Stephen Cummings

Universal Surfactant for Water, Oils, and CO2

A trichain anionic surfactant sodium 1,4-bis(neopentyloxy)-3-(neopentyloxycarbonyl)-1,4-dioxobutane-2-sulfonate (TC14) is shown to aggregate in three different types of solvent: water, heptane, and liquid CO(2). Small-angle neutron scattering (SANS) has been used to characterize the surfactant aggregates in water, heptane, and dense CO(2). Surface tension measurements, and analyses, show that the addition of a third branched chain to the surfactant structural template is critical for sufficiently lowering the surface energy, tipping the balance between a CO(2)-incompatible surfactant (AOT) and CO(2)-philic compounds that will aggregate to form micelles in dense CO(2) (TC14). These results highlight TC14 as one of the most adaptable and useful surfactants discovered to date, being compatible with a wide range of solvent types from high dielectric polar solvent water to alkanes with low dielectrics and even being active in the uncooperative and challenging solvent environment of liquid CO(2).

Tri‐Chain Hydrocarbon Surfactants as Designed Micellar Modifiers for Supercritical CO2

Getting their feet wet: Low-cost hydrocarbon surfactants act as fluid modifiers for supercritical carbon dioxide (scCO(2)). Increased terminal branching of the surfactant chains aids micelle formation (see middle picture: CO(2) green), and more chains allows water to be incorporated (right, blue).

Super-Efficient Surfactant for Stabilizing Water-in-Carbon Dioxide Microemulsions

The fluorinated double-tailed glutarate anionic surfactant, sodium 1,5-bis[(1H,1H,2H,2H-perfluorodecyl)oxy]-1,5-dioxopentane-2-sulfonate (8FG(EO)(2)), was found to stabilize water-in-supercritical CO(2) microemulsions with high water-to-surfactant molar ratios (W(0)). Studies were carried out here to obtain detailed information on the phase stability and nanostructure of the microemulsions by using a high-pressure UV-vis dye probe and small-angle neutron scattering (SANS) measurements. The UV-vis spectra, with methyl orange as a reporter dye, indicated a maximum attainable W(0) of 60 at 45 and 75 °C, and SANS profiles indicated regular droplet swelling with a linear relationship between the water core nanodroplet radius and W(0). This represents the highest water solubilization reported to date for any water-in-CO(2) microemulsion. Further analysis of the SANS data indicated critical packing parameters for 8FG(EO)(2) at the microemulsion interface >1.34, representing approximately 1.1 times the value for common aerosol-OT in water-in-heptane microemulsions under equivalent conditions.

Low Fluorine Content CO2-philic Surfactants

The article addresses an important, and still unresolved question in the field of CO(2) science and technology: what is the minimum fluorine content necessary to obtain a CO(2)-philic surfactant? A previous publication (Langmuir 2002, 18, 3014) suggested there should be an ideal fluorination level: for optimization of possible process applications in CO(2), it is important to establish just how little F is needed to render a surfactant CO(2)-philic. Here, optimum chemical structures for water-in-CO(2) (w/c) microemulsion stabilization are identified through a systematic study of CO(2)-philic surfactant design based on dichain sulfosuccinates. High pressure small-angle neutron scattering (HP-SANS) measurements of reversed micelle formation in CO(2) show a clear relationship between F content and CO(2) compatibility of any given surfactant. Interestingly, high F content surfactants, having lower limiting aqueous surface tensions, γ(cmc), also have better performance in CO(2), as indicated by lower cloud point pressures, P(trans). The results have important implications for the rational design of CO(2)-philic surfactants helping to identify the most economic and efficient compounds for emerging CO(2) based fluid technologies.

Amphiphiles for supercritical CO2.

A semi-fluorinated hybrid amphiphile, pentadecafluoro-5-dodecyl (F7H4) sulfate, has been shown to form reversed micelles in dense CO(2); the aggregates evolve to form water-in-CO(2) (w/c) microemulsion droplets on addition of water. Aggregation structures in these w/c phases have been characterised by small-angle neutron scattering (SANS), showing the presence of cylindrical droplets, which change into dispersed lamellar phases at even higher water loadings. Other systems are also introduced, being high internal phase emulsions (HIPEs) with brine, and liquid and supercritical CO(2), stabilized by certain commercially available nonylphenol ethoxylates (Dow Tergitol NP-, and Huntsman Surfonic N- amphiphiles). These dispersions have been characterised by SANS for the first time. Quantitative analyses of the HIPEs SANS profiles show that they behave similarly to hydrocarbon-water emulsion analogues, with regard to total interfacial areas and the effects of amphiphile concentration on the underlying structures. Finally, the advantages and disadvantages of both approaches for controlling the physico-chemical properties of liquid/supercritical CO(2) in potential applications are compared and contrasted. These results highlight the importance of using specially designed CO(2)-philic amphiphiles for generating self-assembly structures in dense CO(2).

Design principles for supercritical CO2 viscosifiers

This work reveals new principles for designing new self-assembling additives as viscosity enhancers for supercritical fluid CO2. Employing the approaches outlined in this work a maximum increase in CO2 viscosity of 100% has been achieved, the highest ever reported for surfactant CO2 viscosifiers. A series of semi-fluorinated F–H hybrid surfactants were synthesised based on the pentadecafluoro-5-dodecyl (F7H4) sulfate anion, but featuring different metallic counterions: Li-F7H4, K-F7H4, Na-F7H4 and Rb-F7H4 (denoted M-F7H4). These M-F7H4 variants were designed to reveal the effects of hydrated cation radius (rhyd) on packing self-assembly in supercritical CO2 (scCO2). The CO2-philic M-F7H4 surfactants were investigated at the air–water interface by surface tensiometry, and in the bulk by small-angle neutron scattering (SANS), in both aqueous solutions and scCO2. Surface tensiometry of aqueous solutions showed that interfacial packing density and limiting head group area at the critical micelle concentration (Acmc), depends implicitly on the identity of M+, suggesting that micelles in water or scCO2 should have different geometric packing parameters (PlimC) as a function of M+. SANS measurements on M-F7H4 aqueous micellar solutions confirmed sphere → ellipsoid → vesicle transitions as a function of M+ with decreasing rhyd. Using high pressure SANS (HP-SANS), and changing solvent from water to scCO2 showed that all the M-F7H4 variants stabilise water-in-CO2 (w/c) microemulsion droplets on addition of water. In scCO2 Li-F7H4 forms prolate ellipsoidal droplets, Na-F7H4 forms long cylindrical droplets, K-F7H4 forms ellipsoidal droplets, whereas Rb-F7H4 stabilises spherical microemulsion droplets. The ability of M-F7H4 additives to enhance the viscosity of scCO2 was shown by high pressure falling cylinder viscometry. The HP-SANS and viscometry experiments were shown to be quantitatively consistent, in that aggregate aspect ratios (X) determined in structural studies account for the enhanced relative viscosities (ηmic/ηCO2).

Effective and Efficient Surfactant for CO2 Having Only Short Fluorocarbon Chains

A previous study (Langmuir2011, 27, 5772) found the fluorinated double-tail sulfogulutarate 8FG(EO)(2) to act as a superefficient solubilizer for water in supercritical CO(2) (W/CO(2)) microemulsions. To explore more economic CO(2)-philic surfactants with high solubilizing power as well as rapid solubilization rates, the effects of fluorocarbon chain length and linking group were examined with sodium 1,5-bis(1H,1H,2H,2H-perfluoroalkyloxy)-1,5-dioxopentane-2-sulfonates (nFG(EO)(2), fluorocarbon chain length n = 4, 6, 8) and sodium 1,4-bis(1H,1H,2H,2H-perfluoroalkyloxy)-1,4-dioxobutane-2-sulfonate (nFS(EO)(2), n = 4, 8). Visual observation and UV-vis spectral measurements with methyl orange as a reporter dye indicated a maximum water-to-surfactant molar ratio (W(0)) in the microemulsions, which was 60-80 for nFG(EO)(2) and 40-50 for nFG(EO)(2). Although it is normally expected that high solubilizing power requires long fluorocarbon surfactant chains, the shortest fluorocarbon 4FG(EO)(2) interestingly achieved the highest W(0) (80) transparent single-phase W/CO(2) microemulsion. In addition, a very rapid solubilization of loaded water into CO(2) was observed for 4FG(EO)(2) even at a high W(0) of ~80.

Hydrocarbon Metallosurfactants for CO2

Cobalt and nickel salts of the highly branched trichain anionic surfactant sodium 1,4-bis(neopentyloxy)-3-(neopentyloxycarbonyl)-1,4-dioxobutane-2-sulfonate (TC14) are shown to be soluble in dense CO(2) at concentrations up to 6 wt % at 500 bar pressure. This is a remarkably high solubility for such hydrocarbon transition metal surfactants in CO(2). High-pressure small-angle neutron scattering (HP-SANS) has been used to study the surfactant aggregates in a normal organic solvent, cyclohexane, dense CO(2), and also mixtures of these two pure solvents. The results show that transition metal TC14 derivatives are viable compounds for incorporating reactive and functional metal ions into CO(2).

Nanostructures in Water-in-CO2 Microemulsions Stabilized by Double-Chain Fluorocarbon Solubilizers

High-pressure small-angle neutron scattering (HP-SANS) studies were conducted to investigate nanostructures and interfacial properties of water-in-supercritical CO2 (W/CO2) microemulsions with double-fluorocarbon-tail anionic surfactants, having different fluorocarbon chain lengths and linking groups (glutarate or succinate). At constant pressure and temperature, the microemulsion aqueous cores were found to swell with an increase in water-to-surfactant ratio, W0, until their solubilizing capacities were reached. Surfactants with fluorocarbon chain lengths of n = 4, 6, and 8 formed spherical reversed micelles in supercritical CO2 even at W0 over the solubilizing powers as determined by phase behavior studies, suggesting formation of Winsor-IV W/CO2 microemulsions and then Winsor-II W/CO2 microemulsions. On the other hand, a short C2 chain fluorocarbon surfactant analogue displayed a transition from Winsor-IV microemulsions to lamellar liquid crystals at W0 = 25. Critical packing parameters and aggregation numbers were calculated by using area per headgroup, shell thickness, the core/shell radii determined from SANS data analysis: these parameters were used to help understand differences in aggregation behavior and solubilizing power in CO2. Increasing the microemulsion water loading led the critical packing parameter to decrease to ~1.3 and the aggregation number to increase to >90. Although these parameters were comparable between glutarate and succinate surfactants with the same fluorocarbon chain, decreasing the fluorocarbon chain length n reduced the critical packing parameter. At the same time, reducing chain length to 2 reduced negative interfacial curvature, favoring planar structures, as demonstrated by generation of lamellar liquid crystal phases.