Yoshitaka Fukano

Fuel Pin Behavior under Slow-Ramp-type Transient-Overpower Conditions in the CABRI-FAST Experiments

In the CABRI-FAST experimental program, four in-pile tests were performed with slow-power-ramptype transient-overpower conditions (called hereafter as “slow TOP”) to study transient fuel pin behavior under inadvertent control-rod-withdrawal-type events in liquid-metal-cooled fast breeder reactors. The slow TOP test with a preirradiated solid-pellet fuel pin under a power ramp rate of approximately 3%Po/s was realized as a comparatory test against an existing test in the CABRI-2 program where approximately 1%Po/s was adopted with the same type of fuel pin. In spite of the different power ramp rates, the evaluated fuel thermal conditions at the observed failure time are quite similar. Three slow TOP tests with the preirradiated annular fuel resulted in no pin failure showing a high failure threshold. Based on posttest examination data and a theoretical evaluation, it was concluded that intrapin free spaces, such as central hole, macroscopic cracks, and fuel-cladding gap, effectively mitigated the fuel cladding mechanical interaction. It was also clarified that cavity pressurization became effective only in the case of a very large amount of fuel melting. These CABRI-FAST slow TOP tests, in combination with the existing CABRI and TREAT tests, provided an extended slow TOP test database under various fuel and transient conditions.

Three-Pin Cluster CABRI Tests Simulating the Unprotected Loss-of-Flow Accident in Sodium-Cooled Fast Reactors

Two three-pin cluster tests simulating the Unprotected Loss-of-Flow (ULOF) accident of Sodiumcooled Fast Reactors (SFRs) were conducted focusing on postfailure fuel relocation and freezing behavior. These tests supplied complementary information to the existing CABRI tests with a single-pin geometry. Based on detailed data evaluation and theoretical interpretation for the three-pin cluster tests, it is concluded that axial fuel relocation and freezing are dominated by local fuel enthalpy, and the relation between penetration length and local fuel enthalpy observed in these CABRI tests is basically applicable to the large-bundle condition. It is also clarified that a fuel/steel mixture tends to create tight blockages near the axial ends of the relocating fuel. Part of the fission gas released from the heating-up and melting fuel is expected to be trapped within the bottled-up region between the upper and lower blockages and will keep this region pressurized for a relatively long period.

Development of Natural Circulation Analytical Model in Super-COPD Code and Evaluation of Core Cooling Capability in Monju During a Station Blackout

Abstract The capability of natural circulation for core cooling has been evaluated in detail for a station blackout (SBO) event induced by an earthquake and a subsequent tsunami hit. The evaluation was prompted by the accident at the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear power station of Tokyo Electric Power Company. The plant dynamics computer code Super-COPD was used for the evaluation, which has been validated by analyses of preliminary test results on the natural circulation in Monju. As a result, it was concluded that natural circulation of the sodium coolant will enable the decay heat from the core to be removed under such an SBO condition.

Fuel Pin Behavior up to Cladding Failure under Pulse-Type Transient Overpower in the CABRI-FAST and CABRI-RAFT Experiments

In the CABRI-FAST and CABRI-RAFT programs within a collaboration with the Institut de Radioprotection et de Sûreté Nucléaire (IRSN) and Forschungszentrum Karlsruhe (FZK), five pulse-type transient overpower tests were performed in order to study fuel pin behavior and failure condition in the Unprotected Loss-of-Flow (ULOF) accident. In these tests, two types of low-smear-density fuels irradiated in the French Phénix reactor at different burn-up levels were used so that an experimental database extension from the former CABRI-1 and CABRI-2 programs can be obtained. Pin failure took place in three of these tests giving information on the failure threshold. In two tests, no pin failure took place and useful information related to the transient fuel behavior up to failure and failure mechanism was obtained. These test results were interpreted through detailed analysis of experimental data and PAPAS-2S code calculations. In these calculations, pretransient fuel characteristics obtained from the sibling fuels were reflected, such that the uncertainty of the boundary condition can be minimized. Through the comparison among these tests and formerly existing CABRI tests, generalized understanding on the transient fuel behavior was obtained. It was concluded that the low-smear-density fuel mitigates cavity pressurization, thereby enhancing the margin-to-failure. It was also understood that this failure-thresholdenhancing capability is dependent on the type of transient.

Development of safety assessment methodology on fuel element failure propagation in SFR and its application to Monju

Probabilistic and deterministic safety assessments and experimental studies on local fault (LF) propagation in sodium-cooled fast reactors (SFRs) have been performed in many countries because LFs have been historically considered as one of the possible causes of severe accidents. Adventitious fuel pin failures have been considered to be the most dominant initiators of LFs in these probabilistic assessments because of its high frequency of occurrence during reactor operation and possibility of subsequent pin-to-pin failure propagation. Four possible mechanisms of fuel element failure propagation from adventitious fuel pin failure (FEFPA) were identified from a state-of-the-art review of open papers. All the mechanisms for FEFPA analysis including thermal, mechanical and chemical propagation are modeled into a safety assessment code which is applicable to arbitrary SFRs by developing some needed but missing methods. Furthermore, an assessment on FEFPA of Japanese prototype fast breeder reactor (Monju) was performed using this methodology. It was clarified that FEFPA was highly unlikely and limited at most within one subassembly in Monju owing to its redundant and diverse detection and shutdown systems for FEFPA even assuming the propagation. These results also suggested future possibility of run-beyond-cladding-breach operation which would enhance the economic efficiency in Monju.

Comprehensive and consistent interpretation of local fault experiments and application to hypothetical local overpower accident in Monju

Experimental studies on local fault (LF) accidents in fast breeder reactors have been performed in many countries because LFs have been historically considered as one of the possible causes of severe accidents. Comprehensive and consistent interpretations of in-pile and out-of-pile experiments related to LF were arrived at in this study based on state-of-the-art review and data analysis techniques. Safety margins for a hypothetical local overpower accident, which was evaluated as a LF accident in the licensing document of the construction permit for a prototype fast breeder reactor called Monju, were also studied. Based on comprehensive interpretations of the latest experimental database, including those performed after the permission of Monju construction, it was clarified that the evaluation of the hypothetical local overpower accident in the Monju licensing was sufficiently conservative. Furthermore, it incorporated adequate safety margins in terms of failure thresholds of the fuel pin, molten fuel ejection, fuel sweep-out behavior after molten fuel ejection, and pin-to-pin failure propagation. Moreover, these comprehensive interpretations are valid and applicable to the safety evaluation of LF accidents of other fast breeder reactors with various fuel and core designs.

Updating of adventitious fuel pin failure frequency in sodium-cooled fast reactors and probabilistic risk assessment on consequent severe accident in Monju

Experimental studies, deterministic approaches and probabilistic risk assessments (PRAs) on local fault (LF) propagation in sodium-cooled fast reactors (SFRs) have been performed in many countries because LFs have been historically considered as one of the possible causes of severe accidents. Adventitious-fuel-pin-failures (AFPFs) have been considered to be the most dominant initiators of LFs in these PRAs because of their high frequency of occurrence during reactor operation and possibility of fuel-element-failure-propagation (FEFP). A PRA on FEFP from AFPF (FEFPA) in the Japanese prototype SFR (Monju) was performed in this study based on the state-of-the-art knowledge, reflecting the most recent operation procedures under off-normal conditions. Frequency of occurrence of AFPF in SFRs which was the initiating event of the event tree in this PRA was updated using a variety of methods based on the above-mentioned latest review on experiences of this phenomenon. As a result, the frequency of occurrence of, and the core damage frequency (CDF) from, AFPF in Monju was significantly reduced to a negligible magnitude compared with those in the existing PRAs. It was, therefore concluded that the CDF of FEFPA in Monju could be comprised in that of anticipated transient without scram or protected loss of heat sink events from both the viewpoint of occurrence probability and consequences.

Updating of local blockage frequency in the reactor core of SFR and PRA on consequent severe accident in Monju

ABSTRACT Fuel subassemblies of sodium-cooled fast reactors (SFRs) are densely arranged and have high power densities. Therefore, the local fault has been considered as one of the possible initiating events of severe accidents. In the conventional analyses for the license of Japanese prototype SFR (Monju), according to the local fault evaluation under the condition of one sub-channel flow blockage in the analyses of design basis accident (DBA), it was confirmed that the pin failures were limited locally without severe core damage. In addition, local flow blockage of 66% central planar in the subassembly was historically investigated as one of the beyond-DBAs. However, it became clear that these deterministic analyses were not based on a realistic assumption by experimental studies. Therefore, probabilistic risk assessment on local fault which was initiated from local flow blockage was performed reflecting the state-of-the-art knowledge in this study. As a result, damage propagation from local fault caused by local flow blockage in Monju can be negligible compared with the core damage due to anticipated transient without scram or protected loss of heat sink in the viewpoint of both frequency and consequence.