Henry R. Maun

Monovalent antibody design and mechanism of action of onartuzumab, a MET antagonist with anti-tumor activity as a therapeutic agent

Significance Therapeutic antibodies have revolutionized the treatment of human disease. Despite these advances, antibody bivalency limits their utility against some targets. Here, we describe the development of a one-armed (monovalent) antibody, onartuzumab, targeting the receptor tyrosine kinase MET. While initial screening of bivalent antibodies produced agonists of MET, engineering them into monovalent antibodies produced antagonists instead. We explain the structural basis of the mechanism of action with the crystal structure of onartuzumab antigen-binding fragment in complex with MET and HGF-β. These discoveries have led to an additional antibody-based therapeutic option and shed light on the underpinnings of HGF/MET signaling. Binding of hepatocyte growth factor (HGF) to the receptor tyrosine kinase MET is implicated in the malignant process of multiple cancers, making disruption of this interaction a promising therapeutic strategy. However, targeting MET with bivalent antibodies can mimic HGF agonism via receptor dimerization. To address this limitation, we have developed onartuzumab, an Escherichia coli-derived, humanized, and affinity-matured monovalent monoclonal antibody against MET, generated using the knob-into-hole technology that enables the antibody to engage the receptor in a one-to-one fashion. Onartuzumab potently inhibits HGF binding and receptor phosphorylation and signaling and has antibody-like pharmacokinetics and antitumor activity. Biochemical data and a crystal structure of a ternary complex of onartuzumab antigen-binding fragment bound to a MET extracellular domain fragment, consisting of the MET Sema domain fused to the adjacent Plexins, Semaphorins, Integrins domain (MET Sema-PSI), and the HGF β-chain demonstrate that onartuzumab acts specifically by blocking HGF α-chain (but not β-chain) binding to MET. These data suggest a likely binding site of the HGF α-chain on MET, which when dimerized leads to MET signaling. Onartuzumab, therefore, represents the founding member of a class of therapeutic monovalent antibodies that overcomes limitations of antibody bivalency for targets impacted by antibody crosslinking.

Suppressor of Fused Regulates Gli Activity through a Dual Binding Mechanism

ABSTRACT The Hedgehog pathway drives proliferation and differentiation by activating the Gli/Ci family of zinc finger transcription factors. Gli/Ci proteins form Hedgehog signaling complexes with other signaling components, including the kinesin-like protein Costal-2, the serine-threonine kinase Fused, and Suppressor of Fused [Su(fu)]. In these complexes Gli/Ci proteins are regulated by cytoplasmic sequestration, phosphorylation, and proteolysis. Here we characterize structural and functional determinants of Su(fu) required for Gli regulation and show that Su(fu) contains at least two distinct domains: a highly conserved carboxy-terminal region required for binding to the amino-terminal ends of the Gli proteins and a unique amino-terminal domain that binds the carboxy-terminal tail of Gli1. While each domain is capable of binding to different Gli1 regions independently, interactions between Su(fu) and Gli1 at both sites are required for cytoplasmic tethering and repression of Gli1. Furthermore, we have solved the crystal structure of the amino-terminal domain of human Su(fu)27-268 at 2.65 Å resolution. This domain forms a concave pocket with a prominent acidic patch. Mutation at Asp159 in the acidic patch disrupts Gli1 tethering and repression while not strongly disrupting binding, indicating that the amino-terminal domain of Su(fu) likely impacts Gli binding through a mechanism distinct from that for tethering and repression. These studies provide a structural basis for understanding the function of Su(fu).

Hedgehog pathway antagonist 5E1 binds hedgehog at the pseudo-active site.

Proper hedgehog (Hh) signaling is crucial for embryogenesis and tissue regeneration. Dysregulation of this pathway is associated with several types of cancer. The monoclonal antibody 5E1 is a Hh pathway inhibitor that has been extensively used to elucidate vertebrate Hh biology due to its ability to block binding of the three mammalian Hh homologs to the receptor, Patched1 (Ptc1). Here, we engineered a murine:human chimeric 5E1 (ch5E1) with similar Hh-binding properties to the original murine antibody. Using biochemical, biophysical, and x-ray crystallographic studies, we show that, like the regulatory receptors Cdon and Hedgehog-interacting protein (Hhip), ch5E1 binding to Sonic hedgehog (Shh) is enhanced by calcium ions. In the presence of calcium and zinc ions, the ch5E1 binding affinity increases 10–20-fold to tighter than 1 nm primarily because of a decrease in the dissociation rate. The co-crystal structure of Shh bound to the Fab fragment of ch5E1 reveals that 5E1 binds at the pseudo-active site groove of Shh with an epitope that largely overlaps with the binding site of its natural receptor antagonist Hhip. Unlike Hhip, the side chains of 5E1 do not directly coordinate the Zn2+ cation in the pseudo-active site, despite the modest zinc-dependent increase in 5E1 affinity for Shh. Furthermore, to our knowledge, the ch5E1 Fab-Shh complex represents the first structure of an inhibitor antibody bound to a metalloprotease fold.

Efficient production of antibodies against a mammalian integral membrane protein by phage display

The application of phage display technology to mammalian proteins with multiple transmembrane regions has had limited success due to the difficulty in generating these proteins in sufficient amounts and purity. We report here a method that can be easily and generally applied to sorting of phage display libraries with multispan protein targets solubilized in detergent. A key feature of this approach is the production of biotinylated multispan proteins in virions of a baculovirus vector that allows library panning without prior purification of the target protein. We obtained Fab fragments from a naïve synthetic antibody phage library that, when engineered into full-length immunoglobulin (Ig)G, specifically bind cells expressing claudin-1, a protein with four transmembrane regions that is used as an entry co-receptor by the hepatitis C virus (HCV). Affinity-matured variants of one of these antibodies efficiently inhibited HCV infection. The use of baculovirus particles as a source of mammalian multispan protein facilitates the application of phage display to this difficult class of proteins.

Utilizing the activation mechanism of serine proteases to engineer hepatocyte growth factor into a Met antagonist

Hepatocyte growth factor (HGF), the ligand for the receptor tyrosine kinase Met, is secreted as single chain pro-HGF that lacks signaling activity. Pro-HGF acquires functional competence upon cleavage between R494 and V495, generating a disulfide-linked α/β-heterodimer, where the β-chain of HGF (HGF β) has a serine protease fold that lacks enzymatic activity. We show that, like serine proteases, insertion of the newly formed N terminus in the β-chain is critical for activity, here by allosterically stabilizing interactions with Met. The HGF β crystal structure shows that V495 inserts into the “activation pocket” near the Met binding site where the positively charged N terminus forms a salt bridge with the negatively charged D672, and the V495 side chain has hydrophobic interactions with main- and side-chain residues. Full-length two-chain HGF mutants designed to interrupt these interactions (D672N, V495G, V495A, G498I, and G498V) displayed <10% activity in Met receptor phosphorylation, cell migration, and proliferation assays. Impaired signaling of full-length mutants correlated with >50-fold decreases in Met binding of the low-affinity HGF β domain alone bearing the same mutations and further correlated with impaired N-terminal insertion. Because high-affinity binding resides in the HGF α-chain, full-length mutants maintained normal Met binding and efficiently inhibited HGF-mediated Met activation. Conversion of HGF from agonist to antagonist was achieved by as little as removal of two methyl groups (V495A) or a single charge (D672N). Thus, although serine proteases and HGF have quite distinct functions in proteolysis and Met signal transduction, respectively, they share a similar activation mechanism.

Disulfide locked variants of factor VIIa with a restricted β‐strand conformation have enhanced enzymatic activity

Proteolytic processing of zymogen Factor VII to Factor VIIa (FVIIa) is necessary but not sufficient for maximal proteolytic activity, which requires an additional allosteric influence induced upon binding to its cofactor tissue factor (TF). A key conformational change affecting the zymogenicity of FVIIa involves a unique three‐residue shift in the position of β‐strand B2 in their zymogen and protease forms. By selectively introducing new disulfide bonds, we locked the conformation of these strands into an active TF•FVIIa‐like state. FVIIa mutants designated 136:160, 137:159, 138:160, and 139:157, reflecting the position of the new disulfide bond (chymotypsinogen numbering), were expressed and purified by TF affinity chromatography. Mass spectrometric analysis of tryptic peptides from the FVIIa mutants confirmed the new disulfide bond formation. Kinetic analysis of amidolytic activity revealed that all FVIIa variants alone had increased specific activity compared to wild type, the largest being for variants 136:160 and 138:160 with substrate S‐2765, having 670‐ and 330‐fold increases, respectively. Notably, FVIIa disulfide‐locked variants no longer required TF as a cofactor for maximal activity in amidolytic assays. In the presence of soluble TF, activity was enhanced 20‐ and 12‐fold for variants 136:160 and 138:160, respectively, compared to wild type. With relipidated TF, mutants 136:160 and 137:159 also had an approximate threefold increase in their Vmax/Km values for FX activation but no significant improvement in TF‐dependent clotting assays. Thus, while large rate enhancements were obtained for amidolytic substrates binding at the active site, macro‐molecular substrates that bind to FVIIa exosites entail more complex catalytic requirements.

Allosteric Peptide Activators of Pro-Hepatocyte Growth Factor Stimulate Met Signaling

Hepatocyte growth factor (HGF) binds to its target receptor tyrosine kinase, Met, as a single-chain form (pro-HGF) or as a cleaved two-chain disulfide-linked α/β-heterodimer. However, only two-chain HGF stimulates Met signaling. Proteolytic cleavage of the Arg494-Val495 peptide bond in the zymogen-like pro-HGF results in allosteric activation of the serine protease-like β-chain (HGF β), which binds Met to initiate signaling. We use insights from the canonical trypsin-like serine protease activation mechanism to show that isolated peptides corresponding to the first 7–10 residues of the cleaved N terminus of the β-chain stimulate Met phosphorylation by pro-HGF to levels that are ∼25% of those stimulated by two-chain HGF. Biolayer interferometry data demonstrate that peptide VVNGIPTR (peptide V8) allosterically enhances pro-HGF β binding to Met, resulting in a KDapp of 1.6 μm, only 8-fold weaker than the Met/HGF β-chain affinity. Most notably, in vitro cell stimulation with peptide V8 in the presence of pro-HGF leads to Akt phosphorylation, enhances cell survival, and facilitates cell migration between 75 and 100% of that found with two-chain HGF, thus revealing a novel approach for activation of Met signaling that bypasses proteolytic processing of pro-HGF. Peptide V8 is unable to enhance Met binding or signaling with HGF proteins having a mutated activation pocket (D672N). Furthermore, Gly substitution of the N-terminal Val residue in peptide V8 results in loss of all activity. Overall, these findings identify the activation pocket of the serine protease-like β-chain as a “hot spot” for allosteric regulation of pro-HGF and have broad implications for developing selective allosteric activators of serine proteases and pseudoproteases.

An allosteric switch for pro-HGF/Met signaling using zymogen activator peptides

Stimulation of hepatocyte growth factor (HGF) signaling through the Met receptor is an attractive approach for promoting tissue repair and preventing fibrosis. Using structure-guided peptide phage display combined with an activity-based sorting strategy, we engineered allosteric activators of zymogen-like pro-HGF to bypass proteolytic activation and reversibly stimulate pro-HGF signaling through Met. Biochemical, structural and biological data showed that zymogen activator peptides (ZAPtides) potently and selectively bind the activation pocket within the serine protease-like β-chain of pro-HGF and display titratable activation of pro-HGF-dependent Met signaling, leading to cell survival and migration. To further demonstrate the versatility of our ZAPtide platform, we identified allosteric activators for pro-macrophage stimulating protein and a zymogen serine protease, Protein C, which also provides evidence for target selectivity. These studies reveal that ZAPtides use molecular mimicry of the trypsin-like N-terminal insertion mechanism and establish a new paradigm for selective pharmacological activation of plasminogen-related growth factors and zymogen serine proteases.

Pseudo-active sites of protease domains: HGF/Met and Sonic hedgehog signaling in cancer.

Abstract Proteases represent a large class of enzymes with crucial biological functions. Although targeting various relevant proteases for therapeutic intervention has been widely investigated, structurally related proteins lacking proteolytic activity (pseudo-proteases) have received relatively little attention. Two distinct clinically relevant cancer pathways that contain signaling proteins with pseudo-protease domains include the Met and Hedgehog (Hh) pathways. The receptor tyrosine kinase Met pathway is driven by hepatocyte growth factor (HGF), a plasminogen-related ligand that binds Met and activates intracellular pathways resulting in cell proliferation, angiogenesis, motility and survival. HGF is a disulfide-linked α/β-heterodimer having a trypsin serine protease-like β-chain. The Hh pathway is driven by Sonic hedgehog (Shh), which has a Zn2+ metalloprotease fold and binds Patched1 (Ptc1), which de-represses Smoothened and ultimately activates Gli-dependent transcription. Although HGF and Shh differ in structure and function, the pseudo-catalytic sites of both HGF and Shh are crucial for signal transduction. For HGF, this region binds the Met β-propeller domain, which leads to Met dimerization and signaling. For Hh, this region binds to the antagonist receptor Hedgehog-interacting protein (Hhip) and most probably to Ptc1 as well. Thus, for both HGF and Hh pathways, targeting ligand pseudo-active sites represents a new strategy for regulation.

3-2-1: Structural insights from stepwise shrinkage of a three-helix Fc-binding domain to a single helix

The well-studied B-domain from Staphylococcal protein A is a 59 amino acid three-helix bundle that binds the Fc portion of IgG with a dissociation constant of ~35 nM. The B-domain variant bearing a Gly to Ala mutation (=Z-domain) has been the subject of efforts to minimize a domains size while retaining its function. We report X-ray crystallographic characterization of three steps in such a process using complexes with Fc: the full three-helix Z-domain, a 34 amino acid two-helix version called Z34C and a 13 amino acid single helix stabilized with an exo-helix tether, called LH1.