Rudolf A. Raff

Evo-devo: the evolution of a new discipline

The history of life documented in the fossil record shows that the evolution of complex organisms such as animals and plants has involved marked changes in morphology, and the appearance of new features. However, evolutionary change occurs not by the direct transformation of adult ancestors into adult descendants but rather when developmental processes produce the features of each generation in an evolving lineage. Therefore, evolution cannot be understood without understanding the evolution of development, and how the process of development itself biases or constrains evolution. A revolutionary synthesis of developmental biology and evolution is in progress.

The testis-specific β-tubulin subunit in drosophila melanogaster has multiple functions in spermatogenesis

We have isolated four recessive male sterile mutations in the structural gene for the testis-specific Drosophila beta 2-tubulin. Each of these mutations encodes a variant beta 2-tubulin subunit synthesized at normal levels, but which is subsequently unstable and rapidly degraded within the testis. In such testes, the normal alpha tubulins are also synthesized at normal levels and then degraded. Thus in mutant males the testis tubulin pool is drastically reduced relative to wild-type. In males homozygous for any of the recessive beta 2-tubulin mutations, the early mitotic divisions, which are completed before the time of synthesis of beta 2-tubulin, are normal. Thereafter, however, all microtubule-mediated events subsequent to the expression of the altered subunit are defective: meiosis, nuclear shaping and assembly of the axoneme all fail to occur. We thus conclude that the beta 2-tubulin subunit that forms the Drosophila sperm axoneme is not functionally restricted but serves multiple functions in spermatogenesis, including the assembly of both singlet and doublet tubules.

Constraint, flexibility, and phylogenetic history in the evolution of direct development in sea urchins☆

Development in sea urchins typically involves the production of an elaborate feeding larva, the pluteus, within which the juvenile sea urchin grows. However, a significant fraction of sea urchins have completely or partially eliminated the pluteus, and instead undergo direct development from a large egg. Direct development is achieved primarily by heterochrony, that is, by the abbreviation or elimination of larval developmental processes and the acceleration of processes involved in development of adult features. Direct development has evolved independently several times, and in several ways. These radically altered ontogenies offer remarkable opportunities for the study of the mechanisms by which early development undergoes evolutionary modification. The recent availability of monoclonal antibody and cDNA probes that recognize homologous cells in embryos of closely related typical and direct developing species makes possible an experimental analysis of the cellular and molecular bases for heterochronic changes in development.

Heterochrony: Developmental mechanisms and evolutionary results

The concept of heterochrony, that the relative timing of ontogenetic events can shift during evolution, has been a major paradigm for understanding the role of developmental processes in evolution. In this paper we consider heterochrony from the perspective of developmental biology. Our objective is to redefine heterochrony more broadly so that the concept becomes readily applicable to the evolution of the full range of ontogenetic processes, from embryogenesis through the adult. Throughout, we stress the importance of considering heterochrony from a hierarchical perspective. Thus, we recognize that a heterochronic change at one level of organization may be the result of non‐heterochronic events at an underlying level. As such, heterochrony must be studied using a combination of genetic, molecular, cellular, and morphological approaches.

The evolution of developmental strategy in marine invertebrates.

Developmental mode varies widely in most animal phyla. These differences in developmental strategy exert a profound influence on the ecology and evolution of closely related species. The mechanistic alterations in ontogeny that lead to switches in developmental mode are coming under increasing scrutiny. Echinoids are one of the best-understood groups in this regard. Parallel modifications in direct-developing echinoids point to some of the key changes in oogenesis and embryogenesis that produce switches in developmental mode.

POPULATION GENETIC CONSEQUENCES OF DEVELOPMENTAL EVOLUTION IN SEA URCHINS (GENUS HELIOCIDARIS)

Within the sea urchin genus Heliocidaris, changes in early embryonic and larval development have resulted in dramatic differences in the length of time larvae spend in the plankton before settling. The larvae of one species, H. tuberculata, spend several weeks feeding in the plankton before settling and metamorphosing into juveniles. The other species, H. erythrogramma, has modified this extended planktonic larval stage and develops into a juvenile within 3–4 days after fertilization. We used restriction site polymorphisms in mitochondrial DNA to examine the population genetic consequences of these developmental changes. Ten restriction enzymes were used to assay the mitochondrial genome of 29 individuals from 2 localities for H. tuberculata and 62 individuals from 5 localities for H. erythrogramma. Within H. tuberculata, 11 mitochondrial genotypes were identified. A GST analysis showed high levels of genetic exchange between populations separated by 1,000 kilometers of open ocean. In contrast, in H. erythrogramma, 13 mitochondrial genotypes differing by up to 2.33% were geographically partitioned over spatial scales ranging from 800 to 3,400 kilometers. Between distant localities, there was complete mitochondrial lineage sorting and large sequence divergence between resulting clades. Over much smaller spatial scales (< 1,000 km), genetic differentiation was due to the differential sorting of very similar genotypes. This pattern of mitochondrial variation suggests that these population differences have arisen recently and may reflect the historical interplay between the restricted dispersal capabilities of H. erythrogramma and the climatic and geological changes associated with Pleistocene Ice Ages.

A test for masked message: The template activity of messenger ribonucleoprotein particles isolated from sea urchin eggs☆

Abstract The hypothesis that the “masked message” of unfertilized eggs consists of nontranslatable mRNP particles was directly tested by in vitro translation of mRNPs in a system derived from wheat germ. Three classes of mRNPs were tested: particles prepared from sea urchin eggs in buffers containing 0.35 M K + , particles prepared from sea urchin eggs in 0.35 M Na + , and particles released with EDTA in 0.35 M K + from polysomes of sea urchin embryos cultured in the presence of actinomycin D. The mRNA content of particles was monitored by determination of poly(A) content. The wheat germ system used is quantitatively stimulated by addition of mRNA derived from eggs or from any of the classes of mRNPs used. Particles prepared from eggs with Na + or released from polysomes contain less protein than particles isolated from eggs in K + , and as expected these particles are fully translatable in vitro . Particles prepared from eggs in buffers containing 0.35 M K + produce little or no stimulation in the in vitro system. That this lack of translation represents in vivo masking is indicated by several considerations: (1) The nontranslatable particles were prepared in 0.35 M K + and 5 m M Mg 2+ , ion concentrations similar to those found in echinoderm eggs; (2) density and sedimentation rate characteristics of the particles are little changed by isolation; (3) RNA extracted from isolated particles is fully translatable; and (4) particles prepared from polysomes or under conditions which destabilize RNPs are translatable. These data support the masking hypothesis for the protein synthesis repression system of eggs.

Novel origins of lineage founder cells in the direct-developing sea urchin Heliocidaris erythrogramma☆

The lineage and fate of each blastomere in the 32-cell embryo of the direct-developing sea urchin Heliocidaris erythrogramma have been traced by microinjection of tetramethylrhodamine-dextran. The results reveal substantive evolutionary modifications of the ancestral cell lineage pattern of indirect sea urchin development. Significant among these modifications are changes in the time and order of cell lineage segregation: vegetal ectodermal founder cells consistently arise earlier than during indirect development, while internal founder cells generally segregate later and in a different sequence. Modifications have also arisen in proportions of the embryo fated to become various cell types and larval structures. Ectodermal fates, particularly vestibular ectoderm, comprise a greater proportion of the total cellular volume in H. erythrogramma. Among internal cell types, coelom consumes more and endoderm less of the remaining cellular volume than during indirect sea urchin development. Evolutionary modifications are also apparent in the positional origin of larval cell types and structures in H. erythrogramma. These include an apparent tilt in the axis of prospective cell fate relative to the animal-vegetal axis as defined by cleavage planes. Together these evolutionary changes in the cell lineage of H. erythrogramma produce an accelerated loss of dorsoventral symmetry in cell fate relative to indirect development. The extent and diversity of rearrangements in its cell lineage indicate that the non-feeding larva of H. erythrogramma is a highly modified, novel form rather than a degenerate pluteus larva. These same modifications underscore the evolutionarily flexible relationship between cell lineage, gene expression, and larval morphology in sea urchin development.

Mutation in a testis-specific β-tubulin in Drosophila: Analysis of its effects on meiosis and map location of the gene

The structural gene for a testis-specific beta--tubulin subunit in Drosophila melanogaster was mapped genetically and cytogenetically by means of a dominant male sterile mutation, B2tD, in which a variant form of the testis beta--tubulin is expressed. The B2t locus is at 48.5 map units on the third chromosome genetic map, and in bands 85D4-7 on the salivary chromosome map. The mutation B2tD causes disruption of microtubule function in all stages of spermatogenesis, beginning with meiosis. The effects of gene dosage of B2tD on meiosis were examined in detail cytologically at the light microscope level. In testes of flies in which the variant tubulin subunit is expressed, abnormal meiotic spindle formation, improper chromosome movement and failure to undergo cytokinesis occur. The extent of these defects in microtubule function depends on the dosage of the B2tD mutation, being most severe in males homozygous for the mutation, intermediate in males heterozygous for the mutation, and least marked in males heterozygous for B2tD and a tandem duplication of the region of the genome containing the B2t locus. Chromosomal events unrelated to microtubule function, such as replication and condensation, occur normally. Results obtained during mapping of the B2t locus strongly suggest a haplo-insufficient site at or closely linked to this locus.

Evolutionary modification of cell lineage in the direct-developing sea urchin Heliocidaris erythrogramma☆

The sea urchin Heliocidaris erythrogramma undergoes direct development, bypassing the usual echinoid pluteus larva. We present an analysis of cell lineage in H. erythrogramma as part of a definition of the mechanistic basis for this evolutionary change in developmental mode. Microinjection of fluoresceinated tracer dye and surface marking with vital dye are used to follow larval fates of 2-cell, 8-cell, and 16-cell blastomeres, and to examine axial specification. The animal-vegetal axis and adult dorsoventral axis are basically unmodified in H. erythrogramma. Animal cell fates are very similar to those of typically developing species; however, vegetal cell fates in H. erythrogramma are substantially altered. Radial differences exist among vegetal blastomere fates in the 8-cell embryo: dorsal vegetal blastomeres contribute proportionately more descendants to ectodermal and fewer to mesodermal fates, while ventral vegetal blastomeres have a complementary bias in fates. In addition, vegetal cell fates are more variable than in typical developers. There are no cells in H. erythrogramma with fates comparable to those of the micromeres and macromeres of typically developing echinoids. Instead, all vegetal cells in the 16-cell embryo can contribute progeny to ectoderm and gut. Alterations have thus arisen in cleavage patterns and timing of cell lineage partitioning during the evolution of direct development in H. erythrogramma.