Peter Sutovsky

Ubiquitin tag for sperm mitochondria

Like other mammals, humans inherit mitochondria from the mother only, even though the sperm contributes nearly one hundred mitochondria to the fertilized egg. In support of the idea that this strictly maternal inheritance of mitochondrial DNA arises from the selective destruction of sperm mitochondria, we show here that sperm mitochondria inside fertilized cow and monkey eggs are tagged by the recycling marker protein ubiquitin. This imprint is a death sentence that is written during spermatogenesis and executed after the sperm mitochondria encounter the eggs cytoplasmic destruction machinery.

Ubiquitinated sperm mitochondria, selective proteolysis, and the regulation of mitochondrial inheritance in mammalian embryos

Abstract The strictly maternal inheritance of mitochondria and mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) in mammals is a developmental paradox promoted by an unknown mechanism responsible for the destruction of the sperm mitochondria shortly after fertilization. We have recently reported that the sperm mitochondria are ubiquitinated inside the oocyte cytoplasm and later subjected to proteolysis during preimplantation development (P. Sutovsky et al., Nature 1999; 402:371–372). Here, we provide further evidence for this process by showing that the proteolytic destruction of bull sperm mitochondria inside cow egg cytoplasm depends upon the activity of the universal proteolytic marker, ubiquitin, and the lysosomal apparatus of the egg. Binding of ubiquitin to sperm mitochondria was visualized by monospecific antibodies throughout pronuclear development and during the first embryonic divisions. The recognition and disposal of the ubiquitinated sperm mitochondria was prevented by the microinjection of anti-ubiquitin antibodies and by the treatment of the fertilized zygotes with lysosomotropic agent ammonium chloride. The postfecundal ubiquitination of sperm mitochondria and their destruction was not seen in the hybrid embryos created using cow eggs and sperm of wild cattle, gaur, thus supporting the hypothesis that sperm mitochondrion destruction is species specific. The initial ligation of ubiquitin molecules to sperm mitochondrial membrane proteins, one of which could be prohibitin, occurs during spermatogenesis. Even though the ubiquitin cross-reactivity was transiently lost from the sperm mitochondria during epididymal passage, likely as a result of disulfide bond cross-linking, it was restored and amplified after fertilization. Ubiquitination therefore may represent a mechanism for the elimination of paternal mitochondria during fertilization. Our data have important implications for anthropology, treatment of mitochondrial disorders, and for the new methods of assisted procreation, such as cloning, oocyte cytoplasm donation, and intracytoplasmic sperm injection.

Development: Ubiquitin tag for sperm mitochondria

Like other mammals, humans inherit mitochondria from the mother only, even though the sperm contributes nearly one hundred mitochondria to the fertilized egg. In support of the idea that this strictly maternal inheritance of mitochondrial DNA arises from the selective destruction of sperm mitochondria, we show here that sperm mitochondria inside fertilized cow and monkey eggs are tagged by the recycling marker protein ubiquitin. This imprint is a death sentence that is written during spermatogenesis and executed after the sperm mitochondria encounter the eggs cytoplasmic destruction machinery.

Centrosome Reduction During Gametogenesis and Its Significance

Abstract Animal spermatids and primary oocytes initially have typical centrosomes comprising pairs of centrioles and pericentriolar fibrous centrosomal proteins. These somatic cell–like centrosomes are partially or completely degenerated during gametogenesis. Centrosome reduction during spermiogenesis comprises attenuation of microtubule nucleation function, loss of pericentriolar material, and centriole degeneration. Centrosome reduction during oogenesis is due to complete degeneration of centrioles, which leads to dispersal of the pericentriolar centrosomal proteins, loss of replicating capacity of the spindle poles, and switching to acentrosomal mode of spindle organization. Oocyte centrosome reduction plays an important role in preventing parthenogenetic embryogenesis and balancing centrosome number in the embryonic cells.

Unique checkpoints during the first cell cycle of fertilization after intracytoplasmic sperm injection in rhesus monkeys.

Intracytoplasmic sperm injection has begun an era of considerable improvements in treating male infertility. Despite its success, questions remain about the dangers of transmitting traits responsible for male infertility, sex and autosomal chromosome aberrations and possible mental, physical and reproductive abnormalities. We report here the first births of rhesus monkeys produced by intracytoplasmic sperm injection at rates greater or equal to those reported by clinics. Essential assumptions about this process are flawed, as shown by results with the preclinical, nonhuman primate model and with clinically discarded specimens. Dynamic imaging demonstrated the variable position of the second meiotic spindle in relation to the first polar body; consequently, microinjection targeting is imprecise and potentially lethal. Intracytoplasmic sperm injection resulted in abnormal sperm decondensation, with the unusual retention of vesicle-associated membrane protein and the perinuclear theca, and the exclusion of the nuclear mitotic apparatus from the decondensing sperm nuclear apex. Male pronuclear remodeling in the injected oocytes was required before replication of either parental genome, indicating a unique G1-to-S transition checkpoint during zygotic interphase (the first cell cycle). These irregularities indicate that the intracytoplasmic sperm injection itself might lead to the observed increased chromosome anomalies.

Paternal Contributions to the Mammalian Zygote: Fertilization after Sperm-Egg Fusion

Mammalian fertilization has traditionally been regarded as a simple blending of two gametes, during which the haploid genome of the fertilizing spermatozoon constitutes the primary paternal contribution to the resulting embryo. In contrast to this view, new research provides evidence of important cytoplasmic contributions made by the fertilizing spermatozoon to the zygotic makeup, to the organization of preimplantation development, and even reproductive success of new forms of assisted fertilization. The central role of the sperm-contributed centriole in the reconstitution of zygotic centrosome has been established in most mammalian species and is put in contrast with strictly maternal centrosomal inheritance in rodents. The complementary reduction or multiplication of sperm and oocyte organelles during gametogenesis, exemplified by the differences in the biogenesis of centrosome in sperm and oocytes, represents an intriguing mechanism for avoiding their redundancy during early embryogenesis. New studies on perinuclear theca of sperm revealed its importance for both spermatogenesis and fertilization. Remodeling of the sperm chromatin into a male pronucleus is guided by oocyte-produced, reducing peptide glutathione and a number of molecules required for the reconstitution of the functional nuclear envelope and nuclear skeleton. Although some of the sperm structures are transformed into zygotic components, the elimination of others is vital to early stages of embryonic development. Sperm mitochondria, carrying potentially harmful paternal mtDNA, appear to be eliminated by a ubiquitin-dependent mechanism. Other accessory structures of the sperm axoneme, including fibrous sheath, microtubule doublets, outer dense fibers, and the striated columns of connecting piece, are discarded in an orderly fashion. The new methods of assisted fertilization, represented by intracytoplasmic sperm injection and round spermatid injection, bypass multiple steps of natural fertilization by introducing an intact spermatozoon or spermatogenic cell into oocyte cytoplasm. Consequently, the carryover of sperm accessory structures that would normally be eliminated before or during the entry of sperm into oocyte cytoplasm persist therein and may interfere with early embryonic development, thus decreasing the success rate of assisted fertilization and possibly causing severe embryonic anomalies. Similarly, foreign organelles, proteins, messenger RNAs, and mitochondrial DNAs, which may have a profound impact on the embryonic development, are propagated by the nuclear transfer of embryonic blastomeres and somatic cell nuclei. This aspect of assisted fertilization is yet to be explored by a focused effort.

Ubiquitination of Prohibitin in Mammalian Sperm Mitochondria: Possible Roles in the Regulation of Mitochondrial Inheritance and Sperm Quality Control

Abstract Ubiquitination of the sperm mitochondria during spermatogenesis has been implicated in the targeted degradation of paternal mitochondria after fertilization, a mechanism proposed to promote the predominantly maternal inheritance of mitochondrial DNA in humans and animals. The identity of ubiquitinated substrates in the sperm mitochondria is not known. In the present study, we show that prohibitin, a highly conserved, 30- to 32-kDa mitochondrial membrane protein, occurs in a number of unexpected isoforms, ranging from 64 to greater than 185 kDa in the mammalian sperm mitochondria, which are the ubiquitinated substrates. These bands bind antiubiquitin antibodies, displaying a pattern consistent with polyubiquitinated “ladders.” Immunoprecipitation of sperm extracts with antiprohibitin antibodies followed by probing of the resultant immunocomplexes with antiubiquitin yields a banding pattern identical to that observed by antiprohibitin Western blot analysis. In fact, the presumably nonubiquitinated 30-kDa prohibitin band shows no antiubiquitin immunoreactivity. We demonstrate that ubiquitination of prohibitin occurs in testicular spermatids and spermatozoa. Ubiquitinated prohibitin molecules also accumulate in the defective fractions of ejaculated spermatozoa, which are thought to undergo surface ubiquitination during epididymal passage. In such sperm fractions, ubiquitin also coprecipitates with tubulin and microtubule-associated proteins, presumably contributed by the axonemes of defective, ubiquitinated spermatozoa. The results of the present study suggest that prohibitin is one of the ubiquitinated substrates that makes the sperm mitochondria recognizable by the eggs ubiquitin-proteasome dependent proteolytic machinery after fertilization and most likely facilitates the marking of defective spermatozoa in the epididymis for degradation.

PAWP, a Sperm-specific WW Domain-binding Protein, Promotes Meiotic Resumption and Pronuclear Development during Fertilization

We report a novel alkaline extractable protein of the sperm head that exclusively resides in the post-acrosomal sheath region of the perinuclear theca (PT) and is expressed and assembled in elongating spermatids. It is a protein that shares sequence homology to the N-terminal half of WW domain-binding protein 2, while the C-terminal half is unique and rich in proline. A functional PPXY consensus binding site for group-I WW domain-containing proteins, and numerous unique repeating motifs, YGXPPXG, are identified in the proline-rich region. Considering these molecular characteristics, we designated this protein PAWP for postacrosomal sheath WW domain-binding protein. Microinjection of recombinant PAWP or alkaline PT extract into metaphase II-arrested porcine, bovine, macaque, and Xenopus oocytes induced a high rate of pronuclear formation, which was prevented by co-injection of a competitive PPXY motif containing peptide derived from PAWP but not by co-injection of the point-mutated peptide. Intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) of porcine oocytes combined with co-injection of the competitive PPXY peptide or an anti-recombinant PAWP antiserum prevented pronuclear formation and arrested fertilization. Conversely, co-injection of the modified PPXY peptide, when the tyrosine residue of PPXY was either phosphorylated or substituted with phenylalanine, did not prevent ICSI-induced fertilization. This study uncovers a group I WW domain module signal transduction event within the fertilized egg that appears compulsory for meiotic resumption and pronuclear development during egg activation and provides compelling evidence that a PPXY motif of sperm-contributed PAWP can trigger these events.

Proteasomal Interference Prevents Zona Pellucida Penetration and Fertilization in Mammals

Abstract The ubiquitin-proteasome pathway has been implicated in the penetration of ascidian vitelline envelope by the fertilizing spermatozoon (Sawada et al., Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 2002; 99:1223–1228). The present study provides experimental evidence demonstrating proteasome involvement in the penetration of mammalian zona pellucida (ZP). Using porcine in vitro fertilization as a model, penetration of ZP was completely inhibited by specific proteasomal inhibitors MG-132 and lactacystin. Three commercial rabbit sera recognizing 20S proteasomal core subunits β-1i, β-2i, α-6, and β-5 completely blocked fertilization at a very low concentration (i.e., diluted 1/2000 to 1/8000 in fertilization medium). Neither proteasome inhibitors nor antibodies had any effects on sperm-ZP binding and acrosome exocytosis in zona-enclosed oocytes or on fertilization rates in zona-free oocytes, which were highly polyspermic. Consistent with a possible role of ubiquitin-proteasome pathway in ZP penetration, ubiquitin and various α and β type proteasomal subunits were detected in boar sperm acrosome by specific antibodies, immunoprecipitated and microsequenced by MALDI-TOF from boar sperm extracts. Antiubiquitin-immunoreactive substrates were detected on the outer face of ZP by epifluorescence microscopy. This study therefore provides strong evidence implicating the ubiquitin-proteasome pathway in mammalian fertilization and zona penetration. This finding opens a new line of acrosome/ZP research because further studies of the sperm acrosomal proteasome can provide new tools for the management of polyspermia during in vitro fertilization and identify new targets for contraceptive development.

Vesicular traffic and golgi apparatus dynamics during mammalian spermatogenesis: implications for acrosome architecture.

Abstract Vesicular membrane trafficking during acrosome biogenesis in bull and rhesus monkey spermatogenesis differs from the somatic cell paradigm as imaged dynamically using the Golgi apparatus probes β-COP, giantin, Golgin-97, and Golgin-95/GM130. In particular, sorting and delivery of proteins seemed less precise during spermatogenesis. In early stages of spermiogenesis, many Golgi resident proteins and specific acrosomal markers were present in the acrosome. Trafficking in both round and elongating spermatids was similar to what has been described for somatic cells, as judged by the kinetics of Golgi protein incorporation into endoplasmic reticulum-like structures after brefeldin A treatment. These Golgi components were retrieved from the acrosome at later stages of differentiation and were completely devoid of immature spermatozoa. Our data suggest that active anterograde and retrograde vesicular transport trafficking pathways, involving both β-COP- and clathrin-coated vesicles, are involved in retrieving Golgi proteins missorted to the acrosome and in controlling the growth and shape of this organelle.