Jean-Yves Natoli

Investigation of nanodefect properties in optical coatings by coupling measured and simulated laser damage statistics

We propose a model to link laser damage initiator properties (such as nature, size distribution, and density) to measured laser damage probabilities in optical materials. The model is based on the calculation of light absorption in nanoabsorbers and subsequent heating, coupled to laser damage statistics, and allows to obtain the laser damage probability as a function of laser fluence. Applications to the case of optical coatings irradiated in the nanosecond regime are presented. Laser damage probability curves are measured in hafnia single layer coatings made under different conditions: electron beam deposition and reactive low voltage ion plating. By studying the influence of the laser irradiation parameters (wavelength and beam size) and coating properties on the simulations, we show with our methodology that initiating defects (hafnium inclusions) can be identified. The implications of this approach for physical understanding and metrology applications are discussed.

Laser induced damage investigation at 1064 nm in KTiOPO4 crystals and its analogy with RbTiOPO4

Bulk laser-induced damage at 1064 nm has been investigated in KTiOPO4 (KTP) and RbTiOPO4 (RTP) crystals with a nanosecond pulsed Nd:YAG laser. Both crystals belong to the same family. Throughout this study, their comparison shows a very similar laser-damage behavior. The evolution of the damage resistance under a high number of shots per site (10,000 shots) reveals a fatigue effect of KTP and RTP crystals. In addition, S-on-1 damage probability curves have been measured in both crystals for all combinations of polarization and propagation direction aligned with the principal axes of the crystals. The results show an influence of the polarization on the laser-induced damage threshold (LIDT), with a significantly higher threshold along the z axis, whereas no effect of the propagation direction has been observed. This LIDT anisotropy is discussed with regard to the crystallographic structure.

Influence of longitudinal mode beating on laser-induced damage in fused silica

In our study, the laser-induced damage densities on a fused silica surface produced by multiple longitudinal mode (MLM) pulses are found to be higher than those produced by single longitudinal mode pulses at 1064 nm. This behavior is explained by the enhancement of the three-photon absorption due to the intensity spikes related to longitudinal mode beating. At 355 nm, the absorption is linear and an opposite behavior occurs. It can be explained with the help of a process involving thermomechanics coupled with the fine time structure of MLM pulses, leading to the possible annealing of part of the absorbent defects.

Laser-induced damage of KDP crystals by 1ω nanosecond pulses: influence of crystal orientation

We investigate the influence of THG-cut KDP crystal orientation on laser damage at 1064 nm under nanosecond pulses. Since laser damage is now assumed to initiate on precursor defects, this study makes a connection between these nanodefects (throughout a mesoscopic description) and the influence of their orientation on laser damage. Some investigations have already been carried out in various crystals and particularly for KDP, indicating propagation direction and polarization dependences. We performed experiments for two orthogonal positions of the crystal and results clearly indicate that KDP crystal laser damage depends on its orientation. We carried out further investigations on the effect of the polarization orientation, by rotating the crystal around the propagation axis. We then obtained the evolution of the damage probability as a function of the rotation angle. To account for these experimental res ts, we propose a laser damage model based on ellipsoid-shaped defects. This modeling is a refined implementation of the DMT model (Drude Mie Thermal) [Dyan et al., J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 25, 1087-1095 (2008)], by introducing absorption efficiency calculations for an ellipsoidal geometry. Modeling simulations are in good agreement with experimental results.

Integrated photothermal microscope and laser damage test facility for in-situ investigation of nanodefect induced damage.

An integrated setup allowing high resolution photothermal microscopy and laser damage measurements at the same wavelength has been implemented. The microscope is based on photothermal deflection of a transmitted probe beam : the probe beam (633 nm wavelength) and the CW pump beam (1.06 microm wavelength) are collinear and focused through the same objective. In-situ laser irradiation tests are performed thanks to a pulsed beam (1.06 microm wavelength and 6 nanosecond pulse). We describe this new facility and show that it is well adapted to the detection of sub-micronic absorbing defects, that, once located, can be precisely aimed and irradiated. Photothermal mappings are performed before and after shot, on metallic inclusions in dielectric. Results obtained on gold inclusions of about 600 nm in diameter embedded in silica are presented.

Multipulse laser damage in potassium titanyl phosphate: statistical interpretation of measurements and the damage initiation mechanism

Abstract. Multipulse laser-induced damage is an important topic for many applications of nonlinear crystals. We studied multipulse damage in X-cut KTiOPO4. Using a 6-ns Nd:YAG laser with a weakly focused beam, a fatigue phenomenon was observed. We addressed whether this phenomenon necessarily implies material modifications. Two possible models were tested, both of them predicting increasing damage probability with increasing pulse number while all material properties are kept constant. The first model, pulse energy fluctuations and depointing, increases the probed volume during multiple pulse experiments. The probability to cause damage thus increases with increasing pulse number; however, this effect is too small to explain the observed fatigue. The second model assumes a constant single-shot damage probability p1, so a multipulse experiment can be described by statistically independent resampling of the material. Very good agreement was found between the 2000-on-1 volume damage data and this statistical multipulse model. Additionally, the spot size dependency of the damage probability is well described by a precursor presence model. Supposing that laser damage precursors are transient, the presented data explain the experimental results without supposing material modifications.

Contrasted material responses to nanosecond multiple-pulse laser damage: from statistical behavior to material modification

This work is dedicated to the study of so-called fatigue effects upon nanosecond laser-induced damage of several crystalline materials and synthetic fused silica irradiated by multiple pulses. The obtained damage probability versus fluence and pulse number data are exploited to determine if the observed fatigue is due to statistics (the more often the material is irradiated, the higher the probability for it to be damaged) or to material modification under irradiation. Whereas 1064 nm irradiation seems to be responsible for statistic behavior, 355 nm irradiation generates material modifications in the case of synthetic fused silica.

Multiple pulse nanosecond laser induced damage study in LiB 3 O 5 crystals

Multiple pulse nanosecond laser induced damage in the bulk of LiB3O5 (LBO) crystals was investigated at 1064 nm, 532 nm and 355 nm. Scanning electron microscopy of cleaved damage sites confirmed the presence of different zones that have already been reported in the case of KH2PO4 (KDP). Multi pulse measurements reveal a strong decrease of the damage threshold with increasing pulse number at 1064 nm (fatigue effect). A weaker fatigue effect was observed at 532 nm and no fatigue effect was found at 355 nm. This observation is best explained by an inherently statistical light matter interaction generating laser induced damage. Finally, a polarization dependent damage threshold anisotropy was evidenced at all three wavelengths, being strongest at 1064 nm. The results indicate the importance of Li+ vacancy stabilized color centers for the damage mechanism.

High-resolution photothermal microscope: a sensitive tool for the detection of isolated absorbing defects in optical coatings

The photothermal deflection technique allows us to highlight the presence of inhomogeneities of absorption in optical components. This nondestructive tool is of great interest to the study of the role of contaminants, inclusions, and impurities in the laser-induced damage process. We show that the detection of nanometer-sized isolated absorbing defects requires the development of an adapted photothermal setup with high detectivity and high spatial resolution. Thus it is essential to improve the resolving power up to its theoretical limit.

Model for nanosecond laser induced damage in potassium titanyl phosphate crystals

A model for nanosecond laser induced damage in the bulk of potassium titanyl phosphate nonlinear optical crystals is presented. In a first step, laser-induced damage precursors are produced by multiphoton absorption. In a second step, the damage precursors are activated. Damage occurs if the precursor activation rate exceeds a critical value. Basic considerations allow evaluating the parameters of the model. The validity of the model is discussed by comparing it to several experimental observations, in particular, the decrease of the laser damage threshold during second harmonic generation of 1064 nm pulses.