Philippe Moingeon

Tumoral and Immunologic Response After Vaccination of Melanoma Patients With an ALVAC Virus Encoding MAGE Antigens Recognized by T Cells

PURPOSE To evaluate the toxicity, antitumoral effectiveness, and immunogenicity of repeated vaccinations with ALVAC miniMAGE-1/3, a recombinant canarypox virus containing a minigene encoding antigenic peptides MAGE-3(168-176) and MAGE-1(161-169), which are presented by HLA-A1 and B35 on tumor cells and can be recognized by cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTLs). MATERIALS AND METHODS The vaccination schedule comprised four sequential injections of the recombinant virus, followed by three booster vaccinations with the MAGE-3(168-176) and MAGE-1(161-169) peptides. The vaccines were administered, both intradermally and subcutaneously, at 3-week intervals. RESULTS Forty patients with advanced cancer were treated, including 37 melanoma patients. The vaccines were generally well tolerated with moderate adverse events, consisting mainly of transient inflammatory reactions at the virus injection sites. Among the 30 melanoma patients assessable for tumor response, a partial response was observed in one patient, and disease stabilization in two others. The remaining patients had progressive disease. Among the patients with stable or progressive disease, five showed evidence of tumor regression. A CTL response against the MAGE-3 vaccine antigen was detected in three of four patients with tumor regression, and in only one of 11 patients without regression. CONCLUSION Repeated vaccination with ALVAC miniMAGE-1/3 is associated with tumor regression and with a detectable CTL response in a minority of melanoma patients. There is a significant correlation between tumor regression and CTL response. The contribution of vaccine-induced CTL in the tumor regression process is discussed in view of the immunologic events that could be analyzed in detail in one patient.

Towards the rational design of Th1 adjuvants

Finding adjuvants in order to enhance immune responses against target immunogens has been a major and recurrent issue for the vaccine industry. It is yet to be solved, most particularly in the context of a growing interest in designing new types of vaccines capable of eliciting Th1 immune responses. A review of synthetic adjuvants which have been (or are being) tested in clinical studies is presented. Importantly, recent advances in our understanding of the physiology of immune responses offer new avenues to design and test candidate adjuvants, based on either synthetic or natural molecules, with the aim to mimic and recapitulate pro-inflammatory signals initiating both innate and adaptative immune effector mechanisms. Thus, adjuvants of the future might be a mixture of molecules selected singularly for a capacity to attract, target or activate professional antigen presenting cells. Used as a combination, such molecules should facilitate antigen presentation by professional APCs and lead to a potent induction of T cell-mediated effector and immune memory mechanisms.

Recombinant viruses as a tool for therapeutic vaccination against human cancers

Viral vectors can be used to express a variety of genes in vivo, that encode tumor associated antigens, cytokines, or accessory molecules. For vaccination purposes, the ideal viral vector should be safe and enable efficient presentation of expressed antigens to the immune system. It should also exhibit low intrinsic immunogenicity to allow for its re-administration in order to boost relevant specific immune responses. Furthermore, the vector system must meet criteria that enable its industrialization. The characteristics of the most promising viral vectors, including retroviruses, poxviruses, adenoviruses, adeno-associated viruses, herpes simplex viruses, and alphaviruses, will be reviewed in this communication. Such recombinant viruses have been successfully used in animal models as therapeutic cancer vaccines. Based on these encouraging results, a series of clinical studies, reviewed herein, have been undertaken. Human clinical trials, have as of today, allowed investigators to establish that recombinant viruses can be safely used in cancer patients, and that such recombinants can break immune tolerance against tumor-associated antigens. These promising results are now leading to improved immunization protocols associating recombinant viruses with alternate antigen-presentation platforms (prime-boost regimens), in order to elicit broad tumor-specific immune responses (humoral and cellular) against multiple target antigens.

Therapeutic vaccines against melanoma and colorectal cancer.

Our overall strategy is to develop multivalent recombinant vaccines capable of eliciting broad immune responses in patients with malignant melanoma or colorectal cancer. We report herein results from initial studies conducted in cancer patients to evaluate the effect of intratumoral administration of recombinant canarypox viruses carrying cytokine genes. Our current focus is on the induction of tumor-specific T-cell responses using a prime/boost immunization schedule with a unique vector system derived from the canary pox virus called ALVAC, in which we incorporate genes encoding Tumor Associated Antigens (TAAs) of interest. Clinical studies in colorectal cancer evaluating an ALVAC CEA candidate vaccine have shown that this approach is safe and can induce tumor-specific T cell responses. Additional clinical studies evaluating candidate vaccines against melanoma and colorectal cancer, targeting either the gp100, Mage 1, Mage 3 or p53 molecules are ongoing.

Safety of intravenous administration of a canarypox virus encoding the human wild-type p53 gene in colorectal cancer patients

Overexpression of p53 occurs in more than 50% of colorectal cancers. Therefore, p53 represents an attractive target antigen for immunotherapy. We assessed the safety of a canarypox virus encoding the human wild-type p53 gene given intravenously to end-stage colorectal cancer patients in a three-step dose escalation study aimed at inducing p53 immune responses. Patients with metastatic disease of p53-overexpressing colorectal cancers were vaccinated three times at 3-week intervals, each time with 106.5 CCID50 (CCID50=cell culture infectious dose 50%; group 1, n=5), 107.0 CCID50 (group 2, n=5) or 107.5 CCID50 (group 3, n=6). Vital signs and the occurrence of adverse events were monitored and blood was analyzed for biochemical and hematological parameters as well as signs of auto-immune safety. In all, 16 patients were enrolled and 15 patients completed three vaccinations. No anaphylactic reaction or unwanted auto-immune reactions were observed. A total of 16 serious adverse events (SAEs) occurred: 10 in group 1, three in group 2 and three in group 3. All SAEs were tumor-related complications. There was no difference in the frequency of adverse events between the three groups, except for fever. Fever was the only vaccination-related adverse event consistently observed and was most frequent and outspoken in the group 3 patients. The majority was a grade 1 or 2 fever (93%) and grade 3 fever (7%) was observed in three patients of group 3. Some patients showed humoral and cellular responses against p53, following vaccinations. After having completed his initial treatment cycle, one patient (group 2) received a second treatment cycle of three doses of 107.5 CCID50 and subsequently showed stable disease. All other patients showed progressive disease. We conclude that ALVAC-p53 can be administered intravenously to colorectal cancer patients without serious toxicity or pathological autoimmunity and can induce immune responses against p53.

Delivery technologies for human vaccines

Abstract There is currently intense research activity aimed at the development of new delivery systems for vaccines. The goal is to identify optimal methods for presenting target antigens to the immune system in a manner that will elicit immune responses appropriate for protection against, or treatment of, a specific disease. Several different approaches to this general goal have been developed, some are empirical and remain poorly understood, others are more rational, being based, for example, on mimicking natural infections in vivo or on targeting particular features of the immune system. This article will review three categories of delivery systems: (i) adjuvants and formulations; (ii) antigen vectors, including live attenuated micro-organisms and synthetic vectors; and (iii) novel devices for vaccine administration. The review will be restricted to late stage developments in the field of human vaccination.

Safety and immunogenicity of ALVAC wild-type human p53 (vCP207) by the intravenous route in rhesus macaques

p53 is over-expressed in approximately 50% of human cancers, and transfer of cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) against wild-type p53 protects mice against p53-over-expressing tumors, suggesting that p53 might be an attractive target for immunotherapy. Immunization of mice with a recombinant canarypox virus, ALVAC, expressing human wild-type p53 (vCP207) prevented growth of p53-over-expressing tumors. Since intravenous administration induced better immune responses in mice than other routes, we have proposed to use this route in cancer patients. However, because this vector has never been administered intravenously to humans, and because of the possibility of inducing auto-immunity to a self-antigen, we felt it was necessary to first evaluate safety in rhesus macaques. We found that three intravenous administrations of vCP207 at proportional doses up to 10x those proposed for humans produced no abnormalities in hematologic or clinical chemistry parameters. Serologic markers of autoimmunity and inflammation were unaffected, despite the >95% amino acid identity between human and rhesus p53. Pathological examination of numerous tissues yielded findings comparable to those in animals given placebo. Some animals showed anti-p53 antibody responses following vaccination, indicating that tolerance could be broken to some extent. However, with the exception of one animal with a possible delayed type hypersensitivity reaction to p53 protein, we did not see evidence for a cell-mediated response. The safety profile in monkeys with ALVAC-p53 provides encouragement for using such live, modified vectors via the intravenous route for human immunotherapy.

Canarypox virus expressing wild type p53 for gene therapy in murine tumors mutated in p53

The antitumor activity of a recombinant canarypox virus expressing wild type murine p53 (ALVAC-p53) was investigated in two murine syngeneic tumors harboring an endogenous p53 mutation (CMS4 and TS/A). Direct intratumor injections of ALVAC-p53 in CMS4 pre-established subcutaneous tumors induced total tumor regression in 66% of mice. Furthermore, 100% of the cured mice was protected against a contralateral subsequent challenge with the parental tumor cells. The intravenous treatment of experimental lung metastasis by ALVAC-p53 also induced significant tumor growth inhibition in both models. The antitumor effect of ALVAC-p53 was only observed in immunocompetent animals and was associated with the generation of a specific antitumor immune response. ALVAC-p53 induced the expression of a functional p53 wild type protein as demonstrated by up-regulation of p21waf1 and induction of apoptosis. A vaccine strategy using intravenous or subcutaneous ALVAC-p53/NYVAC-p53 prime boost protocol failed to induce CTL against p53 wild type used as target tumor antigen, and failed to protect mice against challenge with the mutated tumor cells. The mechanism of the curative and protective effects observed after direct intratumor injections results from the induction of a specific antitumor response directed against other antigens than p53. Our results suggest that the local induction of tumor apoptosis, combined with the adjuvant effect of ALVAC vector, enhances the immunogenicity of the intratumor environment and allows induction of specific antitumor immune response. Cancer Gene Therapy (2001) 8, 87–98

Challenges and issues in new vaccine development

The Euroconference on Vaccines of the Future: from Rational Design to Clinical Development was held at the Pasteur Institute, Paris, France from 17-19 October 2001.