Scott Lewis

Effects of Temperature and Particle Size on Deposition in Land Based Turbines

Four series of tests were performed in an accelerated deposition test facility to study the independent effects of particle size, gas temperature, and metal temperature on ash deposits from two candidate power turbine synfuels (coal and petcoke). The facility matches the gas temperature and velocity of modern first stage high pressure turbine vanes while accelerating the deposition process. Particle size was found to have a significant effect on capture efficiency with larger particles causing significant thermal barrier coating (TBC) spallation durin ga4h accelerated test. In the second series of tests, particle deposition rate was found to decrease with decreasing gas temperature. The threshold gas temperature for deposition was approximately 960°C. In the third and fourth test series, impingement cooling was applied to the back side of the target coupon to simulate internal vane cooling. Capture efficiency was reduced with increasing mass flow of coolant air; however, at low levels of cooling, the deposits attached more tenaciously to the TBC layer. Postexposure analyses of the third test series (scanning electron microscopy and X-ray spectroscopy) show decreasing TBC damage with increased cooling levels. DOI: 10.1115/1.2903901

Effects of Particle Size, Gas Temperature and Metal Temperature on High Pressure Turbine Deposition in Land Based Gas Turbines From Various Synfuels

Four series of tests were performed in an accelerated deposition test facility to study the independent effects of particle size, gas temperature, and metal temperature on ash deposits from two candidate power turbine synfuels. The facility matches the gas temperature and velocity of modern first stage high pressure turbine vanes while accelerating the deposition process. This is done by matching the net throughput of particulate out of the combustor with that experienced by a modern power turbine. In the first series of tests, four different size particles were studied by seeding a natural-gas combustor with finely-ground coal ash particulate. The entrained ash particles were accelerated to a combustor exit flow Mach number of 0.25 before impinging on a thermal barrier coated (TBC) target coupon at 1183°C. Particle size was found to have a significant effect on capture efficiency with larger particles causing significant TBC spallation during a 4-hour accelerated test. In the second series of tests, different gas temperatures were studied while the facility maintained a constant exit velocity of 170m/s (Mach = 0.23–0.26). Coal ash with a mass mean diameter of 3 μm was used. Particle deposition rate was found to decrease with decreasing gas temperature. The threshold gas temperature for deposition was approximately 960°C. In the third and fourth test series impingement cooling was applied to the backside of the target coupon to simulate internal vane cooling. Ground coal and petcoke ash particulates were used for the two tests respectively. Capture efficiency was reduced with increasing massflow of coolant air, however at low levels of cooling the deposits attached more tenaciously to the TBC layer. Post exposure analyses of the third test series (scanning electron microscopy and x-ray spectroscopy) show decreasing TBC damage with increased cooling levels. Implications for the power generation goal of fuel flexibility are discussed.Copyright

Film Cooling Effectiveness and Heat Transfer Near Deposit-Laden Film Holes

Experiments were conducted to determine the impact of synfuel deposits on film cooling effectiveness and heat transfer. Scaled up models were made of synfuel deposits formed on film-cooled turbine blade coupons exposed to accelerated deposition. Three distinct deposition patterns were modeled: a large deposition pattern (maximum deposit peak≅2 hole diameters) located exclusively upstream of the holes, a large deposition pattern (maximum deposit peak≅1.25 hole diameters) extending downstream between the cooling holes, and a small deposition pattern (maximum deposit peak≅0.75 hole diameter) also extending downstream between the cooling holes. The models featured cylindrical holes inclined at 30 deg to the surface and aligned with the primary flow direction. The spacing of the holes were 3, 3.35, and 4.5 hole diameters, respectively. Flat models with the same film cooling hole geometry and spacing were used for comparison. The models were tested using blowing ratios of 0.5–2 with a turbulent approach boundary layer and 0.5% freestream turbulence. The density ratio was approximately 1.1 and the primary flow Reynolds number at the film cooling row location was 300,000. An infrared camera was used to obtain the film cooling effectiveness from steady state tests and surface convective heat transfer coefficients using transient tests. The model with upstream deposition caused the primary flow to lift off the surface over the roughness peaks and allowed the coolant to stay attached to the model. Increasing the blowing ratio from 0.5 to 2 only expanded the region that the coolant could reach and improved the cooling effectiveness. Though the heat transfer coefficient also increased at high blowing ratios, the net heat flux ratio was still less than unity, indicating film cooling benefit. For the two models with deposition between the cooling holes, the freestream air was forced into the valleys in line with the coolant holes and degraded area-averaged coolant performance at lower blowing ratios. It is concluded that the film cooling effectiveness is highest when deposition is limited to upstream of the cooling holes. When accounting for the insulating effect of the deposits between the film holes, even the panels with deposits downstream of the film holes can yield a net decrease in heat flux for some cases.

Blockage Effects From Simulated Thermal Barrier Coatings for Cylindrical and Shaped Cooling Holes

Film cooling and sprayed thermal barrier coatings (TBCs) protect gas turbine components from the hot combustion gas temperatures. As gas turbine designers pursue higher turbine inlet temperatures, film cooling and TBCs are critical in protecting the durability of turbomachinery hardware. One obstacle to the synergy of these technologies is that TBC coatings can block cooling holes when applied to the components, causing a decrease in the film cooling flow area thereby reducing coolant flow for a given pressure ratio (PR). In this study, the effect of TBC blockages was simulated on film cooling holes for widely spaced cylindrical and shaped holes. At low blowing ratios for shaped holes, the blockages were found to have very little effect on adiabatic effectiveness. At high blowing ratios, the area-averaged effectiveness of shaped and cylindrical holes decreased as much as 75% from blockage. The decrease in area-averaged effectiveness was found to scale best with the effective momentum flux ratio of the jet exiting the film cooling hole for the shaped holes. [DOI: 10.1115/1.4029879]

The Effect of Area Ratio Change via Increased Hole Length for Shaped Film Cooling Holes with Constant Expansion Angles

Shaped film cooling holes are used as a cooling technology in gas turbines to reduce metal temperatures and improve durability, and they generally consist of a small metering section connected to a diffuser that expands in one or more directions. The area ratio (AR) of these holes is defined as the area at the exit of the diffuser, divided by the area at the metering section. A larger AR increases the diffusion of the coolant momentum, leading to lower average momentum of the coolant jet at the exit of the hole and generally better cooling performance. Cooling holes with larger ARs are also more tolerant of high blowing ratio conditions, and the increased coolant diffusion typically better prevents jet lift-off from occurring. Higher ARs have traditionally been accomplished by increasing the expansion angle of the diffuser while keeping the overall length of the hole constant. The present study maintains the diffuser expansion angles and instead increases the length of the diffuser, which results in longer holes. Various ARs have been examined for two shaped holes: one with forward and lateral expansion angles of 7 deg (7-7-7 hole) and one with forward and lateral expansion angles of 12 deg (12-12-12 hole). Each hole shape was tested at numerous blowing ratios to capture trends across various flow rates. Adiabatic effectiveness measurements indicate that for the baseline 7-7-7 hole, a larger AR provides higher effectiveness, especially at higher blowing ratios. Measurements also indicate that for the 12-12-12 hole, a larger AR performs better at high blowing ratios but the hole experiences ingestion at low blowing ratios. Steady Reynolds-averaged Navier–Stokes simulations did not accurately predict the levels of adiabatic effectiveness, but did predict the trend of improving effectiveness with increasing AR for both hole shapes. Flowfield measurements with particle image velocimetry (PIV) were also performed at one downstream plane for a low and high AR case, and the results indicate an expected decrease in jet velocity due to a larger diffuser. [DOI: 10.1115/1.4038871]

The Effect of a Meter-Diffuser Offset on Shaped Film Cooling Hole Adiabatic Effectiveness

Shaped film cooling holes are used extensively in gas turbines to reduce component temperatures. These holes generally consist of a metering section through the material and a diffuser to spread coolant over the surface. These two hole features are created separately using electrical discharge machining (EDM), and occasionally, an offset can occur between the meter and diffuser due to misalignment. The current study examines the potential impact of this manufacturing defect to the film cooling effectiveness for a wellcharacterized shaped hole known as the 7-7-7 hole. Five meter-diffuser offset directions and two offset sizes were examined, both computationally and experimentally. Adiabatic effectiveness measurements were obtained at a density ratio of 1.2 and blowing ratios ranging from 0.5 to 3. The detriment in cooling relative to the baseline 7-7-7 hole was worst when the diffuser was shifted upstream (aft meter-diffuser offset), and least when the diffuser was shifted downstream (fore meter-diffuser offset). At some blowing ratios and offset sizes, the fore meter-diffuser offset resulted in slightly higher adiabatic effectiveness than the baseline hole, due to a reduction in the high-momentum region of the coolant jet caused by a separation region created inside the hole by the fore meterdiffuser offset. Steady Reynolds-averaging Navier–Stokes (RANS) predictions did not accurately capture the levels of adiabatic effectiveness or the trend in the offsets, but it did predict the fore offset’s improved performance. [DOI: 10.1115/1.4036199]

Computational and Experimental Studies of Midpassage Gap Leakage and Misalignment for a Non-Axisymmetric Contoured Turbine Blade Endwall

Turbine vanes and blades are generally manufactured as single or double airfoil sections that must each be installed onto a turbine disk. Between each section, a gap at the endwalls through the blade passage is present, through which high pressure coolant is leaked. Furthermore, sections can become misaligned due to thermal expansion or centrifugal forces. Flow and heat transfer around the gap is complicated due to the interaction of the mainstream and the leakage flow. An experimental and computational study was undertaken to determine the physics of the leakage flow interaction for a realistic turbine blade endwall, and assess whether steady RANS CFD, commonly used for non-axisymmetric endwall design, can be used to accurately model this interaction. Computational models were compared against experimental observations of endwall heat transfer on a contoured endwall with a midpassage gap. Endwall heat transfer coefficients were determined experimentally by using infrared thermography to capture spatially-resolved surface temperatures on a uniform heat flux surface (heater) attached to the endwall. Predictions and measurements both indicated an increase in endwall heat transfer with increasing gap leakage flow, although the distribution of heat transfer coefficients along the gap was not well captured by CFD. A misalignment of the blade endwall causing a forward-facing step for the near-endwall flow resulted in a large highly turbulent recirculation region downstream of the step and high local heat transfer that was overpredicted by CFD. Conversely, a backward-facing step reduced turbulence and local heat transfer. The misprediction of local heat transfer around the gap is thought to be caused by unsteady interaction of the passage secondary flow and gap leakage flow, which cannot be well-captured by a steady RANS approach. INTRODUCTION The design of turbine blade endwalls in modern high temperature gas turbines is an optimization of both aerodynamic and heat transfer performance. Three-dimensional (non-axisymmetric) modifications to the endwall shape which reduce secondary flow vortical structures in the blade passage can improve turbine aerodynamic efficiency, but can also create regions of high heat transfer on the endwall which require cooling in order to ensure part durability. To cool the endwall, as well as ensure that no hot gas enters into gaps between the blades, air from the compressor is diverted around the combustor and injected through the gaps and through film cooling holes. This leakage air is provided at a penalty to the overall power generation of the turbine. Design of non-axisymmetric contoured endwalls is often done using steady RANS CFD models, which run many geometric configurations of the endwall in order to find an optimum. However, this method generally does not consider the interface gap between adjacent turbine blade endwalls in the blade passage, referred to as a midpassage gap in this study. Previous studies of midpassage gaps have shown that it has a significant effect on aerodynamic performance and endwall heat transfer, even without leakage flow [1, 2]. Further, during operation, it is not uncommon for misalignment of adjacent turbine blade endwalls to occur, and the localized effect of such misalignments are not well understood. As endwall design tools mature, they will start to account for these realistic effects, but it is currently not clear whether RANS-based CFD can capture these effects accurately, or even on a trend-wise basis. The objective of this study was to utilize RANS-based modeling to predict the effect of the midpassage gap on endwall heat transfer and compare with observed experimental data for identical computational and experimental geometries and inlet conditions. The influence of gap leakage flow is compared for aligned blade endwalls, and the effect of vertical (radial) misalignment of 3% of the blade axial chord is also compared. In addition, the computed flowfield was used to correlate regions of high endwall heat transfer predicted by CFD with regions of separated flow around the midpassage gap, in an