Rebecca Smees

Differential Secondary School Effectiveness: comparing the performance of different pupil groups

Abstract This article reports the results of an Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC) funded study which focuses on the differential academic achievement of different groups of pupils. The paper describes the findings on the size and extent of school effects across 3 years (1990, 1991, 1992) for different groups of pupils (classified by gender, eligibility for free school means [FSM], ethnic group and by prior attainment). Pupils’ overall General Certificate of Secondary Education performance and their performance in selected subjects (English, English literature, French, history, mathematics and science) have been analysed using multilevel modelling, employing a total sample of 94 inner London secondary schools. A ‘value added’ approach is adopted, controlling for selected student background measures of prior attainment (at secondary transfer), gender, age, ethnicity and low income to provide statistical controls for differences between schools in the characteristics of their intakes. Differential ...

Stability and Consistency in Secondary Schools’ Effects on Students’ GCSE Outcomes over Three Years∗

ABSTRACT This paper reports the results of a UK study investigating the issue of differential school effectiveness. The size of overall school effects versus departmental differences in effects on 16 year old students’ General Certificate in Secondary Education performance are examined, as well as the internal (within school) consistency of departmental effects across six GCSE subject outcomes and the stability of school and departmental effects across three GCSE cohorts (1990‐1992). A value added approach is adopted, controlling for selected student intake measures (such as attainment at secondary transfer). The findings of multilevel analyses suggest that very few schools perform both consistently (across subjects) and with stability (over time). The implications of the results are discussed in relation to the publication and interpretation of schools’ examination results as well as the use of school and departmental effectiveness measures for school self‐evaluation. ∗Work on this paper was supported by...

Valuing Pupils’ Views in Scottish Schools

Pupil attitude data have frequently been utilised in school effectiveness and improvement research to examine aspects of a school’s educational processes, culture and ethos. However, a related approach is based on the belief that the views and attitudes of pupils are important outcomes of schooling in their own right, in addition to academic or vocational achievement. The rationale for this approach is that schools and teachers can have a positive influence on pupils’ attitudes in a range of important areas that are central to the overall aims of schooling. These aims encompass enhancing pupils’ capacity for lifelong and independent learning and positive attitudes to education, behaviour and self-concept as well as promoting vocational aspirations and civic values. This article addresses a sub-set of these aims, specifically in terms of pupils’ attitudes to school, the learning context, self-concept and behaviour. This article also highlights the various issues and implications raised by measuring and using pupil attitudes in Scottish schools for the purpose of school self-evaluation and illustrations are drawn from the findings of the Improving School Effectiveness project funded by SOEID. Briefly, the results showed that generally both primary and secondary pupils’ reported attitudes were more positive than negative. However, differences between schools in terms of the extent of positive (or negative) attitude outcomes were identified and these differences appear to be greater at the primary level than at the secondary level. The findings are discussed in relation to the development of approaches to school self-evaluation in the UK.

Measuring Pupil Progress at Key Stage 1: Using baseline assessment to investigate value added

This paper presents results from an LEA-commissioned value-added project conducted with 107 primary schools in Surrey. The project was designed to explore the use of baseline assessment at entry to reception classes to measure pupil progress across Key Stage 1 (KS1). Pupil performance in KS1 assessments of the core curriculum areas English (reading and writing), mathematics and science were analysed. The results of multi-level analyses, the impact of pupil background factors, the feedback of results to schools and the way Surrey Education Service and schools are using the information in school improvement activities are described.

Measuring the combined risk to young children's cognitive development: An alternative to cumulative indices

In studies of child development, the combined effect of multiple risks acting in unison has been represented in a variety of ways. This investigation builds upon this preceding work and presents a new procedure for capturing the combined effect of multiple risks. A representative sample of 2,899 British children had their cognitive development measured at 36 and 58 months of age along with 10 potential risks during this period of development. Comparing a cumulative index of these risks against the previously undocumented alternative of confirmatory factor analysis using formative measurement, this study found differences favouring the factor analysis. The factor analysis procedure demonstrated greater predictive power of childrens cognitive development while it systematically tested two of the assumptions implicit in cumulative risk indices.

Comparing Teacher Assessment and Standard Task Results in England: The relationship between pupil characteristics and attainment

Abstract This study examines the 1992 National Curriculum assessment data from one large LEA in England in order to address the issue of equity. For comparison purposes we also present additional data obtained front the same sample of pupils on an NFER standardised word recognition test. The report focuses on the relative performance of gender, low income, linguistic, and special needs groups on a standardised reading test and the teacher (TA) and standard task (ST) performance assessments administered in 1992 to 7‐year‐olds as part of the national curriculum (NC) in England and Wales. The impact of schools and teacher effectiveness on student attainments scores is also examined and discussed. Briefly, the findings show that irrespective of the method of assessment, differences in attainment were found between most pupil groups investigated. However, importantly, only very modest evidence was found that particular methods of assessment appeared either to reduce or increase the differences in attainment an...

Making the Most of Your Data: School self-evaluation using value added measures

added element, albeit a rather crude score, in this year’s GCSE league tables. In response, John Carvel, the education correspondent for The Guardian, welcomes the ’first step towards a fairer system o f secondary school league tables’ but adds that ’parents may need evening classes (or the help of a good newspaper) to understand their growing sophistication’ (The Guardian, I 988a). Hill ( I 996) also highlights this as a key issue, stating, ’One of the main challenges which remain in value added work is the