Stefen Brady

Long-term observational study of sporadic inclusion body myositis

We describe a long-term observational study of a large cohort of patients with sporadic inclusion body myositis and propose a sporadic inclusion body myositis weakness composite index that is easy to perform during a clinic. Data collection from two groups of patients (Paris and Oxford) was completed either during a clinic visit (52%), or by extraction from previous medical records (48%). One hundred and thirty-six patients [57% males, 61 (interquartile range 55-69) years at onset] were included. At the last visit all patients had muscle weakness (proximal British Medical Research Council scale <3/5 in 48%, distal British Medical Research Council scale <3/5 in 40%, swallowing problems in 46%). During their follow-up, 75% of patients had significant walking difficulties and 37% used a wheelchair (after a median duration from onset of 14 years). The sporadic inclusion body myositis weakness composite index, which correlated with grip strength (correlation coefficient: 0.47; P < 0.001) and Rivermead Mobility Index (correlation coefficient: 0.85; P < 0.001), decreased significantly with disease duration (correlation coefficient: -0.47; P < 0.001). The risk of death was only influenced by older age at onset of first symptoms. Seventy-one (52%) patients received immunosuppressive treatments [prednisone in 91.5%, associated (in 64.8%) with other immunomodulatory drugs (intravenous immunoglobulins, methotrexate or azathioprine) for a median duration of 40.8 months]. At the last assessment, patients who had been treated were more severely affected on disability scales (Walton P = 0.007, Rivermead Mobility Index P = 0.004) and on the sporadic inclusion body myositis weakness composite index (P = 0.04). The first stage of disease progression towards handicap for walking was more rapid among patients receiving immunosuppressive treatments (hazard ratio = 2.0, P = 0.002). This study confirms that sporadic inclusion body myositis is slowly progressive but not lethal and that immunosuppressive treatments do not ameliorate its natural course, thus confirming findings from smaller studies. Furthermore, our findings suggest that immunosuppressant drug therapy could have modestly exacerbated progression of disability. The sporadic inclusion body myositis weakness composite index might be a valuable outcome measure for future clinical trials, but requires further assessment and validation.

Clinical assessment determines the diagnosis of inclusion body myositis independently of pathological features

Background and objective Historically, the diagnosis of sporadic inclusion body myositis (IBM) has required the demonstration of the presence of a number of histopathological findings on muscle biopsy—namely, rimmed vacuoles, an inflammatory infiltrate with invasion of non-necrotic muscle fibres (partial invasion) and amyloid or 15–18 nm tubulofilamentous inclusions (Griggs criteria). However, biopsies of many patients with clinically typical IBM do not show all of these histopathological findings, at least at presentation. We compared the clinical features at presentation and during the course of disease in 67 patients with histopathologically diagnosed IBM and clinically diagnosed IBM seen within a single UK specialist muscle centre. Methods and results At presentation, using clinically focused diagnostic criteria (European Neuromuscular Centre (ENMC) 2011), a diagnosis of IBM was made in 88% of patients whereas 76% fulfilled the 1997 ENMC criteria and only 27% satisfied the histopathologically focused Griggs criteria. There were no differences in clinical features or outcomes between clinically and histopathologically diagnosed patients, but patients lacking the classical histopathological finding of rimmed vacuoles were younger, suggesting that rimmed vacuoles may be a later feature of the disease. Conclusions These findings have important implications for diagnosis and future studies or trials in IBM as adherence to histopathologically focused diagnostic criteria will exclude large numbers of patients with IBM. Importantly, those excluded may be at an earlier stage of the disease and more amenable to treatment.

A retrospective cohort study identifying the principal pathological features useful in the diagnosis of inclusion body myositis.

Objective The current pathological diagnostic criteria for sporadic inclusion body myositis (IBM) lack sensitivity. Using immunohistochemical techniques abnormal protein aggregates have been identified in IBM, including some associated with neurodegenerative disorders. Our objective was to investigate the diagnostic utility of a number of markers of protein aggregates together with mitochondrial and inflammatory changes in IBM. Design Retrospective cohort study. The sensitivity of pathological features was evaluated in cases of Griggs definite IBM. The diagnostic potential of the most reliable features was then assessed in clinically typical IBM with rimmed vacuoles (n=15), clinically typical IBM without rimmed vacuoles (n=9) and IBM mimics—protein accumulation myopathies containing rimmed vacuoles (n=7) and steroid-responsive inflammatory myopathies (n=11). Setting Specialist muscle services at the John Radcliffe Hospital, Oxford and the National Hospital for Neurology and Neurosurgery, London. Results Individual pathological features, in isolation, lacked sensitivity and specificity. However, the morphology and distribution of p62 aggregates in IBM were characteristic and in a myopathy with rimmed vacuoles, the combination of characteristic p62 aggregates and increased sarcolemmal and internal major histocompatibility complex class I expression or endomysial T cells were diagnostic for IBM with a sensitivity of 93% and specificity of 100%. In an inflammatory myopathy lacking rimmed vacuoles, the presence of mitochondrial changes was 100% sensitive and 73% specific for IBM; characteristic p62 aggregates were specific (91%), but lacked sensitivity (44%). Conclusions We propose an easily applied diagnostic algorithm for the pathological diagnosis of IBM. Additionally our findings support the hypothesis that many of the pathological features considered typical of IBM develop later in the disease, explaining their poor sensitivity at disease presentation and emphasising the need for revised pathological criteria to supplement the clinical criteria in the diagnosis of IBM.

Longitudinal observational study of sporadic inclusion body myositis: Implications for clinical trials

Sporadic inclusion body myositis (IBM) is the most common acquired myopathy occurring in adults aged over 50 years. The aim of the study was to assess prospectively the clinical features and functional impact of sporadic inclusion body myositis (IBM). Clinical data, manual muscle testing (MMT), quantitative muscle testing (QMT) of quadriceps muscle and IBM functional rating scale (IBM-FRS) were collected according to a standardised protocol at baseline (n=51) and one-year follow-up (n=23). MMT, quadriceps QMT and IBM-FRS significantly declined after one year (by 5.2%, 27.9%, and 13.8%, respectively). QMT of the quadriceps muscle and IBM-FRS were the most sensitive measures of disease progression. After a median time of seven years of disease duration, 63% of patients had lost independent walking. Disease onset after 55 years of age, but not sex or treatment, is predictive of a shorter time to requirement of a walking stick. We detected no differences in disease presentation and progression between clinically and pathologically defined IBM patients. The study provides evidence that quadriceps QMT and IBM-FRS could prove helpful as outcome measures in future therapeutic trials in IBM.

Targeting protein homeostasis in sporadic inclusion body myositis

Augmenting the heat shock response with arimoclomol ameliorates pathology in cellular and animal models of inclusion body myositis. Targeting protein dyshomeostasis in myopathy Sporadic inclusion body myositis (sIBM) is a debilitating adult myopathy that is difficult to treat. Although both inflammation and protein dyshomeostasis have been implicated in sIBM pathogenesis, treatments have only targeted the inflammatory component, and all have failed in clinical trials. In a new study, Ahmed et al. tested the effects of targeting protein dyshomeostasis using arimoclomol, a co-inducer of the heat shock response. In rat myoblast cell culture, arimoclomol reduced key pathological features of IBM. In mutant valosin-containing protein (VCP) mice, which develop an inclusion body myopathy, treatment with arimoclomol ameliorated disease pathology and improved muscle function. The authors then treated a small number of sIBM patients with arimoclomol and showed that it was safe and well tolerated. Sporadic inclusion body myositis (sIBM) is the commonest severe myopathy in patients more than 50 years of age. Previous therapeutic trials have targeted the inflammatory features of sIBM but all have failed. Because protein dyshomeostasis may also play a role in sIBM, we tested the effects of targeting this feature of the disease. Using rat myoblast cultures, we found that up-regulation of the heat shock response with arimoclomol reduced key pathological markers of sIBM in vitro. Furthermore, in mutant valosin-containing protein (VCP) mice, which develop an inclusion body myopathy, treatment with arimoclomol ameliorated disease pathology and improved muscle function. We therefore evaluated arimoclomol in an investigator-led, randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled, proof-of-concept trial in sIBM patients and showed that arimoclomol was safe and well tolerated. Although arimoclomol improved some IBM-like pathology in the mutant VCP mouse, we did not see statistically significant evidence of efficacy in the proof-of-concept patient trial.

Update in inclusion body myositis.

Purpose of reviewThe purpose of this study is to review recent scientific advances relating to the natural history, cause, treatment and serum and imaging biomarkers of inclusion body myositis (IBM). Recent findingsSeveral theories regarding the aetiopathogenesis of IBM are being explored and new therapeutic approaches are being investigated. New diagnostic criteria have been proposed, reflecting the knowledge that the diagnostic pathological findings may be absent in patients with clinically typical IBM. The role of MRI in IBM is expanding and knowledge about pathological biomarkers is increasing. The recent description of autoantibodies to cytosolic 5′ nucleotidase 1A in patients with IBM is a potentially important advance that may aid early diagnosis and provides new evidence regarding the role of autoimmunity in IBM. SummaryIBM remains an enigmatic and often misdiagnosed disease. The pathogenesis of the disease is still not fully understood. To date, pharmacological treatment trials have failed to show clear efficacy. Future research should continue to focus on improving understanding of the pathophysiological mechanisms of the disease and on the identification of reliable and sensitive outcome measures for clinical trials. IBM is a rare disease and international multicentre collaboration for trials is important to translate research advances into improved patient outcomes.

Widespread RNA metabolism impairment in sporadic inclusion body myositis TDP43-proteinopathy.

TDP43 protein mislocalization is a hallmark of the neurodegenerative diseases amyotrophic lateral sclerosis and frontotemporal dementia, and mutations in the gene encoding TDP43 cause both disorders, further highlighting its role in disease pathogenesis. TDP43 is a heterogenous ribonucleoprotein, therefore suggesting that alterations in RNA metabolism play a role in these disorders, although direct evidence in patients is lacking. Sporadic inclusion body myositis (sIBM) is the most common acquired myopathy occurring in adults aged older than 50 years and abnormal cytoplasmic accumulations of TDP43 have been consistently described in sIBM myofibers. Here, we exploit high quality RNA from frozen sIBM muscle biopsies for transcriptomic studies on TDP43-proteinopathy patient tissue. Surprisingly, we found widespread sIBM-specific changes in the RNA metabolism pathways themselves. Consistent with this finding, we describe novel RNA binding proteins to mislocalize in the cytoplasm of sIBM myofibers and splicing changes in MAPT, a gene previously shown to play a role in sIBM. Our data indicate widespread alterations of RNA metabolism are a novel aspect of disease pathogenesis in sIBM. These findings also document an association, in TDP43-proteinopathy patients, between heterogenous ribonucleoprotein pathology and RNA metabolism alterations and carry importance for neurodegenerative diseases, such as amyotrophic lateral sclerosis and frontotemporal dementia.

Rare variants in SQSTM1 and VCP genes and risk of sporadic inclusion body myositis

Genetic factors have been suggested to be involved in the pathogenesis of sporadic inclusion body myositis (sIBM). Sequestosome 1 (SQSTM1) and valosin-containing protein (VCP) are 2 key genes associated with several neurodegenerative disorders but have yet to be thoroughly investigated in sIBM. A candidate gene analysis was conducted using whole-exome sequencing data from 181 sIBM patients, and whole-transcriptome expression analysis was performed in patients with genetic variants of interest. We identified 6 rare missense variants in the SQSTM1 and VCP in 7 sIBM patients (4.0%). Two variants, the SQSTM1 p.G194R and the VCP p.R159C, were significantly overrepresented in this sIBM cohort compared with controls. Five of these variants had been previously reported in patients with degenerative diseases. The messenger RNA levels of major histocompatibility complex genes were upregulated, this elevation being more pronounced in SQSTM1 patient group. We report for the first time potentially pathogenic SQSTM1 variants and expand the spectrum of VCP variants in sIBM. These data suggest that defects in neurodegenerative pathways may confer genetic susceptibility to sIBM and reinforce the mechanistic overlap in these neurodegenerative disorders.

LB0002 Safety and Tolerability of Arimoclomol in Patients with Sporadic Inclusion Body Myositis: A Randomised, Double-Blind, Placebo-Controlled, Phase IIa Proof-of-Concept Trial

Background Sporadic inclusion body myositis (IBM) is the commonest idiopathic inflammatory myopathy occurring in patients over the age of 50 years. IBM muscle displays inflammatory and degenerative features. Previous trials have only involved agents directed purely at the inflammatory component of IBM pathology and all were ineffective. Modulating the cytoprotective “heat shock response” (HSR) represents a therapeutic strategy through which the detrimental aspects of both inflammation and degeneration could be dampened. Arimoclomol is an orally administered pharmacological agent that can up-regulate the HSR by amplifying heat shock protein (HSP) expression. Objectives To evaluate the safety and tolerability of arimoclomol in IBM and to gather exploratory efficacy data of arimoclomol in IBM. Methods In this double-blind, placebo-controlled, two-centre (London, UK and Kansas, USA), phase IIa study, 24 patients with IBM were randomised to arimoclomol 100mg TID or placebo (2:1 ratio) over 4 months (as mandated by the FDA), followed by an 8 month follow up period. The primary outcome was adverse event reporting (safety and tolerability). Measures of physical function (IBM functional rating scale (IBMFRS)), muscle strength (manual muscle testing (MMT) and maximum isometric contraction testing (MVICT)) and fat-free mass percentage (measured by dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (DEXA)) were included as secondary outcome measures. HSP70 levels in muscle biopsy tissue (adjusted to myosin content) before and after the treatment phase were also measured. Mann-Whitney U test was used to compare changes in the arimoclomol and placebo groups at 4 months (IBMFRS, MMT, MVICT, DEXA and HSP70), 8 months (IBMFRS, MMT and MVICT) and 12 months (IBMFRS, MMT, MVICT and DEXA). Results We enrolled 17 men and 7women with a mean age of 66.8±7.5 years and mean disease duration of 8.4±4.3 years. All patients fulfilled the Griggs criteria for definite (42%) or probable (58%) IBM. One serious adverse event was observed in the arimoclomol group (hypertension requiring prolonged hospitalization on the day of the first biopsy). One arimoclomol recipient developed transient hyponatremia. Ophthalmologic examination did not reveal any significant ocular morbidity. Overall, the safety and tolerability profiles were similar between groups. At 8 months, we detected a trend of slower decline in the IBMFRS (-0.68±1.58 vs -2.50±3.31, p=0.055), average MMT (-0.12±0.22 vs -0.26±0.27, p=0.147) and MVICT of right hand grip (1.26±2.63 vs -0.54±1.86, p=0.064) of the arimoclomol group but no differences were seen for changes in the other MVICT scores (left hand grip, left and right quadriceps, and total sum score), DEXA fat free mass percentage and HSP70 levels in the muscle tissue. Conclusions Arimoclomol was safe and well tolerated and demonstrated a preliminary signal for potential therapeutic benefit in patients with IBM. These data support further research of arimoclomol in IBM. Acknowledgements This investigator-initiated trial was funded by Arthritis Research UK, Kansas University Neurology Ziegler Grant and Kansas University General Clinical Research Centre CReFF Grant. Disclosure of Interest None Declared

The effects of an intronic polymorphism in TOMM40 and APOE genotypes in sporadic inclusion body myositis

A previous study showed that, in carriers of the apolipoprotein E (APOE) genotype ε3/ε3 or ε3/ε4, the presence of a very long (VL) polyT repeat allele in “translocase of outer mitochondrial membrane 40” (TOMM40) was less frequent in patients with sporadic inclusion body myositis (sIBM) compared with controls and associated with a later age of sIBM symptom onset, suggesting a protective effect of this haplotype. To further investigate the influence of these genetic factors in sIBM, we analyzed a large sIBM cohort of 158 cases as part of an International sIBM Genetics Study. No significant association was found between APOE or TOMM40 genotypes and the risk of developing sIBM. We found that the presence of at least 1 VL polyT repeat allele in TOMM40 was significantly associated with about 4 years later onset of sIBM symptoms. The age of onset was delayed by 5 years when the patients were also carriers of the APOE genotype ε3/ε3. In addition, males were likely to have a later age of onset than females. Therefore, the TOMM40 VL polyT repeat, although not influencing disease susceptibility, has a disease-modifying effect on sIBM, which can be enhanced by the APOE genotype ε3/ε3.