Peter G. Wardle

Relative influence of serum follicle stimulating hormone, age and other factors on ovarian response to gonadotrophin stimulation

Objective To determine the relative value of the womans age, basal follicle stimulating hormone (FSH), basal luteinising hormone (LH) and menstrual cycle pattern (all denned prior to treatment) in predicting the ovarian response to gonadotrophin stimulation for in vitro fertilisation.

Ovarian Dysfunction in Endometriosis-Associated and Unexplained Infertility

Purpose: The impact of endometriosis and unexplained infertility on follicular function and fertilization of oocytes in cycles totally unperturbed by exogenous gonadotrophins, when compared with controls with tubal damage, were examined.Methods: In natural cycles, without any exogenous gonadotropins, endocrine and ultrasonographic studies of follicular maturation in 18 women with minor endometriosis (41 cycles), 15 women with unexplained infertility (31 cycles), and 34 women with tubal damage (88 cycles) were performed.Results: The endometriosis group had a significantly longer follicular phase (median: 15,13, and 13 days). Both endometriosis and unexplained infertility had significantly reduced LH concentrations in follicular fluid compared with tubal damage (median: 12.1, 11.5, and 15.9 IU/L, respectively). Endometriosis was associated with a significantly reduced fertilization rate compared with unexplained infertility or tubal damage (46, 65, and 69%, respectively).Conclusions: These data show continuing evidence of ovulatory dysfunction leading to reduced fertilization rates in women with minor endometriosis.

Onset of the preovulatory luteinizing hormone surge: diurnal timing and critical follicular prerequisites

OBJECTIVE To determine the diurnal variation in the onset of the preovulatory LH surge in women. DESIGN Prospective open cohort study. SETTING University hospital research program. PATIENT(S) Thirty-five women with infertility resulting from tubal damage that was associated with minor endometriosis or with infertility of prolonged unexplained etiology. INTERVENTION(S) Women underwent transvaginal ultrasonography and serum E2 estimation daily during monitored cycles before unstimulated natural cycle IVF: exogenous gonadotropins were not administered. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S) Serum E2 concentration, follicle diameter, and endometrial thickness. RESULTS Of 169 cycles. 155 progressed to an ovulatory LH surge, of which 146 occurred within 8 hours of assessment of the outcome measures. The relationship between follicle diameter and E2 was weak, but an abnormal value for one always was countered by a normal value for the other. CONCLUSIONS Most women begin the preovulatory LH surge between midnight and 8:00 A.M., but with no particular variation by day of the week. The relationship between follicle size and serum E2 is not sufficiently strong to predict the LH surge confidently on the basis of only one variable, but the LH surge is unlikely to occur before either the follicle diameter has reached 15 mm and/or the serum E2 level has reached 600 pmol/L.

1 Is endometriosis a disease

Summary Recent comparative studies and developments in our understanding of the pathogenesis and pathophysiology of endometriosis have led to increasing doubts about whether it should always be considered a disease. Widespread use of laparoscopy for gynaecological investigation and treatment, recognition of non-pigmented lesions which are more active than classical implants, and the documentation of microscopic lesions in visually normal peritoneum, have all resulted in an increase in the frequency with which endometriosis is diagnosed. Recent studies suggest a prevalence of up to 80% in women complaining of infertility or pelvic pain, but also in up to 22% of fertile asymptomatic women undergoing sterilization. Perhaps it is a normal physiological variant, being present in such a high proportion of the population. Circumstantial evidence suggests this may be so, and the results with placebo treatment in controlled trials suggest that endometriosis is self-limiting and will regress or disappear spontaneously in 58% of women. The frequency and severity of symptoms which are often presumed to result from endometriosis do not correlate with the extent or site of lesions. Most women are pain-free. There is no dysmenorrhoea in up to 77%, no dyspareunia in up to 70%, and no pelvic pain at all in up to 61% of women with endometriosis. The pathophysiology of pain related to endometriosis is not understood. There is no medical or conservative surgical treatment that is wholly effective for symptom relief, and there is considerable placebo benefit. All treatments have risks or side-effects, and recurrent symptoms will develop in up to 45% of women within 5 years. For these reasons treatment should only be used where endometriosis fulfils the criteria of a disease, showing signs of progression with tissue damage or physiological disturbance. Asymptomatic endometriosis without tissue damage should not be considered a disease and should not be treated. Treatment of pain associated with minor endometriosis, or prophylactic treatment to prevent progression, must be regarded as empirical and not the specific requirement to control what is a questionable disease.

Serial Transvaginal Ultrasonography Following McDonald Cerclage and Repeat Suture Insertion

Summary: The aim of this study was to explore the hypothesis that serial transvaginal ultrasonography identifies early evidence of suture failure and that repeat cerclage delays delivery. We undertook a review of our policy of transvaginal ultrasonographic cervical surveillance after McDonald cerclage and of repeat suture insertion if persistent cervical effacement developed. Data from 26 pregnancies in 26 women are analyzed. The women had had a total of 57 mid‐trimester miscarriages with a median of 2 (1–6) mid‐trimester losses per woman. Twelve (46%) of the 26 women developed cervical changes at scan and underwent repeat cerclage. All 14 women who had a single suture inserted progressed to live births but 1 of the 13 women who had repeat cerclage had a mid‐trimester miscarriage (p>0.05). The median gestation at delivery for the women who had repeat cerclage was 35 (22–39) weeks compared with 38 (36–40) weeks for those who had a single suture (p>0.05). The median interval from the detection of cervical changes at scan to delivery was 13 (4–19) weeks. Serial transvaginal ultrasonography after cervical cerclage identifies a group of women who are more likely to deliver preterm, and provides an opportunity for intervention (repeat cerclage) which appears to delay delivery by an average of 7 weeks.

Ovarian Response to Purified FSH in Infertile Women with Long‐standing Hypogonadotrophic Hypogonadism

EDITORIAL COMMENT: We accepted this paper to illustrate an important point, namely that purified FSH preparations may not be appropriate for ovulation induction in ‐women lacking adequate levels of endogenous luteinizing hormone. Furthermore, if these preparations are used then reliance on oestradiol determinations alone may lead to inappropriate conclusions about the number of preovulatory follicles. However, there is probably a place for preparations of purified FSH in women with high circulating levels of endogenous luteinizing hormone.

Osteoporotic fractures in young amenorrheic women

Two cases of osteoporotic fractures in young women are presented, which highlight the risks and need for prophylactic therapy.

REDUCED PREOVULATORY GRANULOSA CELL STEROIDOGENESIS IN WOMEN WITH ENDOMETRIOSIS

To examine the cause of altered follicular fluid steroid levels and lower in vitro fertilization rate observed in infertile women with minor endometriosis, we have compared the production of estradiol (aromatase activity) and progesterone of freshly isolated granulosa cells (3h. incubation) from such women and a control group with tubal or unexplained infertility, having IVF during unstimulated or gonadotropin-stimulated cycles. As previously observed, mature oocytes from women with endometriosis had a reduced fertilization and cleavage rate in vitro in unstimulated cycles (19/37[51%] vs. 69/94[73%], p < 0.05) and stimulated cycles (20/37[57%] vs. 32/39[82%], p < 0.01). Median [95%CI] basal aromatase activity was lower in endometriosis compared with control in unstimulated cycles (2.84[2.03-3.49] pmol E2/10(3) cells/3h, n = 31 vs. 3.63[2.72-3.49], n = 55, p = 0.057) and stimulated cycles (0.31[0.16-0.50], n = 14 vs. 0.99[0.70-1.52], n = 20, p < 0.001). Progesterone production followed a similar pattern in unstimulated (0.56[0.50-0.89] pmol/10(3) cells/3h, n = 29 vs. 1.23[0.69-1.54], n = 52,) and stimulated (0.37[0.20-0.73], n = 16 vs. 0.95[0.72-1.17], n = 21) cycles (p < 0.05). Addition of FSH, LH or hCG (30ng/mL) to the incubation medium enhanced progesterone production 2 to 3-fold, but had no effect on aromatase activity. Our results indicate a defect in granulosa cell steroidogenesis associated with endometriosis, which could affect oocyte function and explain the reduction in fertilizing capacity and subsequent competence of the corpus luteum, and the associated subfertility.