Robert F. Raff

Marrow toxicity of fractionated vs. single dose total body irradiation is identical in a canine model

PURPOSE We explored in dogs the marrow toxicity of single dose total body irradiation delivered from two opposing 60Co sources at a rate of 10 cGy/min and compared results to those seen with total body irradiation administered in 100 cGy fractions with minimum interfraction intervals of 6 hr. Dogs were not given marrow transplants. RESULTS We found that 200 cGy single dose total body irradiation was sublethal, with 12 of 13 dogs showing hematopoietic recovery and survival. Seven of 21 dogs given 300 cGy single dose total body irradiation survived compared to 6 of 10 dogs given 300 cGy fractionated total body irradiation (p = .18). One of 28 dogs given 400 cGy single dose total body irradiation survived compared to none of six given fractionated radiation (p > .20). With granulocyte colony stimulating factor administered from day 0-21 after 400 cGy total body irradiation, most dogs survived with hematological recovery. Because of the almost uniform success with granulocyte colony stimulating factor after 400 cGy single dose total body irradiation, a study of granulocyte colony stimulating factor after 400 cGy fractionated total body irradiation was deemed not to be informative and, thus, not carried out. Additional comparisons between single dose and fractionated total body irradiation were carried out with granulocyte colony stimulating factor administered after 500 and 600 cGy of total body irradiation. As with lower doses of total body irradiation, no significant survival differences were seen between the two modes of total body irradiation, and only 3 of 26 dogs studied survived with complete hematological recovery. Overall, therefore, survival among dogs given single dose total body irradiation was not different from that of dogs given fractionated total body irradiation (p = .67). Similarly, the slopes of the postirradiation declines of granulocyte and platelet counts and the rates of their recovery in surviving dogs given equal total doses of single versus fractionated total body irradiation were indistinguishable. CONCLUSION Within the limitations of the experimental design, we conclude that single-dose and fractionated total body irradiation have comparable marrow toxicity in dogs.

FK-506 and methotrexate prevent graft-versus-host disease in dogs given 9.2 Gy total body irradiation and marrow grafts from unrelated dog leukocyte antigen-nonidentical donors.

FK-506 was evaluated either alone or combined with methotrexate (MTX) for prevention of graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) in dogs given 9.2 Gy total body irradiation and dog leukocyte antigen-nonidentical unrelated marrow grafts. Studies with marrow autografts showed gut toxicity and weight loss to be major side effects of FK-506. There was no hematopoietic toxicity with FK-506. In an initial allograft study, 5 dogs were given FK-506 intramuscularly at 0.3 mg/kg/day from days 0 to 8 and then orally at 0.5 mg/kg/day. All 5 died, 3 with intussusception most likely due to FK-506 toxicity, 1 with graft failure, and 1 with GVHD. Subsequently, the FK-506 dose was reduced and these drug schedules were used: FK-506 days 0–8 at 0.15 mg/kg/day i.m. and then orally at 0.5 mg/kg/day until day 90, with or without MTX intravenously at 0.4 mg/kg days 1, 3, 6, and 11. Twenty allografts were done, 10 with FK-506 alone, and 10 with MTX/FK-506. Results were compared with those in concurrent and historical controls given either no immunosuppression (n=64), MTX (n=114), CsA (n=15), or MTX/CsA (n=17). Five of 20 current dogs died with intussusception, too early to be evaluated for GVHD. The 10 dogs given FK-506 alone survived significantly better than those not given immunosuppression but not differently from those given short-term MTX or CsA alone. Three died from toxicity, 2 with graft failure, and 4 with GVHD. Only 1 dog became a long-term survivor, and this dog inadvertently received a single dose of MTX on day 7. Two of 10 dogs given MTX/FK-506 died from toxicity, 1 died with graft failure, 2 died with GVHD, and 5 became long-term survivors, a result that is significantly better than seen with either drug alone and similar to that seen with MTX/CsA. Four of the 5 survivors had no clinical GVHD. FK-506 blood levels were 15–35 ng/ml between days 8 and 15, when gut toxicity was most severe. Thereafter, levels were approximately 5 ng/ml. In conclusion, FK-506 prolonged survival of recipients of dog leukocyte antigen-nonidentical unrelated marrow grafts. When FK-506 was combined with MTX, graft-host tolerance was induced in 50% of dogs, even though FK-506 was stopped on day 90.

Prevention of transfusion-induced sensitization to minor histocompatibility antigens on DLA-identical canine marrow grafts by gamma irradiation of marrow donor blood

Dogs given total-body irradiation and marrow transplants from DLA-identical littermates exhibit prompt and sustained hematopoietic engraftment. However, animals given three preceding blood transfusions from the marrow donor before transplant become sensitized and reject the marrow graft. Rejection is due to exposure to polymorphic minor non-DLA histocompatibility antigens expressed on blood mononuclear cells. We sought to determine whether heat treatment would prevent blood from sensitizing recipients in this model since heating blood to 45°C for 45 min abrogates the ability of blood mononuclear cells to stimulate in mixed lymphocyte culture. Three of 4 evaluable dogs given heat-treated blood before transplant rejected their marrow grafts. To prevent possible reexpression/reacquisition of mononuclear cell functional activity in vivo after transfusion, subsequent dogs were given heated blood that was additionally exposed to 2000 cGy gamma irradiation. Eight of 10 evaluable dogs given blood treated in this fashion engrafted. Unexpectedly, 9 out of 10 evaluable dogs transfused with blood treated only with gamma irradiation also engrafted. These results demonstrate that treatment of blood with gamma irradiation alone or in combination with heat prevents transfusion-induced sensitization to minor histocompatibility antigens. Results from this canine model suggest that blood products be gamma irradiated before transfusion in patients who are transplant candidates in order to prevent sensitization to minor histocompatibility antigens and reduce the risk of marrow graft rejection.

Bone marrow transplantation in canine GM1 gangliosidosis

Allogeneic bone marrow transplantation was carried out in an 81‐day‐old Portuguese water dog with GM1 gangliosidosis using a DLA identical sibling as donor. Engraftment was complete and β‐galactosidase activity in leukocytes of the transplanted dog were similar to those in the donor. Over the next 2.5 months neurological deterioration in the transplanted dog was similar to that in untreated dogs with GM1 gangliosidosis. Cerebral ganglioside GM1 concentrations were not diminished by bone marrow transplantation and cerebral β‐galactosidase activity was negligible. We conclude that allogeneic bone marrow transplantation early in life is ineffective in canine GM1 gangliosidosis.

L-leucyl-l-leucine methyl ester treatment of canine marrow and peripheral blood cells: Inhibition of proliferative responses with maintenance of the capacity for autologous marrow engraftment

Incubation of canine marrow and peripheral blood mononuclear cells with L-leucyl-L-leucine methyl ester resulted in the inhibition of mitogen- and alloantigen-induced blastogenesis, the elimination of allosensitized CTL and NK activity, and prevented the development of CTL from pCTL. The effects of these incubations were similar to those described in mice and humans. Additionally, in vitro CFU-GM growth from treated canine marrow was reduced, but could be regained when the Leu-Leu-OMe-treated marrow was cocultured with either untreated autologous peripheral blood mononuclear cells or monocyte-enriched PBMC but not with untreated monocyte-depleted PBMC. Six of seven dogs conditioned with 920 cGy total-body irradiation engrafted successfully after receiving autologous marrow that was incubated with Leu-Leu-OMe prior to infusion. These cumulative results indicate that incubation with Leu-Leu-OMe is a feasible method to deplete canine marrows of alloreactive and cytotoxic T cells prior to transplantation.

Marrow grafts between phenotypically DLA-identical and haploidentical unrelated dogs. Additional antigens controlling engraftment are not detected by cell-mediated lympholysis

Bone marrow transplants with low marrow cell doses (≤4 × 108 cells/kg) from unrelated donors were carried out in 16 dogs conditioned with 9 Gy (900 rad) of total body irradiation. No immunosuppression was given after grafting. Eleven donor-recipient pairs were phenotypically identical (group 1) for the known antigens of the canine major histocompatibility complex (DLA) and in five the donor was homozygous and the recipient heterozygous for DLA (group 2), as determined by serological histocompatibility typing and mixed leukocyte cultures including homozygous cell typing. In addition, lymphocytes from donors and recipients in group 1 were mutually nonreactive in cell-mediated lympholysis; lymphocytes from recipients in group 2 were not cytotoxic against donor cells. Eight dogs rejected their grafts and eight showed sustained engraftment; of these, four died from graft-versus-host disease. The incidence of rejection was higher than in DLA-identical littermates but lower than in DLA-nonidentical unrelated or littermate dogs. These results indicate that antigens different from the recognized alleles at DLA are involved in the control of engraftment. These antigens most likely represent the expression of unrecognized differences within DLA or are coded for by a locus different from but linked to DLA-A, B, C or D; they are not recognized in the cell-mediated lympholysis assay.

DOSE RATE-DEPENDENT SPARING OF THE GASTROINTESTINAL TRACT BY FRACTIONATED TOTAL BODY IRRADIATION IN DOGS GIVEN MARROW AUTOGRAFTS

PURPOSE We compared gastrointestinal toxicity of single vs. fractionated total body irradiation (TBI) administered at dose rates ranging from 0.021 to 0.75 Gy/min in a canine model of marrow transplantation. METHODS AND MATERIALS Dogs were given otherwise marrow-lethal single or fractionated TBI from dual 60Co sources at total doses ranging from 8-18 Gy and delivered at dose rates of 0.021, 0.05, 0.10, 0.20, 0.40, and 0.75 Gy/min, respectively. They were protected from marrow death by infusion of previously stored autologous marrow cells and they were given intensive supportive care posttransplant. The study endpoint was 10-day mortality from gastrointestinal toxicity. Logistic regression analyses were used to jointly evaluate the effects of dose rate, total dose, and delivery regimen on toxicity. RESULTS AND CONCLUSION With increasing dose rates, mortality increased for either mode of delivery of TBI. With dose rates through 0.10 Gy/min, mortality among dogs given single vs. fractionated TBI appeared comparable. Beginning at 0.20 Gy/min, fractionation appeared protective for the gastrointestinal tract. Results in dogs given TBI at 0.40 and 0.75 Gy/min, respectively, were comparable, and dose fractionation permitted the administration of considerably higher total doses of TBI than were possible after single doses, an increment that was on the order of 4.00 Gy. The data indicate that the impact of fractionating the total dose at high dose rates differs from the effect of fractionation at low dose rates.

Studies of the use of L-leucyl-L-leucine methyl ester in canine allogeneic marrow transplantation.

L-leucyl-L-leucine methyl ester (Leu-Leu-OMe) is a lysosomotropic agent that selectively kills cytotoxic T cells and their precursors, natural killer cells, and monocytes but not helper T cells or other cells of hematopoietic origin. In this study, the effects of treatment of bone marrow and peripheral blood buffy coat with Leu-Leu-OMe on the outcome of allogeneic marrow transplantation were studied in several canine models. Whereas incubation of autologous marrow with Leu-Leu-OMe had no adverse effects on subsequent engraftment, incubation of marrow from dog leukocyte antigen (DLA)-identical littermates resulted in a high rate of graft failure. Previous studies have demonstrated that the addition of peripheral blood buffy coat allows engraftment of unrelated DLA-nonidentical marrow, and in this study we found that incubation of buffy coat with Leu-Leu-OMe did not alter this graft promoting effect. In a final experiment it was demonstrated that incubation of both marrow and peripheral blood buffy coat did not prevent the development of graft-versus-host disease in recipients of marrow from DLA-haploidentical littermates. In considering the eventual application of Leu-Leu-OMe in the clinic, these results are less encouraging than those previously reported using murine models.

Dog leukocyte antigen nonidentical unrelated canine marrow grafts: enhancement of engraftment by CD4 and CD8 T cells.

Background. Previous studies have demonstrated that most marrow grafts from dog leukocyte antigen (DLA)-mismatched unrelated donors were rejected after 9.2 Gy total body irradiation (TBI), and that graft resistance could be overcome by infusing viable peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) in addition to marrow. Methods. To investigate the donor cell populations that facilitate engraftment, we determined the minimal dose of PBMCs required to ensure stable engraftment. Nineteen dogs underwent transplantation with DLA-mismatched unrelated marrow and PBMCs in a dose de-escalation study. In subsequent studies, 12 dogs were given selected CD4 or CD8 cells in addition to marrow. Results. When 3×108 PBMC/kg were given in addition to a median of 4×108 marrow cells/kg, five of six animals engrafted. At a dose of 1×108 PBMC/kg, four of eight animals engrafted, and none of five dogs engrafted at a dose of 3×107 PBMC/kg. Accordingly, 12 dogs were given 9.2 Gy TBI, marrow grafts from DLA-mismatched unrelated dogs, and a median of 5.2×107 selected CD8 cells/kg or 10.4×107 selected CD4 cells/kg corresponding to the number of CD8 or CD4 cells contained in 3×108 PBMC/kg. Five of six dogs given CD8 cells and five of six dogs given CD4 cells engrafted. Conclusion. Results indicate that at least 3×108 unmodified PBMC/kg are needed for stable engraftment of DLA-mismatched unrelated marrow, and that both CD4 and CD8 cell subpopulations are capable of facilitating engraftment.

Pharmacologic, toxicologic, and marrow transplantation studies in dogs given succinyl acetone

A novel immunosuppressant, succinyl acetone (4,6-dioxoheptanoic acid), was studied in dogs. Results with bolus intravenous injections at doses ranging from 50 to 1600 mg/kg showed dose-dependent α and β half-lives, ranging from 30 to 80 min and 7 to 27 hr, respectively. Results suggested that continuous i.v. infusion was necessary to maintain constant plasma levels. Four dogs were given 9.2 Gy total-body irradiation and autologous marrow transplants along with continuous i.v. infusion of succinyl acetone at 50, 100, 200, or 400 mg/kg/day for 21 days, and all four had rapid, sustained hematopoietic engraftment. However, two of the four dogs receiving 200 and 400 mg succinyl acetone/kg/day, respectively, developed bilateral hind-limb ataxia, with histologically confirmed cerebellar lesions in the dog given the higher dose, thus establishing a potential doselimiting neurotoxicity. Prevention of graft-versus-host disease was studied in recipients of allogeneic marrow. Dogs were given 9.2 Gy TBI, followed by hematopoietic grafts from unrelated DLA-nonidentical or DLA-haploidentical littermate dogs. Succinyl acetone was given as continuous infusion for 21 days after transplant at doses of 100–300 mg/kg/day. Starting succinyl acetone on the day of marrow infusion in four dogs failed to prevent rapid onset of acute GVHD, and dogs survived no longer than controls. Starting succinyl acetone 3 days before transplant delayed the onset of acute GVHD and prolonged survival significantly compared with that of dogs not given postgrafting immunosuppression (P=0.008); survival was comparable to that in previously reported dogs given either methotrexate or cyclosporine as postgrafting immunosuppression (P=0.88 and 0.99, respectively). Seven of the sixteen allogeneic recipients developed evidence of neurotoxicity during succinyl-acetone infusion. Neurological dysfunctions were manifested by hind-limb ataxia and posterior paresis. In conclusion, succinyl acetone significantly delayed the onset of GVHD and prolonged survival of DLA-nonidentical marrow graft recipients but did not induce graft-host tolerance and was associated with dose-limiting neurotoxicity.