S. Davies

The relationship between radiation-induced DNA double-strand breaks and cell kill in hamster V79 fibroblasts irradiated with 250 kVp X-rays, 2.3 MeV neutrons or 238Pu alpha-particles.

Using the neutral filter elution technique, the induction of DNA double-strand breaks (dsb) has been measured in 250 kVp X-irradiated V79-379A Chinese hamster cells irradiated under air or nitrogen. The dose-effect curves for induced dsb were curvilinear, mirroring cell survival curves, such that there was an approximately linear relationship between induced dsb and lethal lesions (-In (cell survival)) which was independent of oxygen. With cells irradiated with 2.3 MeV neutrons or 238Pu alpha-particles the correlations between lethal events and dsb, although also approximately linear, do not match those for X-rays. With neutrons there is approximately a 2.5-fold reduction in the level of dsb induction per lethal event. Thus either the apparently linear relationships found are spurious, and there is no general correlation between induced dsb and lethal effect, or there are qualitative differences between neutron, alpha-particle and X-ray induced dsb that give them differing probabilities of cell kill.

Cell killing and DNA damage in Chinese hamster V79 cells treated with hydrogen peroxide.

Hydrogen peroxide induces lesions in cells similar to those from ionizing radiation, by a Fenton-type production of hydroxyl radicals. At 4 degrees C significant levels of DAN single-strand breaks (ssb) could be measured using the alkaline elution technique, after a 20-min incubation with 10(-5) mol dm-3 H2O2. Only at higher concentrations of H2O2 (greater than 10(-4) mol dm-3) where the levels of ssb measured corresponded to that induced by more than 18 Gy of X-rays, was any significant cell killing detected in a clonogenic assay. Cell killing was observed to coincide with the measurement of significant levels of DNA double-strand breaks (dsb) using the filter elution technique at pH 9.6. This suggests that dsb and not ssb are important as regards hydroxyl-radical-induced cell kill, as found for ionizing radiation. The correlation of induced dsb with lethal events showed that the predicted lethal effect of the H2O2-induced dsb was approximately 5 times less than that of X-ray-induced dsb. This is compared with data previously obtained which showed differences in the lethality of dsb with the quality of radiation (Prise et al. 1987).

The irradiation of V79 mammalian cells by protons with energies below 2 MeV. Part I: Experimental arrangement and measurements of cell survival.

The relative biological effectiveness (RBE) has been determined for protons with mean energies of 1.9, 1.15 and 0.76 MeV, from measurements of the survival of V79 Chinese hamster cells. The cells are supported as a monolayer and are swept through a beam of scattered protons produced using a 4 MeV Van de Graaff accelerator. An estimation of the dose and unrestricted linear energy transfer (LET) variation within the sensitive volume of the cells is given for the three proton energies. The RBEs for cell survival (relative to 250 kVp X-rays) at the 10 per cent survival level are 1.6, 1.9 and 3.36 for protons with track-average LETs of 17, 24 and 32 keV microns-1 respectively, and the data suggest that protons are most effective at about 40-50 keV microns-1. It is shown that the proton RBEs can be reconciled with those of other light ions if plotted against z*2/beta 2 (where z* is the effective charge and beta is the relative velocity) rather than against LET.

Measurement of DNA Damage by Electrons with Energies between 25 and 4000 EV

All ionizing radiations deposit energy stochastically along their tracks. The resulting distribution of energies deposited in a small target such as the DNA helix leads to a corresponding spectrum in the severity of damage produced. So far, most information about the probable spectra of DNA lesion complexity has come from Monte Carlo studies which endeavour to model the relationship between the energy deposited in DNA and the damage induced. The aim of this paper is to establish methods of determining this relationship by irradiating pBR322 plasmid DNA using low energy electrons with energies comparable with the minimum energy thought to produce critical damage. The technique of agarose gel electrophoresis has been used to ascertain the fraction of DNA single- and double-strand breaks induced by monoenergetic electrons with energies as low as 25 eV. Our data show that the threshold electron energy for induction of single-strand breaks is < 25 eV, and for double-strand breaks between 25 and 50 eV.

The Irradiation of V79 Mammalian Cells by Protons with Energies below 2 MeV. Part II. Measurement of Oxygen Enhancement Ratios and DNA Damage

The effectiveness of low-energy (below 2 MeV) protons at inducing DNA damage in the form of single- and double-strand breaks has been determined. Protons with mean energies of 1.90 MeV, 1.15 MeV and 0.76 MeV corresponding to track average LETs of 17 keV/microns, 24 keV/microns and 32 keV/microns, respectively, have been used and compared with 250 kVp X-rays and 3.8 MeV 238Pu alpha-particles. Although there was variation in the RBE for DNA ssb induction with LET, the RBEs for dsb induction at all three proton energies and for 3.8 MeV alpha-particles were all around 1.0. This suggests that, if DNA dsb are important in radiation-induced cell lethality, the probability of an induced dsb leading to a lethal event increases with increasing LET of radiation. Oxygen enhancement ratios were measured for both cell survival and DNA dsb induction, and in both cases a decrease in OER with increasing LET was observed.

Evidence for Induction of DNA Double-Strand Breaks at Paired Radical Sites

Isolated plasmid pBR322 DNA was irradiated in the gas explosion apparatus in the presence of 10 mmol dm-3 GSH. By varying the time of the oxygen shot relative to the 5-ns pulse of electrons, the chemical repair kinetics of the oxygen-dependent free-radical precursors of DNA single- and double-strand breaks (SSBs and DSBs) can be determined. The first-order repair rate of the SSB precursors was 1370 s-1 in comparison to 2900 s-1 for DSB precursors. Under these conditions the oxygen enhancement ratio for SSBs was 3.0 in comparison to 7.5 for DSBs. This twofold difference in chemical repair rate may be interpreted on the basis of the free-radical precursor of a DSB consisting of two radicals, one on either strand of the DNA. With the chemical repair of one or other of these radicals by hydrogen atom donation from GSH, a DSB is not produced. This process will occur at twice the rate of the chemical repair of an SSB precursor consisting of a single radical. These data are consistent with the concept that DSBs are formed at the sites of clustered energy depositions with the production of a paired radical.

Measurement of DNA Damage and Cell Killing in Chinese Hamster V79 Cells Irradiated with Aluminum Characteristic Ultrasoft X Rays

Chinese hamster V79 cells were irradiated with 1.487 keV aluminum characteristic X rays produced using a cold-cathode discharge tube. Under aerobic conditions a relative biological effectiveness (RBE) of 2.18 for cell killing in comparison to 250-kVp X rays was measured using cells grown in suspension and irradiated on membrane filters. DNA damage in the form of single-strand (ssb) and double-strand breaks (dsb) was measured using the filter elution technique. The aerobic RBEs are 1.64 for dsb induction and 0.49 for ssb induction, consistent with the view that dsb are more closely related to cell kill than ssb. A reduced oxygen enhancement ratio (OER) for cell killing was measured for Al-K X rays, but the OER for dsb induction was similar to that measured for 250-kVp X rays. A curvilinear relationship between dsb induction and dose is observed, similar to that seen for 250-kVp X rays. This agrees with the concept that ultrasoft X rays produce critical lesions similar to hard X rays but with a greater efficiency per unit dose.

A Comparison of the Chemical Repair Rates of Free Radical Precursors of DNA Damage and Cell Killing in Chinese Hamster V79 Cells

One of the important temporal stages of radiation action in cellular systems is the chemical phase, where oxygen fixation reactions compete with chemical repair reactions involving reducing agents such as GSH. Using the gas explosion technique it is possible to follow the kinetics of these fast (greater than 1 ms) reactions in intact cells. We have compared the chemical repair kinetics of the oxygen-dependent free radical precursors leading to DNA single-strand and double-strand breaks, measured using filter elution techniques, with those leading to cell killing in V79 cells. The chemical repair rates for DNA dsb (670s-1 at pH 7.2 and 380s-1 at pH 9.6) and cell killing (530s-1) were similar. This is in agreement with the important role of DNA dsb in radiation induced cell lethality. The rate for DNA ssb precursors was significantly slower (210s-1). The difference in rate between DNA ssb and dsb precursors may be explained on the basis of a dsb free radical precursor consisting of a paired radical, one radical on each strand. The instantaneous probability of one or other of these radicals being chemically repaired and not proceeding to form a dsb will be twice that of ssb radical precursor. This agrees well with the concept of locally multiply damaged sites (LMDS) produced from clusters of ionizations in DNA (Ward 1985).

Ultrafast Chemical Repair of DNA Single and Double Strand Break Precursors in Irradiated V79 Cells

The fast kinetics of reactions of free radical precursors of DNA single strand breaks (ssb) and double strand breaks (dsb) have been determined in Chinese hamster V79 cells by fast mixing and irradiation methods using the alkaline unwinding technique to assay breaks. Fast chemical repair of oxygen-dependent ssb and dsb precursors was observed and approached completion within 10-20 ms of irradiation. Treatment of cells with the glutathione synthesis blocking agent, buthionine sulphoximine, showed that approximately half of the chemical repair was attributable to intracellular non-protein thiols. The nature of the residual repair is obscure, but it is apparently not attributable to non-protein thiols. Similar repair rates and thiol dependences were also found for cell kill. With all three endopoints, oxygen competes with and blocks the chemical repair.

The Role of Non-protein Sulphydryls in Determining the Chemical Repair Rates of Free Radical Precursors of DNA Damage and Cell Killing in Chinese Hamster V79 Cells

Chinese hamster V79 fibroblasts were irradiated in the gas explosion apparatus and the chemical repair rates of the oxygen-dependent free radical precursors of DNA double-strand breaks (dsb) and lethal lesions measured using filter elution (pH 9.6) and a clonogenic assay. Depletion of cellular GSH levels, from 4.16 fmol/cell to 0.05 fmol/cell, by treatment with buthionine sulphoximine (50 mumol dm-3; 18 h), led to sensitization as regards DNA dsb induction and cell killing. This was evident at all time settings but was particularly pronounced when the oxygen shot was given 1 ms after the irradiation pulse. A detailed analysis of the chemical repair kinetics showed that depletion of GSH led to a reduction in the first-order rate constant for dsb precursors from 385 s-1 to 144 s-1, and for lethal lesion precursors from 533 s-1 to 165 s-1. This is generally consistent with the role of GSH in the repair-fixation model of radiation damage at the critical DNA lesions. However, the reduction in chemical repair rate was not proportional to the severe thiol depletion (down to approximately 1% for GSH) and a residual repair capacity remained (approximately 30%). This was found not to be due to compartmentalization of residual GSH in the nucleus, as the repair rate for dsb precursors in isolated nuclei, washed virtually free of GSH, was identical to that found in GSH-depleted cells (144 s-1), also the OER remained substantially above unity. This suggests that other reducing agents may have a role to play in the chemical repair of oxygen-dependent damage. One possible candidate is the significant level of protein sulphydryls present in isolated nuclei.