Richard J. Lawrence

A concerted DNA methylation/histone methylation switch regulates rRNA gene dosage control and nucleolar dominance

Eukaryotes regulate the effective dosage of their ribosomal RNA (rRNA) genes, expressing fewer than half of the genes at any one time. Likewise, genetic hybrids displaying nucleolar dominance transcribe rRNA genes inherited from one parent but silence the other parental set. We show that rRNA gene dosage control and nucleolar dominance utilize a common mechanism. Central to the mechanism is an epigenetic switch in which concerted changes in promoter cytosine methylation density and specific histone modifications dictate the on and off states of the rRNA genes. A key component of the off switch is HDT1, a plant-specific histone deacetylase that localizes to the nucleolus and is required for H3 lysine 9 deacetylation and subsequent H3 lysine 9 methylation. Collectively, the data support a model in which cytosine methylation and histone deacetylation are each upstream of one another in a self-reinforcing repression cycle.

Arabidopsis histone deacetylase HDA6 is required for maintenance of transcriptional gene silencing and determines nuclear organization of rDNA repeats

Histone acetylation and deacetylation are connected with transcriptional activation and silencing in many eukaryotic organisms. Gene families for enzymes that accomplish these modifications show a surprising multiplicity in sequence and expression levels, suggesting a high specificity for different targets. We show that mutations in Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana) HDA6, a putative class I histone deacetylase gene, result in loss of transcriptional silencing from several repetitive transgenic and endogenous templates. Surprisingly, total levels of histone H4 acetylation are only slightly affected, whereas significant hyperacetylation is restricted to the nucleolus organizer regions that contain the rDNA repeats. This switch coincides with an increase of histone 3 methylation at Lys residue 4, a modified DNA methylation pattern, and a concomitant decondensation of the chromatin. These results indicate that HDA6 might play a role in regulating activity of rRNA genes, and this control might be functionally linked to silencing of other repetitive templates and to its previously assigned role in RNA-directed DNA methylation.

Multimegabase silencing in nucleolar dominance involves siRNA-directed DNA methylation and specific methylcytosine-binding proteins.

In genetic hybrids, the silencing of nucleolar rRNA genes inherited from one progenitor is the epigenetic phenomenon known as nucleolar dominance. An RNAi knockdown screen identified the Arabidopsis de novo cytosine methyltransferase, DRM2, and the methylcytosine binding domain proteins, MBD6 and MBD10, as activities required for nucleolar dominance. MBD10 localizes throughout the nucleus, but MBD6 preferentially associates with silenced rRNA genes and does so in a DRM2-dependent manner. DRM2 methylation is thought to be guided by siRNAs whose biogenesis requires RNA-DEPENDENT RNA POLYMERASE 2 (RDR2) and DICER-LIKE 3 (DCL3). Consistent with this hypothesis, knockdown of DCL3 or RDR2 disrupts nucleolar dominance. Collectively, these results indicate that in addition to directing the silencing of retrotransposons and noncoding repeats, siRNAs specify de novo cytosine methylation patterns that are recognized by MBD6 and MBD10 in the large-scale silencing of rRNA gene loci.

Natural variation in nucleolar dominance reveals the relationship between nucleolus organizer chromatin topology and rRNA gene transcription in Arabidopsis

In genetic hybrids, nucleolus formation on chromosomes inherited from only one parent is the epigenetic phenomenon, nucleolar dominance. By using Arabidopsis suecica, the allotetraploid hybrid of Arabidopsis thaliana and Arabidopsis arenosa, natural variation in nucleolar dominance was found to occur, providing a unique opportunity to examine homologous nucleolus organizer regions (NORs) in their active and inactive states. In A. suecica strain LC1, NORs derived from A. arenosa are active, whereas A. thaliana-derived NORs are silenced. In A. suecica strain 9502, NORs of both parental species are active. When active, NORs are partially, but not fully, decondensed. Both active and inactive LC1 NORs colocalize with the nucleolus, contradicting the long-standing assumption that rRNA gene transcription drives nucleolus association. Collectively, these observations clarify the relationships among NOR chromatin topology, rRNA gene transcription, and NOR–nucleolus associations. A. suecica strains LC1 and 9502 have each lost one pair of A. thaliana NORs during evolution, and amplified fragment-length polymorphism analysis further indicates that these strains are genetically very similar. These data suggest that nucleolar dominance can result from subtle genetic or epigenetic variation but is not a trait fundamental to a given interspecies hybrid combination.

Chromatin Turn Ons and Turn Offs of Ribosomal RNA Genes

Eukaryotes have hundreds (sometimes thousands) of ribosomal RNA (rRNA) genes whose transcription by RNA polymerase I helps establish the proliferative ability of cells by dictating the pace of ribosome production and protein synthesis. Interestingly, only a subset of the total rRNA gene pool is active at any one time, making rRNA genes attractive for understanding the dynamic balance between gene silencing and activation. However, the fact that rRNA genes are essentially identical in sequence in a pure species has been an obstacle to telling apart the active and inactive genes. Nature has provided one solution to this conundrum in the form of the epigenetic phenomenon, nucleolar dominance: the transcriptional silencing of one parental set of rRNA genes in a genetic hybrid. Parental genes in hybrids typically differ in sequence as well as expression, allowing a definition of the chromatin modifications of rRNA genes in the on and off states in vivo. By exploiting nucleolar dominance in plants, we recently showed that concerted changes in DNA methylation and histone methylation comprise an epigenetic switch that turns rRNA genes on and off. Independent studies using mouse and human cells have led to similar conclusions, implicating chromatin modifications as important components of the regulatory networks that control the effective dosage of active rRNA genes.

Msc1 links dynamic Swi6/HP1 binding to cell fate determination

Eukaryotic genomes can be organized into distinct domains of heterochromatin or euchromatin. In the fission yeast Schizosaccharomyces pombe, assembly of heterochromatin at the silent mating-type region is critical for cell fate determination in the form of mating-type switching. Here, we report that the ubiquitin ligase, Msc1, is a critical factor required for proper cell fate determination in S. pombe. In the absence of Msc1, the in vivo mobility of Swi6 at heterochromatic foci is compromised, and centromere heterochromatin becomes hyperenriched with the heterochromatin binding protein Swi6/HP1. However, at the mating-type locus, Swi6 recruitment is defective in the absence of Msc1. Therefore, Msc1 links maintaining dynamic heterochromatin with proper heterochromatin assembly and cell fate determination. These findings have implications for understanding mechanisms of differentiation in other organisms.

Uniting the paths to gene silencing.

A new study of ribosomal RNA gene silencing in the mouse provides clues as to how repressive chromatin states become established. At center stage is a chromatin remodeling complex that recruits DNA methyltransferase and histone deacetylase activities to the gene promoter, initiating a process that includes de novo DNA methylation, methylation of histone H3 on Lys9 and heterochromatin protein binding.

Detecting differential expression of parental or progenitor alleles in genetic hybrids and allopolyploids.

Three assays useful for detecting specific RNA transcripts are primer extension, S1 nuclease protection, and reverse-transcription-cleaved amplified polymorphic sequence (RT-CAPS) analysis. All three of these techniques are used routinely for gene expression analyses and allow insights not possible by RNA blot (northern blot) hybridization. In this chapter, we describe how the primer extension, S1 nuclease protection, and RT-CAPS methods can be used to discriminate one or more parental or progenitor alleles in hybrids or allopolyploids. We discuss the rationale for using the different techniques and provide examples of the data generated.