Kyle G. Battiston

Biomaterials in co-culture systems: towards optimizing tissue integration and cell signaling within scaffolds.

Most natural tissues consist of multi-cellular systems made up of two or more cell types. However, some of these tissues may not regenerate themselves following tissue injury or disease without some form of intervention, such as from the use of tissue engineered constructs. Recent studies have increasingly used co-cultures in tissue engineering applications as these systems better model the natural tissues, both physically and biologically. This review aims to identify the challenges of using co-culture systems and to highlight different approaches with respect to the use of biomaterials in the use of such systems. The application of co-culture systems to stimulate a desired biological response and examples of studies within particular tissue engineering disciplines are summarized. A description of different analytical co-culture systems is also discussed and the role of biomaterials in the future of co-culture research are elaborated on. Understanding the complex cell-cell and cell-biomaterial interactions involved in co-culture systems will ultimately lead the field towards biomaterial concepts and designs with specific biochemical, electrical, and mechanical characteristics that are tailored towards the needs of distinct co-culture systems.

Electrospun elastin-like polypeptide enriched polyurethanes and their interactions with vascular smooth muscle cells

In vascular tissue, elastin is an essential extracellular matrix protein that plays an important biomechanical and biological signalling role. Native elastin is insoluble and is difficult to extract from tissues, which results in its relatively rare use for the fabrication of vascular tissue engineering scaffolds. Recombinant elastin-like polypeptide-4 (ELP4), which mimics the structure and function of native tropoelastin, represents a practical alternative to the native elastic fibre for vascular applications. In this study, electrospinning was utilized to fabricate fibrous scaffolds which were subsequently surface modified with ELP4 and used as substrates for smooth muscle cell culture. ELP4 surface modified materials demonstrated enhanced smooth muscle cell (SMC) adhesion and maintenance of cell numbers over a 1-week period relative to controls. SMCs seeded on the ELP4 surface modified materials were also shown to exhibit the cell morphology and biological markers of a contractile phenotype including a spindle-like morphology, actin filament organization and smooth muscle myosin heavy chain expression. Competitive inhibition experiments demonstrated that the elastin-laminin cell surface receptor and its affinity for the VGVAPG peptide sequence on ELP4 molecules are likely involved in the initial SMC contact with the ELP4 modified materials. Elastin-like polypeptides show promise as surface modifiers for candidate scaffolds for engineering contractile vascular tissues.

Protein binding mediation of biomaterial-dependent monocyte activation on a degradable polar hydrophobic ionic polyurethane

Protein adsorption is an important phenomenon influencing the cellular response to biomaterials. Previous studies comparing monocyte activation on a degradable polar hydrophobic ionic polyurethane (D-PHI) indicated a reduced pro-inflammatory monocyte response relative to tissue culture polystyrene (TCPS) and poly(lactide-co-glycolide) (PLGA) substrates. The present study investigated the influence of protein binding in order to gain further insight into the observed differential monocyte activation. Several proteins, identified in different relative amounts within the bound protein layers on D-PHI vs. PLGA and TCPS, were evaluated for their effect on monocyte activation. It was found that, in general, both non-coated and protein pre-adsorbed D-PHI supported a reduced pro-inflammatory response relative to PLGA, as indicated by lower levels of tumor necrosis factor-α (TNF-α) release. An initial increase in TNF-α release occurred when α(2)-macroglobulin (A2M) was pre-adsorbed to D-PHI, which was shown to involve the α(2)-macroglobulin receptor and was active on D-PHI but not on the two other biomaterials. This response was not observed during competitive protein binding in the presence of fetal bovine serum (FBS), suggesting that a more complex arrangement of the bound proteins and their interactions with one another, as well as with the surface chemistry of the individual biomaterials, resulted in the low-activating character of D-PHI when interacting with human monocytes.

Surface immobilization of elastin-like polypeptides using fluorinated surface modifying additives

Elastin-like polypeptide (ELP) surface modification represents a valuable approach for the development of biomaterials in a wide range of medical applications. In this study, ELP surface modification has been achieved through the use of elastin cross-linking peptide (ECP) bioactive fluorinated surface modifiers (ECP-BFSMs). The synthesis of low molecular weight fluorinated additives was described and their subsequent blending with a base polycarbonate urethane (PCNU) was shown to successfully enrich the surface to allow for ELP surface cross-linking via lysine moieties on the peptide segments of the ECP-BFSMs. The kinetics for the surface migration of fluorescent ECP-BFSMs was studied over a 2-week period by two-photon confocal microscopy. A decrease in advancing contact angle from 87.9° to 75.3° was observed for ECP-BFSM modified PCNU and was associated with the presence of ECP peptides on the surface. X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy demonstrated an increase in surface atomic percent of fluorine (from 0.2 to 7.2%) and nitrogen (from 1.0 to 3.0%) associated with the surface localization of fluoro groups and amide groups associated with the peptides in the ECP-BFSMs. A further increase in surface atomic percent of nitrogen (from 3.0 to 8.3%) was observed after ELP surface cross-linking. These ELP-modified surfaces were shown to promote increased smooth muscle cell adhesion, spreading and retention over a 7-day culture period relative to their non-ELP4 analogs. This novel surface modifying additive approach may be used for various biomimetic applications since it generates a stable ECM-like surface retained onto a relatively inert fluorinated background.

Monocyte/macrophage cytokine activity regulates vascular smooth muscle cell function within a degradable polyurethane scaffold

Tissue engineering strategies rely on the ability to promote cell proliferation and migration into porous biomaterial constructs, as well as to support specific phenotypic states of the cells in vitro. The present study investigated the use of released factors from monocytes and their derived macrophages (MDM) and the mechanism by which they regulate vascular smooth muscle cell (VSMC) response in a VSMC-monocyte co-culture system within a porous degradable polyurethane (D-PHI) scaffold. VSMCs cultured in monocyte/MDM-conditioned medium (MCM), generated from the culture of monocytes/MDM on D-PHI scaffolds for up to 28 days, similarly affected VSMC contractile marker expression, growth and three-dimensional migration when compared to direct VSMC-monocyte co-culture. Monocyte chemotactic protein-1 (MCP-1) and interleukin-6 (IL-6) were identified as two cytokines present in MCM, at concentrations that have previously been shown to influence VSMC phenotype. VSMCs cultured alone on D-PHI scaffolds and exposed to MCP-1 (5 ng ml(-1)) or IL-6 (1 ng ml(-1)) for 7 days experienced a suppression in contractile marker expression (with MCP-1 or IL-6) and increased growth (with MCP-1) compared to no cytokine medium supplementation. These effects were also observed in VSMC-monocyte co-culture on D-PHI. Neutralization of IL-6, but not MCP-1, was subsequently shown to decrease VSMC growth and enhance calponin expression for VSMC-monocyte co-cultures on D-PHI scaffolds for 7 days, implying that IL-6 mediates VSMC response in monocyte-VSMC co-cultures. This study highlights the use of monocytes and their derived macrophages in conjunction with immunomodulatory biomaterials, such as D-PHI, as agents for regulating VSMC response, and demonstrates the importance of monocyte/MDM-released factors, such as IL-6 in particular, in this process.

Differences in protein binding and cytokine release from monocytes on commercially sourced tissue culture polystyrene.

Tissue culture polystyrene (TCPS) is a ubiquitous substrate used by many researchers in the biomedical and biological sciences. Different parameters involved in the production of TCPS, including the treatment time and the use of reactive gases and chemical agents, can have a significant influence on the ultimate surface properties achieved. The assumption that they will all yield a consistent and controlled product has not proven to be true. To provide a better insight into the bioactivity differences in TCPS supplied by different manufacturers, TCPS from three different companies (Sarstedt, Wisent Corp., and Becton Dickinson (BD)) were analyzed for their surface properties, protein adsorption characteristics, and interactions with human monocytes. Marked differences were observed in terms of surface wettability and surface chemistry. Furthermore, Wisent TCPS adsorbed more than twice the amount of serum proteins compared with BD and Sarstedt TCPS. Sarstedt showed significantly more cell retention (more DNA) compared with both BD and Wisent TCPS brands over a 7 day culture period. Cytokine release from monocytes adherent on the three different TCPS also differed significantly, suggesting that the differences in the surface properties were sufficient to differentially mediate monocyte activation. These results have important implications for TCPS research use, in terms of appreciating the interpretation of the data when TCPS is used as a control substrate as well as when it is used where a pre-conditioned state would influence the outcome of the study.

Immunomodulatory polymeric scaffold enhances extracellular matrix production in cell co-cultures under dynamic mechanical stimulation.

UNLABELLED Despite the importance of immune cells in regulating the wound healing process following injury, there are few examples of synthetic biomaterials that have the capacity to push the bodys immune cells toward pro-regeneration phenotypes, and fewer still that are designed with the intention of achieving this immunomodulatory character. While monocytes and their derived macrophages have been recognized as important contributors to tissue remodeling in vivo, this is primarily believed to be due to their ability to regulate other cell types. The ability of monocytes and macrophages to generate tissue products themselves, however, is currently not well appreciated within the field of tissue regeneration. Furthermore, while monocytes/macrophages are found in remodeling tissue that is subjected to mechanical loading, the effect this biomechanical strain on monocytes/macrophages and their ability to regulate tissue-specific cellular activity has not been understood due to the complexity of the many factors involved in the in vivo setting, hence necessitating the use of controlled in vitro culture platforms to investigate this phenomenon. In this study, human monocytes were co-cultured with human coronary artery smooth muscle cells (VSMCs) on a tubular (3mm ID) degradable polyurethane scaffold, with a unique combination of non-ionic polar, hydrophobic and ionic chemistry (D-PHI). The goal was to determine if such a synthetic matrix could be used in a co-culture system along with dynamic biomechanical stimulus (10% circumferential strain, 1Hz) conditions in order to direct monocytes to enhance tissue generation, and to better comprehend the different ways in which monocytes/macrophages may contribute to new tissue production. Mechanical strain and monocyte co-culture had a complementary and non-mitigating effect on VSMC growth. Co-culture samples demonstrated increased deposition of sulphated glycosaminoglycans (GAGs) and elastin, as well as increases in the release of FGF-2, a growth factor that can stimulate VSMC growth, while dynamic culture supported increases in collagen I and III as well as increased mechanical properties (elastic modulus, tensile strength) vs. static controls. Macrophage polarization toward an M1 state was not promoted by the biomaterial or culture conditions tested. Monocytes/macrophages cultured on D-PHI were also shown to produce vascular extracellular matrix components, including collagen I, collagen III, elastin, and GAGs. This study highlights the use of synthetic biomaterials having immunomodulatory character in order to promote cell and tissue growth when used in tissue engineering strategies, and identifies ECM deposition by monocytes/macrophages as an unexpected source of this new tissue. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE The ability of biomaterials to regulate macrophage activation towards a wound healing phenotype has recently been shown to support positive tissue regeneration. However, the ability of immunomodulatory biomaterials to harness monocyte/macrophage activity to support tissue engineering strategies in vitro holds enormous potential that has yet to be investigated. This study used a monocyte co-culture on a degradable polyurethane (D-PHI) to regulate the response of VSMCs in combination with biomechanical strain in a vascular tissue engineering context. Results demonstrate that immunomodulatory biomaterials, such as D-PHI, that support a desirable macrophage activation state can be combined with biomechanical strain to augment vascular tissue production in vitro, in part due to the novel and unexpected contribution of monocytes/macrophages themselves producing vascular ECM proteins.

Design of biodegradable polyurethanes and the interactions of the polymers and their degradation by-products within in vitro and in vivo environments

From 2005 to 2015 the development of new biodegradable polymers and the use of established biodegradable materials such as polylactic–glycolic acid have dominated the landscape of the implantable biomedical devices field, driven in large part by the need for tissue engineering (TE) and drug delivery applications. This chapter provides an overview of the contributions that degradable polyurethanes (PUs) have made over the past decade, and starts with a brief summary of PU chemistry and their mechanisms of biodegradation, condenses knowledge learned from the failure of PU devices in the 1980s, elaborates on the extensive knowledge built from the work on inflammatory processes involved in wound healing and biodegradation in the 1990s, and then provides a comprehensive analysis of new degradable PU synthesis from 2005 to 2015, with comments on their strategic uses in TE, interactions with primary and stem cells, and highlights their innovative applications in drug delivery.

Interaction of a block-co-polymeric biomaterial with immunoglobulin G modulates human monocytes towards a non-inflammatory phenotype

UNLABELLED Monocyte interactions with implanted biomaterials can contribute significantly to the ability of a biomaterial to support tissue integration and wound healing, as opposed to a chronic pro-inflammatory foreign body reaction, provided the materials are designed to do so. However, there are few biomaterials available designed to regulate immune cell response with the intention of reducing the pro-inflammatory activation state. Material chemistry is a powerful tool for regulating protein and cell interactions that can be incorporated into surfaces while maintaining desired mechanical properties. The aspects of material chemistry that can support monocyte activation away from a pro-inflammatory state are still poorly understood. Protein adsorption is a key initial event that transforms the surface of a biomedical device into a biological substrate that will govern subsequent cellular interactions. In this study, the chemistry of degradable block polyurethanes, termed degradable polar hydrophobic ionic (D-PHI) polyurethanes, were studied for their unique interactions with bound immunoglobulin G (IgG), a pro-inflammatory protein that supports monocyte-biomaterial interactions. The specific immunological active sites of the polyurethane-adsorbed protein were compared with IgGs adsorbed state on a homopolymeric material with surface chemistry conducive to cell interactions, e.g. tissue culture polystyrene (TCPS). IgG-coated TCPS supported sustained monocyte adhesion and enhanced monocyte spreading, effects not observed with IgG-coated PU. The degradable PU was subsequently shown to reduce the number of exposed IgG-Fab sites following pre-adsorption vs. IgG adsorbed to TCPS, with antibody inhibition experiments demonstrating that Fab-site exposure appears to dominate monocyte-biomaterial interactions. Minor changes in chemical segments within the PU molecular chains were subsequently investigated for their influence on directing IgG interactions towards reducing pro-inflammatory activity. A reduction in chemical heterogeneity within the PU, without significant differences in other material properties known to regulate monocyte response, was shown to increase Fab exposure and subsequently led to monocyte interactions similar to those observed for IgG-coated TCPS. These results infer that reduced IgG-Fab site exposure can be directed by material chemistry to attenuate pro-inflammatory monocyte interactions with biomaterial surfaces, and identify the chemical features of polymeric biomaterial design responsible for this process. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE There is currently limited understanding of material design features that can regulate protein-material interactions in order to prevent adverse inflammatory responses to implanted biomaterials. In this paper, monocyte interactions with biomaterials (specifically a block co-polymeric degradable polyurethane [D-PHI] and tissue culture polystyrene [TCPS]) were investigated as a function of their interactions with adsorbed immunoglobulin G (IgG). D-PHI was shown to attenuate IgG-induced monocyte retention and spreading by reducing IgG-Fab site exposure upon adsorption relative to TCPS. Aspects of D-PHI chemistry important in regulating Fab site exposure were determined. This study thus identifies features of biomaterials, using D-PHI as a case study, which can contribute to the development of new immunomodulatory biomaterial design.

Generating favorable growth factor and protease release profiles to enable extracellular matrix accumulation within an in vitro tissue engineering environment

Tissue engineering (particularly for the case of load-bearing cardiovascular and connective tissues) requires the ability to promote the production and accumulation of extracellular matrix (ECM) components (e.g., collagen, glycosaminoglycan and elastin). Although different approaches have been attempted in order to enhance ECM accumulation in tissue engineered constructs, studies of underlying signalling mechanisms that influence ECM deposition and degradation during tissue remodelling and regeneration in multi-cellular culture systems have been limited. The current study investigated vascular smooth muscle cell (VSMC)-monocyte co-culture systems using different VSMC:monocyte ratios, within a degradable polyurethane scaffold, to assess their influence on ECM generation and degradation processes, and to elucidate relevant signalling molecules involved in this in vitro vascular tissue engineering system. It was found that a desired release profile of growth factors (e.g. insulin growth factor-1 (IGF-1)) and hydrolytic proteases (e.g. matrix-metalloproteinases 2, 9, 13 and 14 (MMP2, MMP9, MMP13 and MMP14)), could be achieved in co-culture systems, yielding an accumulation of ECM (specifically for 2:1 and 4:1 VSMC:monocyte culture systems). This study has significant implications for the tissue engineering field (including vascular tissue engineering), not only because it identified important cytokines and proteases that control ECM accumulation/degradation within synthetic tissue engineering scaffolds, but also because the established culture systems could be applied to improve the development of different types of tissue constructs. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE Sufficient extracellular matrix accumulation within cardiovascular and connective tissue engineered constructs is a prerequisite for their appropriate function in vivo. This study established co-culture systems with tissue specific cells (vascular smooth muscle cells (VSMCs)) and defined ratios of immune cells (monocytes) to investigate extracellular matrix (ECM) generation and degradation processes, revealing important mechanisms underlying ECM turnover during vascular tissue regeneration/remodelling. A specific growth factor (IGF-1), as well as hydrolytic proteases (e.g. MMP2, MMP9, MMP13 and MMP14), were identified as playing important roles in these processes. ECM accumulation was found to be dependent on achieving a desired release profile of these ECM-promoting and ECM-degrading factors within the multi-cellular microenvironment. The findings enhance our understanding of ECM deposition and degradation during in vitro tissue engineering and would be applicable to the repair or regeneration of a variety of tissues.