T. Webb

Population prevalence and estimated birth incidence and mortality rate for people with Prader-Willi syndrome in one UK Health Region

Editor—Prader-Willi syndrome (PWS) is a genetically determined disorder in which the absence of expression of one or more maternally imprinted gene(s) in the chromosomal region 15q11-13 results in a characteristic facial appearance, learning disabilities (mental retardation), and severe overeating behaviour owing to an abnormal satiety response to food intake, together with a range of other behaviours. Initially, as reported by Prader et al ,1 PWS was conceived as a syndrome of obesity, short growth, cryptorchidism, and mental retardation following hypotonia in the neonatal period. As more and more people with PWS were reported and research into the syndrome began, behavioural characteristics and other clinical features were added, culminating in the consensus diagnostic criteria.2Concurrently, the genetics of the disorder were receiving attention. First was the discovery that for many there was a visible chromosomal deletion in the proximal part of the long arm of chromosome 15 (15q11-13). Reports of an apparently similar deletion being associated with a phenotypically very different syndrome (Angelman syndrome, AS),3 and the observation that PWS was the result of a deletion on the chromosome 15 of paternal origin, and AS the chromosome 15 of maternal origin, led to the recognition that gender specific imprinting of genes at that locus accounted for two diverse syndromes being associated with apparently similar chromosomal deletions.4 Maternal chromosome 15 disomies, mutations of an imprinting centre, and chromosomal translocations accounted for non-deletion cases of PWS.5 In published reports on Prader-Willi syndrome (PWS), prevalence has been variously quoted as “about 1 in 25 000 live births”,6 “between one in 25 000 and one in 10 000 live born children”,7 “[estimates] vary 6-fold from 1 in 5000 to 10 000; 1 in 10 000; 1 in 15 000; 1 in 25 000; to 1 in 10 000 to 30 000”.8 Only two estimates …

Uniparental paternal disomy in Angelman's syndrome

Angelmans syndrome and Prader-Willi syndrome are both causes of mental retardation with recognisable, but quite different, clinical phenotypes. Both are associated with deletions of chromosome 15q11-13, of maternal origin in Angelmans and paternal in Prader-Willi. Prader-Willi can arise by inheritance of two chromosomes 15 from the mother and none from the father (uniparental maternal disomy). In 2 patients with Angelmans syndrome we found evidence of uniparental paternal disomy. The phenotypic effects of maternal and paternal disomy of chromosome 15 are very different and inheritance of two normal 15s from one parent does not lead to normal development--strong evidence in man for genomic imprinting, in which the same gene has different effects dependent upon its parental origin.

Psychotic illness in people with Prader Willi syndrome due to chromosome 15 maternal uniparental disomy

In a population-based study of Prader Willi syndrome (PWS), we investigated the relation between genetic subtypes of the syndrome and psychiatric morbidity. Of 25 patients aged 18 years or older, seven (28%) had severe affective disorder with psychotic features, with a mean age of onset of 26 years (SD 5.9). The seven people affected, all aged 28 years or older, included all five with disomies of chromosome 15, one with a deletion in this chromosome, and one with an imprinting centre mutation in the same chromosome. We postulate that in PWS, an abnormal pattern of expression of a sex-specific imprinted gene on chromosome 15 is associated with psychotic illness in early adult life.

Prevalence of, and risk factors for, physical ill‐health in people with Prader‐Willi syndrome: a population‐based study

The medical findings from a population-based study of Prader-Willi syndrome (PWS) are discussed (in which birth incidence of PWS was estimated at 1:22,000 and death rate at over 3% per annum). In this study the prevalence of specific medical disorders that might account for a shortened life expectancy were investigated. Of all people with a possible diagnosis of PWS, only those meeting clinical criteria and/or with a confirmed genetic diagnosis were included in the study. Sixty-six individuals, 40 males and 26 females with a mean age of 19 years (range of 0 to 46 years) agreed to participate in the population-based study group. A prevalence rate of 25% for non-insulin dependent diabetes mellitus (NIDDM) was found in adults. Mean age at onset was 20 years. Those with NIDDM had a higher past maximum body weight and a greater likelihood of positive family history. Nearly 50% across the age groups reported a history of recurrent respiratory infections. High rates of fractures (29%), leg ulceration (22% in adults), sleep disorders (20%), and severe scoliosis (15% in childhood) were also reported. It is postulated that hypotonia is a possible contributory factor to the risk of strabismus, scoliosis, and respiratory infections. Other causes of morbidity, in particular the high rates of NIDDM, may be due to a failure to manage over-eating resulting in severe obesity. Early diagnosis and clear guidance to families about these risks and how they might be prevented is recommended. It is hypothesized that the high pain threshold may result in the presence of some illness not being apparent.

Molecular mechanisms in Angelman syndrome: a survey of 93 patients.

Angelman syndrome (AS) results from a lack of maternal contribution from chromosome 15q11-13, arising from de novo deletion in most cases or rarely from uniparental disomy. These families are associated with a low recurrence risk. However, in a minority of families, more than one child is affected. No deletion has been found in these families, except one. The mode of inheritance in these families is autosomal dominant modified by imprinting. Sporadic cases, with no observable deletion, therefore pose a counselling dilemma as there could be a recurrence risk as high as 50%. We present a series of 93 AS patients, showing the relative contribution of these different genetic mechanisms. Eighty-one AS patients were sporadic cases while 12 cases came from six families. Sixty cases had deletions in 15q11-13 detected by a set of highly polymorphic (CA)n repeats markers and conventional RFLPs. Ten sporadic cases plus all 12 familial cases had no detectable deletion. In addition, two cases of de novo deletions occurred in a chromosome 15 carrying a pericentric inversion. In one of these the AS child had a cousin with Prader-Willi syndrome (PWS) arising from a de novo deletion in an inv(15) inherited from his father. One case arose from a maternal balanced t(9;15)(p24;q15) translocation. There were three cases of uniparental disomy. Five patients were monoallelic for all loci across the minimal AS critical region, but the presence of a deletion cannot be confirmed. In familial cases, all affected sibs inherited the same maternal chromosome 15 markers for the region 15q11-13. Two cases were observed with a de novo deletion starting close to the locus D15S11 (IR4-2R), providing evidence for the development of classical AS with smaller deletions. Cytogenetic analysis proved limited in its ability to detect deletions, detecting only 42 out of 60 cases. However, cytogenetic analysis is still essential to detect chromosomal abnormalities other than deletions such as inversions and balanced translocations since both have an increased risk for deletions. A staged diagnostic strategy based on the use of highly informative (CA)n repeat markers is proposed.

Duplication of chromosome 15 in the region 15q11-13 in a patient with developmental delay and ataxia with similarities to Angelman syndrome.

Duplications of the proximal long arm of chromosome 15 have been seen in the Prader-Willi syndrome (PWS), and in subjects without the Prader-Willi phenotype but with other clinical features including short stature, diabetes, anal and jejunal atresia, and acanthosis nigricans. The non-PWS subjects all had different phenotypes despite the identical findings on cytogenetic analysis. A normal phenotype has also been observed in patients with similar duplications. We report a further patient with a duplication of 15q11-13 which was detected cytogenetically and confirmed on molecular genetic analysis. She has developmental delay, particularly concerning the acquisition of speech, and an ataxic gait. These are interesting clinical features in view of the association of Angelman syndrome with abnormalities of 15q11-13.

Relationship between clinical and genetic diagnosis of Prader-Willi syndrome

A s part of a population based study of Prader-Willi syndrome (PWS), we have examined more closely the relationship between clinical and genetic diagnoses in a large number of people with established or suspected PWS. We report here on agreements and disagreements between clinical and genetic diagnoses. We consider whether a genetic diagnosis implies the presence of any one (or more) of the major, minor, or supportive diagnostic criteria, and also whether the presence of any one (or more) particular diagnostic criteria1 implies a positive genetic finding, and what minimal genetic findings correspond to a positive finding on the basis of the clinical diagnostic criteria. In this paper, we also report on four specific cases that illustrate diagnostic difficulties. An early diagnosis of PWS is of particular importance as the propensity to overeat can start as early as 2 years of age, and parental control of access to food can prevent the development of life threatening obesity. As part of this study, we have found high rates of physical morbidity and mortality that are likely to be preventable if weight is adequately controlled.2,3 Initially, as reported by Prader et al ,4 PWS was conceptualised as a syndrome of obesity, short stature, cryptorchidism, and mental retardation following severe hypotonia in the neonatal period (decreased activity in utero, “floppy” at birth, marked feeding difficulties). With increasing clinical experience and research studies, behavioural characteristics such as hyperphagia, outbursts of temper, obsessional traits, and stubbornness, and clinical features such as central adiposity, sleep disorders, abnormalities of temperature and pain perception were added, culminating in the Consensus Diagnostic Criteria.1 A weighted score of 8 or more for ages >3 (5 or more for ages <4), based on the presence of eight major (score 1) and 11 minor (score 0.5) symptoms, …

A study of the influence of different genotypes on the physical and behavioral phenotypes of children and adults ascertained clinically as having PWS

A population‐based cohort of people with a clinical diagnosis of Prader–Willi syndrome (PWS) was genetically assessed using molecular diagnostic methods and subsequently divided into the following genetic subtypes involving chromosome 15: ‘deletion’, ‘disomy’ and genetically negative (referred to as ‘PWS‐like’). The physical and behavioral characteristics of the three groups were compared in order to evaluate the unique characteristics of the phenotype resulting from loss of expression of imprinted genes at 15q11q13 (PWS vs. PWS‐like cases), the possible effect of either haploid insufficiency of non‐imprinted genes (deletion cases), or gain of function of imprinted genes (disomy cases) located within the PWS critical region at 15q11q13. In this study, the main differences between probands with either a deletion or disomy are considered, and the possible involvement of contributing genes discussed. The differences within the PWS group proved difficult to quantify. It would appear that haploid insufficiency or gain of function are more subtle contributors than gender‐specific genomic imprinting in the production of the PWS phenotype.

Frequency and replication status of the fragile X, fra(X)(q27-28), in a pair of monozygotic twins of markedly differing intelligence.

Chromosome analysis using conventional staining, G banding, and, after BUdR incorporation, two R banding methods, one using Hoechst and one acridine orange, were performed on lymphocytes from a pair of female monozygotic twins. The culture conditions were designed to show the presence of the fragile X (q27-28) which had previously been found to be segregating in the family. One twin was of higher than normal intelligence and the other had been diagnosed as mentally retarded. The frequency of the occurrence of the early/active fragile X compared to the overall total of informative fragile X was determined using both methods described above and was also compared with previous published data in the form of a graph showing percentage of early/active fragile X against intelligence.

In Search of the Psychosis Gene in People With Prader-Willi Syndrome

The two main causes of Prader‐Willi syndrome (PWS) are a paternally derived deletion in the maternally imprinted 15q11–q13 region or UPD(15)mat. Both mechanisms result in a loss of the active paternal contribution to the region. The affective psychosis associated with PWS has been found to be mainly confined to the propositi with UPD(15)mat rather than to those with a deletion. This suggests that the psychosis may be related to the presence of two copies rather than a single copy of a gene or genes located in the distal half of the region which is paternally imprinted, but maternally active, and whose loss results in Angelman syndrome (AS). A large population‐based study of PWS allowed the identification of 12 people with a 15q11–q13 deletion who had suffered psychotic episodes and four adults with UPD(15)mat who so far had not. When these people were investigated using microsatellite markers, the 12 with a deletion were found to have two maternally derived copies of a narrow region between D15S975 and D15S661 making them effectively disomic for these loci. Thus all of the people with psychosis had two active copies of any imprinted genes in the region while all non‐psychotic people (including controls) had only one. Quantitative RT‐PCR studies suggest that a lack of expression of FLJ33332, either as a result of or resulting in gene dysregulation, may be associated with psychosis in PWS.