Pedro Laterra

Concepts and methods for landscape multifunctionality and a unifying framework based on ecosystem services

The potential of landscapes to supply multiple benefits to society beyond commodities production has received increasing research and policy attention. Linking the concept of multifunctionality with the ecosystem services (ES) approach offers a promising avenue for producing scientific evidence to inform landscape planning, e.g., about the relative utility of land-sharing and land-sparing. However, the value for decision-making of ES-based multifunctionality assessments has been constrained by a significant conceptual and methodological dispersion. To contribute towards a cohesive framework for landscape multifunctionality, we analyse case studies of joint ES supply regarding ten criteria designed to ultimately answer four aspects: (i) the multifunctionality of what (e.g., landscapes), (ii) the type of multifunctionality (e.g., based on ES synergies), (iii) the procedure of multifunctionality assessments, and (iv) the purpose of multifunctionality. We constructed a typology of methodological approaches based on scores for criteria describing the evaluation method and the level of stakeholder participation in assessments of joint ES supply. Surveyed studies and underlying types of methodological approaches (spatial, socio-spatial, functional, spatio-functional) differed in most criteria. We illustrate the influence of methodological divergence on planning recommendations by comparing two studies employing contrasting approaches (spatial and functional) to assess the joint supply of wildlife habitat and agricultural production in the Argentine Chaco. We distinguish between a pattern-based and process-based multifunctionality, where the latter can only be detected through approaches considering the ecological processes (e.g., ES complementarities) supporting the supply of multiple ES (functional and spatio-functional). Finally, we propose an integrated approach for assessing a socially-relevant process-based multifunctionality.

Fragmentation Status of Tall-Tussock Grassland Relicts in the Flooding Pampa, Argentina

Abstract Since European settlement vast areas of the tall tussock grassland dominated by Paspalum quadrifarium Lam. and Paspalum exaltatum J. Presl (“pajonal” grassland) in the Flooding Pampa of Argentina were converted to croplands and short grasslands. With the use of Landsat satellite images, we analyzed current (1998–2000) cover and spatial integrity of the pajonal community, and compared it with a vegetation map made 50 yr ago (1956–1960). Six categories of land cover were adopted: crops, sown pastures, short grassland, pajonal, wetlands, and anthropogenic areas. With the use of metrics from FRAGSTATS, landscape pattern and composition were analyzed at two scales: 1) regionally, by comparing two edaphic domain areas with relatively low and high restrictions for agriculture (low-restriction domain [LRD] and high-restriction domain [HRD], respectively); and 2) at landscape scale, by comparing ten 22 500-ha randomly selected areas (landscapes) within each edaphic domain. Current relative cover of pajonal grassland (2 173 600 ha) was 32.5%, and similar values were obtained within each edaphic domain. However, the number of pajonal patches was higher and their mean patch size, the Euclidean nearest-neighbor distance among patches (degree of isolation), and their border regularity were lower in the LRD than in the HRD. At landscape scale, the mean size of pajonal patches diminished with the percent of agricultural land within both edaphic domains. The isolation among pajonal patches increased with percent of agricultural land in the HRD, whereas no relationship between the isolation of pajonal patches and percent of agriculture was found in the LRD. As suggested by comparison with past vegetation, current pajonal status mostly results from replacement of pajonal grassland by short grassland types, cultivated pastures, and annual crops (52% and 44% of previously occupied areas in LRD and HRD, respectively), but some expansion of pajonal grassland was also observed (10% and 4% of previously unoccupied areas in LRD and HRD, respectively).

Demographic variability in tiller populations of two perennial pampa grasses

. The general objectives of this study were: (1) to investigate the importance of internal influences in regulating the tiller dynamics in natural populations of the warm-season perennial grasses Paspalum dilatatum and Sporobolus indicus, coexisting in Argentine flooded pampa, in as much as they act independently of the underlying external environment, and (2) to evaluate the extent to which interactions between internal and external factors affect the variation in tiller dynamics within such populations. Within-population variation in seasonal development of plants and tillers with different neighbour composition was studied for an annual growth cycle. Tiller survival and tillering were significantly influenced by tiller size. Tiller age influenced tiller fate, as suggested by the additive effects of age and size of tillers. These relationships varied with season and with species. Size and age of tillers showed additive effects with their neighbouring species on the tiller fate of P. dilatatum, but the effects of age and size of S. indicus changed according their neighbourhood. Tiller survival of S. indicus during the early growth season was more size-dependent when the cold-season species Poa lanigera, was the principal neighbour. Flowering and tillering probabilities were positively related through their common positive responses to tiller size. Tiller survival and recruitment between different seasons were strongly related. Independently of neighbour composition, tiller survival was generally inversely related to tiller recruitment in previous seasons. Therefore, significant density-dependent mortality of tillers was found for both species during the early summer when tiller density was expressed by basal area units.

Focusing Conservation Efforts on Ecosystem Service Supply May Increase Vulnerability of Socio-Ecological Systems

Growing concern about the loss of ecosystem services (ES) promotes their spatial representation as a key tool for the internalization of the ES framework into land use policies. Paradoxically, mapping approaches meant to inform policy decisions focus on the magnitude and spatial distribution of the biophysical supply of ES, largely ignoring the social mechanisms by which these services influence human wellbeing. If social mechanisms affecting ES demand, enhancing it or reducing it, are taken more into account, then policies are more effective. By developing and applying a new mapping routine to two distinct socio-ecological systems, we show a strong spatial uncoupling between ES supply and socio-ecological vulnerability to the loss of ES, under scenarios of land use and cover change. Public policies based on ES supply might not only fail at detecting priority conservation areas for the wellbeing of human societies, but may also increase their vulnerability by neglecting areas of currently low, but highly valued ES supply.

From biophysical to social-ecological trade-offs: integrating biodiversity conservation and agricultural production in the Argentine Dry Chaco

Agricultural intensification in rural areas of developing countries compromises the provision of ecosystem services. Social conflict arises among landholders with different preferences for ecosystem services and land-use practices in agricultural frontiers of the Argentine Dry Chaco. We explored policy and management options by assessing the actual and potential outcomes of alternative land-use systems and scenarios. We first constructed the efficiency frontier for avian habitat and agricultural productivity to analyze the combinations of ecosystem services that can be achieved under different land-use intensities. A nonlinear, concave efficiency frontier indicated opportunities to achieve large gains for production with small losses for conservation, for instance, by transitioning from lowto intermediate-intensity systems. Second, we projected production and conservation outcomes, which can be achieved through the implementation of five alternative policy options. The land sharing with conservation scenario, 70% of the landscape covered by intermediate-intensity systems and 30% by undisturbed forests, yielded the higher combination of avian habitat and agricultural productivity. Third, we constructed indifference curves of three landholder groups, i.e., preproductivist, multifunctional, and productivist, by assessing their intentions (proxies for preferences) to conserve and convert remnant forests in their landholdings. Multifunctional landholders showed balanced preferences for conserving and converting forests in their landholdings, and maintaining intermediate-intensity systems. A general willingness to conserve forests coexisted in preproductivist landholders with the intention to clear some portions of the landholding and intensify landuse, indicating the potential of an endogenously motivated transition toward a multifunctional regime. Such transition may increase their productivity by 35-65% without compromising avian habitat. Productivist landholders showed a strong inclination toward converting forests for pasture cultivation, despite the observation that they can increase their conservation outcomes by 30-50% without significantly reducing productivity by transitioning toward a multifunctional regime. Promoting this transition will require exogenous incentives and regulations tailored to the behavior of this landholder group.

Neighbour influence on the tiller demography of two perennial pampa grasses

. The aim of this study was to evaluate the possibility to use neighbour species composition to explain demographic variations in seasonal tillers in perennial grasses. Two warm-season species of the Argentina flooded pampa, Paspalum dilatatum and Sporobolus indicus, were used as models. Tiller structure and dynamics of target plants and the identity of their nearest neighbours were analyzed within a natural grassland community for an entire annual growth cycle. Canonical Correlation Analysis of tillering behaviour of target plants and neighbour species composition showed significant relationships for summer neighbourhood data. Community components affecting tiller demography were identified, and their spatial variation was described as different gradients of neighbourhood composition (NCG). NCG varied between target species, determining different spatial variation in neighbouring canopy dynamics and tiller dynamics. The tiller structure and dynamics of P. dilatatum plants were significantly correlated with the seasonal pattern of their neighbouring canopy density (NCD). Plants placed on the NCD-fluctuating extremes along NCG showed an unstable modular structure and short-lived tillers, as compared to those placed in the centre of the gradient. Relative density of the neighbouring canopy showed little variation along the NCG of S. indicus plants, which presented a tiller structure more stable and uniform than P. dilatatum plants did. Identification of NCG may be a promising approach to understanding changes in tiller dynamics of target species in relation to spatial and temporal changes in community structure.

Water regulation by grasslands: A global meta-analysis

Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones Científicas y Técnicas (CONICET), Buenos Aires, Argentina Facultad de Ciencias Agrarias, Universidad Nacional de Mar del Plata, Ruta Nacional 226 km 73.5, Mar del Plata, Argentina Estación Experimental Agropecuaria Balcarce, INTA. Centro Regional Buenos Aires Sur, Buenos Aires, Argentina Fundación Bariloche, Av. Bustillo, San Carlos de Bariloche 9500, Argentina Correspondence Ximena Sirimarco, Facultad de Ciencias Agrarias, Universidad Nacional de Mar del Plata, Ruta Nacional 226 km 73.5, Mar del Plata, Argentina. Email: ximesiri@gmail.com Funding information Fondo para la Investigación Científica y Tecnológica, Grant/Award Number: 2012‐ 0607; Inter‐American Institute for Global Change Research, Grant/Award Numbers: “Integrated Research on Ecosystem Services under and CRN3095