental models were established to interrogate the role of Trask in tumor progression, including two gain-of-function models with tet-inducible expression of Trask in tumor cells lacking Trask expression, and one loss-of-function model to suppress Trask expression in tumor cells with abundant Trask expression. The induction of Trask expression and phosphorylation in MCF-7 cells and in 3T3v-src cells was associated with a reduction in tumor metastases while the shRNA-induced knockdown of Trask in L3.6pl cancer cells was associated with increased tumor metastases. The results from these three models are consistent with a tumor-suppressing role for Trask. These data identify Trask as one of several potential candidates for functionally relevant tumor suppressors on the 3p21.3 region of the genome frequently lost in human cancers.

Reinforcing targeted therapeutics with phenotypic stability factors

Deregulated cell cycle progression can often be traced to intrinsic defects in specific regulatory proteins in cancer cells. Knowledge of these primary defects has led to targeted approaches that exploit the defects and spare normal cells. However, the success of such targeted approaches is still hit-or-miss. Genetic and epigenetic variability inherent in most tumors often results in phenotypic heterogeneity that, in turn, results in de novo or acquired resistance to therapeutic agents. The ability of cells to compensate and adapt to the inhibition of a specific cell cycle mediator is not remarkable. What is novel and of great potential importance is that the ability of cells to exhibit such adaptability varies markedly. “Phenotypic stability factors” that restrict the ability of cells to undergo epithelial-mesenchymal transitions (EMT) may dictate the success or failure of targeted therapies by interfering with compensatory changes such as deregulation of CDK2 activity. Identification of existing and new agents that induce and maintain phenotypic stability factors will inform and enable synergistic approaches to the eradication of even the most aggressive tumors.

HDAC inhibitors conquer polycomb proteins

Comment on: Bommi P, et al. Cell Cycle 2010; 9:2663-73.