Terrence G. Frey

The internal structure of mitochondria.

Electron microscopic (EM) tomography is providing important new insights into the internal organization of mitochondria. The standard baffle model for cristae structure, called into question years ago, has now clearly been shown to be inaccurate. Depending on source and conformational state, cristae can vary from simple tubular structures to more complex lamellar structures merging with the inner boundary membrane through tubular structures 28 nm in diameter. The structural information provided by EM tomography has important implications for mitochondrial bioenergetics, biogenesis and the role of mitochondria in apoptosis. The structural paradigm defined by EM tomography is helping in the design of new experimental approaches to mitochondrial function.

Mitofusins and OPA1 Mediate Sequential Steps in Mitochondrial Membrane Fusion

Mitochondrial fusion requires the coordinated fusion of the outer and inner membranes. Three large GTPases--OPA1 and the mitofusins Mfn1 and Mfn2--are essential for the fusion of mammalian mitochondria. OPA1 is mutated in dominant optic atrophy, a neurodegenerative disease of the optic nerve. In yeast, the OPA1 ortholog Mgm1 is required for inner membrane fusion in vitro; nevertheless, yeast lacking Mgm1 show neither outer nor inner membrane fusion in vivo, because of the tight coupling between these two processes. We find that outer membrane fusion can be readily visualized in OPA1-null mouse cells in vivo, but these events do not progress to inner membrane fusion. Similar defects are found in cells lacking prohibitins, which are required for proper OPA1 processing. In contrast, double Mfn-null cells show neither outer nor inner membrane fusion. Mitochondria in OPA1-null cells often contain multiple matrix compartments bounded together by a single outer membrane, consistent with uncoupling of outer versus inner membrane fusion. In addition, unlike mitofusins and yeast Mgm1, OPA1 is not required on adjacent mitochondria to mediate membrane fusion. These results indicate that mammalian mitofusins and OPA1 mediate distinct sequential fusion steps that are readily uncoupled, in contrast to the situation in yeast.

Correlated three-dimensional light and electron microscopy reveals transformation of mitochondria during apoptosis

In addition to their role in cellular bioenergetics, mitochondria also initiate common forms of programmed cell death (apoptosis) through the release of proteins such as cytochrome c from the intermembrane and intracristal spaces. The release of these proteins is studied in populations of cells by western blotting mitochondrial and cytoplasmic fractions of cellular extracts, and in single cells by fluorescence microscopy using fluorescent indicators and fusion proteins. However, studying the changes in ultrastructure associated with release of proteins requires the higher resolution provided by transmission electron microscopy. Here, we have used fluorescence microscopy to characterize the state of apoptosis in HeLa cells treated with etoposide followed by electron microscopy and three-dimensional electron microscope tomography of the identical cells to study the sequence of structural changes. We have identified a remodelling of the inner mitochondrial membrane into many separate vesicular matrix compartments that accompanies release of proteins; however, this remodelling is not required for efficient release of cytochrome c. Swelling occurs only late in apoptosis after release of cytochrome c and loss of the mitochondrial membrane potential.

Insight into mitochondrial structure and function from electron tomography.

In recent years, electron tomography has provided detailed three-dimensional models of mitochondria that have redefined our concept of mitochondrial structure. The models reveal an inner membrane consisting of two components, the inner boundary membrane (IBM) closely apposed to the outer membrane and the cristae membrane that projects into the matrix compartment. These two components are connected by tubular structures of relatively uniform size called crista junctions. The distribution of crista junction sizes and shapes is predicted by a thermodynamic model based upon the energy of membrane bending, but proteins likely also play a role in determining the conformation of the inner membrane. Results of structural studies of mitochondria during apoptosis demonstrate that cytochrome c is released without detectable disruption of the outer membrane or extensive swelling of the mitochondrial matrix, suggesting the formation of an outer membrane pore large enough to allow passage of holo-cytochrome c. The possible compartmentation of inner membrane function between the IBM and the cristae membrane is also discussed.

Streptolysin O Promotes Group A Streptococcus Immune Evasion by Accelerated Macrophage Apoptosis

Group A Streptococcus (GAS) is a leading human bacterial pathogen capable of producing invasive infections even in previously healthy individuals. As frontline components of host innate defense, macrophages play a key role in control and clearance of GAS infections. We find GAS induces rapid, dose-dependent apoptosis of primary and cultured macrophages and neutrophils. The cell death pathway involves apoptotic caspases, is partly dependent on caspase-1, and requires GAS internalization by the phagocyte. Analysis of GAS virulence factor mutants, heterologous expression, and purified toxin studies identified the pore-forming cytolysin streptolysin O (SLO) as necessary and sufficient for the apoptosis-inducing phenotype. SLO-deficient GAS mutants induced less macrophage apoptosis in vitro and in vivo, allowed macrophage cytokine secretion, and were less virulent in a murine systemic infection model. Ultrastructural evidence of mitochondrial membrane remodeling, coupled with loss of mitochondrial depolarization and cytochrome c release, suggests a direct attack of the toxin initiates the intrinsic apoptosis pathway. A general caspase inhibitor blocked SLO-induced apoptosis and enhanced macrophage killing of GAS. We conclude that accelerated, caspase-dependent macrophage apoptosis induced by the pore-forming cytolysin SLO contributes to GAS immune evasion and virulence.

Recent structural insight into mitochondria gained by microscopy.

Novel applications of microscopy have recently provided new insights into mitochondrial structures. Diverse techniques such as high resolution scanning electron microscopy, transmission electron microscopy, electron microscope tomography and light microscopy have contributed a better understanding of mitochondrial compartmentalization, dynamic networks of mitochondria, intermembrane bridges, segregation of mitochondrial DNA and contacts with the endoplasmic reticulum among other aspects. This review focuses on advances reported in the last five years concerning aspects of mitochondrial substructure or dynamics gained through new techniques, whether they be novel microscope methods or new ways to prepare or label specimens. Sometimes these advances have produced surprising results and more often than not, they have challenged current conceptions of how mitochondria work.

Electron Tomography of Mitochondria from Brown Adipocytes Reveals Crista Junctions

Electron microscope tomography was used to examine the membrane topology of brown adipose tissue (BAT) mitochondria prepared by cryofixation or chemical fixation techniques. These mitochondria contain an uncoupling protein which results in the conversion of energy from electron transport into heat. The three-dimensional reconstructions of BAT mitochondria provided a view of the inner mitochondrial membrane different in important features from descriptions found in the literature. The work reported here provides new insight into BAT mitochondria architecture by identifying crista junctions, including multiple junctions connecting a crista to the same side of the inner boundary membrane, in a class of mitochondria that have no tubular cristae, but only lamellar cristae. Crista junctions were defined previously as the tubular membranes of relatively uniform diameter that connect a crista membrane with the inner boundary membrane. We have also found that the cristae architecture of cryofixed mitochondria, including crista junctions, is similar to that found in chemically fixed mitochondria, suggesting that this architecture is not a fixation artifact. The stacks of lamellar cristae extended through more of the BAT mitochondrial volume than did the cristae we observed in neuronal mitochondria. Hence, the inner membrane surface area was larger in the former. In chemically fixed mitochondria, contact sites were easily visualized because the outer and inner boundary membranes were separated by an 8 nm space. However, in cryofixed mitochondria almost all the outer membrane was observed to be in close contact with the inner boundary membrane.

Membrane architecture of mitochondria in neurons of the central nervous system

Electron tomography was used to help redefine the membrane architecture of mitochondria in neurons of the brain. Investigations were conducted on unexplored questions of structural homogeneity between mitochondria in the four intensely studied regions of the brain and in the functionally distinct neuronal sub‐compartments. These mitochondria have the majority of cristae composed of both tubular and lamellar segments with the tubes arranged more peripherally and the lamellae more centrally located. Cristae that are entirely tubular were not commonly seen and those that are entirely lamellar were rare. It was determined that cristae connect through narrow, sometimes very long tubular regions to the peripheral surface of the inner membrane. A structurally distinct type of contact site was revealed in brain mitochondria, which we named the bridge contact site. These bridges may play a role in the structural integrity of the outer and inner membrane systems. It was found that the membrane architecture in the various brain regions and neuronal compartments was strikingly uniform, including consistently tubular crista junctions. The functional consequences of this junctional architecture are discussed in relation to the segregation of proteins between the inner boundary membrane and the cristae membranes, and in relation to the model of microcompartmentation of macromolecules inside cristae.

A thermodynamic model describing the nature of the crista junction: a structural motif in the mitochondrion

The use of electron tomography has allowed the three-dimensional membrane topography of the mitochondrion to be better understood. The most striking feature of this topology is the crista junction, a structure that may serve to divide functionally the inner membrane and intermembrane spaces. In situ these junctions seem to have a preferred size and shape independent of the source of the mitochondrion with few exceptions. When mitochondria are isolated and have a condensed matrix the crista junctions enlarge and become nondiscrete. Upon permeation of the inner membrane and subsequent swelling of the matrix space, the uniform circular nature of the crista junction reappears. We examine the distribution of shapes and sizes of crista junctions and suggest a thermodynamic model that explains the distribution based on current theories of bilayer membrane shapes. The theory of spontaneous curvature shows the circular junction to be a thermodynamically stable structure whose size and shape is influenced by the relative volume of the matrix. We conclude that the crista junction exists predominantly as a circular junction, with other shapes as exceptions made possible by specific characteristics of the lipid bilayer.

Electron cryo-microscopic analysis of crystalline cytochrome oxidase

The structure of cytochrome oxidase from beef heart mitochondria has been analysed by cryo-electron microscopy of vesicle crystals of the space group p22(1)2(1), with cell dimensions a = 102 A, b = 123 A, gamma = 90 degrees. Several methods of specimen preparation were applied to the vesicular two-dimensional crystals in the electron microscope, to ensure that the structure was preserved to the maximum resolution. The two most informative density maps were from specimens embedded in ice and from negative staining in a 1:1 mixture of glucose and uranyl acetate. The three-dimensional structure of the ice-embedded molecule shows a single, well resolved, but convoluted density, which represents in size and shape one cytochrome oxidase dimer. At the bottom of the molecule, a substantial part of the protein is embedded in the lipid bilayer of the vesicle. The molecule then extends upwards, out of the bilayer, into the internal space within the vesicle. Here, the structure first passes through a region within the molecule containing a hollow cavity that lies roughly at the centre of mass of the dimer, and then branches into two well-resolved halves at some distance from the membrane. The negatively stained structure, in contrast, shows a stain-excluding region in the centre of the vesicle at the level of the cavity in the ice-embedded structure, but otherwise has a similar overall external shape. In addition, there is a small rotation of the whole molecule by approximately 25 degrees relative to the orientation of ice-embedded specimens. We interpret these differences to mean that the central cavity seen in the ice-embedded structure is too small to allow the stain to penetrate during the drying process and that the drying process causes the rotation. The structures described here are consistent with one another and allow an interpretation at higher resolution than from previous work.