Robert O. Ritchie

Tough, Bio-Inspired Hybrid Materials

The notion of mimicking natural structures in the synthesis of new structural materials has generated enormous interest but has yielded few practical advances. Natural composites achieve strength and toughness through complex hierarchical designs that are extremely difficult to replicate synthetically. We emulate natures toughening mechanisms by combining two ordinary compounds, aluminum oxide and polymethyl methacrylate, into ice-templated structures whose toughness can be more than 300 times (in energy terms) that of their constituents. The final product is a bulk hybrid ceramic-based material whose high yield strength and fracture toughness [∼200 megapascals (MPa) and ∼30 MPa·m1/2] represent specific properties comparable to those of aluminum alloys. These model materials can be used to identify the key microstructural features that should guide the synthesis of bio-inspired ceramic-based composites with unique strength and toughness.

Bioinspired structural materials.

Natural structural materials are built at ambient temperature from a fairly limited selection of components. They usually comprise hard and soft phases arranged in complex hierarchical architectures, with characteristic dimensions spanning from the nanoscale to the macroscale. The resulting materials are lightweight and often display unique combinations of strength and toughness, but have proven difficult to mimic synthetically. Here, we review the common design motifs of a range of natural structural materials, and discuss the difficulties associated with the design and fabrication of synthetic structures that mimic the structural and mechanical characteristics of their natural counterparts.

The conflicts between strength and toughness

The attainment of both strength and toughness is a vital requirement for most structural materials; unfortunately these properties are generally mutually exclusive. Although the quest continues for stronger and harder materials, these have little to no use as bulk structural materials without appropriate fracture resistance. It is the lower-strength, and hence higher-toughness, materials that find use for most safety-critical applications where premature or, worse still, catastrophic fracture is unacceptable. For these reasons, the development of strong and tough (damage-tolerant) materials has traditionally been an exercise in compromise between hardness versus ductility. Drawing examples from metallic glasses, natural and biological materials, and structural and biomimetic ceramics, we examine some of the newer strategies in dealing with this conflict. Specifically, we focus on the interplay between the mechanisms that individually contribute to strength and toughness, noting that these phenomena can originate from very different lengthscales in a materials structural architecture. We show how these new and natural materials can defeat the conflict of strength versus toughness and achieve unprecedented levels of damage tolerance within their respective material classes.

Mechanisms of fatigue-crack propagation in ductile and brittle solids

The mechanisms of fatigue-crack propagation are examined with particular emphasis on the similarities and differences between cyclic crack growth in ductile materials, such as metals, and corresponding behavior in brittle materials, such as intermetallics and ceramics. This is achieved by considering the process of fatigue-crack growth as a mutual competition between intrinsic mechanisms of crack advance ahead of the crack tip (e.g., alternating crack-tip blunting and resharpening), which promote crack growth, and extrinsic mechanisms of crack-tip shielding behind the tip (e.g., crack closure and bridging), which impede it. The widely differing nature of these mechanisms in ductile and brittle materials and their specific dependence upon the alternating and maximum driving forces (e.g., ΔK andKmax) provide a useful distinction of the process of fatigue-crack propagation in different classes of materials; moreover, it provides a rationalization for the effect of such factors as load ratio and crack size. Finally, the differing susceptibility of ductile and brittle materials to cyclic degradation has broad implications for their potential structural application; this is briefly discussed with reference to lifetime prediction.

Critical fracture stress and fracture strain models for the prediction of lower and upper shelf toughness in nuclear pressure vessel steels

Critical fracture stress and stress modified fracture strain models are utilized to describe the variation of lower and upper shelf fracture toughness with temperature and strain rate for two alloy steels used in the manufacture of nuclear pressure vessels, namely SA533B-1 (HSST Plate 02) and SA302B (Surveillance correlation heat). Both steels have been well characterized with regard to static and dynamic fracture toughness over a wide range of temperatures (−190 to 200°C), although validJIc measurements at upper shelf temperatures are still somewhat scarce. The present work utilizes simple models for the relevant fracture micromechanisms and local failure criteria to predict these variations in toughness from uniaxial tensile properties. Procedures are discussed for modelling the influence of neutron fluence on toughness in irradiated steel, and predictions are derived for the effect of increasing fluence on the variation of lower shelf fracture toughness with temperature in SA533B-1.

Plasticity and toughness in bone

Our bones are full of microscopic cracks, but the hierarchical character of the bones’ structure—from molecular to macroscopic scales—makes them remarkably resistant to fracture.

Mechanisms of tempered martensite embrittlement in low alloy steels

An investigation into the mechanisms of tempered martensite embrittlement (TME), also know as “500°F” or “350°C” or one-step temper embrittlement, has been made in commercial, ultra-high strength 4340 and Si-modified 4340 (300-M) alloy steels, with particular focus given to the role of interlath films of retained austenite. Studies were performed on the variation of i) strength and toughness, and ii) the morphology, volume fraction and thermal and mechanical stability of retained austenite, as a function of tempering temperature, following oil-quenching, isothermal holding, and continuous air cooling from the austenitizing temperature. TME was observed as a decrease in bothKIc and Charpy V-notch impact energy after tempering around 300°C in 4340 and 425°C in 300-M, where the mechanisms of fracture were either interlath cleavage or largely transgranular cleavage. The embrittlement was found to be concurrent with the interlath precipitation of cementite during temperingand the consequent mechanical instability of interlath films of retained austenite during subsequent loading. The role of silicon in 300-M was seen to retard these processes and hence retard TME to higher tempering temperatures than for 4340. The magnitude of the embrittlement was found to be significantly greater in microstructures containing increasing volume fractions of retained austenite. Specifically, in 300-M the decrease inKIc, due to TME, was a 5 MPa√m in oil quenched structures with less than 4 pct austenite, compared to a massive decrease of 70 MPa√m in slowly (air) cooled structures containing 25 pct austenite. A complete mechanism of tempered martensite embrittlement is proposed involving i) precipitation of interlath cementite due to partial thermal decomposition of interlath films of retained austenite, and ii) subsequent deformation-induced transformation on loading of remaining interlath austenite, destabilized by carbon depletion from carbide precipitation. The deterioration in toughness, associated with TME, is therefore ascribed to the embrittling effect of i) interlath cementite precipitates and ii) an interlath layer of mechanically-transformed austenite,i.e., untempered martensite. The presence of residual impurity elements in prior austenite grain boundaries, having segregated there during austenitization, may accentuate this process by providing an alternative weak path for fracture. The relative importance of these effects is discussed.

Further considerations on the inconsistency in toughness evaluation of AISI 4340 steel austenitized at increasing temperatures

A study has been made of the influence of austenitizing temperature on the ambient temperature toughness of commercial AISI 4340 ultrahigh strength steel in the as-quenched (untempered) and quenched and tempered at 200°C conditions. As suggested in previous work, a systematic trend ofincreasing plane strain fracture toughness(K)Ic anddecreasing Charpy V-notch energy is observed as the austenitizing temperature is raised while the yield strength remains unaffected. This effect is seen under both static and dynamic (impact) loading conditions, and is rationalized in terms of a differing response of the microstructure, produced by each austenitizing treatment, to the influence of notch root radius on toughness. Since failure in all microstructures was observed to proceed primarily by a ductile rupture (microvoid coalescence) mechanism, an analysis is presented to explain these results, similar to that reported previously for stress-controlled fracture, based on the assumption that ductile rupture can be considered to be strain-controlled. Under such conditions, the decrease in V-notch Charpy energy is associated with a reduction in critical fracture strain at increasing austenitizing temperatures, consistent with an observed decrease in uniaxial and plane strain ductility. The increase in sharp-crack fracture toughness, on the other hand, is associated with an increase in “characteristic distance” for ductile fracture, resulting from dissolution of void-initiating particles at high austenitizing temperatures. The microstructural factors which affect this behavior are discussed, and in particular the specific role of retained austenite is examined. No evidence was found that the enhancement of fracture toughness at high austenitizing temperatures was due to the presence of films of retained austenite. The significance of this work on commonly-used Charpy/KIc empirical correlations is briefly discussed.

A novel biomimetic approach to the design of high-performance ceramic–metal composites

The prospect of extending natural biological design to develop new synthetic ceramic–metal composite materials is examined. Using ice-templating of ceramic suspensions and subsequent metal infiltration, we demonstrate that the concept of ordered hierarchical design can be applied to create fine-scale laminated ceramic–metal (bulk) composites that are inexpensive, lightweight and display exceptional damage-tolerance properties. Specifically, Al2O3/Al–Si laminates with ceramic contents up to approximately 40 vol% and with lamellae thicknesses down to 10 µm were processed and characterized. These structures achieve an excellent fracture toughness of 40 MPa√m at a tensile strength of approximately 300 MPa. Salient toughening mechanisms are described together with further toughening strategies.

On the calibration of the electrical potential technique for monitoring crack growth using finite element methods

Finite element analysis procedures are utilized to provide theoretical calibration curves for the electrical potential crack-monitoring system as applied to single-edge-notch (SEN) and compact tension (CT) fracture specimens. The results are compared to existing calibrations for such test piece geometries derived using experimental, electrical analog and analytical (conformal mapping) procedures.RésuméDes procédures danalyse par éléments finis sont utilisées pour fournir la courbe de calibrage théorique dans le cas dun système davertissement de fissuration par potentiel électrique tel que appliqué dans les éprouvettes à entaille simple latérale et dans les éprouvettes de traction compactes utilisées pour létude de la rupture. Les résultats sont comparés avec les calibrages existants pour des géométries déprouvettes dessai de ce type, qui dérivent de procédures expérimentales analogiques électriques et analytiques par représentation conforme.