Tracey Edgell

Fresh versus frozen embryo transfer: backing clinical decisions with scientific and clinical evidence

BACKGROUND Improvements in vitrification now make frozen embryo transfers (FETs) a viable alternative to fresh embryo transfer, with reports from observational studies and randomized controlled trials suggesting that: (i) the endometrium in stimulated cycles is not optimally prepared for implantation; (ii) pregnancy rates are increased following FET and (iii) perinatal outcomes are less affected after FET. METHODS This review integrates and discusses the available clinical and scientific evidence supporting embryo transfer in a natural cycle. RESULTS Laboratory-based studies demonstrate morphological and molecular changes to the endometrium and reduced responsiveness of the endometrium to hCG, resulting from controlled ovarian stimulation. The literature demonstrates reduced endometrial receptivity in controlled ovarian stimulation cycles and supports the clinical observations that FET reduces the risk of ovarian hyperstimulation syndrome and improves outcomes for both the mother and baby. CONCLUSIONS This review provides the basis for an evidence-based approach towards changes in routine IVF, which may ultimately result in higher delivery rates of healthier term babies.

The Microenvironment of Human Implantation: Determinant of Reproductive Success.

Successful implantation requires synchronous development of embryo and endometrium. Endometrial receptivity results from progesterone‐induced differentiation of endometrial cells, generally achieved during the mid‐secretory phase of the cycle. Failure to properly develop receptivity results in failed or inadequate implantation and hence no ongoing pregnancy. The blastocyst undergoes final development, apposition, attachment and initiates invasion of the endometrial epithelium within the uterine cavity. Thus, the microenvironment provided by uterine fluid, particularly glandular secretions, is essential for implantation. Analysis of endometrial fluid has identified cytokines, chemokines, proteases, antiproteases and other factors that modulate blastocyst functions relevant to implantation. Exosomes/microvesicular bodies released from the endometrium (and likely also the embryo) are present in uterine fluid. These can transfer miRNA, proteins and lipids between cells, thus providing endometrial–embryo communication in the peri‐implantation period. Understanding the uterine microenvironment, and its effects on endometrial–embryo interactions, will provide opportunities to modify current infertility treatments to improve success rates.

Assessing receptivity in the endometrium: the need for a rapid, non-invasive test.

Successful implantation of an embryo into the uterus requires synchrony between the blastocyst and the endometrium. Endometrial preparedness, or receptivity, occurs only for a very short time during the mid-secretory phase of the menstrual cycle in fertile women. Failure to achieve receptivity results in infertility and is a rate-limiting step for IVF success. Frozen embryo transfer in non-stimulation cycles is already improving live birth rates. However, an important tool that is missing in the armoury of reproductive specialists is a means to rapidly assess endometrial receptivity, either during initial assessment or immediately prior to embryo transfer. The development of a wealth of omics technologies now opens the way for identifying potential receptivity markers, although validation of these is still a major issue. This review assesses the current state of the field and the requirements to proceed to a valid clinical test.

The proliferative phase underpins endometrial development: Altered cytokine profiles in uterine lavage fluid of women with idiopathic infertility

Endometrial gland development occurs during the proliferative phase of a womans menstrual cycle, laying the foundation for the subsequent receptive, secretory phase when pregnancy is established. Idiopathic infertility has been rarely investigated with respect to the proliferative phase endometrium. We investigated whether gland development and/or altered secretion of cytokines during the proliferative phase is associated with infertility. Area of the glandular epithelium (GE) was measured in proliferative phase endometrial tissue collected from fertile (n=18) and infertile (n=14) women. Cytokines were measured in proliferative phase uterine lavage of fertile (n=15) and infertile (n=15) women. Immunohistochemistry determined cellular localisation of transforming growth factor alpha (TGFα) and interferon gamma (IFNγ) in proliferative phase endometrial tissue. For statistical analysis the cohort was divided into women <35years and ⩾35years. There were no significant differences in GE area of infertile and fertile women. C-C motif chemokine 11 (P=0.048), TGFα (P=0.049), IFNγ (P=0.033) and interleukin-1 alpha (P=0.047) were significantly elevated in uterine lavage from infertile women <35years compared to fertile but not in women ⩾35years. TGFα and IFNγ localised predominantly to GE in both the fertile and infertile endometrium. The potential impact of this altered proliferative phase environment on subsequent receptivity is discussed.

Development of a high-throughput assay for human proprotein convertase 5/6 for detecting uterine receptivity.

Embryo implantation requires a healthy embryo and a receptive uterus. In women, the inner lining of the uterus, the endometrium, remains in a hostile state and becomes receptive for embryo implantation for only a short period during each menstrual cycle. Determining endometrial receptivity is vital in in vitro fertilization (IVF) treatment because the timing of embryo transfer needs to be synchronized with endometrial receptivity. We have previously demonstrated that proprotein convertase 5/6A (PC6) is highly expressed in the receptive endometrium and that PC6 is critical for receptivity establishment in women. Furthermore, endometrial PC6 is secreted into the uterine fluid, and levels correlate with receptivity status. Detection of PC6 in uterine fluids, therefore, would provide a nonsurgical assessment of endometrial receptivity. However, to date no assays are available for human PC6. In this study, we produced three PC6 monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) and developed a sandwich enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) for PC6 detection in human uterine fluids. The PC6 mAbs were confirmed to be highly specific to PC6, and the ELISA detected PC6 in human uterine fluids with a significantly higher level during the receptive phase. This newly established PC6 ELISA provides an important tool in the development of noninvasive strategies to detect endometrial receptivity in women.

Assessment of potential biomarkers of pre-receptive and receptive endometrium in uterine fluid and a functional evaluation of the potential role of CSF3 in fertility

Abstract The endometrium lines a women’s uterus becoming receptive, and allowing embryo implantation to occur, for just a few days during the post‐ovulatory mid‐secretory phase of each menstrual cycle. We investigated whether concentrations of proposed receptivity biomarkers (VEGF, IL8, FGF2, CSF3 sFlt‐1, sGP130 and PlGF) secreted by the endometrium into the uterine cavity and forming the microenvironment for embryo implantation is altered among a population of age‐matched women with unexplained (idiopathic) infertility compared to fertile women during the receptive mid‐secretory phase (n = 16 fertile, 18 infertile) and the prior pre‐receptive early secretory phase (n = 19 fertile, 18 infertile) of their cycle. In the mid‐secretory cohort significantly elevated concentrations of five biomarkers; PlGF (p = 0.001), IL8 (p = 0.004), sGP130 (p = 0.009), sFlt‐1 (p = 0.021), and CSF3 (p = 0.029) was present in uterine fluid of infertile women during the mid‐secretory phase, but only CSF3 was significantly elevated in the pre‐receptive early secretory phase (p = 0.006). In vitro studies of glycosylated and non‐glycosylated forms of CSF3 at representative fertile (20 ng/mL) and infertile (70 ng/mL) effects on endometrium and embryo behaviour were performed. Non‐glycosylated CSF3 at fertile concentrations significantly (p < 0.001) elevated endometrial epithelial cell proliferation however chronic treatment or elevated (infertile) concentrations of CSF3 in glycosylated form abrogated the positive effects. Both forms of CSF3 increased trophoblast cell invasion (p < 0.001) regardless of concentration. Mouse embryo outgrowth was significantly (p < 0.01) increased at fertile but not at infertile concentrations. The study confirmed potential utility of five biomarkers of endometrial receptivity for future application in the mid‐secretory phase while highlighting CSF3 is elevated in the earlier pre‐receptive phase. Our data provides evidence that CSF3 acts on both human endometrium and embryo in a manner that is concentration and glycosylation dependent.

Idiopathic infertility in women is associated with distinct changes in proliferative phase uterine fluid proteins

Abstract The regenerative, proliferative phase of a womans menstrual cycle is a critical period which lays the foundation for the subsequent, receptive secretory phase. Although endometrial glands and their secretions are essential for embryo implantation and survival, the proliferative phase, when these glands form, has been rarely examined. We hypothesized that alterations in the secreted proteome of the endometrium of idiopathic infertile women would reflect a disturbance in proliferative phase endometrial regeneration. Our aim was to compare the proteomic profile of proliferative phase uterine fluid from fertile (n = 9) and idiopathic infertile (n = 10) women. Proteins with ≥2-fold change (P < 0.05) were considered significantly altered between fertile and infertile groups. Immunohistochemistry examined the endometrial localization of identified proteins. Western immunoblotting defined the forms of extracellular matrix protein 1 (ECM1) in uterine lavage fluid. Proteomic analysis identified four proteins significantly downregulated in infertile women compared to fertile women, including secreted frizzled-related protein 4 (SFRP4), CD44, and ECM1: two proteins were upregulated. Seven proteins were unique to the fertile group and six (including isoaspartyl peptidase/L-asparaginase [ASRGL1]) were unique to the infertile group. Identified proteins were classified into biological processes of tissue regeneration and regulatory processes. ASRGL1, SFRP4, and ECM1 localized to glandular epithelium and stroma, cluster of differentiation 44 (CD44) to stroma and immune cells. ECM1 was present in two main molecular weight forms in uterine fluid. Our results indicate a disturbance in endometrial development during the proliferative phase among infertile women, providing insights into human endometrial development and potential therapeutic targets for infertility. Summary Sentence Proteomic analysis of proliferative phase uterine fluid in both fertile and infertile women showed significant differences in the secreted proteins including ECM1 which was further studied for its cellular location and hormonal regulation.