Simone Piccinin

Alloys in catalysis: phase separation and surface segregation phenomena in response to the reactive environment

Alloys play a crucial role in several heterogeneous catalytic processes, and their applications are expected to rise rapidly. This is essentially related to the vast number of configurations and type of surface sites that multi-component materials can afford. It is well established that the chemical composition at the surface of an alloy usually differs from that in the bulk. This phenomenon, referred to as surface segregation, is largely controlled by the surface free energy. However, surface energy alone cannot safely predict the active surface state of a solid catalyst, since the contribution of other parameters such as size and support effects, as well as influence of the adsorbates, play a major role. This can lead to numerous surface configurations as for example over the length of a catalytic reactor, as the chemical potential of the gas phase changes continuously over the catalyst bed and hence different reactions may prevail at different catalyst bed segments. Thanks to the rapid improvement of the analytical surface science characterization techniques and theoretical methodologies, the potential effects induced by alloyed catalysts are better understood. For catalysis, the relevance of measurements performed on well-defined surfaces under idealized ultrahigh vacuum conditions has been questioned and studies in environments that closely resemble conditions of working alloy catalysts are needed. In this review we focus on experimental and theoretical studies related to in situ (operando) observations of surface segregation and phase separation phenomena taking place on the outermost surface layers of alloy catalysts. The combination of first principles theoretical treatment and in situ observation opens up new perspectives of designing alloy catalysts with tailored properties.

Electronic properties of metal-molecule-metal systems at zero bias: A periodic density functional study

We have studied the electronic properties of conjugated and saturated dithiol molecules sandwiched between two Au(111) electrodes using first principles density functional calculations with a slab geometry. Relaxation of the molecule/surface adsorption geometry as well as the extended character of the metal electrode states are fully taken into account by our approach. Investigated quantities include the alignment of molecular energy levels with the Fermi energy (EF) of the metal, the charge transfer and electrostatic potential profile, and the local density of electronic states (LDOS) at EF. The behavior of the LDOS for benzene–, dibenzene–, and xylyl–dithiol molecules is analyzed and compared with that of alkane–dithiols of various lengths.

Water oxidation surface mechanisms replicated by a totally inorganic tetraruthenium–oxo molecular complex

Solar-to-fuel energy conversion relies on the invention of efficient catalysts enabling water oxidation through low-energy pathways. Our aerobic life is based on this strategy, mastered by the natural Photosystem II enzyme, using a tetranuclear Mn–oxo complex as oxygen evolving center. Within artificial devices, water can be oxidized efficiently on tailored metal-oxide surfaces such as RuO2. The quest for catalyst optimization in vitro is plagued by the elusive description of the active sites on bulk oxides. Although molecular mimics of the natural catalyst have been proposed, they generally suffer from oxidative degradation under multiturnover regime. Here we investigate a nano-sized Ru4–polyoxometalate standing as an efficient artificial catalyst featuring a totally inorganic molecular structure with enhanced stability. Experimental and computational evidence reported herein indicates that this is a unique molecular species mimicking oxygenic RuO2 surfaces. Ru4–polyoxometalate bridges the gap between homogeneous and heterogeneous water oxidation catalysis, leading to a breakthrough system. Density functional theory calculations show that the catalytic efficiency stems from the optimal distribution of the free energy cost to form reaction intermediates, in analogy with metal-oxide catalysts, thus providing a unifying picture for the two realms of water oxidation catalysis. These correlations among the mechanism of reaction, thermodynamic efficiency, and local structure of the active sites provide the key guidelines for the rational design of superior molecular catalysts and composite materials designed with a bottom–up approach and atomic control.

Atomistic structure of cobalt-phosphate nanoparticles for catalytic water oxidation.

Solar-driven water splitting is a key photochemical reaction that underpins the feasible and sustainable production of solar fuels. An amorphous cobalt-phosphate catalyst (Co-Pi) based on earth-abundant elements has been recently reported to efficiently promote water oxidation to protons and dioxygen, a main bottleneck for the overall process. The structure of this material remains largely unknown. We here exploit ab initio and classical atomistic simulations combined with metadynamics to build a realistic and statistically meaningful model of Co-Pi nanoparticles. We demonstrate the emergence and stability of molecular-size ordered crystallites in nanoparticles initially formed by a disordered Co-O network and phosphate groups. The stable crystallites consist of bis-oxo-bridged Co centers that assemble into layered structures (edge-sharing CoO(6) octahedra) as well as in corner- and face-sharing cubane units. These layered and cubane motifs coexist in the crystallites, which always incorporate disordered phosphate groups at the edges. Our computational nanoparticles, although limited in size to ~1 nm, can contain more than one crystallite and incorporate up to 18 Co centers in the cubane/layered structures. The crystallites are structurally stable up to high temperatures. We simulate the extended X-ray absorption fine structure (EXAFS) of our nanoparticles. Those containing several complete and incomplete cubane motifs-which are believed to be essential for the catalytic activity-display a very good agreement with the experimental EXAFS spectra of Co-Pi grains. We propose that the crystallites in our nanoparticles are reliable structural models of the Co-Pi catalyst surface. They will be useful to reveal the origin of the catalytic efficiency of these novel water-oxidation catalysts.

Photo-driven oxidation of water on α-Fe2O3 surfaces: An ab initio study

Adopting the theoretical scheme developed by the Nørskov group [see, for example, Nørskov et al., J. Phys. Chem. B 108, 17886 (2004)], we conducted a density functional theory study of photo-driven oxidation processes of water on various terminations of the clean hematite (α-Fe2O3) (0001) surface, explicitly taking into account the strong correlation among the 3d states of iron through the Hubbard U parameter. Six best-known terminations, namely, Fe−Fe−O3− (we call S1), O−Fe−Fe−(S2), O2−Fe−Fe−(S3), O3−Fe−Fe− (S4), Fe−O3−Fe− (S5), and O−Fe−O3−(S6), are first exposed to water, the stability of resulting surfaces is investigated under photoelectrochemical conditions by considering different chemical reactions (and their reaction free energies) that lead to surfaces covered by O atoms or/and OH groups. Assuming that the water splitting reaction is driven by the redox potential for photogenerated holes with respect to the normal hydrogen electrode, UVB, at voltage larger than UVB, most 3-oxygen terminated substrates are stable. These results thus suggest that the surface, hydroxylated in the dark, should release protons under illumination. Considering the surface free energy of all the possible terminations shows that O3–S5 and O3–S1 are the most thermodynamically stable. While water oxidation process on the former requires an overpotential of 1.22 V, only 0.84 V is needed on the latter.

Energetics of Water Oxidation Catalyzed by Cobalt Oxide Nanoparticles: Assessing the Accuracy of DFT and DFT+U Approaches against Coupled Cluster Methods.

Some of the most promising catalysts for water oxidation rely on crystalline and amorphous cobalt oxide nanoparticles. Density functional theory (DFT) calculations are routinely used to study the electronic and atomic structures of these materials as well as the thermodynamics and mechanisms of the electrochemical oxygen evolution reaction. The accuracy of these theoretical predictions has never been compared to high-level quantum chemistry methods. We perform coupled cluster (CC) quantum chemistry calculations on model cobalt oxide surface sites and use them to benchmark the accuracy of the most popular exchange and correlation functionals. Hybrid B3LYP and PBE0 functionals lead to fair agreement with the CC energies, while standard gradient-corrected functionals show important discrepancies. The inclusion of on-site electronic repulsion (DFT+U) substantially improves the calculated electronic and structural properties, but no value of the U parameter reproduces the CC results. We discuss the implications of these findings for amorphous cobalt phosphate nanoparticles, showing that the reactivity of these catalysts is not altered by surface phosphate groups.

First-principles investigation of Ag-Cu alloy surfaces in an oxidizing environment

In this paper, we investigate by means of first-principles density functional theory calculations the 111 surface of the Ag-Cu alloy under varying conditions of pressure of the surrounding oxygen atmosphere and temperature. This alloy has been recently proposed as a catalyst with improved selectivity for ethylene epoxidation with respect to pure silver, the catalyst commonly used in industrial applications. Here, we show that the presence of oxygen leads to copper segregation to the surface. Considering the surface free energy as a function of the surface composition, we construct the convex hull to investigate the stability of various surface structures. By including the dependence of the free surface energy on the oxygen chemical potential, we are able compute the phase diagram of the alloy as a function of temperature, pressure, and surface composition. We find that, at temperature and pressure, typically used in ethylene epoxidation, a number of structures can be present on the surface of the alloy, including clean Ag111, thin layers of copper oxide, and thick oxidelike structures. These results are consistent with, and help explain, recent experimental results.

Ag-Cu alloy surfaces in an oxidizing environment: A first-principles study

Recent experiments on model catalysts have shown that Ag–Cu alloys have improved selectivity with respect to pure silver for ethylene epoxidation. In this paper, we review our first-principles investigations on the (1 1 1) surface of this alloy and present new findings on other low index surfaces. We find that, for every surface orientation, the presence of oxygen leads to copper segregation to the surface. Considering the alloy to be in equilibrium with an oxygen atmosphere and accounting for the effect of temperature and pressure, we compute the surface free energy and study the stability of several surface structures. Investigating the dependence of the surface free energy on the surface composition, we construct the phase diagram of the alloy for every surface orientation. Around the temperature, pressure and composition of interest for practical applications, we find that a limited number of structures can be present, including a thin layer of copper oxide on top of the silver surface and copper-free structures. Different surface orientations show a very similar behavior and in particular a single layer with CuO stoichiometry, significantly distorted when compared to a layer of bulk CuO, has a wide range of stability for all orientations. Our results are consistent with, and help explain, recent experimental measurements.

Bridging the temperature and pressure gaps: close-packed transition metal surfaces in an oxygen environment

An understanding of the interaction of atoms and molecules with solid surfaces on the microscopic level is of crucial importance to many, if not most, modern high-tech materials applications. Obtaining such accurate, quantitative information has traditionally been the realm of surface science experiments, carried out under ultra-high vacuum conditions. Over recent years scientists have realized the importance of obtaining such knowledge also under the high pressure and temperature conditions under which many industrial processes take place, e.g. heterogeneous catalysis, since the material under these conditions may be quite different to that under the conditions of typical surface science experiments. Theoretical studies too have been aimed at bridging the so-called pressure and temperature gaps, and great strides have been made in recent years, often in conjunction with experiment. Here we review recent progress in the understanding of the hexagonal close-packed surfaces of late transition and noble metals in an oxygen environment, which is of relevance to many heterogeneous catalytic reactions. In many cases it is found that, on exposure to high oxygen pressures and elevated temperatures, thin oxide-like structures form which may or may not be stable, and which may have little similarity to the bulk oxides, and thus possess unique chemical and physical properties.

Ag-Cu catalysts for ethylene epoxidation: selectivity and activity descriptors.

Ag-Cu alloy catalysts for ethylene epoxidation have been shown to yield higher selectivity towards ethylene oxide compared to pure Ag, the unique catalyst employed in the industrial process. Previous studies showed that under oxidizing conditions Cu forms oxide layers on top of Ag. Using first-principles atomistic simulations based on density functional theory, we investigate the reaction mechanism on the thin oxide layer structures and establish the reasons for the improved selectivity. We extend the range of applicability of the selectivity descriptor proposed by Kokalj et al. [J. Catal. 254, 304 (2008)], based on binding energies of reactants, intermediates, and products, by refitting its parameters so as to include thin oxide layer catalysts. We show that the selectivity is mainly controlled by the relative strength of the metal-carbon vs. metal-oxygen bonds, while the height of the reaction barriers mostly depend on the binding energy of the common oxametallacycle intermediate.