Prateek K. Buch

Effective gene therapy with nonintegrating lentiviral vectors

Retroviral and lentiviral vector integration into host-cell chromosomes carries with it a finite chance of causing insertional mutagenesis. This risk has been highlighted by the induction of malignancy in mouse models, and development of lymphoproliferative disease in three individuals with severe combined immunodeficiency–X1 (refs. 2,3). Therefore, a key challenge for clinical therapies based on retroviral vectors is to achieve stable transgene expression while minimizing insertional mutagenesis. Recent in vitro studies have shown that integration-deficient lentiviral vectors can mediate stable transduction. With similar vectors, we now show efficient and sustained transgene expression in vivo in rodent ocular and brain tissues. We also show substantial rescue of clinically relevant rodent models of retinal degeneration. Therefore, the high efficiency of gene transfer and expression mediated by lentiviruses can be harnessed in vivo without a requirement for vector integration. For therapeutic application to postmitotic tissues, this system substantially reduces the risk of insertional mutagenesis.

AAV-mediated gene therapy for retinal disorders: from mouse to man

A wide range of retinal disorders can potentially be treated using viral vector-mediated gene therapy. The most widely used vectors for ocular gene delivery are based on adeno-associated virus (AAV), because they elicit minimal immune responses and mediate long-term transgene expression in a variety of retinal cell types. Proof-of-concept experiments have demonstrated the efficacy of AAV-mediated transgene delivery in a number of animal models of inherited and acquired retinal disorders. Following extensive preclinical evaluation in large animal models, gene therapy for one form of inherited retinal degeneration due to RPE65 deficiency is now being tested in three concurrent clinical trials. Here, we review different approaches for treating inherited retinal degenerations and more common acquired retinal disorders using AAV-based vectors.

Long-Term Preservation of Cones and Improvement in Visual Function Following Gene Therapy in a Mouse Model of Leber Congenital Amaurosis Caused by Guanylate Cyclase-1 Deficiency

Leber congenital amaurosis (LCA) is a severe retinal dystrophy manifesting from early infancy as poor vision or blindness. Loss-of-function mutations in GUCY2D cause LCA1 and are one of the most common causes of LCA, accounting for 20% of all cases. Human GUCY2D and mouse Gucy2e genes encode guanylate cyclase-1 (GC1), which is responsible for restoring the dark state in photoreceptors after light exposure. The Gucy2e(-/-) mouse shows partially diminished rod function, but an absence of cone function before degeneration. Although the cones appear morphologically normal, they exhibit mislocalization of proteins involved in phototransduction. In this study we tested the efficacy of an rAAV2/8 vector containing the human rhodopsin kinase promoter and the human GUCY2D gene. Following subretinal delivery of the vector in Gucy2e(-/-) mice, GC1 protein was detected in the rod and cone outer segments, and in transduced areas of retina cone transducin was appropriately localized to cone outer segments. Moreover, we observed a dose-dependent restoration of rod and cone function and an improvement in visual behavior of the treated mice. Most importantly, cone preservation was observed in transduced areas up to 6 months post injection. To date, this is the most effective rescue of the Gucy2e(-/-) mouse model of LCA and we propose that a vector, similar to the one used in this study, could be suitable for use in a clinical trial of gene therapy for LCA1.

Guanylate cyclases and associated activator proteins in retinal disease

Two isoforms of guanylate cyclase, GC1 and GC2 encoded by GUCY2D and GUCY2F, are responsible for the replenishment of cGMP in photoreceptors after exposure to light. Both are required for the normal kinetics of photoreceptor sensitivity and recovery, although disease mutations are restricted to GUCY2D. Recessive mutations in this gene cause the severe early-onset blinding disorder Leber congenital amaurosis whereas dominant mutations result in a later onset less severe cone–rod dystrophy. Cyclase activity is regulated by Ca2+ which binds to the GC-associated proteins, GCAP1 and GCAP2 encoded by GUCA1A and GUCA1B, respectively. No recessive mutations in either of these genes have been reported. Dominant missense mutations are largely confined to the Ca2+-binding EF hands of the proteins. In a similar fashion to the disease mechanism for the dominant GUCY2D mutations, these mutations generally alter the sensitivity of the cyclase to inhibition as Ca2+ levels rise following a light flash.

Subretinal delivery of adeno-associated virus serotype 2 results in minimal immune responses that allow repeat vector administration in immunocompetent mice.

Adeno‐associated virus serotype 2 (AAV2) vectors show considerable promise for ocular gene transfer. However, one potential barrier to efficacious long‐term therapy is the development of immune responses against the vector or transgene product.

Dominant Cone-Rod Dystrophy: A Mouse Model Generated by Gene Targeting of the GCAP1/Guca1a Gene

Cone dystrophy 3 (COD3) is a severe dominantly inherited retinal degeneration caused by missense mutations in GUCA1A, the gene encoding Guanylate Cyclase Activating Protein 1 (GCAP1). The role of GCAP1 in controlling cyclic nucleotide levels in photoreceptors has largely been elucidated using knock-out mice, but the disease pathology in these mice cannot be extrapolated directly to COD3 as this involves altered, rather than loss of, GCAP1 function. Therefore, in order to evaluate the pathology of this dominant disorder, we have introduced a point mutation into the murine Guca1a gene that causes an E155G amino acid substitution; this is one of the disease-causing mutations found in COD3 patients. Disease progression in this novel mouse model of cone dystrophy was determined by a variety of techniques including electroretinography (ERG), retinal histology, immunohistochemistry and measurement of cGMP levels. It was established that although retinal development was normal up to 3 months of age, there was a subsequent progressive decline in retinal function, with a far greater alteration in cone than rod responses, associated with a corresponding loss of photoreceptors. In addition, we have demonstrated that accumulation of cyclic GMP precedes the observed retinal degeneration and is likely to contribute to the disease mechanism. Importantly, this knock-in mutant mouse has many features in common with the human disease, thereby making it an excellent model to further probe disease pathogenesis and investigate therapeutic interventions.

Neuroprotective Gene Therapy for the Treatment of Inherited Retinal Degeneration

Inherited retinal degeneration (IRD) affects around 1/3000 of the population in Europe and the United States. It is a diverse group of conditions that results from mutations in any one of over 100 different genes. Many of the genes have now been identified and their functions elucidated, providing a major impetus to develop gene-based treatments. Whilst gene replacement and gene silencing strategies offer prospects for the treatment of specific inherited retinal disorders, other disorders may be less amenable to these corrective approaches. These conditions include, in particular, those associated with abnormal retinal development and those in which retinal degeneration is advanced at birth. Furthermore, the development of individualized corrective gene therapy strategies for patients with disorders due to very rare mutations may be unfeasible. However, generic gene therapy strategies that aim not to correct the gene defect but to ameliorate its consequences offer the possibility of therapies that are widely applicable across a range of conditions. One potential strategy in these cases is to halt or delay the process of cell death, so that useful visual function can be maintained throughout the lifetime of an affected individual. It has been shown in variety of experimental models over the last three decades, that neurotrophic factors have the potential to delay neuronal apoptosis. Neurotrophic factors are small proteins which have relatively short half lives and a requirement for repeated administration has limited their clinical application. Since these proteins do not ordinarily cross the blood-brain barrier, previous approaches have relied upon intrathecal infusion pumps or similar complex devices to sustain elevated neurotrophin levels within the central nervous system (CNS). However, sustained delivery through viral vector mediated expression of genes encoding neurotrophic factors may circumvent the potential side effects of repeated administration. In this review we shall explore some of the concepts of neurotrophic gene therapy and how this might be applicable to preserving vision in inherited retinal degenerations.

Absence of ocular malignant transformation after sub-retinal delivery of rAAV2/2 or integrating lentiviral vectors in p53 -deficient mice

Insertional mutagenesis following gene therapy with gammaretroviral vectors can cause the development of lymphoproliferation in children with X-linked severe combined immunodeficiency. In experimental studies, recombinant adeno-associated virus (rAAV) vectors have also been reported to increase susceptibility to carcinogenesis. The possibility of vector-induced transformation in quiescent ocular cells is probably significantly lower than in mitotically active cells, but given the increasing number of clinical applications of rAAV and lentiviral vectors for ocular disease, a specific assessment of their oncogenic potential in the eye is important. In this study, we investigated the effect of rAAV2/2 and integrating HIV-1 vectors upon the incidence of ocular neoplasia in p53 tumour-suppressor gene-knockout (p53−/−) mice, which are highly susceptible to intraocular malignant transformation. Subretinal injections of high titre rAAV2/2 or integrating HIV-1 vectors induced no tumours in p53−/− or p53+/− animals, nor significantly affected their natural longevity. We conclude that any insertional events arising from subretinal delivery of these vectors appear insufficient to cause intraocular malignancy, even in highly susceptible animals. These findings support the continued development of these vectors for ocular applications.