Beth L. Sanderson

A LARGE-SCALE, MULTISPECIES STATUS ASSESSMENT: ANADROMOUS SALMONIDS IN THE COLUMBIA RIVER BASIN

Twelve salmonid evolutionarily significant units (ESUs) throughout the Columbia River Basin are currently listed as threatened or endangered under the Endangered Species Act; these ESUs are affected differentially by a variety of human activities. We present a standardized quantitative status and risk assessment for 152 listed salmonid stocks in these ESUs and 24 nonlisted stocks. Using data from 1980–2000, which represents a time of stable conditions in the Columbia River hydropower system and a period of ocean conditions generally regarded as poor for Columbia Basin salmonids, we estimated the status of these stocks under two different assumptions: that hatchery-reared spawners were not reproducing during the period of the censuses, or that hatchery-reared spawners were reproducing and thus that reproduction from hatchery inputs was masking population trends. We repeated the analyses using a longer time period containing both “good” and “bad” ocean conditions (1965–2000) as a first step toward determini...

Native invaders – challenges for science, management, policy, and society

The term “invader” is typically paired with adjectives such as “non-native” and “alien”, yet native species can also cause ecological and economic impacts that rival those of well-known invasive species. By spreading within their historical range, attaining extreme abundances, and exerting severe per-capita effects as a result of predation or competition, native invaders can create an unusual set of challenges for science, management, policy, and society. Identifying when, where, and why species become invaders in their native ranges requires additional scientific inquiry, outside the current focus of invasion biology. Management strategies often mitigate the symptoms rather than address the causes of problematic native species invasions. Convincing stakeholders to comply with management actions aimed at controlling native invaders creates societal challenges and policy makers must prioritize goals from varied and often conflicting human interests. We illustrate these challenges by highlighting native spe...

Nonindigenous Species of the Pacific Northwest: An Overlooked Risk to Endangered Salmon?

Nonindigenous species, which are associated with the decline of many threatened and endangered species, are a major threat to global diversity. This risk extends to salmonids, the most widespread threatened and endangered species in the Pacific Northwest. Pacific salmonids traverse large geographic areas that include freshwater, estuarine, and ocean habitats in which they encounter numerous nonnative species. For this article, we examined the extent to which introduced species are a risk to threatened and endangered salmon. We identified all documented nonindigenous species in the Pacific Northwest, including fish, invertebrates, birds, plants, and amphibians. Where data exist, we quantified the impact of nonindigenous species on threatened and endangered salmonids. The results indicate that the effect of nonindigenous species on salmon could equal or exceed that of four commonly addressed causes of adverse impacts—habitat alteration, harvest, hatcheries, and the hydrosystem; we suggest that managing nonindigenous species may be imperative for salmon recovery.

Nonlethal Sampling of Fish Caudal Fins Yields Valuable Stable Isotope Data for Threatened and Endangered Fishes

Abstract Fin clipping is gaining momentum for stable isotope analysis in fish as a nonlethal alternative to lethally collecting dorsal white muscle tissue. The main advantage of fin clipping is the elimination of lethal collection, which thus increases the potential for stable isotope research involving threatened or endangered species. To make comparisons across studies using different methods, the degree to which fin clips and dorsal muscle are correlated for both δ15N and δ13C across time and space must be quantified. We evaluated the efficacy of using caudal fin clips by comparing tissues collected across time (2003-2005), space (21 streams), and body size (fork length, 40-140 mm) for juvenile Chinook salmon Oncorhynchus tshawytscha and O. mykiss (rainbow trout and steelhead [anadromous rainbow trout]). We also addressed several analytical and sampling issues to assess the potential benefits and limitations of using fin clips for δ15N and δ13C determination. We found that the relationship between fin ...

Nutrient limitation of periphyton in Idaho streams: results from nutrient diffusing substrate experiments

Abstract Many streams and rivers in the Pacific Northwest of the US are inherently oligotrophic, and primary production in these ecosystems is assumed to be nutrient-limited. In many of these streams, reductions in the amount of marine-derived nutrients delivered by spawning salmonids could be exacerbating the degree of oligotrophication. To test whether primary producers are nutrient-limited, nutrient diffusing substrate (NDS) experiments were used to measure algal responses to amendments of N, P, and a combination of N and P (N+P) in 13 Salmon River basin streams in central Idaho, USA. Thirty-eight experiments were conducted between 2003 and 2006 to determine whether nutrient limitation varied among streams and over time within individual streams. Primary producers in most streams showed some form of nutrient limitation. Thirty-nine percent of our experiments suggested N and P colimitation, 18% suggested N limitation, 11% suggested primary N and secondary P limitation, and 32% did not indicate limitation by either N or P. The type of nutrient limitation within individual streams varied with time, and the relative importance of N or P changed seasonally or annually in 7 of the 13 streams. Algal accrual rates on control and treatment substrates were most strongly predicted by water temperature, light, and ambient concentrations of N and P. Among all of the experiments, algal accrual rates were greater on N substrates in streams with lower ambient N concentrations and greater ambient P concentrations. Our results suggest that a combination of N and P typically limits primary producers in these streams. Our efforts to characterize current nutrient limitation in these streams will be of value to managers considering nutrient additions as a tool to improve stream productivity to benefit threatened and endangered salmonids.

Evolutionary consequences of habitat loss for Pacific anadromous salmonids

Large portions of anadromous salmonid habitat in the western United States has been lost because of dams and other blockages. This loss has the potential to affect salmonid evolution through natural selection if the loss is biased, affecting certain types of habitat differentially, and if phenotypic traits correlated with those habitat types are heritable. Habitat loss can also affect salmonid evolution indirectly, by reducing genetic variation and changing its distribution within and among populations. In this paper, we compare the characteristics of lost habitats with currently accessible habitats and review the heritability of traits which show correlations with habitat/environmental gradients. We find that although there is some regional variation, inaccessible habitats tend to be higher in elevation, wetter and both warmer in the summer and colder in the winter than habitats currently available to anadromous salmonids. We present several case studies that demonstrate either a change in phenotypic or life history expression or an apparent reduction in genetic variation associated with habitat blockages. These results suggest that loss of habitat will alter evolutionary trajectories in salmonid populations and Evolutionarily Significant Units. Changes in both selective regime and standing genetic diversity might affect the ability of these taxa to respond to subsequent environmental perturbations. Both natural and anthropogenic and should be considered seriously in developing management and conservation strategies.

Smallmouth Bass in the Pacific Northwest: A Threat to Native Species; a Benefit for Anglers

As a popular sportfish, smallmouth bass (Micropterus dolomieu) generates considerable angling opportunities with benefits to local economies even outside of their native range. Smallmouth bass was first introduced to the Pacific Northwest region of North America as a sportfish over 80 years ago, and this species is now widely distributed. More recently, smallmouth bass have become a large component of the fish community in many streams, rivers, and lakes. Smallmouth bass thrive in the Pacific Northwest largely due to the habitat created by human modifications of the landscape. While a desired sportfish, smallmouth bass may also negatively affect native fishes. Of greatest concern is predation on threatened and endangered Pacific salmon; however, the current level of knowledge is inadequate to make informed management decisions for smallmouth bass. Management options for smallmouth bass are complicated further because fisheries agencies are simultaneously charged with enhancing fishing opportunities and controlling predators of threatened and endangered salmon. To advance conservation science, there is a need to determine the utility of different management approaches, and testing options in key areas of overlap between smallmouth bass and salmon is suggested.

Evaluating the consequences of salmon nutrients for riparian organisms: Linking condition metrics to stable isotopes

Abstract Stable isotope ratios (δ13C and δ15N) have been used extensively to trace nutrients from Pacific salmon, but salmon transfer more than carbon and nitrogen to stream ecosystems, such as phosphorus, minerals, proteins, and lipids. To examine the importance of these nutrients, metrics other than isotopes need to be considered, particularly when so few studies have made direct links between these nutrients and how they affect riparian organisms. Our study specifically examined δ13C and δ15N of riparian organisms from salmon and non‐salmon streams in Idaho, USA, at different distances from the streams, and examined whether the quality of riparian plants and the body condition of invertebrates varied with access to these nutrients. Overall, quality and condition metrics did not mirror stable isotope patterns. Most notably, all riparian organisms exhibited elevated δ15N in salmon streams, but also with proximity to both stream types suggesting that both salmon and landscape factors may affect δ15N. The amount of nitrogen incorporated from Pacific salmon was low for all organisms (<20%) and did not correlate with measures of quality or condition, probably due to elevated δ15N at salmon streams reflecting historical salmon runs instead of current contributions. Salmon runs in these Idaho streams have been declining, and associated riparian ecosystems have probably seen about a 90% reduction in salmon‐derived nitrogen since the 1950s. In addition, our results support those of other studies that have cautioned that inferences from natural abundance isotope data, particularly in conjunction with mixing models for salmon‐derived nutrient percentage estimates, may be confounded by biogeochemical transformations of nitrogen, physiological processes, and even historical legacies of nitrogen sources. Critically, studies should move beyond simply describing isotopic patterns to focusing on the consequences of salmon‐derived nutrients by quantifying the condition and fitness of organisms putatively using those resources.