Simona Malucchi

Persistent neutralizing antibodies abolish the interferon β bioavailability in MS patients

Background: MxA is an antiviral protein exclusively induced by type I interferons (IFN) and some viruses, and MxA gene expression is one of the most appropriate markers for measuring the biologic activity of exogenous IFNβ. Methods: A new quantitative-competitive PCR method was used to quantify MxA mRNA in peripheral blood mononuclear cells of 99 treatment-naïve and 92 IFNβ-treated patients with MS (22 Avonex, 17 Betaferon, and 53 Rebif-22). Every 3 months, IFNβ-induced neutralizing antibodies (NAb) were evaluated in sera using a cytopathic effect assay. Three categories of patients were identified: NAb negative (NAb−), persistent NAb positive (NAb+, ≥2 consecutive positive samples), and isolated NAb+ (one positive sample). Results: Treatment-naïve patients expressed detectable MxA mRNA levels (mean = 36 ± 32 fg MxA/pg glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase (GAPDH); range 1 to 160) and an upper normal threshold was established (mean + 3 SD = 132 fg MxA/pg GAPDH). IFNβ-treated patients exhibited more than 11-fold higher levels (mean = 412 ± 282 fg MxA/pg GAPDH; range 16 to 1,172). However, 17 patients did not exhibit an increase in MxA mRNA level; 15 of these 17 patients showed a concurrent Nab+ titer. Moreover, 13 were persistent NAb+. Isolated NAb+ patients did not show a decrease in bioavailability of IFNβ (n = 9; mean = 567 ± 366 fg MxA/pg GAPDH; range 83 to 1,120). In NAb− patients, bioavailability was comparable among the three different IFNβ preparations 12 hours after injection. Conclusion: During IFNβ therapy, the presence of NAb reduced or abolished bioavailability in a relevant percentage of patients. These data could be important for the early detection of patients with MS who are not responsive to IFNβ therapy.

Neutralizing antibodies reduce the efficacy of βIFN during treatment of multiple sclerosis

Objective: To analyze the impact of neutralizing antibodies (NAbs) on the clinical efficacy of IFNβ. Methods: This was an open-label study involving 78 patients with multiple sclerosis treated with Betaferon 8 million IU (MIU) subcutaneously (SC) every other day (n = 20), Rebif 22 μg SC 3 times weekly (n = 25), or Avonex 30 μg IM once weekly (n = 33). Every 3 months, blood samples were collected and sera were analyzed for NAbs using an antiviral cytopathic effect assay. Patients were categorized according to their NAb status: NAb negative (NAb−); isolated NAb positive (NAb+), patients with ≥1 positive sample (titer ≥ 20); and persistent NAb+, patients with ≥2 consecutive positive samples (titer ≥ 20). Patients who were NAb− and persistent NAb+ were compared for relapse rate, time between first and second relapse, percentage of relapse-free patients, and percentage of patients who had a sustained progression of ≥1 point on the Expanded Disability Status Scale (EDSS). Results: The incidence of persistent NAb+ patients was 35% for Betaferon, 20% for Rebif, and 3% for Avonex. During IFNβ treatment, both NAb+ and NAb− patients showed a reduction in relapse rate; this reduction (25%) was not significant in NAb+ patients but was significant (67%; p < 0.0001) in NAb− patients. In addition, the mean relapse rate was higher (p = 0.039), mean time between first and second relapse was shorter (13 vs 21 months; p = 0.0064), and there was a trend suggesting that NAbs affected the probability of remaining relapse free (p = 0.08). A higher percentage of NAb+ patients versus NAb− patients had worsening of EDSS scores during follow-up (p = 0.013). Conclusion: Persistent NAbs significantly reduce the clinical efficacy of IFNβ.

Interferon β neutralizing antibodies in multiple sclerosis : neutralizing activity and cross-reactivity with three different preparations

The presence and titer of neutralizing antibodies (NABs) was evaluated by an antiviral biological assay in 387 samples of 111 multiple sclerosis (MS) patients treated with one of the three commercial preparations of interferon beta (IFNbeta). Fifty NAB positive samples were found in 19 patients: 11 treated with IFNbeta-1b (Betaferon(R)) and eight with IFNbeta-1a (five with Avonex(R) and three with Rebif(R)). All the 38 NABs+ samples of patients treated with IFNbeta-1b cross-reacted with IFNbeta-1a of both commercial types. The median level of neutralizing units (NUs) of the sera was higher when tested against IFNbeta-1a than against IFNbeta-1b (p=0.000 vs. Avonexr(R) and p=0.003 vs. Rebif(R)). In line with these data, the NABs+ sera of patients treated with IFNbeta-1a cross-reacted with IFNbeta-1b and the level of NUs were lower when tested against IFNbeta-1b than against IFNbeta-1a (p=0.003). The different amount of NUs against IFNbeta types 1a and 1b could be due to the presence of aggregates in the IFNbeta-1b preparation. The different levels of cross-reactivity of NABs could reduce the bioavailability and therapeutic efficacy of IFNbeta in NABs+ patients switching from IFNbeta-1b to IFNbeta-1a.

Biological markers of interferon-beta therapy: comparison among interferon-stimulated genes MxA, TRAIL and XAF-1.

Biological activity of interferon-beta (IFNβ) can be assessed by measuring IFN-stimulated genes (ISGs). Among them, myxovirus resistance protein A (MxA) appears to have the highest specificity, but it has no role in the pathogenesis of multiple sclerosis (MS). To investigate the reliability of MxA as a biomarker, we compared its expression to that of two other ISGs: TNF-related apoptosis-inducing ligand (TRAIL) and X-linked inhibitor of apoptosis factor-1 (XAF-1). Both were shown to be involved in immunoregulatory mechanisms and might play a role in MS. Quantitative-PCR measurements were performed in peripheral blood mononuclear cells from 73 MS patients after short-term and long-term treatment with IFNβ. A time-dependent response for multiple ISGs was observed in all patients after short-term treatment. In contrast, long-term treatment induced concurrent inhibition of ISGs in 12.3% (9/73) of patients, in whom neutralizing antibodies (NAbs) were detectable. Besides, 22% (16/73) of chronically treated patients showed a non-NAbs-related abrogation of TRAIL expression. In summary, 1) MxA expression was significantly higher than both TRAIL and XAF-1, and 2) MxA was the most sensitive gene to detect decreased bioavailability due to NAbs. These findings identify MxA as an appropriate biomarker for IFNβ, although there is no evidence for a functional role of it in MS.

Predictive markers for response to interferon therapy in patients with multiple sclerosis.

Background: Prolonged therapy with interferon β (IFNβ) often leads to the development of anti-IFNβ binding antibodies (BAbs). A subset of the BAbs is of a neutralizing nature (neutralizing antibodies, NAbs) and is associated with reduced clinical efficacy of therapy. Myxovirus-resistance-protein A (MxA) has proven to be a reliable biomarker of IFNβ bioactivity. We analyzed the prognostic value of MxA mRNA, NAbs, and BAbs on the risk of having a new relapse in IFNβ-treated patients. Methods: A 3-year study was conducted in 137 IFNβ-treated patients. Blood samples for BAbs, NAbs, and MxA mRNA measurements were taken after 12 ± 3 months of therapy. Analysis of relapse-free survival (RFS) was performed for all measures by using known thresholds, generating “positive” and “negative” groups. Also, time between sampling and following relapse and risk of new relapses were calculated. Results: The MxA-negative group showed poorer RFS rates than the MxA-positive group [p < 0.0001, hazard ratio (HR) = 2.87]. Likewise, the NAb-positive group showed poorer RFS rates than the NAb-negative group (p =0.0013; HR = 2.49). On the contrary, BAb measurement did not show a clear clinical significance. Conclusions: Findings indicate that measurements of both myxovirus-resistance-protein A (MxA) and neutralizing antibodies (NAbs) predict the risk of new relapses; however, the slightly stronger prognostic significance of MxA mRNA and the easier method for it measurement make MxA mRNA the preferred biomarker for monitoring interferon β (IFNβ)-treated patients. This information can be used to better tailor treatment to the individual patient with MS. GLOSSARY: BAb = binding antibody; CPE = cytopathic effect; EDSS = Expanded Disability Status Scale; GAPDH = glyceraldehyde phosphate dehydrogenase; HR = hazard ratio; IFN = interferon; MxA = myxovirus-resistance-protein A; NAb = neutralizing antibody; RFS = relapse-free survival; ROC = receiver operating characteristic; TRU = 10-fold reduction units.

Learning from nature: pregnancy changes the expression of inflammation-related genes in patients with multiple sclerosis.

Background Pregnancy is associated with reduced activity of multiple sclerosis (MS). However, the biological mechanisms underlying this pregnancy-related decrease in disease activity are poorly understood. Methodology We conducted a genome-wide transcription analysis in peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) from 12 women (7 MS patients and 5 healthy controls) followed during their pregnancy. Samples were obtained before, during (i.e. at the third, sixth, and ninth month of gestation) and after pregnancy. A validation of the expression profiles has been conducted by using the same samples and an independent group of 25 MS patients and 11 healthy controls. Finally, considering the total group of 32 MS patients, we compared expression profiles of patients relapsing during pregnancy (n = 6) with those of relapse-free patients (n = 26). Principal Findings Results showed an altered expression of 347 transcripts in non-pregnant MS patients with respect to non-pregnant healthy controls. Complementary changes in expression, occurring during pregnancy, reverted the previous imbalance particularly for seven inflammation-related transcripts, i.e. SOCS2, TNFAIP3, NR4A2, CXCR4, POLR2J, FAM49B, and STAG3L1. Longitudinal analysis showed that the overall deregulation of gene expression reverted to “normal” already within the third month of gestation, while in the post-partum gene expressions rebounded to pre-pregnancy levels. Six (18.7%) of the 32 MS patients had a relapse during pregnancy, mostly in the first trimester. The latter showed delayed expression profiles when compared to relapse-free patients: in these patients expression imbalance was reverted later in the pregnancy, i.e. at sixth month. Conclusions Specific changes in expression during pregnancy were associated with a decrease in disease activity assessed by occurrence of relapses during pregnancy. Findings might help in understanding the pathogenesis of MS and may provide basis for the development of novel therapeutic strategies.

Biological responsiveness to first injections of interferon-beta in patients with multiple sclerosis

This study is the first to evaluate biological response to first injections of interferon-beta (IFNbeta) in patients with multiple sclerosis. MxA mRNA was measured in 96 patients receiving IFNbeta-1a (Avonex, n=32), IFNbeta-1b (Betaferon, n=19), IFNbeta-1a (Rebif) 22 microg (n=30), or IFNbeta-1a 44 microg (n=15). Patients were analysed before, 3 and 24 h after the first injection, and 12 h after the second administration. Results showed that up-regulation was evident within 3 h of IFNbeta injection, peaked 12 h after injection, and progressively declined 24 h after administration. The cumulative responses were similar after a single administration, regardless of product/dose. Moreover, data indicate that the abolition of the biological activity detected during IFNbeta therapy is due to underlying phenomena (e.g., neutralizing antibodies), because all patients were constitutively responders to IFNbeta at treatment initiation.

Variable responses to rituximab treatment in neuromyelitis optica (Devic's disease).

We have described two cases of Devic’s disease patients treated with rituximab with different outcomes. The results indicate that there may be early unresponsiveness in very aggressive cases. Well designed clinical trials are needed to assess treatment effects in such a rare disease.SommarioAbbiamo descritto due casi di Malattia di Devic trattati con Rituximab con differente risposta terapeutica. I risultati indicano la possibilità di una non risposta precoce nei casi molto aggressivi. Sono necessari trial clinici ben strutturati per la valutazione dell’efficacia dei trattamenti in questa rara malattia.

Early detection of neutralizing antibodies to interferon-beta in multiple sclerosis patients: binding antibodies predict neutralizing antibody development:

Background: Neutralizing antibodies (NAb) affect efficacy of interferon-beta (IFN-b) treatment in multiple sclerosis (MS) patients. NAbs evolve in up to 44% of treated patients, usually between 6–18 months on therapy. Objectives: To investigate whether early binding antibody (BAb) titers or different IFN-b biomarkers predict NAb evolution. Methods: We included patients with MS or clinically isolated syndrome (CIS) receiving de novo IFN-b treatment in this prospective European multicenter study. Blood samples were collected at baseline, before and after the first IFN-b administration, and again after 3, 12 and 24 months on that therapy; for determination of NAbs, BAbs, gene expression of MxA and protein concentrations of MMP-9, TIMP-1, sTRAIL, CXCL-10 and CCL-2. Results: We found that 22 of 164 (13.4%) patients developed NAbs during a median time of 23.8 months on IFN-b treatment. Of these patients, 78.9% were BAb-positive after 3 months. BAb titers ≥ 1:2400 predicted NAb evolution with a sensitivity of 74.7% and a specificity of 98.5%. Cross-sectionally, MxA levels were significantly diminished in the BAb/NAb-positive samples; similarly, CXCL-10 and sTRAIL concentrations in BAb/NAb-positive and BAb-positive/NAb-negative samples, respectively, were also diminished compared to BAb/NAb-negative samples. Conclusions: BAb titers reliably predict NAbs. CXCL-10 is a promising sensitive biomarker for IFN-b response and its abrogation by anti-IFN-b antibodies.

Transforming growth factor β1 (TGFβ1) mRNA level correlates with magnetic resonance imaging disease activity in Multiple Sclerosis patients

Eight relapsing-remitting multiple sclerosis (MS) patients were tested for the level of transforming growth factor β1 (TGFβ1) mRNA in peripheral blood mononuclear cells every 15 days for 6 months. Disease activity was evaluated every 4 weeks by magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and neurological examination. An inverse correlation was found between the level of TGFβ1 mRNA and MRI disease activity. The level of TGFβ1 mRNA predicted the presence of disease activity in the scans performed 2–4 weeks later with high sensitivity (88%) and specificity (87.5%) suggesting that TGFβ1 mRNA quantification could be an indicator of disease activity in MS.