Ashwani K. Thakur

Polyglutamine disruption of the huntingtin exon 1 N terminus triggers a complex aggregation mechanism

Simple polyglutamine (polyQ) peptides aggregate in vitro via a nucleated growth pathway directly yielding amyloid-like aggregates. We show here that the 17-amino-acid flanking sequence (HTTNT) N-terminal to the polyQ in the toxic huntingtin exon 1 fragment imparts onto this peptide a complex alternative aggregation mechanism. In isolation, the HTTNT peptide is a compact coil that resists aggregation. When polyQ is fused to this sequence, it induces in HTTNT, in a repeat-length dependent fashion, a more extended conformation that greatly enhances its aggregation into globular oligomers with HTTNT cores and exposed polyQ. In a second step, a new, amyloid-like aggregate is formed with a core composed of both HTTNT and polyQ. The results indicate unprecedented complexity in how primary sequence controls aggregation within a substantially disordered peptide and have implications for the molecular mechanism of Huntingtons disease.

Mutational analysis of the structural organization of polyglutamine aggregates

The formation of amyloid-like aggregates by expanded polyglutamine (polyGln) sequences is suspected to play a critical role in the neuropathology of Huntingtons disease and other expanded CAG-repeat diseases. To probe the folding of the polyGln sequence in the aggregate, we replaced Gln–Gln pairs at different sequence intervals with Pro–Gly pairs, elements that are compatible with β-turn formation and incompatible with β-extended chain. We find that PGQ9 and PGQ10, peptides consisting of four Q9 or Q10 elements interspersed with PG elements, undergo spontaneous aggregation as efficiently as a Q45 sequence, whereas the corresponding PGQ7 and PGQ8 peptides aggregate much less readily. Furthermore, a PDGQ9 sequence containing d-prolines aggregates more efficiently than the peptide with l-prolines, consistent with β-turn formation in aggregate structure. Introduction of one additional Pro residue in the center of a Q9 element within PGQ9 completely blocks the peptides ability to aggregate. This strongly suggests that the Q9 elements are required to be in extended chain for efficient aggregation to occur. We determined the critical nucleus for aggregation nucleation of the PGQ9 peptide to be one, a result identical to that for unbroken polyGln sequences. The PGQN peptide aggregates are structurally quite similar to Q45 aggregates, as judged by heterologous seeding aggregation kinetics, recognition by an anti-polyGln aggregate antibody, and electron microscopy. The results suggest that polyGln aggregate structure consists of alternating elements of extended chain and turn. In the future it should be possible to conduct detailed and interpretable mutational studies in the PGQ9 background.

Polyglutamine aggregation nucleation: Thermodynamics of a highly unfavorable protein folding reaction

Polyglutamine (polyGln) aggregation is implicated in the disease progression of Huntingtons disease and other expanded CAG repeat diseases. PolyGln aggregation in vitro follows a simple nucleated growth polymerization pathway without apparent complications such as populated intermediates, alternative assembly pathways, or secondary nucleation phenomena. Previous analysis of the aggregation of simple polyGln peptides revealed that the critical nucleus (the number of monomeric units involved in the formation of an energetically unfavorable aggregation nucleus) is equal to one, suggesting that polyGln nucleation can be viewed as an unfavorable protein folding reaction. We provide here a method for experimentally determining the number of elongation growth sites per unit weight for any polyGln aggregate preparation, a key parameter required for completion of the nucleation kinetics analysis and determination of the thermodynamics of nucleation. We find that, for the polyGln peptide Q47, the second-order rate constant for fibril elongation is 11,400 liters/mol per s, whereas Kn*, the equilibrium constant for nucleation of aggregation, is remarkably small, equal to 2.6 × 10-9. The latter value corresponds to a free energy of nucleus formation of +12.2 kcal/mol, a value consistent with a highly unfavorable folding reaction. The methods introduced here should allow further analysis of the energetics of polyGln nucleus formation and accurate comparisons of the seeding capabilities of different fibril preparations, a task of increasing importance in the amyloid field.

Kinetics and thermodynamics of amyloid assembly using a high-performance liquid chromatography-based sedimentation assay

Nonnative protein aggregation has been classically treated as an amorphous process occurring by colloidal coagulation kinetics and proceeding to an essentially irreversible endpoint often ascribed to a chaotic tangle of unfolded chains. However, some nonnative aggregates, particularly amyloid fibrils, exhibit ordered structures that appear to assemble according to ordered mechanisms. Some of these fibrils, as illustrated here with the Alzheimers plaque peptide amyloid beta, assemble to an endpoint that is a dynamic equilibrium between monomers and fibrils exhibiting a characteristic equilibrium constant with an associated free energy of formation. Some fibrils, as illustrated here with the polyglutamine repeat sequences associated with Huntingtons disease, assemble via highly regular mechanisms exhibiting nucleated growth polymerization kinetics. Here, we describe a series of linked methods for quantitative analysis of such aggregation kinetics and thermodynamics, focusing on a robust high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC)-based sedimentation assay. An integrated group of protocols is provided for peptide disaggregation, setting up the HPLC sedimentation assay, the preparation of fibril seed stocks and determination of the average functional molecular weight of the fibrils, elongation and nucleation kinetics analysis, and the determination of the critical concentration describing the thermodynamic endpoint of fibril elongation.

Slow amyloid nucleation via α-helix-rich oligomeric intermediates in short polyglutamine-containing huntingtin fragments.

The 17-amino-acid N-terminal segment (htt(NT)) that leads into the polyglutamine (polyQ) segment in the Huntingtons disease protein huntingtin (htt) dramatically increases aggregation rates and changes the aggregation mechanism, compared to a simple polyQ peptide of similar length. With polyQ segments near or above the pathological repeat length threshold of about 37, aggregation of htt N-terminal fragments is so rapid that it is difficult to tease out mechanistic details. We describe here the use of very short polyQ repeat lengths in htt N-terminal fragments to slow this disease-associated aggregation. Although all of these peptides, in addition to htt(NT) itself, form α-helix-rich oligomeric intermediates, only peptides with Q(N) of eight or longer mature into amyloid-like aggregates, doing so by a slow increase in β-structure. Concentration-dependent circular dichroism and analytical ultracentrifugation suggest that the htt(NT) sequence, with or without added glutamine residues, exists in solution as an equilibrium between disordered monomer and α-helical tetramer. Higher order, α-helix rich oligomers appear to be built up via these tetramers. However, only htt(NT)Q(N) peptides with N=8 or more undergo conversion into polyQ β-sheet aggregates. These final amyloid-like aggregates not only feature the expected high β-sheet content but also retain an element of solvent-exposed α-helix. The α-helix-rich oligomeric intermediates appear to be both on- and off-pathway, with some oligomers serving as the pool from within which nuclei emerge, while those that fail to undergo amyloid nucleation serve as a reservoir for release of monomers to support fibril elongation. Based on a regular pattern of multimers observed in analytical ultracentrifugation, and a concentration dependence of α-helix formation in CD spectroscopy, it is likely that these oligomers assemble via a four-helix assembly unit. PolyQ expansion in these peptides appears to enhance the rates of both oligomer formation and nucleation from within the oligomer population, by structural mechanisms that remain unclear.

Inhibiting the nucleation of amyloid structure in a huntingtin fragment by targeting α-helix-rich oligomeric intermediates.

Although oligomeric intermediates are transiently formed in almost all known amyloid assembly reactions, their mechanistic roles are poorly understood. Recently, we demonstrated a critical role for the 17-amino-acid N-terminus (htt(NT) segment) of huntingtin (htt) in the oligomer-mediated amyloid assembly of htt N-terminal fragments. In this mechanism, the htt(NT) segment forms the α-helix-rich core of the oligomers, leaving much of the polyglutamine (polyQ) segment disordered and solvent-exposed. Nucleation of amyloid structure occurs within this local high concentration of disordered polyQ. Here we demonstrate the kinetic importance of htt(NT) self-assembly by describing inhibitory htt(NT)-containing peptides that appear to work by targeting nucleation within the oligomer fraction. These molecules inhibit amyloid nucleation by forming mixed oligomers with the htt(NT) domains of polyQ-containing htt N-terminal fragments. In one class of inhibitors, nucleation is passively suppressed due to the reduced local concentration of polyQ within the mixed oligomer. In the other class, nucleation is actively suppressed by a proline-rich polyQ segment covalently attached to htt(NT). Studies with D-amino acid and scrambled sequence versions of htt(NT) suggest that inhibition activity is strongly linked to the propensity of inhibitory peptides to make amphipathic α-helices. Htt(NT) derivatives with C-terminal cell-penetrating peptide segments also exhibit excellent inhibitory activity. The htt(NT)-based peptides described here, especially those with protease-resistant d-amino acids and/or with cell-penetrating sequences, may prove useful as lead therapeutics for inhibiting the nucleation of amyloid formation in Huntingtons disease.

In-cell aggregation of a polyglutamine-containing chimera is a multistep process initiated by the flanking sequence.

Toxicity in amyloid diseases is intimately linked to the nature of aggregates, with early oligomeric species believed to be more cytotoxic than later fibrillar aggregates. Yet mechanistic understanding of how aggregating species evolve with time is currently lacking. We have explored the aggregation process of a chimera composed of a globular protein (cellular retinoic acid-binding protein, CRABP) and huntingtin exon 1 with polyglutamine tracts either above (Q53) or below (Q20) the pathological threshold using Escherichia coli cells as a model intracellular environment. Previously we showed that fusion of the huntingtin exon 1 sequence with >40Q led to structural perturbation and decreased stability of CRABP ( Ignatova, Z., and Gierasch, L. M. (2006) J. Biol. Chem. 281, 12959-12967 ). Here we report that the Q53 chimera aggregates in cells via a multistep process: early stage aggregates are spherical and detergent-soluble, characteristics of prefibrillar aggregates, and appear to be dominated structurally by CRABP, in that they can promote aggregation of a CRABP variant but not oligoglutamine aggregation, and the CRABP domain is relatively sequestered based on its protection from proteolysis. Late stage aggregates appear to be dominated by polyGln; they are fibrillar, detergent-resistant, capable of seeding aggregation of oligoglutamine but not the CRABP variant, and show relative protection of the polyglutamine-exon1 domain from proteolysis. These results point to an evolution of the dominant sequences in intracellular aggregates and may provide molecular insight into origins of toxic prefibrillar aggregates.

CA150 Expression Delays Striatal Cell Death in Overexpression and Knock-In Conditions for Mutant Huntingtin Neurotoxicity

Transcriptional dysregulation caused by expanded polyglutamines (polyGlns) in huntingtin (htt) may be central to cell-autonomous mechanisms for neuronal cell death in Huntingtons disease (HD) pathogenesis. We hypothesized that these mechanisms may involve the dysfunction of the transcriptional regulator CA150, a putative modifier of onset age in HD, because it binds to htt and accumulates in an HD grade-dependent manner in striatal and cortical neurons. Consistently, we report herein that CA150 expression rescues striatal cell death in lentiviral overexpression (rats) and knock-in (mouse cells) conditions for mutant htt neurotoxicity. In both systems, rescue was dependent on the (Gln-Ala)38 repeat normally found in CA150. We excluded the possibility that rescue may be caused by the (Gln-Ala)38 repeat interacting with polyGlns and, by doing so, blocking mutant htt toxicity. In contrast, we found the (Gln-Ala)38 repeat is required for the nuclear restriction of exogenous CA150, suggesting that rescue requires nuclear CA150. Additionally, we found the (Gln-Ala)38 repeat was dispensable for CA150 transcriptional repression ability, suggesting further that CA150 localization is critical to rescue. Finally, rescue was associated with increased neuritic aggregation, with no reduction of nuclear inclusions, suggesting the solubilization and nuclear export of mutant htt. Together, our data indicate that mutant htt may induce CA150 dysfunction in striatal neurons and suggest that the restoration of nuclear protein cooperativity may be neuroprotective.

Kinetically competing huntingtin aggregation pathways control amyloid polymorphism and properties

In polyglutamine (polyQ) containing fragments of the Huntingtons disease protein huntingtin (htt), the N-terminal 17 amino acid htt(NT) segment serves as the core of α-helical oligomers whose reversible assembly locally concentrates the polyQ segments, thereby facilitating polyQ amyloid nucleation. A variety of aggregation inhibitors have been described that achieve their effects by neutralizing this concentrating function of the htt(NT) segment. In this paper we characterize the nature and limits of this inhibition for three means of suppressing htt(NT)-mediated aggregation. We show that the previously described action of htt(NT) peptide-based inhibitors is solely due to their ability to suppress the htt(NT)-mediated aggregation pathway. That is, under htt(NT) inhibition, nucleation of polyQ amyloid formation by a previously described alternative nucleation mechanism proceeds unabated and transiently dominates the aggregation process. Removal of the bulk of the htt(NT) segment by proteolysis or mutagenesis also blocks the htt(NT)-mediated pathway, allowing the alternative nucleation pathway to dominate. In contrast, the previously described immunoglobulin-based inhibitor, the antihtt(NT) V(L) 12.3 protein, effectively blocks both amyloid pathways, leading to stable accumulation of nonamyloid oligomers. These data show that the htt(NT)-dependent and -independent pathways of amyloid nucleation in polyQ-containing htt fragments are in direct kinetic competition. The results illustrate how amyloid polymorphism depends on assembly mechanism and kinetics and have implications for how the intracellular environment can influence aggregation pathways.

Inhibition of polyglutamine aggregate cytotoxicity by a structure-based elongation inhibitor

Huntingtons disease and other expanded CAG repeat diseases are associated with the expression of proteins containing polyglutamine (polyGln) tracts expanded beyond a pathological repeat length threshold of ~38. Aggregation of these expanded polyGln proteins may trigger disease by recruiting and sequestering other polyGln‐containing proteins in the cell, depriving the cellular environment of critical protein activities. We describe here proline‐containing polyGln peptide sequences that are effective inhibitors of the ability of polyGln aggregates to be elongated by recruiting additional polyGln monomers. These peptides are also effective inhibitors of polyGln aggregate toxicity in a cell culture model based on delivery of preassembled polyGln aggregates into the cell nucleus. These results are not only consistent with a role for polyGln aggregates in the disease mechanisms of expanded CAG repeat disorders, but also directly implicate the elongation phase of aggregate growth in the toxicity mechanism, supporting the recruitment–sequestration model for polyGln toxicity. These results may be related to the ability of the glutamine/proline‐rich protein PQE‐1 to protect C. elegans against polyglutamine toxicity. Inhibition of aggregate elongation is a therapeutic strategy that, based on our results, may be effective even in neurons already compromised by polyGln aggregates.