Sonia Huecas

The Antibacterial Cell Division Inhibitor PC190723 Is an FtsZ Polymer-stabilizing Agent That Induces Filament Assembly and Condensation

Cell division protein FtsZ can form single-stranded filaments with a cooperative behavior by self-switching assembly. Subsequent condensation and bending of FtsZ filaments are important for the formation and constriction of the cytokinetic ring. PC190723 is an effective bactericidal cell division inhibitor that targets FtsZ in the pathogen Staphylococcus aureus and Bacillus subtilis and does not affect Escherichia coli cells, which apparently binds to a zone equivalent to the binding site of the antitumor drug taxol in tubulin (Haydon, D. J., Stokes, N. R., Ure, R., Galbraith, G., Bennett, J. M., Brown, D. R., Baker, P. J., Barynin, V. V., Rice, D. W., Sedelnikova, S. E., Heal, J. R., Sheridan, J. M., Aiwale, S. T., Chauhan, P. K., Srivastava, A., Taneja, A., Collins, I., Errington, J., and Czaplewski, L. G. (2008) Science 312, 1673–1675). We have found that the benzamide derivative PC190723 is an FtsZ polymer-stabilizing agent. PC190723 induced nucleated assembly of Bs-FtsZ into single-stranded coiled protofilaments and polymorphic condensates, including bundles, coils, and toroids, whose formation could be modulated with different solution conditions. Under conditions for reversible assembly of Bs-FtsZ, PC190723 binding reduced the GTPase activity and induced the formation of straight bundles and ribbons, which was also observed with Sa-FtsZ but not with nonsusceptible Ec-FtsZ. The fragment 2,6-difluoro-3-methoxybenzamide also induced Bs-FtsZ bundling. We propose that polymer stabilization by PC190723 suppresses in vivo FtsZ polymer dynamics and bacterial division. The biochemical action of PC190723 on FtsZ parallels that of the microtubule-stabilizing agent taxol on the eukaryotic structural homologue tubulin. Both taxol and PC190723 stabilize polymers against disassembly by preferential binding to each assembled protein. It is yet to be investigated whether both ligands target structurally related assembly switches.

Assembly of archaeal cell division protein FtsZ and a GTPase-inactive mutant into double-stranded filaments.

We have studied the assembly and GTPase of purified FtsZ from the hyperthermophilic archaeon Methanococcus jannaschii, a structural homolog of eukaryotic tubulin, employing wild-type FtsZ, FtsZ-His6 (histidine-tagged FtsZ), and the new mutants FtsZ-W319Y and FtsZ-W319Y-His6, with light scattering, nucleotide analyses, electron microscopy, and image processing methods. This has revealed novel properties of FtsZ. The GTPase of archaeal FtsZ polymers is suppressed in Na+-containing buffer, generating stabilized structures that require GDP addition for disassembly. FtsZ assembly is polymorphic. Archaeal FtsZ(wt) assembles into associated and isolated filaments made of two parallel protofilaments with a 43 Å longitudinal spacing between monomers, and this structure is also observed in bacterial FtsZ from Escherichia coli. The His6 extension facilitates the artificial formation of helical tubes and sheets. FtsZ-W319Y-His6 is an inactivated GTPase whose assembly remains regulated by GTP and Mg2+. It forms two-dimensional crystals made of symmetrical pairs of tubulin-like protofilaments, which associate in an antiparallel array (similarly to the known Ca2+-induced sheets of FtsZ-His6). In contrast to the lateral interactions of microtubule protofilaments, we propose that the primary assembly product of FtsZ is the double-stranded filament, one or several of which might form the dynamic Z ring during prokaryotic cell division.

The Interactions of Cell Division Protein FtsZ with Guanine Nucleotides

Prokaryotic cell division protein FtsZ, an assembling GTPase, directs the formation of the septosome between daughter cells. FtsZ is an attractive target for the development of new antibiotics. Assembly dynamics of FtsZ is regulated by the binding, hydrolysis, and exchange of GTP. We have determined the energetics of nucleotide binding to model apoFtsZ from Methanococcus jannaschii and studied the kinetics of 2′/3′-O-(N-methylanthraniloyl) (mant)-nucleotide binding and dissociation from FtsZ polymers, employing calorimetric, fluorescence, and stopped-flow methods. FtsZ binds GTP and GDP with Kb values ranging from 20 to 300 μm-1 under various conditions. GTP·Mg2+ and GDP·Mg2+ bind with slightly reduced affinity. Bound GTP and the coordinated Mg2+ ion play a minor structural role in FtsZ monomers, but Mg2+-assisted GTP hydrolysis triggers polymer disassembly. Mant-GTP binds and dissociates quickly from FtsZ monomers, with ∼10-fold lower affinity than GTP. Mant-GTP displacement measured by fluorescence anisotropy provides a method to test the binding of any competing molecules to the FtsZ nucleotide site. Mant-GTP is very slowly hydrolyzed and remains exchangeable in FtsZ polymers, but it becomes kinetically stabilized, with a 30-fold slower k+ and ∼500-fold slower k- than in monomers. The mant-GTP dissociation rate from FtsZ polymers is comparable with the GTP hydrolysis turnover and with the reported subunit turnover in Escherichia coli FtsZ polymers. Although FtsZ polymers can exchange nucleotide, unlike its eukaryotic structural homologue tubulin, GDP dissociation may be slow enough for polymer disassembly to take place first, resulting in FtsZ polymers cycling with GTP hydrolysis similarly to microtubules.

Polymerization of nucleotide-free, GDP- and GTP-bound cell division protein FtsZ: GDP makes the difference

Stable, more than 98% nucleotide‐free apo‐FtsZ was prepared from purified Methanococcus jannaschhi FtsZ. This facilitates the study of the functional mechanisms of this FtsZ, an assembling GTPase, which shares a common fold with eukaryotic tubulin. Apo‐FtsZ underwent cooperative magnesium‐induced polymerization with a similar critical concentration and morphology related to that of reconstituted GTP‐bound FtsZ, suggesting that the binding of GTP contributes insignificantly to the stability of the FtsZ polymers. On the other hand, reconstituted GDP‐FtsZ polymerized with a larger critical concentration than GTP‐FtsZ, indicating that GDP binding destabilizes FtsZ polymers. Upon GTP hydrolysis by FtsZ polymers, in the absence of a continued GTP supply and under macromolecular crowding conditions enhancing FtsZ polymerization, the straight GTP polymers disappeared and were replaced by characteristic helically curved GDP‐bound polymers. These results suggest that the roles of GTP binding and hydrolysis by this archaeal FtsZ are simply to facilitate disassembly. In a physiological situation in GTP excess, GDP‐bound FtsZ subunits could again bind GTP, or trigger disassembly, or be recognized by FtsZ filament depolymerizing proteins, allowing the Z‐ring dynamics during prokaryotic cell division.

Synthetic Inhibitors of Bacterial Cell Division Targeting the GTP-Binding Site of FtsZ

Cell division protein FtsZ is the organizer of the cytokinetic Z-ring in most bacteria and a target for new antibiotics. FtsZ assembles with GTP into filaments that hydrolyze the nucleotide at the association interface between monomers and then disassemble. We have replaced FtsZs GTP with non-nucleotide synthetic inhibitors of bacterial division. We searched for these small molecules among compounds from the literature, from virtual screening (VS), and from our in-house synthetic library (UCM), employing a fluorescence anisotropy primary assay. From these screens we have identified the polyhydroxy aromatic compound UCM05 and its simplified analogue UCM44 that specifically bind to Bacillus subtilis FtsZ monomers with micromolar affinities and perturb normal assembly, as examined with light scattering, polymer sedimentation, and negative stain electron microscopy. On the other hand, these ligands induce the cooperative assembly of nucleotide-devoid archaeal FtsZ into distinct well-ordered polymers, different from GTP-induced filaments. These FtsZ inhibitors impair localization of FtsZ into the Z-ring and inhibit bacterial cell division. The chlorinated analogue UCM53 inhibits the growth of clinical isolates of antibiotic-resistant Staphylococcus aureus and Enterococcus faecalis. We suggest that these interfacial inhibitors recapitulate binding and some assembly-inducing effects of GTP but impair the correct structural dynamics of FtsZ filaments and thus inhibit bacterial division, possibly by binding to a small fraction of the FtsZ molecules in a bacterial cell, which opens a new approach to FtsZ-based antibacterial drug discovery.

Interactions of Bacterial Cell Division Protein FtsZ with C8- Substituted Guanine Nucleotide Inhibitors. A Combined NMR, Biochemical and Molecular Modeling Perspective

FtsZ is the key protein of bacterial cell-division and target for new antibiotics. Selective inhibition of FtsZ polymerization without impairing the assembly of the eukaryotic homologue tubulin was demonstrated with C8-substituted guanine nucleotides. By combining NMR techniques with biochemical and molecular modeling procedures, we have investigated the molecular recognition of C8-substituted-nucleotides by FtsZ from Methanococcus jannaschii (Mj-FtsZ) and Bacillus subtilis (Bs-FtsZ). STD epitope mapping and trNOESY bioactive conformation analysis of each nucleotide were employed to deduce differences in their recognition mode by each FtsZ species. GMP binds in the same anti conformation as GTP, whereas 8-pyrrolidino-GMP binds in the syn conformation. However, the anti conformation of 8-morpholino-GMP is selected by Bs-FtsZ, while Mj-FtsZ binds both anti- and syn-geometries. The inhibitory potencies of the C8-modified-nucleotides on the assembly of Bs-FtsZ, but not of Mj-FtsZ, correlate with their binding affinities. Thus, MorphGTP behaves as a nonhydrolyzable analog whose binding induces formation of Mj-FtsZ curved filaments, resembling polymers formed by the inactive forms of this protein. NMR data, combined with molecular modeling protocols, permit explanation of the mechanism of FtsZ assembly impairment by C8-substituted GTP analogs. The presence of the C8-substituent induces electrostatic remodeling and small structural displacements at the association interface between FtsZ monomers to form filaments, leading to complete assembly inhibition or to formation of abnormal FtsZ polymers. The inhibition of bacterial Bs-FtsZ assembly may be simply explained by steric clashes of the C8-GTP-analogs with the incoming FtsZ monomer. This information may facilitate the design of antibacterial FtsZ inhibitors replacing GTP.

Chrysophaentins are competitive inhibitors of FtsZ and inhibit Z-ring formation in live bacteria.

The bacterial cell division protein FtsZ polymerizes in a GTP-dependent manner to form a Z-ring that marks the plane of division. As a validated antimicrobial target, considerable efforts have been devoted to identify small molecule FtsZ inhibitors. We recently discovered the chrysophaentins, a novel suite of marine natural products that inhibit FtsZ activity in vitro. These natural products along with a synthetic hemi-chrysophaentin exhibit strong antimicrobial activity toward a broad spectrum of Gram-positive pathogens. To define their mechanisms of FtsZ inhibition and determine their in vivo effects in live bacteria, we used GTPase assays and fluorescence anisotropy to show that hemi-chrysophaentin competitively inhibits FtsZ activity. Furthermore, we developed a model system using a permeable Escherichia coli strain, envA1, together with an inducible FtsZ-yellow fluorescent protein construct to show by fluorescence microscopy that both chrysophaentin A and hemi-chrysophaentin disrupt Z-rings in live bacteria. We tested the E. coli system further by reproducing phenotypes observed for zantrins Z1 and Z3, and demonstrate that the alkaloid berberine, a reported FtsZ inhibitor, exhibits auto-fluorescence, making it incompatible with systems that employ GFP or YFP tagged FtsZ. These studies describe unique examples of nonnucleotide, competitive FtsZ inhibitors that disrupt FtsZ in vivo, together with a model system that should be useful for in vivo testing of FtsZ inhibitor leads that have been identified through in vitro screens but are unable to penetrate the Gram-negative outer membrane.

Effective GTP-replacing FtsZ inhibitors and antibacterial mechanism of action.

Essential cell division protein FtsZ is considered an attractive target in the search for antibacterials with novel mechanisms of action to overcome the resistance problem. FtsZ undergoes GTP-dependent assembly at midcell to form the Z-ring, a dynamic structure that evolves until final constriction of the cell. Therefore, molecules able to inhibit its activity will eventually disrupt bacterial viability. In this work, we report a new series of small molecules able to replace GTP and to specifically inhibit FtsZ, blocking the bacterial division process. These new synthesized inhibitors interact with the GTP-binding site of FtsZ (Kd = 0.4-0.8 μM), display antibacterial activity against Gram-positive pathogenic bacteria, and show selectivity against tubulin. Biphenyl derivative 28 stands out as a potent FtsZ inhibitor (Kd = 0.5 μM) with high antibacterial activity [MIC (MRSA) = 7 μM]. In-depth analysis of the mechanism of action of compounds 22, 28, 33, and 36 has revealed that they act as effective inhibitors of correct FtsZ assembly, blocking bacterial division and thus leading to filamentous undivided cells. These findings provide a compelling rationale for the development of compounds targeting the GTP-binding site as antibacterial agents and open the door to antibiotics with novel mechanisms of action.

Cytological profile of antibacterial FtsZ inhibitors and synthetic peptide MciZ

Cell division protein FtsZ is the organizer of the cytokinetic ring in almost all bacteria and a target for the discovery of new antibacterial agents that are needed to counter widespread antibiotic resistance. Bacterial cytological profiling, using quantitative microscopy, is a powerful approach for identifying the mechanism of action of antibacterial molecules affecting different cellular pathways. We have determined the cytological profile on Bacillus subtilis cells of a selection of small molecule inhibitors targeting FtsZ on different binding sites. FtsZ inhibitors lead to long undivided cells, impair the normal assembly of FtsZ into the midcell Z-rings, induce aberrant ring distributions, punctate FtsZ foci, membrane spots and also modify nucleoid length. Quantitative analysis of cell and nucleoid length combined, or the Z-ring distribution, allows categorizing FtsZ inhibitors and to distinguish them from antibiotics with other mechanisms of action, which should be useful for identifying new antibacterial FtsZ inhibitors. Biochemical assays of FtsZ polymerization and GTPase activity combined explain the cellular effects of the FtsZ polymer stabilizing agent PC190723 and its fragments. MciZ is a 40-aminoacid endogenous inhibitor of cell division normally expressed during sporulation in B. subtilis. Using FtsZ cytological profiling we have determined that exogenous synthetic MciZ is an effective inhibitor of B. subtilis cell division, Z-ring formation and localization. This finding supports our cell-based approach to screen for FtsZ inhibitors and opens new possibilities for peptide inhibitors of bacterial cell division.