Bram Slütter

Mechanistic study of the adjuvant effect of biodegradable nanoparticles in mucosal vaccination.

For oral vaccination, incorporation of antigens into nanoparticles has been shown to protect the antigen from degradation, but may also increase its uptake through the intestinal epithelium via M-cells. The aim of this study was to understand the mechanisms by which oral administration of antigen-loaded nanoparticles induces an immune response and to analyze the effect of the nanoparticle composition on these mechanisms. Nanoparticles made from chitosan (CS) and its N-trimethylated derivative, TMC, loaded with a model antigen ovalbumin (OVA) were prepared by ionic gelation with tripolyphosphate. Intraduodenal vaccination with OVA-loaded nanoparticles led to significantly higher antibody responses than immunization with OVA alone. TMC nanoparticles induced anti-OVA antibodies after only a priming dose. To explain these results, the interaction of nanoparticles with the intestinal epithelium was explored, in vitro, using a follicle associated epithelium model and visualized, ex vivo, using confocal laser scanning microscopy. The transport of FITC-OVA-loaded TMC nanoparticles by Caco-2 cells or follicle associated epithelium model was higher than FITC-OVA-loaded CS or PLGA nanoparticles. The association of nanoparticles with human monocyte derived dendritic cells and their effect on their maturation were determined with flow cytometry. TMC nanoparticles but not CS or PLGA nanoparticles had intrinsic adjuvant effect on DCs. In conclusion, depending on their composition, nanoparticles can increase the M-cell dependent uptake and enhance the association of the antigen with DC. In this respect, TMC nanoparticles are a promising strategy for oral vaccination.

Administration routes affect the quality of immune responses: A cross-sectional evaluation of particulate antigen-delivery systems

Particulate delivery systems such as liposomes and polymeric nano- and microparticles are attracting great interest for developing new vaccines. Materials and formulation properties essential for this purpose have been extensively studied, but relatively little is known about the influence of the administration route of such delivery systems on the type and strength of immune response elicited. Thus, the present study aimed at elucidating the influence on the immune response when of immunising mice by different routes, such as the subcutaneous, intradermal, intramuscular, and intralymphatic routes with ovalbumin-loaded liposomes, N-trimethyl chitosan (TMC) nanoparticles, and poly(lactide-co-glycolide) (PLGA) microparticles, all with and without specifically selected immune-response modifiers. The results showed that the route of administration caused only minor differences in inducing an antibody response of the IgG1 subclass, and any such differences were abolished upon booster immunisation with the various adjuvanted and non-adjuvanted delivery systems. In contrast, the administration route strongly affected both the kinetics and magnitude of the IgG2a response. A single intralymphatic administration of all evaluated delivery systems induced a robust IgG2a response, whereas subcutaneous administration failed to elicit a substantial IgG2a response even after boosting, except with the adjuvanted nanoparticles. The intradermal and intramuscular routes generated intermediate IgG2a titers. The benefit of the intralymphatic administration route for eliciting a Th1-type response was confirmed in terms of IFN-gamma production of isolated and re-stimulated splenocytes from animals previously immunised with adjuvanted and non-adjuvanted liposomes as well as with adjuvanted microparticles. Altogether the results show that the IgG2a associated with Th1-type immune responses are sensitive to the route of administration, whereas IgG1 response associated with Th2-type immune responses were relatively insensitive to the administration route of the particulate delivery systems. The route of administration should therefore be considered when planning and interpreting pre-clinical research or development on vaccine delivery systems.

Nasal vaccination with N-trimethyl chitosan and PLGA based nanoparticles: Nanoparticle characteristics determine quality and strength of the antibody response in mice against the encapsulated antigen

Nasal vaccination is a promising, needle-free alternative to classical vaccination. Nanoparticulate delivery systems have been reported to overcome the poor immunogenicity of nasally administered soluble antigens, but the characteristics of the ideal particle are unknown. This study correlates differences in physicochemical characteristics of nanoparticles to their adjuvant effect, using ovalbumin (OVA)-loaded poly(lactic-co-glycolic acid) nanoparticles (PLGA NP), N-trimethyl chitosan (TMC) based NP (TMC NP) and TMC-coated PLGA NP (PLGA/TMC NP). PLGA NP and PLGA/TMC NP were prepared by emulsification/solvent extraction and TMC NP by ionic complexation. The NP were characterized physicochemically. Their toxicity and interaction with and stimulation of monocyte derived dendritic cells (DC) were tested in vitro. Furthermore, the residence time and the immunogenicity (serum IgG titers and secretory IgA levels in nasal washes) of the nasally applied OVA formulations were assessed in Balb/c mice. All NP were similar in size, whereas only PLGA NP carried a negative zeta potential. The NP were non-toxic to isolated nasal epithelium. Only TMC NP increased the nasal residence time of OVA compared to OVA administered in PBS and induced DC maturation. After i.m. administration all NP systems induced higher IgG titers than OVA alone, PLGA NP and TMC NP being superior to PLGA/TMC NP. Nasal immunization with the slow antigen releasing particles, PLGA NP and PLGA/TMC NP, did not induce detectable antibody titers. In contrast, nasal immunization with the positively charged, fast antigen releasing TMC NP led to high serum antibody titers and sIgA levels. In conclusion, particle charge and antigen release pattern of OVA-loaded NP has to be adapted to the intended route of administration. For nasal vaccination, TMC NP, releasing their content within several hours, being mucoadhesive and stimulating the maturation of DC, were superior to PLGA NP and PLGA/TMC NP which lacked some or all of these characteristics.

Rational design of nasal vaccines.

Nasal vaccination is a promising alternative to classical parental vaccination, as it is non-invasive and, in principle, capable of eliciting strong systemic and local immune responses. However, the protective efficacy of nasally administered antigens is often impaired because of delivery problems: free antigens are readily cleared from the nasal cavity, poorly absorbed by nasal epithelial cells and generally have low intrinsic immunogenicity. In this review paper, we describe the main physiological hurdles to nasal vaccine delivery, survey the progress made in technological approaches to overcome these hurdles and discuss emerging opportunities for improving nasal vaccines. According to current insights, encapsulation of the antigen into bioadhesive (nano)particles is a promising approach towards successful nasal vaccine delivery. These antigen-loaded particles can be tailor made by supplying them with targeting ligands, adjuvants or endosomal escape mediators to form the desired vaccine that provides long-lasting protective immunity.

Conjugation of ovalbumin to trimethyl chitosan improves immunogenicity of the antigen.

Subunit vaccines are generally safer, but often less effective than live attenuated vaccines as they lack the necessary co-stimulatory factors. The formulation of an adjuvant like N-trimethyl chitosan (TMC) with an antigen can overcome its poor immunogenicity. Recent data suggest the importance of incorporating the antigen and the adjuvant into one entity for maximum immunostimulatory effect, e.g. by using (nano)particles. In the present paper we introduce the conjugation of an antigen, ovalbumin (OVA), to TMC as an alternative to nanoparticles for subunit vaccination. OVA was covalently linked to TMC using thiol chemistry (SPDP method). The uptake of the resulting TMC-OVA conjugate by dendritic cells (DC) and its effect on DC maturation was assessed in vitro and its immunogenicity was investigated in mice. We found that with the SPDP method a reducible covalent bond between TMC and OVA could be introduced, without disrupting the proteins antigenicity and structure. Uptake of TMC-OVA conjugate by dendritic cells was similar to the uptake of TMC/OVA nanoparticles, over 5-fold increased compared to a solution of OVA and TMC. Mice immunized with TMC-OVA conjugate produced 1000-fold higher OVA specific IgG titers than mice immunized with either OVA or a physical mixture of TMC and OVA. Moreover, these antibody titers were slightly elevated compared to the titers obtained with TMC/OVA nanoparticles. Conjugation of the antigen to an adjuvant is therefore a viable strategy to increase the immunogenicity of subunit vaccines and may provide an alternative to the use of particles.

Efficient induction of immune responses through intradermal vaccination with N-trimethyl chitosan containing antigen formulations.

The function of N-trimethyl chitosan (TMC) in dermal immunisation is unknown. Therefore we investigated the immunogenicity of both antigen-containing TMC nanoparticles and TMC/antigen solutions after intradermal injection. Nanoparticles were prepared with a size around 200 nm and a positive zetapotential. In vitro, TMC nanoparticles increased the uptake of OVA by dendritic cells (DCs) and both nanoparticles and TMC/OVA mixtures were able to induce upregulation of MHC-II, CD83 and CD86. These activated DCs could induce a Th2 biased T cell proliferation. A solution of plain OVA did not induce DC maturation or T cell proliferation. In vivo, mice were injected thrice with TMC based formulations containing either OVA or diphtheria toxoid (DT), a more relevant antigen. All TMC-containing formulations were able to increase the IgG titres compared to unadjuvanted antigen and induced a Th2 biased immune response. When using DT-containing TMC formulations, IgG titres and neutralising antibody titres could match up to those obtained after subcutaneous injection of DT-Alum. In conclusion, both soluble TMC/antigen mixtures and TMC nanoparticles are able to induce DC maturation and enhance immune responses after intradermal injection. This demonstrates that TMC functions as an immune potentiator for antigens delivered via the skin.

Towards tailored vaccine delivery: Needs, challenges and perspectives

The ideal vaccine is a simple and stable formulation which can be conveniently administered and provides life-long immunity against a given pathogen. The development of such a vaccine, which should trigger broad and strong B-cell and T-cell responses against antigens of the pathogen in question, is highly dependent on tailored vaccine delivery approaches. This review addresses vaccine delivery in its broadest scope. We discuss the needs and challenges in the area of vaccine delivery, including restrictions posed by specific target populations, potentials of dedicated stable formulations and devices, and the use of adjuvants. Moreover, we address the current status and perspectives of vaccine delivery via several routes of administration, including non- or minimally invasive routes. Finally we suggest possible directions for future vaccine delivery research and development.

Dual role of CpG as immune modulator and physical crosslinker in ovalbumin loaded N-trimethyl chitosan (TMC) nanoparticles for nasal vaccination.

Nasal vaccination is a promising, but challenging vaccination strategy. Poor absorption by the nasal epithelium and failure to break nasal tolerance are regarded as important reasons for poor efficacy of nasally applied vaccines. Formulation of the antigen into mucoadhesive nanoparticles, made of N-trimethyl chitosan (TMC) crosslinked with tripolyphosphate (TPP), has been shown to overcome these obstacles. However, although nasally administered antigen loaded TMC/TPP nanoparticles induce a strong humoral response, antibody subtyping indicates a Th2 bias. To design a nasal antigen delivery system capable of inducing stronger Th1 type responses, TPP as a crosslinking agent was replaced by unmethylated CpG DNA, a TLR-9 ligand and a potent inducer of Th1 responses, to prepare ovalbumin (OVA) loaded TMC nanoparticles (TMC/CpG/OVA). Several physicochemical characteristics of TMC/CpG/OVA (size, zetapotential, loading efficiency and antigen release profile) were assessed and compared to TMC nanoparticles prepared by crosslinking with TPP (TMC/TPP/OVA). Mice were nasally administered TMC/TPP/OVA and TMC/CpG/OVA after which antibody responses in serum and nasal washes were assessed and T-cell activation in the spleens determined. TMC/CpG/OVA showed similar physical properties as TMC/TPP/OVA in terms of particle size (380 nm), zetapotential (+21 mV) and antigen release characteristics. Nasal administration of TMC/CpG/OVA and TMC/TPP/OVA to mice resulted in comparable serum IgG levels (ca. 1000 fold higher than those induced by unadjuvanted OVA) and local secretory IgA levels. Moreover, TMC/CpG/OVA induced a 10 fold higher IgG2a response than TMC/TPP/OVA and enhanced the number of OVA specific IFN-gamma-producing T-cells in the spleen. In conclusion, OVA loaded TMC nanoparticles, containing CpG as adjuvant and crosslinker, are capable of provoking strong humoral as well as Th1 type cellular immune responses after nasal vaccination.

Adjuvanted, antigen loaded N-trimethyl chitosan nanoparticles for nasal and intradermal vaccination: adjuvant- and site-dependent immunogenicity in mice.

N-trimethyl chitosan (TMC) nanoparticles have been shown to increase the immunogenicity of subunit antigens after nasal and intradermal administration. This work describes a second generation of TMC nanoparticles containing ovalbumin as a model antigen (TMC/OVA nanoparticles) and an immunopotentiator (TMC/OVA/immunopotentiator nanoparticles). The selection of immunopotentiators included Toll-like receptor (TLR) ligands lipopolysaccharide (LPS), PAM(3)CSK(4) (PAM), CpG DNA, the NOD-like receptor 2 ligand muramyl dipeptide (MDP) and the GM1 ganglioside receptor ligand, cholera toxin B subunit (CTB). The TMC/OVA/immunopotentiator nanoparticles were characterised physico-chemically and their immunogenicity was assessed by determining the serum IgG, IgG1, IgG2a titres and secretory IgA levels in nasal washes after intradermal and nasal vaccination in mice. After nasal vaccination, TMC/OVA nanoparticles containing LPS or MDP elicited higher IgG, IgG1 and sIgA levels than non-adjuvanted TMC/OVA particles, whereas nanoparticles containing CTB, PAM or CpG did not. After intradermal vaccination, the TMC/OVA/CpG and TMC/OVA/LPS nanoparticles provoked higher IgG titres than plain TMC/OVA particles. Altogether, our results show that co-encapsulation of an additional immunopotentiator with the antigen into TMC nanoparticles can further improve the immunogenicity of the vaccine. However, the strength and quality of the response depends on the immunopotentiator as well as the route of administration.

Covalently stabilized trimethyl chitosan-hyaluronic acid nanoparticles for nasal and intradermal vaccination

The physical stability of polyelectrolyte nanocomplexes composed of trimethyl chitosan (TMC) and hyaluronic acid (HA) is limited in physiological conditions. This may minimize the favorable adjuvant effects associated with particulate systems for nasal and intradermal immunization. Therefore, covalently stabilized nanoparticles loaded with ovalbumin (OVA) were prepared with thiolated TMC and thiolated HA via ionic gelation followed by spontaneous disulfide formation after incubation at pH 7.4 and 37°C. Also, maleimide PEG was coupled to the remaining thiol-moieties on the particles to shield their surface charge. OVA-loaded TMC/HA nanoparticles had a size of around 250-350nm, a positive zeta potential and OVA loading efficiencies up to 60%. Reacting the thiolated particles with maleimide PEG resulted in a slight reduction of zeta potential (from +7 to +4mV) and a minor increase in particle size. Stabilized TMC-S-S-HA particles (PEGylated or not) showed superior stability in saline solutions compared to non-stabilized particles (composed of nonthiolated polymers) but readily disintegrated upon incubation in a saline buffer containing 10mM dithiothreitol. In both the nasal and intradermal immunization study, OVA loaded stabilized TMC-S-S-HA particles demonstrated superior immunogenicity compared to non-stabilized particles (indicated by higher IgG titers). Intranasal, PEGylation completely abolished the beneficial effects of stabilization and it induced no enhanced immune responses against OVA after intradermal administration. In conclusion, stabilization of the TMC/HA particulate system greatly enhances the immunogenicity of OVA in nasal and intradermal vaccination.