Andrew R. Leach

Exploring the conformational space of protein side chains using dead‐end elimination and the A* algorithm

We describe an algorithm which enables us to search the conformational space of the side chains of a protein to identify the global minimum energy combination of side chain conformations as well as all other conformations within a specified energy cutoff of the global energy minimum. The program is used to explore the side chain conformational energy surface of a number of proteins, to investigate how this surface varies with the energy model used to describe the interactions within the system and the rotamer library. Enumeration of the rotamer combinations enables us to directly evaluate the partition function, and thus calculate the side chain contribution to the conformational entropy of the folded protein. An investigation of these conformations and the relationships between them shows that most of the conformations near to the global energy minimum arise from changes in side chain conformations that are essentially independent; very few result from a concerted change in conformation of two or more residues. Some of the limitations of the approach are discussed. Proteins 33:227–239, 1998.

The in silico world of virtual libraries

Combinatorial chemistry has provided medicinal chemists with an unprecedented ability to synthesize large numbers of molecules. However, early experience was that this did not result in any increase in the number of real candidates for lead optimization. Attention has increasingly focussed on the use of computational techniques for the design of combinatorial libraries. This review will describe some of the issues that have been considered in this area and discuss some of the possible developments in the near future.

Prediction of biological activity for high-throughput screening using binary kernel discrimination.

High-throughput screening has made a significant impact on drug discovery, but there is an acknowledged need for quantitative methods to analyze screening results and predict the activity of further compounds. In this paper we introduce one such method, binary kernel discrimination, and investigate its performance on two datasets; the first is a set of 1650 monoamine oxidase inhibitors, and the second a set of 101 437 compounds from an in-house enzyme assay. We compare the performance of binary kernel discrimination with a simple procedure which we call merged similarity search, and also with a feedforward neural network. Binary kernel discrimination is shown to perform robustly with varying quantities of training data and also in the presence of noisy data. We conclude by highlighting the importance of the judicious use of general pattern recognition techniques for compound selection.

Analysis and optimization of structure-based virtual screening protocols: (3). New methods and old problems in scoring function design

Scoring function research remains a primary focus of current structure-based virtual screening (SVS) technology development. Here, we present an alternative method for scoring function design that attempts to combine crystallographic structural information with data derived from directly within SVS calculations. The technique utilizes a genetic algorithm (GA) to optimize functions based on binding property data derived from multiple virtual screening calculations. These calculations are undertaken on protein data bank (PDB) complex active sites using ligands of known binding mode in conjunction with noise compounds. The advantages of such an approach are that the function does not rely on assay data and that it can potentially use the noise binding data to recognize the sub-optimal docking interactions inherent in SVS calculations. Initial efforts in technique exploration using DOCK are presented, with comparisons made to existing DOCK scoring functions. An analysis of the problems inherent to scoring function development is also made, including issues in dataset creation and limitations in descriptor utility when viewed from the perspective of docking mode resolution. The future directions such studies might take are also discussed in detail.

Synergy between combinatorial chemistry and de novo design.

Traditional de novo design algorithms are able to generate many thousands of ligand structures that meet the constraints of a protein structure, but these structures are often not synthetically tractable. In this article, we describe how concepts from structure-based de novo design can be used to explore the search space in library design. A key feature of the approach is the requirement that specific templates are included within the designed structures. Each template corresponds to the central core of a combinatorial library. The template is positioned within an acyclic chain whose length and bond orders are systematically varied, and the conformational space of each structure that results (core plus chain) is explored to determine whether it is able to link together two or more strongly interacting functional groups or pharmacophores located within a protein binding site. This fragment connection algorithm provides generic 3D molecules in the sense that the linking part (minus the template) is built from an all-carbon chain whose synthesis may not be easily achieved. Thus, in the second phase, 2D queries are derived from the molecular skeletons and used to identify possible reagents from a database. Each potential reagent is checked to ensure that it is compatible with the conformation of its parent 3D conformation and the constraints of the binding site. Combinations of these reagents according to the combinatorial library reaction scheme give product molecules that contain the desired core template and the key functional/pharmacophoric groups, and would be able to adopt a conformation compatible with the original molecular skeleton without any unfavorable intermolecular or intramolecular interactions. We discuss how this strategy compares with and relates to alternative approaches to both structure-based library design and de novo design.

Structure-based selection of building blocks for array synthesis via the World-Wide Web*

In this article we are concerned with the selection of chemical entities for array synthesis in a structure-based design project. We have extended our conformational searching algorithm to permit the enumeration of a set of substituents at a particular position for a fixed template. The conformational space of each of the resulting structures is then explored within the confines of the binding site to identify conformations that do not interact unfavorably with the surrounding protein. The template remains fixed in its original orientation within the binding site. The interaction between each conformation and the binding site can also be quantified using various calculated properties. Each substituent for which one or more acceptable conformations can be found is retained for further analysis. Use of the program is facilitated by a Web-based interface that enables nonexpert molecular modelers to perform searches, view the results in a platform-independent manner (via VRML), and perform simple cluster analysis on the resulting sets of molecules. The approach is illustrated using a series of penicillin-based HIV-1 protease inhibitors.

CHAPTER 4:Current Status and Future Direction of Fragment-Based Drug Discovery: A Computational Chemistry Perspective

Fragment-based drug discovery (FBDD) has become a well-established and widely used approach for lead identification. The computational chemistry community has played a central role in developing the ideas behind this area of research and computational tools are important throughout FBDD campaigns. This article discusses the evolution of best practice, on-going areas of debate and gaps in current capabilities from a computational chemistry perspective. In particular, the contribution of computational methods to areas such as fragment library design, screening analysis, data handling and the role of structure- and ligand-based design is discussed. The potential to combine FBDD with other hit-identification methods such as high-throughput screening in a more integrated approach is also highlighted.

Computational Chemistry in Lead Identification, Library Design and Lead Optimisation

Abstract We describe a variety of the computational techniques which we use in the drug discovery and design process. Some of these computational methods are designed to support the new experimental technologies of high-throughput screening and combinatorial chemistry. We also consider some new approaches to problems of long-standing interest such as protein-ligand docking and the prediction of free energies of binding.

Synergy between combinatorial chemistry and de novo design22European Bioinformatics Institute, Wellcome Trust Genome Campus, Hinxton, Cambridge CB10 1SD, United Kingdom.

Traditional de novo design algorithms are able to generate many thousands of ligand structures that meet the constraints of a protein structure, but these structures are often not synthetically tractable. In this article, we describe how concepts from structure-based de novo design can be used to explore the search space in library design. A key feature of the approach is the requirement that specific templates are included within the designed structures. Each template corresponds to the central core of a combinatorial library. The template is positioned within an acyclic chain whose length and bond orders are systematically varied, and the conformational space of each structure that results (core plus chain) is explored to determine whether it is able to link together two or more strongly interacting functional groups or pharmacophores located within a protein binding site. This fragment connection algorithm provides generic 3D molecules in the sense that the linking part (minus the template) is built from an all-carbon chain whose synthesis may not be easily achieved. Thus, in the second phase, 2D queries are derived from the molecular skeletons and used to identify possible reagents from a database. Each potential reagent is checked to ensure that it is compatible with the conformation of its parent 3D conformation and the constraints of the binding site. Combinations of these reagents according to the combinatorial library reaction scheme give product molecules that contain the desired core template and the key functional/pharmacophoric groups, and would be able to adopt a conformation compatible with the original molecular skeleton without any unfavorable intermolecular or intramolecular interactions. We discuss how this strategy compares with and relates to alternative approaches to both structure-based library design and de novo design.

Synergy between combinatorial chemistry and de novo design 2

Traditional de novo design algorithms are able to generate many thousands of ligand structures that meet the constraints of a protein structure, but these structures are often not synthetically tractable. In this article, we describe how concepts from structure-based de novo design can be used to explore the search space in library design. A key feature of the approach is the requirement that specific templates are included within the designed structures. Each template corresponds to the central core of a combinatorial library. The template is positioned within an acyclic chain whose length and bond orders are systematically varied, and the conformational space of each structure that results (core plus chain) is explored to determine whether it is able to link together two or more strongly interacting functional groups or pharmacophores located within a protein binding site. This fragment connection algorithm provides generic 3D molecules in the sense that the linking part (minus the template) is built from an all-carbon chain whose synthesis may not be easily achieved. Thus, in the second phase, 2D queries are derived from the molecular skeletons and used to identify possible reagents from a database. Each potential reagent is checked to ensure that it is compatible with the conformation of its parent 3D conformation and the constraints of the binding site. Combinations of these reagents according to the combinatorial library reaction scheme give product molecules that contain the desired core template and the key functional/pharmacophoric groups, and would be able to adopt a conformation compatible with the original molecular skeleton without any unfavorable intermolecular or intramolecular interactions. We discuss how this strategy compares with and relates to alternative approaches to both structure-based library design and de novo design.