Liza Shrestha

Heat Shock Protein (HSP) Drug Discovery and Development: Targeting Heat Shock Proteins in Disease

Heat shock proteins (HSPs) present as a double edged sword. While they play an important role in maintaining protein homeostasis in a normal cell, cancer cells have evolved to co-opt HSP function to promote their own survival. As a result, HSPs such as HSP90 have attracted a great deal of interest as a potential anticancer target. These efforts have resulted in over 20 distinct compounds entering clinical evaluation for the treatment of cancer. However, despite the potent anticancer activity demonstrated in preclinical models, to date no HSP90 inhibitor has obtained regulatory approval. In this review we discuss the unique challenges faced in targeting HSPs that have likely contributed to their lack of progress in the clinic and suggest ways to overcome these so that the enormous potential of these compounds to benefit patients can finally be realized. We also provide a guideline for the future development of HSP-targeted agents based on the many lessons learned during the last two decades in developing HSP90 inhibitors.

Chemical Tools to Investigate Mechanisms Associated with HSP90 and HSP70 in Disease

The chaperome is a large and diverse protein machinery composed of chaperone proteins and a variety of helpers, such as the co-chaperones, folding enzymes, and scaffolding and adapter proteins. Heat shock protein 90s and 70s (HSP90s and HSP70s), the most abundant chaperome members in human cells, are also the most complex. As we have learned to appreciate, their functions are context dependent and manifested through a variety of conformations that each recruit a subset of co-chaperone, scaffolding, and folding proteins and which are further diversified by the posttranslational modifications each carry, making their study through classic genetic and biochemical techniques quite a challenge. Chemical biology tools and techniques have been developed over the years to help decipher the complexities of the HSPs and this review provides an overview of such efforts with focus on HSP90 and HSP70.

Structure–Activity Relationship in a Purine-Scaffold Compound Series with Selectivity for the Endoplasmic Reticulum Hsp90 Paralog Grp94

Grp94 is involved in the regulation of a restricted number of proteins and represents a potential target in a host of diseases, including cancer, septic shock, autoimmune diseases, chronic inflammatory conditions, diabetes, coronary thrombosis, and stroke. We have recently identified a novel allosteric pocket located in the Grp94 N-terminal binding site that can be used to design ligands with a 2-log selectivity over the other Hsp90 paralogs. Here we perform extensive SAR investigations in this ligand series and rationalize the affinity and paralog selectivity of choice derivatives by molecular modeling. We then use this to design 18c, a derivative with good potency for Grp94 (IC50 = 0.22 μM) and selectivity over other paralogs (>100- and 33-fold for Hsp90α/β and Trap-1, respectively). The paralog selectivity and target-mediated activity of 18c was confirmed in cells through several functional readouts. Compound 18c was also inert when tested against a large panel of kinases. We show that 18c has biological activity in several cellular models of inflammation and cancer and also present here for the first time the in vivo profile of a Grp94 inhibitor.

Amide-Modified Prenylcysteine based Icmt Inhibitors: Structure Activity Relationships, Kinetic Analysis and Cellular Characterization

Human protein isoprenylcysteine carboxyl methyltransferase (hIcmt) is the enzyme responsible for the α-carboxyl methylation of the C-terminal isoprenylated cysteine of CaaX proteins, including Ras proteins. This specific posttranslational methylation event has been shown to be important for cellular transformation by oncogenic Ras isoforms. This finding led to interest in hIcmt inhibitors as potential anti-cancer agents. Previous analog studies based on N-acetyl-S-farnesylcysteine identified two prenylcysteine-based low micromolar inhibitors (1a and 1b) of hIcmt, each bearing a phenoxyphenyl amide modification. In this study, a focused library of analogs of 1a and 1b was synthesized and screened versus hIcmt, delineating structural features important for inhibition. Kinetic characterization of the most potent analogs 1a and 1b established that both inhibitors exhibited mixed-mode inhibition and that the competitive component predominated. Using the Cheng-Prusoff method, the K(i) values were determined from the IC(50) values. Analog 1a has a K(IC) of 1.4±0.2μM and a K(IU) of 4.8±0.5μM while 1b has a K(IC) of 0.5±0.07μM and a K(IU) of 1.9±0.2μM. Cellular evaluation of 1b revealed that it alters the subcellular localization of GFP-KRas, and also inhibits both Ras activation and Erk phosphorylation in Jurkat cells.

Affinity Purification Probes of Potential Use To Investigate the Endogenous Hsp70 Interactome in Cancer

Heat shock protein 70 (Hsp70) is a family of proteins with key roles in regulating malignancy. Cancer cells rely on Hsp70 to inhibit apoptosis, regulate senescence and autophagy, and maintain the stability of numerous onco-proteins. Despite these important biological functions in cancer, robust chemical tools that enable the analysis of the Hsp70-regulated proteome in a tumor-by-tumor manner are yet unavailable. Here we take advantage of a recently reported Hsp70 ligand to design and develop an affinity purification chemical toolset for potential use in the investigation of the endogenous Hsp70-interacting proteome in cancer. We demonstrate that these tools lock Hsp70 in complex with onco-client proteins and effectively isolate Hsp70 complexes for identification through biochemical techniques. Using these tools we provide proof-of-concept analyses that glimpse into the complex roles played by Hsp70 in maintaining a multitude of cell-specific malignancy-driving proteins.

Function and Chemotypes of Human Hsp70 Chaperones.

In humans, Hsp70 chaperones are ubiquitously expressed in the cytosol, endoplasmic reticulum and mitochondria. They fulfill important roles in protein folding and the protection of cells from stress. Different forms of Hsp70 have also been found to regulate specific signaling pathways, many related to cell death. Cancer cells are notably abnormally dependent on Hsp70 chaperones for their survival. The importance of Hsp70s as drug targets is increasingly being recognized, particularly as potential cancer therapeutics. This review surveys recent advances in understanding Hsp70 mechanisms and then moves to provide an overview of current efforts directed at inhibiting Hsp70s as a target in diseases such as cancer and neurodegenerative disease.

Evaluation of substrate and inhibitor binding to yeast and human isoprenylcysteine carboxyl methyltransferases (Icmts) using biotinylated benzophenone-containing photoaffinity probes

Isoprenylcysteine carboxyl methyltransferases (Icmts) are a class of integral membrane protein methyltransferases localized to the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) membrane in eukaryotes. The Icmts from human (hIcmt) and Saccharomyces cerevisiae (Ste14p) catalyze the α-carboxyl methyl esterification step in the post-translational processing of CaaX proteins, including the yeast a-factor mating pheromones and both human and yeast Ras proteins. Herein, we evaluated synthetic analogs of two well-characterized Icmt substrates, N-acetyl-S-farnesyl-L-cysteine (AFC) and the yeast a-factor peptide mating pheromone, that contain photoactive benzophenone moieties in either the lipid or peptide portion of the molecule. The AFC based-compounds were substrates for both hIcmt and Ste14p, whereas the a-factor analogs were only substrates for Ste14p. However, the a-factor analogs were found to be micromolar inhibitors of hIcmt. Together, these data suggest that the Icmt substrate binding site is dependent upon features in both the isoprenyl moiety and upstream amino acid composition. Furthermore, these data suggest that hIcmt and Ste14p have overlapping, yet distinct, substrate specificities. Photocrosslinking and neutravidin-agarose capture experiments with these analogs revealed that both hIcmt and Ste14p were specifically photolabeled to varying degrees with all of the compounds tested. Our data suggest that these analogs will be useful for the future identification of the Icmt substrate binding sites.

Abstract 1740: Allosteric Hsp70-family inhibitors as targeted anticancer therapeutics

Background: Hsp70, a molecular chaperone responsible, in part, for the folding of nascent peptides following translation, has been implicated as a survival factor and a poor prognostic marker in cancer cells. These pro-cancer mechanisms originate in the ability of Hsp70 to preserve and maintain oncogenic and transformative proteins responsible for the cancer phenotype. Hsp70 is a stress response protein such that expression increases under proteomic/proteotoxic stress events. This increased expression is also evident in cancer cells, an environment under proteomic stress brought on by transformation, and is known to be protective against programmed cell death. Hypothesis: We predict that by interrupting the chaperoning capacity of Hsp70 through allosteric inhibition, we can destabilize oncogenic proteins dependent on Hsp70 for structure and function. Additionally, as Hsp70 is a survival factor, we believe that a loss of Hsp70 activity will result in cancer specific cell death both in vitro and in vivo. Approach: Using chemical tools, primarily novel allosteric Hsp70 inhibiting small molecules, we will determine the fate of oncogenic proteins dependent on Hsp70 for stability. We will also examine the cellular response to the disruption of cancer-specific networks which require Hsp70. In vivo tumor models will be used to examine the pharmacokinetics and pharmacodynamics of small molecule Hsp70 inhibitors and to evaluate the therapeutic potential of Hsp70 inhibition. Significance: The stress response machinery is responsible for the stability of proteins, maintenance of signaling pathways, and evasion from programmed cell death while a cell is under stress; stressors including oncogenic transformation. These pathways maintained by the molecular chaperones have been directly linked to deleterious cancer phenotypes including aggressiveness and the emergence of therapeutic resistances. Targeted therapeutics, and uniquely those targeting the molecular chaperone system, can provide therapeutic options capable of ablating the specific mechanisms involved in proteomic stability and cell survival unique to each tumor cell; effects which can be delivered with minimal effect to normal tissue. This work highlights the potential for therapeutics targeting Hsp70 as anti-cancer agents. Citation Format: John Koren, Chao Xu, Anna Rodina, Liza Shrestha, Tony Taldone, Gabriela Chiosis. Allosteric Hsp70-family inhibitors as targeted anticancer therapeutics. [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the 106th Annual Meeting of the American Association for Cancer Research; 2015 Apr 18-22; Philadelphia, PA. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Res 2015;75(15 Suppl):Abstract nr 1740. doi:10.1158/1538-7445.AM2015-1740

Abstract 1733: Development of chemical tools to study the endogenous Hsp70 interactome in malignant cells

Background: Heat shock protein 70 family members play an important role in cancer. They are up-regulated in wide variety of tumors and the increased Hsp70 protein expression correlates with metastases, resistance to treatment and poor prognosis. Multiple mechanisms explain cancer cells dependence on Hsp70, such as inhibition of apoptosis by Hsp70, induction of autophagy and control of stability of onco-proteins. These Hsp70 activities are mediated in cancer by its ability to chaperone and interact with a large number of proteins in a cell-specific, context dependent manner. Hypothesis: Reagents that enable the capture of tumor-specific Hsp70 complexes facilitate the identification of context-dependent Hsp70 interactomes. Results: Our laboratory recently reported the identification of a novel allosteric site located in the nucleotide binding domain of Hsp70 (Chem Biol 2013). It has also reported the discovery of ligands that bind to the allosteric pocket of Hsp70, inhibit its function in cancer cells and result in anti-cancer activity (J Med Chem 2013). Structure-activity relationship studies in this ligand series gave insights on the attachment of specific linkers for the design of Hsp70-related chemical tools. Here we present the design of Hsp70-directed reagents and use biochemical and cell-based methods to validate Hsp70-directed affinity purification probes. We demonstrate that these tools lock Hsp70 in complex with onco-client proteins and effectively isolate Hsp70 complexes for identification through biochemical techniques. Using these tools we provide proof-of-concept analyses that glimpse into the complex roles played by Hsp70 in maintaining a multitude of cell-specific malignancy-driving proteins. Significance: The knowledge derived from the use of such reagents will be extremely valuable not only to understand tumor-specific roles of Hsp70 and associated mechanisms but also to develop rational strategies for the clinical implementation of these agents to cancer treatment. They may also provide clues on the altered functional proteome in individual tumors, a quest yet elusive by today9s proteomics methods. Citation Format: Anna A. Rodina, Tony Taldone, Yanlong Kang, Pallav Patel, John Koren, Pengrong Yan, Erica DaGama Gomes, Chenghua Yang, Maulik Patel, Liza Shrestha, Stefan Ochiana, Ronnie Maharaj, Alexander Gozman, Marc Cox, Hediye Erdjument-Bromage, Ronald Hendrickson, Leandro Cerchietti, Ari Melnick, Monica Guzman, Gabriela Chiosis. Development of chemical tools to study the endogenous Hsp70 interactome in malignant cells. [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the 106th Annual Meeting of the American Association for Cancer Research; 2015 Apr 18-22; Philadelphia, PA. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Res 2015;75(15 Suppl):Abstract nr 1733. doi:10.1158/1538-7445.AM2015-1733