Simon Carlile

The nature and distribution of errors in sound localization by human listeners

Measurement of localization performance will reflect errors that relate to the sensory processing of the cues to sound location and the errors associated with the method by which the subject indicates the perceived location. This study has measured the ability of human subjects to localize a short noise burst presented in the free field with the subject indicating the perceived location by pointing their nose towards the source. Subjects were first trained using a closed loop training paradigm which involved instantaneous feedback as to the accuracy of head pointing which resulted in the reduction of residual localization errors and a rapid acquisition of the task by the subjects. Once trained, 19 subjects localized between 4 and 6 blocks of 76 target locations. The data were pooled and the distribution of errors associated with each target location was examined using spherical methods. Errors in the localization estimates for about one third of the locations were rotationally symmetrical about their mean but the remaining locations were best described by an elliptical distribution (Kent distributed). For about one half of the latter locations the orientations of the directions of the greatest variance of the distributions were not aligned with the azimuth and elevation coordinates used for describing the spatial location of the targets. The accuracy (systematic errors) and the distribution of the errors (variance) in localization for our population of subjects were also examined for each test location. The size of the data set and the methods of analysis provide very reliable measures of important baseline parameters of human auditory localization.

Virtual Auditory Space: Generation and Applications

1. Auditory Space.- 2. The Physical and Psychophysical Basis of Sound Localization.- 3. Digital Signal Processing for the Auditory Scientist: A Tutorial Introduction.- 4. Generation and Validation of Virtual Auditory Space.- 5. Implementation of Virtual Acoustic Space for Neurophysiological Studies of Directional Hearing.- 6. Recent Developments in Virtual Auditory Space.

The role of high frequencies in speech localization

This study measured the accuracy with which human listeners can localize spoken words. A broadband (300 Hz-16 kHz) corpus of monosyllabic words was created and presented tolisteners using a virtual auditory environment. Localization was examined for 76 locations ona sphere surrounding the listener. Experiment 1 showed that low-pass filtering the speech sounds at 8 kHz degraded performance, causing an increase in polar angle errors associated with the cone of confusion. In experiment 2 it was found that performance in fact varied systematically with the level of the signal above 8 kHz. Although the lower frequencies (below 8 kHz) are known to be sufficient for accurate speech recognition in most situations, these results demonstrate that natural speech contains information between 8 and 16 kHz that is essential for accurate localization.

Methods for spherical data analysis and visualization

A systematic analysis of the localization of objects in extra-personal space requires a three-dimensional method of documenting location. In auditory localization studies the location of a sound source is often reduced to a directional vector with constant magnitude with respect to the observer, data being plotted on a unit sphere with the observer at the origin. This is an attractive form of data representation as the relevant spherical statistical and graphical methods are well described. In this paper we collect together a set of spherical plotting and statistical procedures to visualize and summarize these data. We describe methods for visualizing auditory localization data without assuming that the principal components of the data are aligned with the coordinate system. As a means of comparing experimental techniques and having a common set of data for the verification of spherical statistics, the software (implemented in MATLAB) and database described in this paper have been placed in the public domain. Although originally intended for the visualization and summarization of auditory psychophysical data, these routines are sufficiently general to be applied in other situations involving spherical data.

Directional properties of the auditory periphery in the guinea pig

The directional sensitivity of the outer ear of the guinea pig was determined by recording changes in the amplitude of the cochlear microphonic to frequencies between 1 and 20 kHz as the location of the sound source was changed throughout 360 degrees of horizontal auditory space. The directional responses to frequencies below 3 kHz were almost omnidirectional. The directional responses for frequencies between 3 and 12 kHz were progressively more directional toward the anterior midline. The responses for frequencies above 12 kHz were highly directional along the ipsilateral interaural axis. In contrast, the directional responses to all frequencies in animals whose pinnae had been removed were orientated along the ipsilateral interaural axis. The observations suggest that the orientation and strength of the directional response of the auditory periphery in the guinea pig are dependent on frequency and that this dependence is attributable, at least in part, to the acoustic properties of the pinna. The observations also indicate that there is a substantial change in the interaural intensity difference at various frequencies and in the spectral transfer function of the ear according to the location of the sound source in the ipsilateral hemifield. The observation that these changes are asymmetrical about the interaural axis for a substantial part of the auditory range of the animal is consistent with the hypothesis that the frequency dependent directionality of the auditory periphery provides a spectral cue for the localization of broad band sounds in the free field.

The auditory periphery of the ferret. I: Directional response properties and the pattern of interaural level differences

The transformations of sound by the auditory periphery of the ferret have been investigated using an impulse response technique for a large number of sound locations surrounding the animal. Individual frequencies were extracted from the detailed spectral transformation functions (STFs) obtained for each stimulus location and, using sophisticated spatial interpolation routines, were used to calculate the directional response of the periphery at that frequency. The strength of the directional response was directly related to the analysis frequency. Furthermore, as the analysis frequency was increased to 20 kHz, the orientation of the directional response increased in elevation from the horizon (E0 degrees) to about E30 degrees, while the azimuthal location remained fairly constant at 30 degrees to 40 degrees from the midline. For analysis frequencies above 20 kHz, the response became increasingly directional toward the ipsilateral interaural axis. The interaural level differences (ILDs) were also calculated for all animals studied. ILDs increased from around 5 to 25 dB over the range of frequencies from 3-24 kHz. The two-dimensional patterns of iso-ILD contours were roughly concentric and centered on the interaural axis for frequencies below 16 kHz. For higher frequencies, there was a tendency for the ILD contours to be centered on more anterior and inferior locations. The increased directionality of the auditory periphery with increasing analysis frequency, together with the presence of sharp nulls in the response at high analysis frequencies, is consistent with a diffractive effect produced by the aperture of the pinna. However, this simple model does not predict the directional responses over the low to middle frequency range.

Spectral Information in Sound Localization

Publisher Summary This chapter reviews the psychophysical evidence for the role of spectral cues in sound localization and the manner in which they are combined with the other binaural cues to sound location. In addition, some of the bioacoustic, psychophysical, and neurophysiological studies that have examined the mechanisms of encoding and processing of these cues are reviewed. There is strong evidence that the information used by listeners to resolve the ambiguity in interaural time divergence (ITD) and interaural level divergence (ILD) cues is spectral in nature. The possibility that spectral cues to sound location are specific to the lateral angle of the source has been examined in two studies. Several aspects of spatial cue processing examined neurophysiologically are particularly relevant to the processing of spectral information. The chapter focuses on results obtained using the mammalian auditory system. Recent human psychophysical work has shown that under appropriate conditions the auditory system has a remarkable ability to relearn to use modified spectral cues to a sound location.

Benefit from spatial separation of multiple talkers in bilateral hearing-aid users: Effects of hearing loss, age, and cognition

Abstract To study the spatial hearing abilities of bilateral hearing-aid users in multi-talker situations, 20 subjects received fittings configured to preserve acoustic cues salient for spatial hearing. Following acclimatization, speech reception thresholds (SRTs) were measured for three competing talkers that were either co-located or spatially separated along the front-back or left-right dimension. In addition, the subjects’ working memory and attentional abilities were measured. Left-right SRTs varied over more than 14 dB, while front-back SRTs varied over more than 8 dB. Furthermore, significant correlations were observed between left-right SRTs, age, and low-frequency hearing loss, and also between front-back SRTs, age, and high-frequency aided thresholds. Concerning cognitive effects, left-right performance was most strongly related to attentional abilities, while front-back performance showed a relation to working memory abilities. Altogether, these results suggest that, due to raised hearing thresholds and aging, hearing-aid users have reduced access to interaural and monaural spatial cues as well as a diminished ability to ‘enhance’ a target signal by means of top-down processing. These deficits, in turn, lead to impaired functioning in complex listening environments. Sumario Para estudiar las habilidades auditivas espaciales de usuarios de audífonos bilaterales en situaciones de hablantes múltiples, 20 sujetos recibieron auxiliares configurados para preservar las más destacadas claves acústicas de la audición espacial. Después de un período de adaptación, se midieron los umbrales de recepción del habla (SRTs) con tres hablantes en competencia que fueron colocados cerca o espacialmente separados en las dimensiones frente-atrás o izquierda-derecha. Además, se midieron las habilidades de memoria activa y atención. Los SRTs izquierda-derecha variaron más de 14 dB mientras que los SRTs frente-atrás, variaron más de 8 dB. Más aún, se observaron correlaciones significativas entre SRTs frente-atrás, edad y pérdida auditiva en las frecuencias graves y también entre SRTs frente-atrás, edad y umbrales con auxiliares auditivos en las frecuencias agudas. En relación con los efectos cognitivos, el rendimiento izquierda-derecha se relacionó más firmemente con habilidades de atención, mientras que el rendimiento frente-atrás, mostró relación con habilidades de memoria activa. En general, estos resultados sugieren que, debido a la elevación de los umbrales auditivos y el envejecimiento, los usuarios de auxiliares auditivos tienen un acceso reducido a las claves espaciales interaurales y monoaurales así como una habilidad disminuida para “mejorar” una señal blanco por medio del procesamiento arriba-abajo. Estos déficits, a su vez, conducen a un funcionamiento disminuido en ambientes de escucha complejos.

Separation of concurrent broadband sound sources by human listeners.

The effect of spatial separation on the ability of human listeners to resolve a pair of concurrent broadband sounds was examined. Stimuli were presented in a virtual auditory environment using individualized outer ear filter functions. Subjects were presented with two simultaneous noise bursts that were either spatially coincident or separated (horizontally or vertically), and responded as to whether they perceived one or two source locations. Testing was carried out at five reference locations on the audiovisual horizon (0 degrees, 22.5 degrees, 45 degrees, 67.5 degrees, and 90 degrees azimuth). Results from experiment 1 showed that at more lateral locations, a larger horizontal separation was required for the perception of two sounds. The reverse was true for vertical separation. Furthermore, it was observed that subjects were unable to separate stimulus pairs if they delivered the same interaural differences in time (ITD) and level (ILD). These findings suggested that the auditory system exploited differences in one or both of the binaural cues to resolve the sources, and could not use monaural spectral cues effectively for the task. In experiments 2 and 3, separation of concurrent noise sources was examined upon removal of low-frequency content (and ITDs), onset/offset ITDs, both of these in conjunction, and all ITD information. While onset and offset ITDs did not appear to play a major role, differences in ongoing ITDs were robust cues for separation under these conditions, including those in the envelopes of high-frequency channels.

The localisation of spectrally restricted sounds by human listeners.

The two principal binaural cues to sound location are interaural time differences (ITDs), which are thought to be dominant at low frequencies, and interaural level differences (ILDs), which are thought to dominate at mid to high frequencies. The outer ear also filters the sound in a location dependent manner and provides spectral cues to location. In these experiments we have examined the relative contribution of these cues to the auditory localisation performance by humans. Six subjects localised sounds by pointing their face toward the perceived location of stimuli presented in complete darkness in an anechoic chamber. Control stimuli were spectrally flat (400 Hz to 16 kHz), while the relative contribution of location cues in the low frequency channels was determined using noise high passed at 2 kHz and in the high frequency channels using stimuli low passed at 2 kHz. The removal of frequencies below 2 kHz had little effect on either the pattern of systematic errors or the distribution of localisation estimates with the exception of an increase in the size of the standard deviations associated with a few rear locations. This suggests considerable redundancy in the auditory localisation information contained within a broadband sound. In contrast, restricting the target spectrum to frequencies below 2 kHz resulted in a large increase in the cone-of-confusion errors as well as a subject dependent biasing of the front-to-back or back-to-front confusions. These biases and the reduction in localisation accuracy for high pass stimuli at some posterior locations are consistent with a contribution of spectral information at low frequencies.